Hello and good evening. You're listening to The Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from touristy R&C on Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on community radio network and directly to your device across the globe by a podcast. My name is Evie McGuire and I am bringing you a jam-packed younger show tonight.
Now that is no offense to my co-host Peter Frey, who is as amazing as a host as a user mentor. There's nothing old about you Peter, I promise. I just want to just boost things up a little bit tonight. Now on tonight's show, myself and a panel of young journalists are going to talk about what it's really like being a young journal in this ever-changing, if not sometimes this heartening media landscape.
How do we maintain hope? Why are we pursuing a career when you can please our parents and study law or business instead? And what do we think of those job cuts that we are always reading about? So along with all this, we will have time to chat about entry level quizzes, career changes and advice we would give to aspiring young journalists like ourselves.
Helping me dissect this fractured media world we are living in in the studio, Curie Le Schwartz, journalism law graduate at Deakin University in Melbourne and a young Walkley Award winner I am told. And now with the reporter at News Court welcome, Curie. Thank you, it's nice to have you. So we also have Kate Orman, another journalism law graduate, but this time from UNSW and now a multimedia editor at the Law Society of New South Wales.
Hi Kate. Hi, how you going? Good. And on the line from Lyon in France, I'm not kidding.
I'm delighted to welcome Jason Fellow, UTS Journalism graduate and former journalist at Channel 7 and 2GB. And now I'm told you're working at a quote, press office of an international organisation, Bonjour Jason. Bonjour, Bonjour, how you doing? Good.
I'm so excited to say let's get cracking. As a young journalist myself, I get a lot of my news from Twitter these days. The one post really caught my eye this week and I had to include it in the fourth estate. And that was a post by editor of the South Australian Riverland paper of the Murray Pioneer Paul Mitchell.
Now in his tweet, Paul linked it to the paper's recent recruitment process where six young journalists had to fill out a basic knowledge test. And Paul found out that out of 23 questions answered, the six candidates were completely clueless, quote, and unable to answer the series of basic politics, current affairs and general knowledge questions. Now these questions included things like who is Australian's treasurer, what does the NBN stand for and which party does Donald Trump represent? Apparently only two of the six candidates knew the name of the federal opposition leader, while one actually confused him with the current Prime Minister and spelled his name wrong.
I think just give up there. Anyway, Paul's tweet has caused a lot of buzz around the Twitter sphere and has been picked up by other news outlets such as News.com. Paul told News.com that I knew that it was a combination of the quality of university courses and the reliance on social media for news that caused the obvious responses. Now I have to start with you, Caroline, not because you work for News Corp, but because I know that you would have something going to say about this.
Do you think it is serious or fair for Paul to be ridiculing these candidates? I don't necessarily think you need to be ridiculing them, but I think it is a serious point, especially because the Murray Pioneer is a regional paper. So I think some of the other questions in that quiz focused on geographical issues and political issues, which is the paper actually in. I think things like that are really important, especially in a regional way.
You're going to be writing about everything. You're going to cover sport and politics and business and local affairs. I think a solid general knowledge basis is probably reasonable to expect. But I don't know, in terms of knowing things like Donald Trump or Malcolm Turnbull, which was spelled Malcolm Turnbull, I think in the quote, I think things like that are really important.
It is hard when you're just seeing social media because everything you see is just shared from your mates and they might not necessarily be interested in the treasure. It's got Morrison or whatever. You're probably not going to expose yourself to things like that. So I think that his point was probably been exaggerated, but I do think that it was a fair one to make.
Did you take the test? I did, actually. I know what I was preparing. I did pretty well.
I think a couple of the geographical ones I wasn't quite so good on about, you know, which, you know, electric, they sat in. But I think the other ones are relatively covered. I've got a Melbourne carp. Jason, I'd like to bring you in here.
What do you think this says about the interests of young journalists and their general knowledge? Well, yeah, it's frightening, isn't it? How little are these young journalists seem to know? I mean, our job is to tell people what's happening and explain why.
It's very hard to do in fact, the context of events. And, you know, journalism is like increasingly being thought of as one of the least trusted organizations in the country. So little have like, like, don't you really need to avoid because, you know, you need to read that a few of these days. It's very, very hard to get them back.
