One day you're negotiating with suppliers. The next, you're installing a shelf in the back room. Running a business means moving in many directions all the time. TD's new small business banking accounts are built for how your business moves.
It's how we're making banking more human. Hello, welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism coming to you from 2CR and Sydney on Gadigal lands of the organization right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I'm the co-director of the Center for Media Transition at the University of Tennessee, Sydney.
And my producers today are Anthony Dockrell and Michael Jones. This week on Fourth Estate we're all about your right to know. On Monday the country's papers in a coordinated campaign landed on breakfast tables around the nation with redacted text on the front page. It was a stark reminder that press freedom in Australia is under attack like never before.
And today we're going to ask, has the right to know campaign move the needle on this debate and how does the news media get the public on side for this campaign? Also, the Walkley Award nominees have been announced and there's a little bit more about that in a second, but the Walkley Award nominees have been announced and they are the top gongs for excellence in journalism. And this year they include the Al Jazeera story, a scoop, called How to Sell a Massacre. In that story you may recall, a journalist went undercover, not revealing his true identity to expose the very disturbing links between the National Rifle Association and the United States and the One Nations, Pauline Hanson's One Nation party.
But in doing so the journalist broke the ethical rules that the Emmy double A and the Walkley is normally followed, namely that a journalist must identify themselves as such. So the question really is did the Walkley judges get this right? Making an exception to this piece of journalism was it a question of the rules be damned? We're also going to explore several aspects of indigenous representation in the news media.
Firstly, how indigenous voices are represented inside of newsrooms and secondly how indigenous issues are reported. And time permitting, we should touch on the big business story of the media week that proposed approaches of regional TV channel prime by channel seven. Is this another blow for media diversity? Or just a sign of the times when the only way to survive is to keep getting bigger and bigger.
To discuss this and more, we are joined by two Walkley Award nominees. So no pressure and no conflict of interest here and certainly no jinxing. So Michael Kosio is a fourth estate alumni and a journalist with the City Morning Herald and the age has just been nominated alongside Jennifer Duke for their work on covering the firing of former ABC managing director Michelle Guthrie. Hello Michael.
Hello. Hi. Hello, Lorena. And we asked a bless here you go.
He's a scoop me and we're so blessed to have the indigenous editor of the Guardian Arena, Adam, on the line from Alice Springs. Hello Michael. Hello Peter. And just in case you missed it, Lorena has also been nominated for the Walkley Awards this year for what is an amazing and excellent confronting and essential work called the Killing Time of Massacre Map.
Yeah, so best of luck both of you. Without we're not going to talk at length about the Walkley's because I, you know, we'll talk about the one you've won one. That would be weird. So let's talk about the right to know.
It's not often the media in this country speaks with one voice, but this week it did just that. Your right to know campaign aims to raise awareness, but also change the law and how journalism is conducted in this country. I mean, as we all know so far this year, news corp journalists and Nikas Smithos on the ABC have been raided by federal police in the move. Many inside the media see a clear warning to journalists and whistleblowers.
And we've had, for instance, an example of the ABC chair, Ida Butro's among others saying that it's those raids have already had a chilling effect on the whistleblowers coming forward. And this is on top of government that is now operating in what it seems to me anyway, and ever more opaque, sorry, and secret fashion, stamping top secret on documents so that it makes them harder and harder to get under FLI. Michael, let's start with you. You're kind of happy, but you're surprised by the campaign this Monday, and I guess what outcome are we hoping to see?
Well, I wasn't that surprised because I didn't know it was coming. Also, it's kind of been brewing for quite a few months now, certainly ever since those dramatic raids that you mentioned. So I think it's a good thing, like any journalist, I'm constantly frustrated by attempts to contain and withhold information, sometimes reporting on the Home Affairs Department and the Immigration System, you're constantly banging your head against the wall to try and get anything out of these people, often when it's just not even when it's kind of innocuous, it's not even, you know, Watergate or anything. My friend and colleague, well, not colleague, my friend and fellow journalist Paul Carpet, the Guardian, was just this week trying to work out whether an invoice or a yearly statement included GST or not, and it's taken more than 24 hours just to get an answer on that basic question.
