Befumbled: A Bachelor Nation Podcast
by Annie & Hailey
Join Bachelor nation super fans Annie and Hailey as they talk about Bachelor Nation episodes as they happen - with a twist. In a franchise as ridiculous as the Bachelor, some things seem too crazy to be true, and Annie and Hailey are here to capitalize on that. The girls have guests on every week to talk about the episodes with them, and then present their guests with 2 truths and lie (roses and thorns) and their guest to guess which parts of the show are just crazy enough to be true. On The Bachelor or Bachelorette, that task is harder than it seems...
Episodes
-
Episode 43: Befumbled About 1 Million Contestants
A new season - the ladies are BACK and already over this BS. In true Befumbled fashion, Hailey and Anna are 3 episodes behind, so Annie catches Hailey up on Episode 1 and 2 of Rachel and Gabby's season. The girls giggle over Gabby and discuss their confusion over the number of men in this season....
-
Episode 41: Befumbled About Susie and Clayton's Big Fight
Due to Hailey complete lack of commitment to this season (which the girls get into), Annie is in charge of recounting Fantasy Suites and allll the Susie drama. The girls discuss if Clayton or Susie was in the wrong or if these are just two people with different expectations. Of course, the girls...
-
Episode 40: Befumbled About Our Childhoods
Hello our Befumbled folks! Today we chatted through Hometowns — well, a little. Mostly we talked about our childhoods and our love of Disney and Nickelodeon. We swear we eventually got to the actual Bachelor content but... it took a while.
-
Episode 39: Befumbled About the Contestants' Rings
The ladies are so excited to present their first ever episode recorded in the same room! Join Hailey and Annie in Annie's apartment as the girls discuss the last few weeks of Clayton's season. They finally feel like they're getting to the meat and potatoes of Clayton's season, and they make their...
-
Episode 38: Befumbled About Corporate Sponsors
Hailey and Annie are back and it’s ABSOLUTE chaos. If you don’t want to listen to their amazing banter, skip ahead to 11:00 for bachelor content. The girls discuss Chatty Broads’ new direction and debate the ultimate question: Is Clayton aware of what he’s doing, or is just a himbo? The girls…
more -
Episode 37: Befumbled About the Shrimpcident
Hello, Befumbled nation! This week Annie is on with her pal Stephanie to discuss himboism, Dancing with the Stars thievery and the ill-fated Shrimpcident of Clayton's season.
-
Episode 36: Befumbled About Libel
Hello, team! Today we brought on our favorite future lawyer to ask her all her hot Ivy League goss, what libel/slander really is and so much more. Oh, and we also talked about the latest episode of Colton's — I mean Clayton's — season.
-
Episode 35: Befumbled About Clayton's Last Name
It's a new year, and a new season of this god forsaken franchise. The girls get into their 2022 goals before diving into gossip. They discuss Befumbled's new Twitter account (are you following???) and C*lton's new house with his boyfriend before they dive into Clayton's journey as The Bachelor....
-
Episode 34: Befumbled About Brandon/Brenden
Hailey and Annie are back, and somehow they don't know the names of one of this season's main characters. In our defense, we've seen 50+ people compete for love this past year... so we are excused. On this ep, we discuss Michelle's finale!
-
Episode 33: Befumbled About Bachelor Nation Burnout
It's Fantasy Suites week, folks! And despite what is normally a juicy-filled episode, the girls are BURNT OUT. Bachelor Nation, we can't keep doing this... and you expect us to watch a whole new season one week after Michelle's?! The things we do for this pod. Hailey is here to befumble Annie…
more -
Episode 32: Befumbled About The Boring Men Tell All
Welcome to the shortest episode yet--all thanks to that boring Men Tell All. The girls rehash what little drama there was, including Tayshia's "painful" break up. Annie successfully befumbles Hailey on the bizarre content that there was in this episode--sculptures??? Streaking???? A lawyer???…
more -
Episode 31: Befumbled About Katie and John (Again)
Hello hello! We have returned with a guest and we're about to spill to her all the Olivia Rodrigo "Sour"-esque details about the John/Katie situation, along with an episode rundown of Michelle's hometowns! Will our guest be fooled? You'll have to listen to find out.
-
Episode 30: Befumbled on How to Start a Podcast
It's episode 30 and Annie and Hailey decide they should maybe have some sort of podcast introduction? Annie successfully befumbles Hailey, while the girls reflect on what it means to bring someone home to your parents. The girls are still obsessed with Michelle and also confused why Clayton was...
-
Episode 29: Befumbled about Jojo
We're back and with a brand new guest! Meet our friend, Jojo... but is it Jojo the singer, Jojo the dancer or Jojo the bachelorette? You'll have to listen to find out.
-
Episode 28: Befumbled About Clayton
*This episode was recorded on the eve of Red (Taylor's Version) so skip ahead to 8:00 minutes if you’re not interested in Hailey and Annie’s swiftie talk” Join Annie and Hailey for another week of Michelle's season! Hailey befumbles herself with her poor note-taking skills and then forgets that...
-
Episode 27: Befumbled About Hobby Lobby
Hello hello! Hailey and Annie are spiraling this week. Annie watched the episode and somehow barely retained anything. But what did she remember? Insane quotes. The gals also gab about Hailey's secret life as the Pier One princess and limes. Oh, and they recap the episode.