So, like, obviously, you can't be expected to be an expert in everything, but, you know, trying to know a little about a lot. That's my fault. You don't have to know what Iran's GDP is, but you should know that the president is the same time you don't have to know the name of the name of the name of the name of the secretary general and Tonya Gutierrez for those plans. My mum actually calls it being a specialist in realist.
She's like, you know, kind of specializing knowing not much about other things. Yeah, yeah. Well, like, one of the questions I was about Meghan Markle and I was like, you have to be living under a rock to not know that she married Prince Harry. Come on, or have a spell of like saying, I want to be a cook and making a dish and then going to get every set of olive oil.
I feel like this is sort of really, really necessary. So, what do you think about all this? And do you think the universities are to blame? I'm going to say, you know, I think it is very important to know a little about a lot of things like my fellow journalists here have said, but I remember when I was at university, I didn't really know that much.
I probably would have failed the test too. I don't know. I know where to find information and I think that's important for journalists, but you don't really know or pay attention so much of the news until you start working in it. And then you become a news junkie.
And I think it's very kind of easy for us to all judge these young university students. But really, do you know where Ned Kelly had his last stand? That was one of the questions. I don't know.
I definitely didn't know that. I don't know that. The only reason I might know it is if I'd seen the movie, but I mean, yeah, knowing knowing who our treasure is or what party don't trump along soon, maybe that's a little more important. But I mean, just because they don't know it off the top of their head doesn't mean they couldn't find it.
So, I definitely have to agree with that. I can say, I think we, you know, that's our job, we find information we're curious about things. But how do people trust us if we don't know the information that we're reporting on? I think they also trust our process.
So, like, in terms of being able to actually go out and do interviews and get facts firsthand and then to have them checked in the editing process, that's just as important as knowing people. I would never write a story saying that's that because I know it is. I would quote a source and I would say, where I'd got the information. So either way, you're gonna have to look for other sources to back up what you think.
So, yeah, maybe it's good thing. Maybe it is instilling curiosity and teaching them to go looking for answers when they don't have them. So, essentially, are you saying that you came out of university and you were almost as course, they've come to be underprepared? I wasn't comically underprepared.
I mean, I've done a double degree and I'm jealous and a lot of you can get through that. I mean, no, a few things. At least one or two. So, no, like, I would have maybe done better than the outcomes that seem to have come from this test.
But I definitely wasn't what you'd call a news junkie. And like, I am now, I wasn't reading the news daily. I maybe watched a bit of news. I mean, my first year at university, I was at college because I'm from a country town.
So, I wouldn't even have a TV. We didn't have radios or anything. The only news you'd get was really mostly social media. So, I look back at that and I definitely at that stage was comically underprepared.
But the more you start working and writing in university, the more you start surrounding yourself in more news. But I do think, journalists, we consider ourselves news junkies and whatever. But the average person, sure, they're not consuming the wide range of news that we are. Definitely not.
It's probably more topics based. Like, they've got the topic of interest and they read articles. Yeah. And not everything else.
Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Jase, what do you think over there? I mean, do you think that the universities are to blame?
Well, I don't think it's the, I don't know if there are things that are the universities to like the teachers general knowledge. But as a, Cirely and Kate were saying, it's instilling that sense of curiosity is a really, really important thing. And, you know, having inspired teachers is something that really got me to be curious about. Yeah.
Me too. Definitely. Hearing their stories about, you know, where they've been, what they've done, that was what really got me curious. But I'd also say that in terms of the being comically unprepared thing, I don't know if everything is a bad thing to not know what you're doing.
I mean, if I go and do an interview and I don't learn anything, or if I, you know, go on a new type of story and I haven't learned anything from it, I think that's a bit of a fail. I think part of the final journal is going to be able to learn something, which will be new every day. 100%. Yeah.
Yeah. Well, my final question to you, Carole, did you ever have to take a quiz like this in, in your process of becoming a journal or had you had an experience sort of like this one? Here we go. What did I get?
I had to do a few. So in a couple of my uni classes, we would have a weekly general knowledge test. So it'll be, I don't usually tend questions about, you know, current affairs of the week and then we'd sort of discuss them afterwards and how they'd been covered. So it was definitely in my interests to study up because, you know, I wanted to get good marks at uni.