So you encounter this sort of stuff all the time, and it's great that we are pushing back against it in a very vocal and very forthright way. I guess we're on a bit of a unity ticket here, but, I mean, what do you think of Scott Morrison in Parliament this week, kind of trying to sit both sides of the fence? You know, he kind of said he was in favour of press freedom, but eventually in the same breath, he said, oh, no one's above the law. So how does that sit?
You know, what's he trying to run both sides of the race here? I don't know. Is it surprising that politicians try to have an H-Y-Bets? No, no, not at all.
I guess it's up to us to really question about what that means, whether we have access to politicians to probably answer those questions, is what I think is of concern to journalists, is the accountability that politicians have to the public via art, because we're shrinking. So people can ponder what he means until we have an opportunity to ask him, probably we can only speculate. Well, of course, and there's a few other questions we'd like to ask him, like, did he try and get Brian Houston to the White House, but he seems very good at managing the media. What's your take on the Morrison government in those terms, in terms of not making themselves open to scrutiny?
I think if governments can avoid scrutiny, they do. So I'm not going to let the territory know that it'll be removed for federal politics this week, but what I can tell you about the military government is they don't have it very very badly, the F-O-I regime. They don't have disclosure laws for their departments, which is a common thing in the Commonwealth. You can go to a Commonwealth Department of Education and they will offer you a disclosure law of any and all F-O-I or freedom of any sort of information application that is in May.
The territory doesn't do that, and it's been very, very reluctant to provide that sort of information to journalists. It also doesn't have adequate removal of protection. There is no specific legislation up here to protect removal of blowers. So I think if governments of all type are able to avoid public scrutiny, that's often what they prefer to do.
And yet, at the same time, they say they're in favour of media, bring you to freedom. Michael, the New York Times has been cited a few times in this debate because there was a piece written by Damien Cave, the MIT person, who is saying that Australia is the most secret of democracy in the world. Is that your take on it? I mean, that seems a massive claim to me, to be honest with you.
Well, yeah, I mean, I don't have the knowledge that will be required to make that assessment. And if Damien Cave does, then perhaps he does, I don't know. I mean, look, I think we, you know, let's apply the same skepticism that we as journalists would apply to any other campaign that we might encounter. I mean, you know, Morrison is kind of, you know, he's making a reasonable point, but half the readers I reckon agree with just judging by the feedback.
A lot of people out there say why the journalists think that they should be above the law. And actually, unless you are going to, as a journalist or as a media organisation, make the claim that journalists should be completely exempt from all aspects of these laws, then, and you could make that claim if you wanted to. But unless you are going to say that, then you have to draw a line somewhere and you have to write a law that grants journalists, you know, particular rights, but not car-lock. But I was not arguing that the journalists above the law, are they?
I mean, this is a kind of classic red herring, isn't it? A political tactic to suggest it. Well, I mean, we're certainly arguing that we shouldn't have the same law. Sure, we should be able to do our job.
Yeah. And we should say what we're saying is that the law does not offer the public. Mm. Adequate capacity to understand the decisions that are being made in their name.
Indeed. So it's not about journalists being above the law, it's about journalists being able to operate within a reasonable law or a series of laws. And that I think is what they're saying, we're not saying that we're above the law. And it's a classic political distraction tactic to even say that.
Yes, well, that's right. Just on that point, you mentioned the public. I mean, one aspect of this, I mean, let's call this way, displayed, is that journalists and politicians are both not particularly held in high esteem by the public. So how are we going to get the view first layer in the view, Michael?
How are we going to get the public on side in this debate? I think appealing to their interest. So we, and I think some of those sort of advertising that come out this last week goes to this. So saying to them that we would not have an aged care, well, condition, not the reporting that journalists have exposed the treatment of our elderly in nursing homes.
We would not have an investigation into the Donsey atrocity that the Don Dale used the pension center if it hadn't been for the work of journalists. But the public cares about the way if citizens are treated in this country, then it needs a robust media. It needs a healthy public broadcaster or broadcasters and a healthy media recastions and part of that is being able to operate under reasonable legislation. The Americans are quite astonished when they, when you try to explain to them the restrictions about information, they have a very different, they have a very public system.
