Skip to content
A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime podcast artwork

PODCAST · society

A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime

by Courtney Fenner & Amanda Cronin

Best Friends Amanda and Courtney deep dive into true crime cases with an empathetic standpoint. They focus awareness mainly on lesser known crimes and crimes against those deemed extra vulnerable. Occasionally, the hosts will cover more well known cases due to relevance or a particularly fascinating element. The bees (the honeybee) is seen as synonymous with victims and survivors. We must always protect the bees. We must always let their voices be heard. We must not stifle the buzz of the bees, so bee vigilant, for when you mess with the bees, you get the hive. Welcome to A Nefarious Nightmare. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/a-nefarious-nightmare-true-crime--5908360/support.

Publisher-supplied feed metadata · PodParley refreshed Oct 16, 2026 · Source feed

Episodes

  1. PART TWO - New Year, New Binge

    Thank you so much Allison and Johanna for including us in this fantastic lineup of hidden gems! We love seeing a collaborative, inclusive and supportive space within this community, and cheers to us all for new partnerships, new friendships, truth and JUSTICE FOR ALL. This is part two of your...

  2. PART ONE - New Year, New Binge

    Thank you so much Allison and Johanna for including us in this fantastic lineup of hidden gems! We love seeing a collaborative, inclusive and supportive space within this community, and cheers to us all for new partnerships, new friendships, truth and JUSTICE FOR ALL. This is part one of your...

  3. Introducing SANTA MAYBE, A CRIMINAL

    TODAY'S EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY INDIPOP, ACCIDENT.COM Special deals and offers for our listeners can be found at info.indipop.co/NEFARIOUS See what your claim is worth at accident.com/podcast S6 BONUS II - Introducing Santa Maybe, A Criminal CW/TW - holly jolly follies. This show/episode does...

  4. Introducing MURDER, SHE TOLD

    TODAY'S EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY INDIPOP, ACCIDENT.COMSpecial deals and offers for our listeners can be found at info.indipop.co/NEFARIOUSSee what your claim is worth at accident.com/podcast S6 BONUS I - Introducing Murder, She Told Murder, She Told is an award-winning true-crime podcast created…

    more
  5. S6 E10 - Dark Side of the Moon - Find Prisma Reyes

    TODAY'S EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY INDIPOP, ACCIDENT.COM Special deals and offers for our listeners can be found at info.indipop.co/NEFARIOUS See what your claim is worth at accident.com/podcast S6 E10 - Dark Side of the Moon - Find Prisma Reyes CW/TW - domestic violence, discussion of sex...

  6. S6 E9 - West Texas Psychopath - the murder of Ella Bennett, part 2

    TODAY'S EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY INDIPOP, ACCIDENT.COM Special deals and offers for our listeners can be found at info.indipop.co/NEFARIOUS See what your claim is worth at accident.com/podcast S6 E9 - West Texas Psychopath - the murder of Ella Bennett, part 2 CW/TW - Sororicide of a child, sexual...

  7. S6 E8 - West Texas Psychopath - the murder of Ella Bennett, part 1

    TODAY'S EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY INDIPOP, ACCIDENT.COM Special deals and offers for our listeners can be found at info.indipop.co/NEFARIOUS See what your claim is worth at accident.com/podcast S6 E8 - West Texas Psychopath - the murder of Ella Bennett, part 1 CW/TW - Sororicide of a child, sexual...

  8. S6 E7 - NO MORE BS - Revisiting Justice for Katie Palmer

    TODAY'S EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY INDIPOP! Special deals and offers for our listeners can be found at info.indipop.co/NEFARIOUS S6 E7 -- NO MORE BS - Revisiting Justice for Katie Palmer CW/TW - discussion of reckless driving, sexual abuse/assault, addiction and murder. A quick recap - Katie Palmer...

  9. S6 E6 - Are you listening? - Missing: Samantha Tapp

    TODAY'S EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY INDIPOP! Special deals and offers for our listeners can be found at info.indipop.co/NEFARIOUS S6 E6 - Are you listening? - Missing: Samantha Tapp CW/TW - discussion of drugs and mental health Samantha Tapp, a 16 year old girl who grew up in the system with her...