But I'm actually also after finishing a platform for a grad job with a major sort of news agency. And I had to see a general knowledge test for them, which was quite intimidating because it was sort of not just Australia, but general like global sort of news. So that, and that I sort of, I did study up for a bit in terms of, you know, just reading the news and the weeks leading up to it. But even then, I, I don't think, you know, most of the things I was fairly well across anyway, just from my own sort of reading and research.
I mean, I have to be honest, I remember a couple of years ago when they had the city morning herald cadet ships and I remember that they had to do it, you have to do a test for that. And I didn't even get through the first round, so I didn't have to do it. But I remember being really worried about that test because you sort of get into a mindset of only reading what you're interested in. And yeah, I had no idea about politics at that stage.
Yeah, same. Interesting. Maybe. Yeah, I feel like we should give these candidates the benefit of the data a little bit.
Yeah, I mean, clearly, I were pretty lucky. We were in a cohort that didn't have cadet ships for most of the news outlets. So when we graduated, there was no, it was all just making your own laws. It'd be in the right place at the right time and sticking hands off.
It's your 50 grand hex deck. Yeah, I'll be good luck with that. You're listening to the Fourth Estate, where journalists talk about journalism. I'm Evie McGuire and joining me this week are Kerely Schwartz from Newscorp, Kate Orman from the New South Wales Law Society, and Jason Fellow from an ambiguous organization that he cannot name.
But somewhere in Leon, France, don't worry. If we chat to him enough, he may tell us an answer. Look, we have heard it all before, but I'm going to say it again. More and more journalists are losing their jobs to the current media landscape.
The more it happens, the more it gets talked about, but I really want to actually get the opinion from you guys, especially because we're just getting started in this industry and we only get told that there's enough job security. So in June this year, it was announced that the AAP was going to cut 25 positions. Most of those who work in the news and data areas were going to get made redundant. Just a month before that, ABC announced that we'll see 20 journalists and producers lose their jobs to make room for a new digital strategy, which will address several flaws in its publishing processes.
And we also can't forget what happens last year when Fairfax Media cut 125 editorial jobs, which was 25% of the entire editorial staff. And that obviously prompted a seven-day strike. Now, as dire as this all seems, we have three journalists here, four including Jason, who are just getting started. So I must ask the question, the scary question to you first, Kate, why are you a journalist?
And hearing about these job cuts, does it make you anxious? Yes, in a word. I remember when I was at university in our very first week, and now probably our very first lecture for journalism. One of the lecturers who is a very prominent journalist said to us all, she said, raise your hand if you want to be a journalist, and most of the room raise your hand.
And she said, right, 75% of you put your hands down. Those people who still have their hands up about that many will probably get a job. And we all kind of said, oh my God, she said, everyone else can sit at changing degrees because it's a tough, tough thing. And it was so frightening.
And if you're asking me if that gave me anxiety, yes, it gave me anxiety. And it gave a lot of us anxiety, a lot of my friends actually quit and went to PR the very first week. It seems to be a common trend. But yeah, it's definitely, it seems like there's more of a logical career progression.
And I think with all the changes that is happening in journalism, for example, when Kirely and I graduated, there was no cadet chips offered at any of the major outlets. So Fairfax, ABC, Newscorp all stopped offering cadet chips. So there was no kind of graduate position in our industry. We sort of just had to go and make our own way and that involved doing internships, unpaid internships, a lot of free work, kind of just hustling anyone to give us a bit of work.
And then obviously, when you did get a job, it was paid a lot less than other industries, which is frightening because for me, you know, I moved to Sydney to go to uni, and I was paying rent and I was trying to earn enough money to live in Sydney, but also I couldn't work for free. So I had to have a job at the gym or at Maccos or something to keep myself afloat. So they expect a lot from young journalists, but I say there's definitely opportunities there if you can put in the hard yards. And if you love it, you're going to do it.
And I loved it. And I, you know, had a law degree as well. And I could have gone and sat in an office and been a little cogging them in the corporate machine. But I didn't want to.