I'm talking to a generalist in Norway who talk about jealousy day, which is an annual day in Norway where everybody takes a turn to play public. And basically that is a screaming. I love the Norwegian. That's how public they want to be about.
Everybody takes a turn to play public. Yeah, they are very interesting. We have a long way to go there on that level. Michael, you spend quite a time in Canberra.
Do you think part of the problem here is that the political class and the journalism class are just too chummy? You spend too much time together? No, I don't think it's that. I think you see this all the time, especially around the time of the Winter War when people start whinging about how they are all just hanging out together and enjoying each other's company and they should be out there at the barricades.
24-7 seems to be the view of some. That's what the news cycle is. I mean, I think that's rubbish. No, there's no.
It's not chummy. Any journalist with a salt would kill for a story that brings down a minister or something. So it's not. I don't think it's a problem that we're too close to the political class.
But I do think it is a problem for this campaign. And I think the campaign is pitched in exactly the right way. It's about the stories. It's about the public's right to know.
It's right there in the name. But I do not think we're ever going to get to the stage where people are marching down. In favour of journalism. I just don't think it's going to be proven wrong.
I'm sure we'd all have to be proven wrong in that. Can we move on a little bit to the Walkleys talking about journalism? And the Walkley Award nominations came out this past week. And one of the nominations for I think Scuba the Year was the Algia Zero story, how to sell a massacre.
So for those of you who may not know about the story involves an Algia Zero reporter, Roger Mueller, working undercover and travelling with One Nations James Ashby and Steve Dix in Two America where it's filmed, where Algia Zero filmed and participated in One Nations attempts to gain money from the National Rifle Association, the NRA and other gun rights lobbies. And the couple elements here to tease out, Lorena, there's no one's arguing about this, the reporter went undercover, brought the ethical guidelines. So was it justified? Was it the means justifying the ends in this case?
I'm going to start a little bit earlier. It was Roger Mueller. Roger Mueller. The guy who went undercover was technically a journalist.
He was a mate of the journalist. He was associate of the investigation editor. Yeah. He tried to be because he had he had appeared and he's been making a game.
He's been thinking that sort of a role. But I'm actually talking about it. It was absolutely scary. And I do think in a way the things that it revealed were in the public interest.
I'm not sure that I can comment on the ethics of it. I wasn't involved in making editorial petitions around that program. But I have to say as a viewer, it was absolutely compelling. It was compelling.
But just on that point, I mean, I guess the question really boils down to this. And as you say, we don't really know because we weren't on the team doing it. But was there any other way of getting that information and doing that story? I guess from the outside it looks not.
Yeah, well, can I keep it tucked, but I doubt it? I think those sort of candid comments, you can't get them any other way. That's true. I've just been with the police that's been the police of you, I guess, to entrap people who, you know, the other one that brings to mind is the critic gambling India in the bribery, you know, match the king's scandal.
That was the kind of point that was made without the knowledge of another person. I think in the US it's quite legal in certain states to record a conversation provided one side of the conversation that's been recorded. Not the case here. That's right.
What do you think, Michael? The ethical breach here? I mean, I won't go as far as to say it's unethical, but I would say that it definitely straddled the border. Yes, push it.
And I say that because, I mean, you know, they did hire this guy who was a pet food business owner in an hour or something, you know, five minutes before he was doing this. So, you know, he's not a lifeline. We shouldn't hold that against him. No, but you know, he's something that comes from outside the industry.
Yeah. Now he's operating under the direction of Piet Charlie, the investigations editor. So, you know, you've got someone. But the long history and the rest of the helm.
Yep. That's right. And he's just his judgment. Yep.
But, you know, you also then have to face up to the fact that, well, you know, they did kind of bring these people over here to the US where they then, you know, had meetings with the NRA. Now the central allegation against them was that they went there to solicit donations from the NRA. Now you talked to one nation people about it. They're very unhappy with the way that was portrayed because they, the way they see it, they went over there to have meetings to learn, you know, stuff from the NRA, whatever it is you want to learn from them.
And then, you know, more like got them drunk and they started going about it wouldn't help them. So, does that matter more on the traffic? Yeah. I think we certainly say that there seems to be some entrapment there.