  10. S6 E5 - Sexual Abuse Prevention - an interview with Kimberlee Norris of MinistrySafe

    TODAY'S EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY INDIPOP! Special deals and offers for our listeners can be found at info.indipop.co/NEFARIOUS S6 E5 - Sexual Abuse Prevention - an interview with Kimberlee Norris of MinistrySafe CW/TW - Discussion of child abuse/sexual abuse "SEXUAL ABUSE DOES NOT SKIP ANY…

    more
  11. S6 E4 - "HE was my everything" - Justice for Juan Leon Laureles

    S6 E4 - "HE was my everything" - Justice for Juan Leon Laureles CW/TW - detailed account of murder, discussion of potential hate crime against latinx and/or lgbtq+ Juan “Leon” Laureles was a kind, sweet and quiet 30 year old living in central Texas when on or around May 10, 1996, he was murdered…

    more
  12. S6 E3 - "A lioness’ pride" - Justice for Willow (Part 3)

    S6 E3 - "A lioness’ pride" - Justice for Willow (Part 3) CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - Displays of grandiosity, narcissism or sociopathy, suicidal ideation, domestic violence, murder of a child For today's episode, we will wrap up this multiparter, where we await what will happen with Stephen...

  13. Round table discussion and call to action - Alexander Blake VanDalsen

    CALL TO ACTION - ALEX VANDALSEN We are angry. We demand justice. Say his name - ALEX VANDALSEN. Alex VanDalsen, a transgendered man, was murdered, but his case was conveniently labeled a suicide. His mother, Jennifer VanDalsen, has spent nearly three years fighting for answers and justice. Due to...

  14. S6 E2 - "Listen to your gut" - Justice for Willow (Part 2)

    S6 E2 - "Listen to your gut" - Justice for Willow (Part 2) CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - Displays of grandiosity, narcissism or sociopathy, suicidal ideation, domestic violence, murder of a child Mariah Lee Gardner escaped, barely clinging to life, from a brutal attack on her and her children at...

  15. S6 E1 - "Playing the Long Game" - Justice for Willow (Part 1)

    S6 E1 - "Playing The Long Game" - Justice for Willow (Part 1) CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - Displays of grandiosity, narcissism or sociopathy, domestic violence, murder of a child Mariah Lee Gardner escaped, barely clinging to life, from a brutal attack on her and her children at the hands of her...

  16. Season 5 Recap, updates, teasers

    BONUS - Season 5 Recap, updates, teasers CW/TW - Foul Language, brief discussions of SA, murder, hate crimes, potential spoilers Today, Courtney and Amanda chat about plenty of things in the fashion of 2021 Nefarious (meaning, it’s casual and there will be banter so if you can’t handle it, maybe...

  17. A Conversation with Haley from part 5, Minding the Beehive

    BONUS - A Conversation with Haley from part 5, Minding The Beehive CW/TW - Foul Language, discussions of SA and suicide For today’s bonus episode, Courtney and Haley (who was interviewed in S2E12 Minding the Beehive, part 5) have an open and honest yet casual conversation - as somewhat of an...

  18. PALATE CLEANSER! Not So Nefarious Criminals with Bob Motta

    BONUS - Not So Nefarious Criminals FEATURING Bob Motta, Defense Diaries CW/TW - Foul Language Hey there, it's Courtney! While we're taking a breather until season six, we're putting our mental well-being first. In the meantime, we've got a special treat from our Patreon archives for you - an...

  19. S5 E13 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 13 - FINALE

    S5 E13 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 13 - FINALE PHASE 3 - Surviving Sexual Assault, “Rachel” CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of grooming, sexual assault and/or abuse of a minor, mental health. This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we...

  20. S5 E12 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 12 - Jennifer

    S5 E12 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 12 PHASE 3 - Speaking out, Jennifer CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of grooming, sexual assault and/or abuse of a minor, mental health. This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we felt the urgency to...

  21. S5 E11 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 11 - Ebony

    S5 E11 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 11 PHASE 3 - Australia - Speaking out, Ebony CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of grooming, sexual assault and/or abuse of a minor, mentions of alcohol and drug use, mental health and suicidal ideation. This season is...

  22. S5 E10 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 10 - Sarah

    S5 E10 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 10 PHASE 3 - Surviving Sexual Abuse and kidnapping, Sarah Audio Quality Warning Please accept our apologies in advance for the audio quality within the zoom call in this episode. Sometimes there is no way around it, but we assure…

    more
  23. S5 E9 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 9 - "KIM"

    S5 E9 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 9 PHASE 3 - Surviving Sexual Assault, “Kim” CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of potentially incestuous sexual assault, mentions of alcohol and drug use, mental health and suicidal ideation. This season is more…

    more
  24. S5 E8 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 8 - Mama D

    S5 E8 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 8 PHASE 2 - Love, Support, Advice - a visit with Mama D CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of sexual assault and sextortion, brief mention of CP This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we felt the urgency…

    more
  25. S5 E7 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 7 - HOLLY

    S5 E7 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 7 PHASE 2 - Minding the Beehive updates - PART 7, A VISIT WITH HOLLY CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of sexual assault and sextortion, brief mention of CP This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we felt...

  26. S5 E6 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 6 - KITTY

    S5 E6 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 6 PHASE 2 - Minding the Beehive updates - PART 6, A VISIT WITH KITTY CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of sexual assault and sextortion, brief mention of CP This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we felt...