And if you really like it, you'll find a way. And I got to say now they are offering cadet chips and there are a lot of alternative media outlets. Like if you think of pedestrian, vox, junkie, all those new kind of young digital publishing agencies, they didn't really exist when I studied journalism. So there's a whole lot of new jobs being created just in different areas.
And perhaps not the traditional editorial positions that might have involved processes like start editing and multiple proofing processes that I think are maybe becoming a bit redundant in the 24-hour news cycle that is all online and all very rapid. And I think that that's probably where the jobs have been cut. Well, clearly to you, I mean, did you ever worry that you might lose your job? I haven't worried that I would lose my job, but that said, I've been a journalist for four and a half years and I had probably four and a half jobs.
So I've had all different ones. I agree with Kate that you have to get out and hustle. You have to make your own life. I was sort of the same.
I was from a small country town. I started in Melbourne and I moved up to Sydney with my last 1500 bucks. And I was lucky I had a two-month internship at Channel 9, which was unpaid. But I was fortunate that on the last Friday that I was there, the deputy dean's director of nine years looked at me and she said, can you get?
And I said to her, well, no, actually my internship finished on Friday. She's like, come on Monday, we'll pay you. It's fine. I was like, OK, so you sort of have to take a risk and be willing to put yourself out there a bit, I think.
And then in terms of losing a job, I mean, I started off doing idealistic month freelance, like sort of deal, I was full-time freelance and then I had to fall from contract and then I moved to a different company and then I was on contract for seven months and then I got off full-time job. And I think that you just have to seize opportunities as they come and be prepared to think broadly as well. My current job, I currently work as a commercial content editor, which, like Kate said, that's a job that didn't exist two years ago. And I love it and I enjoy it and I get to do all the favourite things I love about journalism.
I get to go out and meet people and interview really interesting people for stories. I get to come up with original story ideas every day. It's all the bits that I really love. It's just packaged in a slightly different box to what I perhaps anticipated when I first stepped out of university.
Speaking about these opportunities, Jason, you moved to another country. So like, what are your thoughts on this? Well, yeah, I totally agree with everything. It's really saying if you love it, you will find a way to find each other.
And you're always in the beginning. Yeah, jobs are being created every day almost as fast as they're being asked, hopefully after. But yeah, and the world's always going to make good stories to be honest with you. We're always going to need people who can explain to us conflict issues when we understand what generally means basically.
So definitely hustle, make your own mind. Repropose the take of this, prepare to upload your life and make your house. It could pay off. Well, according to an article by The Guardian, in 2013, it was estimated that more than 3,000 Australian journalists had lost their jobs in the past five years prior to that.
And that was in 2013. So it's places like News Corp now that have completely restructured their operations with most of their photographers now being made with them. Unfortunately, I guess my question to you, Curly, you surely hear about this all the time, but do you feel safe at Newscorp as opposed to Fairfax? Oh, that's a really tough question.
I don't really know how to answer that, because I'm really happy working at News Corp. I'm sorry. Did you do that? I think all big media companies at the moment are really rethinking their business strategies.
It's really important to stay current, and so much has changed over the last couple of years. We've had social media, and we've had all kinds of other interesting things, like a lot of platforms having digital publications now that they might know about in the future, and there's such different styles and different business models, different operating costs, all of those things that big businesses have to factor in. So I think it's definitely, I would say, a universal problem for big publishers at the moment, and it's something that I think everyone's just trying to do their best and try and see what works for them. It's very much evolving.
I guess in five years, I mean, who knows what it's going to look like. Yeah, and maybe that's why the smaller publishers are doing so well, because they're finding their niche and they're a little more agile, and they're a little more easier to downscale and change it up and do different things, whereas a big organization like News Corp of Fairfax, where everyone has their little jobs throughout the network, is maybe a lot harder to change and adapt. So, yeah. You're a multimedia journalist now.
It's not necessarily like the traditional journalist role. Yeah, yeah. I mean, is that what the future will look like for more journalists? Yeah, I definitely think it's about being able to do everything.