You know, whether they, I mean, you know, are we going to spend all night crying over this? You know, there are idiots, they've got themselves into the situation. The footage kind of tells the story. But you know, on the other hand, this is something that, yeah, this really straddles the border of what would be considered ethical insurance.
Just to put you on the spot, are you going to be happy if it wins the walk? Oh, I thought it was. Sure, I'll be happy for them. What's it up against?
I don't have the full list of filming. Are you happy if it wins the walkley? I can't. I can't.
It'll be great because it'll be controversial. Yeah, it'll be a good night in the walkies of that. Yeah, yeah, sorry. I just, I just, maybe you'll hit the road.
I mean, you'll get a walkley. I mean, get on the Peter, what's her face? Kretland, tell me, just on this, just to finish on this. What about your own sort of ethics here?
So would you, you know, put on a wig and a pair of dark sunglasses, Lorena, to go undercover to get a yarn? It would not be my only approach to a story. No, I would say no. Okay.
But part, if it were part of a squeeze of other measures, the politicians say, then I would think about it. But upfront, no, absolutely not. Okay. Interesting.
Well, yeah, I don't have a problem with camouflaging my identity because I think the general gist of it is if you're observing what's happening anyway, then that's fine. I mean, when you're creating situations for people, when you're engineering circumstances, that's in trauma, not playing dress ups and secretly recording stuff, I think that's okay. Yeah, because I guess the distinction here is can you go undercover and kind of keep your hands clean? I mean, you know, is it a smart?
Yeah, if you're bearing witness, that seems much more reasonable to me than if you're kind of engineering situations. If you're getting people drunk and what have you. Yeah. And if you're bringing them over to the US to kind of make connections and all this sort of thing, I mean, he was the connection guy.
He was the link. He reported to be this guy who was in with the NRA. So that's why One Nation believes it was a setup. Yeah.
Sorry. I'm going to say you can't publish a report anything that you have collected by means where you haven't declared who you are and who you work for. I would never do that. So we're put on the Wigan glass.
Right. And we aren't declaring to people what I intend to do and who I work for. Yeah, essentially. This is just a final point, I guess, is that it doesn't, it isn't covered by the ethics laws, the AME-AA laws, all the bookies and guidelines.
So does that mean then we need to change our ethics guidelines? Very possibly. I mean, I agree. You should never miss, we should never misrepresent yourself as someone else.
I mean, I'm happy to go and like sit the back of the lecture theater in Wigan, you know, including kind of, you know, that kind of undercover. But you know, if you're actually going to tell people that you're someone that you're not, I think that definitely crosses the line. You can do that. You can't publish it.
You can't report it. That would be the line you're drawing. Yes, okay, you could do that if that gave you information, which you then, you know, declared in subsequent reporting kind of thing. Yeah.
Well, that was a pretty fabulous week. Well, there's some great weeks around. Okay, let's move on. Before we get to this proposed frying purchase by seven, I did want, I mean, I've got Lorina Allen on the phone and I did want to talk a little bit about Aboriginal representation in the news media.
I mean, that's been a long standing point of contention, point of debate. And it seems to be changing a little bit your appointment at the Guardian. I think is an example of that. What do you think, Lorina?
Aboriginal representation inside of mainstream newsrooms, you know, there's a little bit of, there's a few positive signs, or am I being a little bit too optimistic? What's your thinking on that? Maybe a little bit, I'll commit it to it. Okay.
Although it's really encouraging to see that the data is being distributed under the couple of minutes before the Herald Tower, which is fantastic. It's a bit of more than 30 years before you then, that they're employed and Aboriginal persons in the Herald. I guess that's a great legacy of the Chagritha murder and bishop, another Walkley winner. And it's great that the Herald has seen that there is value in employing Aboriginal journalists and seeing the extra angles and the extra access that they can bring to the story in the individual.
So that's really encouraging. But I think the rest of the media, my country will be book-only at a commercial TV. Now that's a huge step forward. It's great to be the Guardian.
I'm really, really happy to be there, to be in a mainstream media organisation that is going to do this kind of work. That is a big change, that is a big step forward. But the public broadcasters need to be there again when it comes to the other city on air and diversity of content. I think having worked for decades at the ABC, the ABC is very well aware of how far it's come in terms of Indigenous representation, that just how far it also needs to go in fully incorporating Indigenous viewpoints and Indigenous commentators into their news coverage.