  27. S5 E5 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 5 - KATI

    S5 E5 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 5 PHASE 2 - AWARENESS AND EDUCATION - PART 5, KATI CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of sexual assault and sextortion, brief mention of CP This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we felt the urgency to...

  28. S5 E4 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 4 - TATUM

    S5 E4 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 4 PHASE 1 - SEXTORTION - PART 4, TATUM CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of sexual assault and sextortion, brief mention of CP Today we wrap up phase one of this series with Tatum, who you all heard from in season two's...

  29. S5 E3 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 3 - PARIS

    S5 E3 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 3 PHASE 1 - SEXTORTION - PART 3, PARIS CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of sexual assault and sextortion, brief mention of CP This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we felt the urgency to raise…

    more
  30. S5 E2 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 2 - LEXIE

    S5 E2 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 2 PHASE 1 - SEXTORTION - PART 2, LEXIE CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of sexual assault and sextortion, brief mention of CP This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we felt the urgency to raise…

    more
  31. S5 E1 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 1 - ASHLYN

    S5 E1 - Still Minding The Beehive - Surviving Sex Crimes, Part 1 PHASE 1 - SEXTORTION - PART 1, ASHLYN CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - detailed accounts of sexual assault and sextortion, brief mention of CP This season is more serialized than it is episodic, and we felt the urgency to raise…

    more
  32. To Exit the Cultiverse - Courtney’s story

    To Exit the Cultiverse - Courtney’s story CW/TW - detailed accounts of sexual assault, suicidal ideation, mentions of mental health Todays episode is a bonus episode. Courtney gets real, raw and finally talks about how she navigated her way out of a labyrinth of what would turn out to be a cult,...

  33. TEASER - STILL MINDING THE BEEHIVE - Surviving Sex Crimes

    Season 5 is among us, and on June 20, 2023, we open it up with a massive deep dive on various sex crimes. From awareness, to advocacy, to various interviews of victims and survivors of these crimes, to reenactments of actual texts with several other podcasters as well as underrated and little…

    more
  34. Deadly Devotion: Motherhood and Mayhem, Part 2

    Deadly Devotion: Motherhood and Mayhem, Part 2 This Mother’s Day, join Shane Waters on a chilling adventure featuring 14 podcasters including Foul Play, Already Gone, Crimelines and Yours Truly, as we all share sinister stories of motherhood. Mother’s Day is typically a time to honor the love and...

  35. Deadly Devotion: Motherhood and Mayhem, Part 1

    Deadly Devotion: Motherhood and Mayhem, Part 1 This Mother’s Day, join Shane Waters on a chilling adventure featuring 14 podcasters including Foul Play, Already Gone, Crimelines and Yours Truly, as we all share sinister stories of motherhood. Mother’s Day is typically a time to honor the love and...

  36. S4 E14 - Subdued and Bound - The Toolbox Killers

    Season 4 Finale! CW/TW - DISTRESSING CONTENT - serial rape and murder of minors under 18, animal cruelty, severe depictions of Polymorphous perverse personality, sexual deviancy. Please take extra care when listening to this episode. Today, for our final episode of Season 4, we close out with…

    more
  37. BONUS - Interview with DFW Exposures

    Todays episode is a special bonus episode I’ve been sitting on for a little while. First off we have a few updates from Holly from the Minding the Beehive series regarding her abuser. Then, Courtney finally had a chance to interview our anonymous friend from the DFW Exposures groups. DFW…

    more
  38. NOT SO NEFARIOUS CRIMINALS Featuring Damsel Ninja Nancy

    WE are about to be ending season 4 with a case that will need approximately 800 disclaimers, so why not serve you all with a palate cleanser ahead of it? Courtney sucks and couldn't make it, so Amanda and Chey are joined by Damsel Ninja Nancy, our resident safety expert. Whitney Houston does get...

  39. S4 E13 - Little Notes - Justice for Karen Bodine

    S4 E13 - Little Notes - Justice for Karen Bodine CW/TW - mentions of drug use, murder. Karen Bodine was 37 years old when she was subjected to a brutal attack resulting in bruises and cuts to her body, as well as a ligature mark around her neck. The perpetrators responsible for her death have yet...

  40. S4 E12 - Red Herring - the trafficking crimes of Anthony Patterson and Janreani Bell

    S4 E12 - Red Herring - the trafficking crimes of Anthony Patterson and Janreani Bell CW/TW - mentions of sex trafficking, sextortion, mentions of sexual assault and abuse of minors. Sex trafficking is a crime that we don’t talk about much on this podcast, but we will moving forward. Sex…

    more
  41. Easter Egg #1 - Something is happening June 2023

    Easter Egg #1 - Something is happening June 2023 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/a-nefarious-nightmare-true-crime--5908360/support.