So, most of the jobs that I think are being cut from traditional news organizations are those jobs that are literally the sub who writes the headline, or although Daily Telly basically makes money off those headlines, but the ones where the editor does one little job and they don't do anything else, that's everything's becoming quicker and easier, and with technology, those kinds of things are becoming less necessary. So, where it used to be a full-time job, it's part of everyone else's job, and everyone has to do something, and everyone has to do everything. But also, when you're publishing a story now, when you're writing, you're thinking about the multimedia content, so you're thinking, how is this going to display on social media? What images do I need?
How can I make this better in terms of can I create some video content? People consume stories over multiple platforms now. So, yeah, I think multimedia journalism is definitely emerging. I mean, I know that we studied multi-platform journalism at university, and that was one of the subjects that I really enjoyed.
I think it's a really good tool to have if you can do it all. You're really employable. So, that's definitely my advice for young journalists. And even once you've got your first job, like I actually did a course about three weeks ago in Premiere Pro, which I never thought I would do.
I've always thought of myself as being a writer first, but I've actually edited a few little projects here and there, and I've actually loved it. So, I did a proper course after a few weeks ago, and it was fantastic. So, I'm hoping to use that moving forward. And how much more employable does that make you in a digital world?
I think it's a process. I have to practice first. It's a really hectic program. There's so many, I think literally this guy's the limit with that program.
So, I'm definitely going to need a bit of practice. But I think that's the whole thing. You just have to upskill as much as you can, and just make yourself as useful as possible to the organization you're working for. My producer made a really interesting note.
He said these job cuts that you just spoke about, it's kind of like looking at a block of Swiss cheese, like it looks right on the outside, but there are obvious holes. And Jason, over to you. I mean, what do you think about these job cuts? Do you think that they're severely hurting the quality of journalism?
Well, yes and no. I mean, at some of the more old school media organizations, if they're actually with your news call to the channel 7s, yes, because they're from the way I said they're still trying to work in the old way, it'll be less. And unfortunately, that does that. That has a time to thank all of you and emerging outlets, the smaller, more agile ones.
I definitely produce a great quality stuff with much fewer resources. So I think there's still hope, and as a bit of a girlfriend, you've just got to upskill, make sure you're across all the new changes. And don't talk about the low-income phenomena, I think, too. I think that's a really nice year.
I think outside the quality is an important story. And I think outside the box, do you think about, hey, because you work for a trade publication, which is something different, I mean, because a lot of people graduate and you think mass media straight away. Yeah. What made you say we wanted to do that?
Oh, yeah, exactly. That's exactly right. Clearly. So you think when you're at university that you can only work for ABC, channel 7, channel 9, channel 10, or Bayhag City, news call, basically.
And when there's actually so many more opportunities out there that maybe aren't advertised or maybe you didn't think of, so I work for the Law Society of New South Wales, and we basically produce a magazine and we have, we're working on like an online version of that magazine. But at the moment, it's a monthly magazine and we have social media content that I produce as well. So I read this in a box article this week that you sent to me. But one of the tips for young journalists was don't trade opportunity for prestige.
And I think that's really pertinent in the modern media world because you think that when you graduate, you're going to get a job and you hope you get a job at one of the big names. But really, there's so many jobs out there in smaller publications or working for companies in sort of content creation roles where you're going to get a lot more experience. So what I do is I work at the Law Society of New South Wales and I, we present a magazine every month called L.S.J. and that's a member magazine.
So if you think of members of an RMA, get a magazine every month, members of the Law Society. So lawyers in New South Wales get this magazine every month. And we also create multimedia content in terms of podcasts and videos for our social media and stuff. So I'm in a very small team.
Like there's me and three other journalists. And we all get to kind of do a whole lot of creative things that I don't think you would have the opportunity to do if you were just a small like, you know, writer in the reporting on, I don't know, whatever your round would be at Fairfax. Instead, I'm one minute, I'm creating a, I'm going to prison video and dogs in a prison project. Then I'm making a podcast that afternoon that I'm interviewing a former High Court judge or, you know, some celebrity chef who also has a law degree for a written story and taking photos for that.
And so I get all this experience on a whole range of platforms that, although I don't work for a big news outlet, I think the actual work I'm doing is perhaps more stimulating and fun. So I guess with the job cuts, then do you think that the worst is over? I think so, yeah. I actually do.