Yeah, as a general statement, journalism is a very white profession. Very, very white and very middle-class. So, yeah, Newterans are very monocultural. And that's true for people from all sorts of walks of life.
And that's not just a problem for Aboriginal reporters, that's across the board. Yeah, it is. And it does affect what gets reported, right? I think it does.
Well, yes, I think it does. One of the great things about being at the Guardian is having the opportunity to do these kind of big data projects that really we hope are driving attention and driving change on issues that Aboriginal people are really, really concerned about. So whether that's true, selling about his field or policing justice and death and custody, those things that matter to people. So I think Newterans wanted to cover this stuff, but they don't know how.
And they know that the old ways of doing it aren't the right way anymore. So I think it's about them reaching out to Indigenous journalists that are, how do we do this? Yeah, because I think you're right. I don't think there's a, well, maybe there is, but in my opinion, in my experience as well, there's not a conscious sort of anti-O Aboriginal people.
Just as you say, that most newsrooms don't seem or haven't seen any up to now, seem to get there. It's just a question of, I don't think it's like a willingness, but maybe I'm wrong on that. Michael, you've been in the newsrooms, what do you think? Oh, I think you only need to look at the sort of, whatever people do, those all newsroom photographs, sometimes for campaigns like the ones we just discussed, you know, you can always see it in the kind of diversity or lack thereof.
So I wouldn't have really had much to add other than, yes, it's, you know, we're very happy to be hiring two new Indigenous reporters, reporter and a visual journalist. It's a visual, yeah. It's a hats off to Lisa Davies, I editor for really driving that with the Jyrts Nelson money, which is fantastic. And alongside the campaign that we started a little while ago about for Indigenous recognition.
So I think they're positive signs. Yeah, long way to go though. OK, let's moving on. You'll listen to the fourth estate with me, Peter Frey.
And fantastic guest this week. Michael Kosil from City Morning Herald the Age. I nearly said Fairfax, but I can't say that anymore. Nine Entertainment Group and Marina Allen from The Guardian.
There's a big news story in the sort of business side of media this week. And that is the moves by the Seven West Media to buy the regional broadcaster of Prime in the 64 million dollar bid. So Prime holds free TV licenses in regional news as well. So Victoria and Western Australia, the ACT, Southeast Queensland and the Gold Coast.
The new boss of Seven West Media said that he was going to start buying and start merging and he's doing exactly that. What do we make of it though, Marina? You're out there in the bush, you're out there in regional areas where there's not a lot of diversity. And here we have a regional broadcaster being sold up by a big city based one.
I think it's hard for regional broadcasters to survive without that bigger parent company popping them up because it's really hard to get advertising. It's hard to get eyeballs on here. I'm proposing it at Freedom Air Station. I think those regional assertions are learning, because they're on the front line of this new on-demand viewing that is really killing freedom ATV.
So it's in a way the industry is under so much pressure changing so quickly. They're not in a way not to thrive, but the regional stations are the first to go. It's very sad for local journalists and it's very sad for like, essentially the rest of the journalists. And because some of the best providers support is who work in the National News Media have covered people's local politics and showing them over the council and coming up through so it's the most urgent when you see those local stations moving there and they're comparing to cover local issues.
Well, I think it did right. I mean, it's a real problem when you're faced with this choice, you either get big or die. I guess to be fair, to be fair to the somewhere media, we don't know the details of what they're going to do with Prime. Obviously there will be cost savings.
There'll be probably the first thing they'll say, we'll be cost savings in the back end among the accountants and what have you. Rather than frontline people, but we have seen last year or so closures of in the Wind Network as well in a place like Dubbo and such. So yeah, it's not the easiest times, is it, Michael? No, well, I mean, I can hardly object to take over that nature, I suppose.
But I think at least our experience with nine shows that it doesn't have to always be negative. I mean, it has cost cut in the back end, as you say. So far, the newsrooms are getting along pretty well. So one wants to be optimistic about these things as much as possible.
I must admit, for a long time, I thought Prime was seven as a kid going up because he'd kind of gone to these regional teams. But they're affiliated, yes. And then I eventually weren't. They were separately owned.