  42. S4 E11 - Collective Blue - Justice for Michelle O’Connell

    S4 E11 - Collective Blue - Justice for Michelle O’Connell CW/TW - mention of suicide, domestic violence, brief mention of sexual assault due to statistics Michelle O’Connell’s death was initially ruled as a suicide, but the circumstances surrounding her death were questionable. Her boyfriend, a...

  43. INTRODUCING - Coffee and Cases - What happened to Dulce Alavez?

    INTRODUCING Coffee and Cases - What happened to Dulce Alavez? Please enjoy this feed drop from our friends Allison and Maggie over at the Coffee and Cases podcast! It was supposed to be a fun day at the park when Noema, along with her 3-year-old son, met both her 5-year-old daughter and her...

  44. S4 E10 Ambush at the Sanctuary - What happened to Jared Bridegan?

    S4 E10 Ambush at the Sanctuary - What happened to Jared Bridegan? CW/TW - brief mention of domestic and child abuse, murder On the evening of Feb. 16, 2022, Jared Bridegan was traveling back to his home in St. Augustine from Jacksonville Beach, where he had just dropped off his 10-year-old twin…

    more
  45. S4 E9 - He had a history - Mass Murder in Tennessee Colony

    S4 E9 - He had a history - Mass Murder in Tennessee Colony CW/TW - murder of a minor, mention of sexual assault, mention of death penalty, mental health issues such as narcissism and psychopathy What would you do if you purchased a deed for land, and wanted to celebrate someone’s birthday by...

  46. S4 E8 - Taken away - the disappearance of Erica Baker

    S4 E8 - Taken away - the disappearance of Erica Baker CW/TW - Mentions of SA/CP and murder of a minor On February 7, 1999, Erica Baker stepped out of her small home in Kettering, Ohio, wearing her raincoat and leashed up her beloved dog. She was on her way to the local park. It was a cold, rainy...

  47. S4 E7 - A motive of estate? Justice for Lori Lynn

    S4 E7 - A motive of estate? Justice for Lori Lynn CW/TW - Mentions of abuse and bullying, mentions of mental health, mentions of animal harm This case is a bit different than what we normally cover, it’s the case of a daughter who lost their mother to murder. It’s widely speculated that the...

  48. INTRODUCING - Murder and Mimosas - The McMartin Preschool Ritual Abuse

    INTRODUCING - Murder and Mimosas - The McMartin Preschool Ritual Abuse CW/TW - Mentions of Sexual Abuse of a minor, references to mental health and belief systems. Did one preschool secretly abuse children for almost 30 years with no disclosures? Or did Satanic Panic lead to a witch hunt of…

    more
  49. INTRODUCING - The Sirens Podcast - VICTIMOLOGY With Professor McNeely

    INTRODUCING - The Sirens Podcast - VICTIMOLOGY With Professor McNeely Raven & Holly get to the nitty gritty with Mandy McNeely, our resident Victimology Professor, about what victimology is. They all have some great safety tips as well. www.thesirenspodcast.com. TRUE CRIME AND PARANORMAL PODCAST...

  50. S4 E6 - To bloom in Bloomington - What happened to Lauren Spierer?

    S4 E6 - To bloom in Bloomington - What happened to Lauren Spierer? DISCLAIMER - Please listen for an important bit of unfortunate news that might explain some things in the coming weeks. Lauren Spierer, born on January 17, 1991, was a 20-year-old student at Indiana University when she disappeared...

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

Best Friends Amanda and Courtney deep dive into true crime cases with an empathetic standpoint. They focus awareness mainly on lesser known crimes and crimes against those deemed extra vulnerable. Occasionally, the hosts will cover more well known cases due to relevance or a particularly fascinating element. The bees (the honeybee) is seen as synonymous with victims and survivors. We must always protect the bees. We must always let their voices be heard. We must not stifle the buzz of the bees, so bee vigilant, for when you mess with the bees, you get the hive.

Welcome to A Nefarious Nightmare.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/a-nefarious-nightmare-true-crime--5908360/support.

HOSTED BY

Courtney Fenner & Amanda Cronin

Produced by A Nefarious Nightmare - Courtney Fenner & Amanda Cronin

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime have?

A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime currently has 123 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime about?

Best Friends Amanda and Courtney deep dive into true crime cases with an empathetic standpoint. They focus awareness mainly on lesser known crimes and crimes against those deemed extra vulnerable. Occasionally, the hosts will cover more well known cases due to relevance or a particularly...

How often does A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime release new episodes?

A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime publishes regularly with 123 episodes available. Check the episode list for the typical release schedule.

Where can I listen to A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime?

You can listen to A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime?

A Nefarious Nightmare - True Crime is created and hosted by Courtney Fenner & Amanda Cronin.
URL copied to clipboard!