I think maybe they're, that finally the most of the news organizations seem to have got their head around the fact that they need a change in a doubt. And yeah, I think so. There'll always be changes. But I think now that the big companies realize that they need to be a little agile and ahead of the game in terms of where media's going.
I think it'll also be as audiences evolve a little bit. Everyone went a little bit crazy when Facebook can tweet and all that kind of like, oh, this is all I need in my life now. Like this is where I spend all of my time. And I think especially in light of recent developments, particularly in the US, people are starting to realize that perhaps actually maybe you do need media that's fact checked, you know, because it's hard to trust what's on your social media.
You don't know if it's true. You don't know if it's from a crazy fan page or a really particular political group or something. You don't know if it's very balanced and accurate. So I think actually audiences are maturing to go back to larger news outlets just because there's sort of more brands that they can trust.
I think there's a real craving for good quality reporting in terms of on your feeds. There's so much dog videos and other kind of crap online that through the noise, you can really discern a great story. And I look at outlets like the Guardian or the New York Times that do just excellent reporting. And I think there's a real craving for that and people are going to read that.
And there'll always be jobs for journalists who can do that really high quality stuff because everything else in the end can be manipulated by computers and AI or whatever. But computers can't tell a great story like that. They can't do the hashtag me too story that is going to go most viral. Grace, what about you over there?
What do you think? Yeah, I totally agree. Me too example is a really, really good one now that I think that. That's just something that you can't replicate without good storytellers.
You know what I mean? And without really digging into the issue. And it's a really great example of how people still have an appetite for important stories, for they want to get into the issues that really affect their everyday lives. And I think that's a really great example of why we should maintain hope.
But is this hunger for quality news? I guess why are these companies still cutting journalists? Well, yeah, that's a good question. But I guess there's always going to be an ebb and flow.
And maybe in five years, they'll start hiring hundreds more. I guess the appetites of the audiences are changing at a faster pace than the media organisations can keep up with. Do you know what I mean? So once the news organisations stop chasing their tail, we can get back into the hardcore story.
You're listening to the Fourth Estate, where journalists talk about journalism. I'm Edie McGuire, and joining me this week are Kila Rishwartz from News Corp, Kate Orman from the New South Wales Law Society, and Jason Vello from the Press Office of an International Organisation which shall not be named, but I am working on it, don't worry. So in an article written by the ABC, a former To Womba journalist, Nancy Webb, has decided to ditch journalism and become a nun. Miss Webb plans on unpugging herself from the daily news cycle, social media technology and life as we know it, and embark on what she sees as a calling from God.
Now, I don't think there could be a bigger career change. I was also shocked to find out that it takes eight years to become a nun. Incredible. I struggled studying journalism for three.
So I want to start with you, Chase, again, because you did kind of do a similar thing in terms of drastic change. You didn't become a nun, but you did have to do a drastic change in moving countries. I mean, do you think Nancy's career change is a reflection on the current journalism industry? Well, I think Nancy's got a great story.
I think you should write a book. You should write a book. Totally. But I didn't become a nun, but you could say I went to the dark side going into the sort of PR Press officer type situation rather than journalism.
But I think these days there's nothing wrong with a career change. I mean, if journalism is what you love, stick with it. But if you're not feeling it, there's nothing wrong with getting out and trying something new. That's one of the great things about working these days is that you, there's no sticking where you're attached to changing professions.
And it's actually can actually be a really good thing. In the article, Nancy said that she finds the parallels between news reporting and becoming a nun. Saying quote, it's all about sharing the news. Carely, what do you think?
That's probably a different style of news. What? I don't know. Would you ever consider such a...
would you ever consider a massive creation? Well, I mean, I don't know if the convent is for me, but I think what she's doing is amazing. And I have to say, I mean, it's sort of one of the perks of growing up millennial, isn't it? That this guy's your oyster and you're told for your whole life that if you work hard, you can do whatever you want.
You know, probably the first generation has really been told that and had it be true, you know, because anything's possible. Like Kate was saying before, I mean, I have a lot of degree too. I could have been a lawyer. That's still a possibility.
I don't know. Or I might go and move to Bali and rent out kayaks or something. You never know where life's going to take you and I guess for who? It's probably an unexpected direction, but I certainly wish her all the best.