So I mean, I don't have a huge philosophical problem with it, you might say. But it's only really ever as good as the judgment of companies' leaders. Yes, OK. Well, we'll see.
You went and see. Before we leave the show, I do want to ask you both about the stories that you're working on. Or actually, in your case, Michael, it's been about a year since we had all that turmoil in the ABC, which you reported to the session extent you've got this more clean on the nation. How do you feel like the ABC is going under ITA SL?
Well, I don't follow it so close to the communications round, but just talking to ABC people kind of very occasionally writing about it, it seems like they at least have the spring in their step might be putting it too far. But they're not particularly springy. No, look, I mean, it's all going to depend on what happens for the funding negotiations. I suspect I don't think Morrison particularly wants another huge kind of cultural war fight over the ABC.
I mean, I could be wrong about that. But we'll see, obviously, in the budget. But I think at least they have someone who is close to Morrison in ITA, not in the way that just a film. And Malcolm Turnbull will close.
But someone who I think he respects her judgment. Yeah, I think that's the same language. He very much wanted her to have that job. He was presented with other options.
He said, no, I want IDA. So there's someone in the chair of the ABC who's got the ear of the Prime Minister on behalf of the ABC. And that can only be a good thing. And I think you're seeing generally throughout the staff of the ABC, they're pretty content with David Anderson as a new managing director.
So, you know, I mean, we'll see what happens in the budget. Yeah, I will. Let me know. You missing ABC?
Yeah. Of course, it's like my home, really. I mean, I worked there for 27 years. Oh, well, yeah.
Of course, I miss it. I'm a big fan of the ABC. So I'm working at the Guardian while the MD and the GM at the board was the job. It was a bit like watching the house burnout from across the street.
So it was quite frustrating to watch. And I was getting to take something from my dear friends who were there in the burning house. So it could be the new MD and the new chair, so cooling down and counting down and producing a United Front to negotiate with this government, which is a hot start for the ABC. There's no two ways about it.
No, it's been seen in the federal police into radio. It's in the declaration, I think. The ABC went with it beautifully. And I have to say, John Mimes, live tweeting the whole event from the room, was just the most gripping tweet.
I think it was the special use of the platform, was it? It certainly was. So it's encouraging me to try to have popular research, at least it's a high-profile privacy. And they hope that she has the kind of media experience and clout and respect that the person in the job needs to see the ABC.
Last question for you. I think what's the next story in terms of that flows out of the massacre map? Right. We're in a process now of releasing the last lot of data for the year.
So we've got another 55 to add to the map that we've been working with the University of Newcastle to refine. There's a lot more that still make their application, but we'll be updating it in the next couple of weeks. We've got new data and some new reporting. Great, we'll watch the space.
In the meantime, have a great time in Alice. When are we going to start seeing that? I guess you're there for the, I'm part of you there for the closure of Iluar really. Yeah, so Mike Bell and I are here in Alice, talking to people about beef and climate change.
I mean, I'm sitting in a car, I don't know if you're in the engine running, but the outside temperature is 38. And it's half that far in the afternoon. That's pretty hot for this time of year. So we're going out to all around Friday for the closure of the climb.
Yeah, well, great story. I've got to thank you so much for your time and taking time out of your road trip. And I'd love to have you on again and really best of luck with the Walkleys and best of luck for the rest of the week. They're in and from the Guardian.
And in the studio, Michael Cozziol. Always great to see you. Pleasure is always. I hope so.
And again, best of luck with the Walkley nomination and everything else. What's your next story? Oh, I could possibly tell you. No, I'll have some good stories and Sunday's, I think, and buy it at all.
Buy it at all. And the final is, and the front page won't be redacted. Or maybe it will. Well, it will be a really good story.
Thank you, and thank you, Michael, for your time. And thank you to everyone for listening to the Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the Studio's 2CR and heard across the country on the community radio network. And Fourth Estate is made possible thanks to the support from the Community Broadcasting Foundation.
Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app. So you can hear us talk about media and politics and a few things in between your leisure. We'll be back with more in very soon. But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter, where our handle is Fourth Estate AU.
A big thanks to my producers. I have two of them this week, Anthony Dockrell and Michael Jones. And my name is Peter Frey, and thanks very much for listening.