Well, God, Zack, you, why not? That's true. You've said anything. It's perfect.
I mean, both of you combined your degree so you have a journalism and law degree. Do you think that it's more common to do that and it almost gives you more of a safe net? Ah, yeah, I think so. And it's funny that Vox article that I was talking about before mentioned in its tips.
Don't be a lawyer. Don't be a lawyer. I think that was an American article because I hear that the law degrees there are like hundreds of thousands of dollars and you won't be paying it off for the rest of your life. But I could say, and I think he really agrees with me, doing the added degree and especially a law degree has been my ticket into a lot of opportunities that I wouldn't otherwise had.
It sets you apart. It's a big highlight on your resume that says this person can think, literally, they're, you know, they've got to drive them disciplined enough to complete two degrees in five years. They can focus on facts and decide what's really important and just synthesise a huge amount of information into something that's actually comprehensible. You can do that with that law degree though, right?
You can. I would agree with Kate. Probably for me, the best thing I got out of that was just that my, my, the way I approach problems, the way I attack problems is really based on that whole destruction style that I learned in my law degree and I found it extremely valuable as a journalist. And I think also, and in terms of even just reporting, also what Kelly said is 100% correct.
Like finding information is so much quicker and easier once you've done a law degree. It's hard to explain, but your brain changes and stuff. But also just in reporting politics and core cases and police news, if you've done a law degree, you actually understand what it is going on and you're careful to get things right and understand why you don't need to allegedly say that allegedly this happened. There's a lot of journalists out there that are reporting things incorrectly, especially core cases.
And I can't help but think, oh, some lawyers reading that and very irritated and I'm reading it irritated. So there's a lot of other people that probably are. And I just think, you know, so much of our news is related to law, politics is lawmaking. And most politicians are law, many politicians are lawyers as well.
If you can match them when you're interviewing them, then I think that gives you a huge edge. Jason, what about you? I mean, you didn't study a combined law degree. You think you needed to combine your to go with law?
Yeah. So I studied international studies, which gave me a, the opportunity to learn not the language, I learnt French. And so it wasn't law, but it definitely did widen my perspective on things in terms of seeing things from a more international perspective and, you know, understanding other cultures and other people's languages, which gives you a new perspective on things. So it wasn't law, but law would have been very helpful, I'm sure.
Exactly. And these days, the world's so interconnected. So it's really important to have that sort of wider perspective. So I would say definitely if you, if someone's out there thinking about, they want to be a journalist, but they also are interested in law or the interest in economics or whatever, combine your degree.
I think there's nothing but a positive that could come out of it. I have to agree with that. Because I think also when I studied journalism at my university, most of the subjects were very process oriented. So it was like, here's how you put a TV bulletin together.
Here's how you produce a radio segment. Here's how you write a feature. Here's how you, whatever. It was all very much how to.
And I think it was nice to color it in with something that I have a bit of, I guess, specialist knowledge in it. And it's probably, I mean, exactly the same with international studies, because now, you know, more than the average person about, you know, the UN and international relations and maybe have a particular interest in trade or something, you know, geography or something. But I think it's just nice to color it in with the specialty. Mm, definitely.
I want to go full circle and chat quickly about where we started off. So we're all from different universities around Australia and have all studied different journalism degrees of thoughts. How important were your degrees to your studies in what you're doing right now? Very important.
You know, just on a practical level, every employer that I've been to has looked at my resume and said, great, you've got a journalism degree. So, yeah, you need a degree. So my experience is probably a little bit different. I would say the most valuable thing that I got out of university was a network or the start of a network.
Because I came from a very small town, so like 1500 people in Western Victoria, more sheep than people. Like, I kind of like, you know, peak hour if there's, you know, five other cars on the road at the same time. Or five other sheep. Or five other sheep, exactly.
So for me, I came into, I guess, the journalism world, not knowing a soul. I didn't know any journalist. I didn't know any editors. I didn't know anyone.
And I got really lucky in that in my final year of uni, well, actually, probably my last years, I had two amazing lecturers and journalism, both of whom were former BBC editors. One was, I think, a foreign editor and one had worked, I used to produce like 6pms or something anyway, both former BBC editors. And they were really encouraging and really inspiring, but also they were aware of opportunities that I had never even heard of. And if I'd been scrolling through a seagull something, I might not have found.
Like, for example, one of my lecturers recommended me for an award right after I finished uni, which I was very fortunate to have won. And then, so that's what led me to Sydney, it gave me an eight-week internship at Channel 9. That led to my first job. And then from there, every job I've had since has been through a network of people I've known.
And so it sort of always kicked off with that first person who sort of had a bit of faith in me at uni, which, I mean, I wouldn't admit her had, like, those two lecturers had not been to the university. I went to. So I think that was really important. Well, on networking, Jason, I assumed that you did a lot of internships throughout your degree.
Was it the internship that you learned the most from or was it the degree itself? That's a really interesting question. I mean, definitely on the internships, I learned a lot, a lot, a lot, but those doors were only open because I was studying journalism, you know, because my lecturers had said, oh, there's an internship going here at TUEE was my first internship, which unfortunately doesn't exist at radio station anymore. But that's where I cut my teeth.
I learned so much there, but I would not have been able to get there with it were it not for the degree. And I wouldn't have been able to, you know, give them some added value, I guess, if I wasn't studying, if I didn't have a basic understanding of how journalism works, how to write a story. I think it's really is a balance. I wouldn't say just do one or the other.
I think really, if you be a journal study, but also take advantage of all the internship opportunities you can. I'd love to end the show on a really light positive enthusiastic note to all those other young donors out there who do want to pursue this career. So I guess for all of you, I'll start off with you, Kelly, first. How do you maintain hope at the young?
I don't maintain hope. She doesn't. She doesn't. She doesn't.
She's just like, I'm just like, I'm just like, I'm just like, I'm just like, no, all the time. No, I don't know. I actually love my job. I'm excited to see how the industry develops in coming years.
I really enjoy learning new things like upskilling, doing new courses where I can, interviewing new people and just making connections with them, and also like within the company and the industry as well. I think I don't know. I sort of enjoy all those aspects and I feel really good about those moving forward. So I'm excited to see what's going to happen.
I think that one of the great things in journalism is we are all really great, interesting, curious people. So journals are very happy to meet other people and there's a lot of networking events you can attend and that always fills me with hope and confidence about our industry because we're really supportive of each other. There's a lot of job cuts going on, but there's always people at these events that I go to that are like, hey, I've heard of an opportunity here or I need freelancers. What do you know?
Who do you know? It's a lot about who you know. So I think if a young journalist, my one bit of advice would be, you know, get off the couch, go to the industry event, follow the MEAA, follow the Walkley Foundation, join the things, pay the 10 bucks, like have the free drinks and whatever, but just get out there and meet people because most of your jobs will come from your network. And it also just inspires me and goes to show like, yes, there's hope for us all.
I always feel really encouraged after I go to things like that. And also, a lot of people at those events are young journalists, but you also occasionally meet someone that you've really looked up to for a long time, which isn't really cool. I've met some of the most inspiring mentors at those events and we've maintained connections, like you know, more fun or senior journalists. They're always willing to sort of lend a hand and take you for a coffee and introduce you to some editor that you really would love to meet.
And I'm just so continually impressed by how much time they'll lend to young journalists. So go for it. Even you two met at a Walkley event. We did.
I met at a Walkley event with Curly, who was an editor who needed a freelancer and I did some freelancers work for her. I was just for each other. Jason, do you have any final words of wisdom over there in France? I don't know about words of wisdom, but in terms of maintaining hope, I think the most important thing to keep in mind is that if you want to become a journalist, you can do it and you can make change in the world.
It is really a very empowering profession. Even though, yes, there are changes. There's always going to be changes. There'll always be job parts.
There'll always be new challenges. But you can make change and you can make it. You can make a real change. We couldn't have ended on more of a positive note.
So that's it from us on the floor of the stage this week. Thanks to my guest Curly Schwartz, Kate Orman and Jason Fellow in Lyon in France. Next week, Peter Frey will be back in the host seat. Make sure you're subscribed to floor of the state on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a few things in between.
We'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Facebook or Twitter. Our handle is floorofthestage.au. My name's Eva McGuire. Thanks for listening.