-
Episode 26: Befumbled About Katie and Blake's Short-Lived Relationship
Michelle's season has begun and Annie and Hailey are ready to dig right into the drama. Hailey does her best to befumble Annie, while also starting to solidify her fave men of the season - where are my Olumide and Martin fans at? The girls discuss the elephant in the room (Katie and Blake's...
-
Episode 25: Befumbled About Everything
Hello Befumbled buds! This week, we're befumbled about everything. Well, Hailey isn't but Annie definitely is. We didn't get a look at the guys because Annie needed a break last week (oops), and then her descriptions to Hailey certainly weren't anything to write home about. But hey, it's only…
more -
Episode 24: Befumbled About How Joe and Serena Can Be So Perfect
In case you were wondering if Annie and Hailey like Joe and Serena, this episode is them just 60 minutes of them spiraling over the best Paradise couple of all time. Hailey recaps the final whirlwind six hours of this year's Bachelor in Paradise. The girls check their BIP predictions made at the...
-
Episode 23: Befumbled About Paradise Meals
If you’re sick of listening to Hailey and Annie's voices, they finally have a guest again! Annie’s boyfriend Chris joins the girls to help Annie befumble Hailey and recap the most recent episode of Bachelor in Paradise. Together, they analyze Joe and Kendall’s history and speculate which couples...
-
Episode 22: Befumbled About Bodies
We're back and Annie is broken! We know we're down to one ep a week, but we couldn't help but make another two-parter. Tune in as we dissect body parts, follower counts and GSJ's future ambitions as a cast member of Survivor.
-
Episode 21: Befumbled About 2 BIP Episodes a Week
The world is burning around Hailey and Annie but at least they have Bachelor in Paradise content to keep them entertained... except is FOUR HOURS of Bachelor in Paradise a week just a bit too much? Annie is not sure she can commit this much of her life to the Bachelor in Paradise dumpster fire…
more -
Episode 20: Befumbled About Banana Boats
Hailey and Annie are ready to discuss FOUR HOURS worth of Bachelor in Paradise content, but they're not sure they can mentally and emotionally handle two BIP episodes a week. They discuss all the drama - including Demi's hypocrisy, Connor's ickiness, and whatever world Victoria P lives in. Annie...
-
Episode 19: Befumbled About David Spade
Hey y'all, this is Befumbled's OOTD... jk. We recorded this a couple weeks ago after Katie's finale and the first ep of Bachelor in Paradise and we are FULL of takes on cute couples, confusing host history and MUCH more.
-
Episode 18: Befumbled About Bachelor Nation's New Found Psychologists
Well well well.... what a week to be a Bachelor Nation fan! Annie and Hailey get into it this week, but not without first going into a couple tangents about their first cell phones and the proper wearing of cowboy boots. The girls briefly discuss the most boring Men Tell All ever, as well…
more -
Episode 17: Befumbled About Brendan
On today's episode, we ask questions — mainly, "how is Brendan still here?" We'll also address runner & track star Katie as she leaps through the hotel to find Andrew, the men's artistic abilities and the concept of attainable hotties.
-
Episode 16: Befumbled About Where Hailey and Annie Have Been
It's been a minute - but Hailey and Annie never promised consistency! Though it's been a few weeks since the girls recorded, they make up for it by providing a MEGA episode covering the last three episodes--which they somehow do in their shortest episode yet? The girls discuss the recent PPP...
-
Episode 15: Befumbled About The Texas Power Grid (Again)
Well, howdy! Hailey and Annie are back, and this time they're in the middle of a heatwave instead of in a crazy snowstorm. Though the weather isn't great, that doesn't stop them from chatting about all the fun of Episode 2 of Katie Thurston's Bachelorette season. Listen up to hear our thoughts on...
-
Episode 14: Befumbled About The Boys
This weekend we brought a on a very special guest to chat all things Episode 1! We are so excited to see where Katie's Bachelorette journey will take her, but mostly we are excited to get past these intros and get into the drama of the season.
-
Episode 13: Befumbled About Not Liking Vegetables
The Bachelorette is BACK and so are Hailey and Annie! The girls give you some life updates before diving into Bachelor nation tea, and then they break down Katie’s cast of men. Based off of their bios and headshots, how much can the girls really tell about these guys? Annie fills Hailey in on her...
-
Episode 12: Befumbled About Being Podcast Hosts
... hello? Is this thing on? After a much-needed break due to our rigorous duties as full-time working women and medical miracles, we hopped back on the pod to chat about the latest Bachelor Nation happenings. And there were a lot. We're excited to be back with fun convos over Bach nation births...
-
Episode 11: Befumbled About Becca Ann
And just like that, another season of this godforsaken show comes to an end. Returning champion Maria joins the girls to discuss all the details of Matt’s finale and (more importantly) that intense After the Final Rose. The girls discuss Annie’s new four degrees of separation from Tyler Cameron…
more -
Episode 10: Befumbled About Why We Watch This Show
Welcome to episode 10! After taking a week off, we're back and ready to befumble our way through the Fantasy Suites dates. We'll chat windmills, dream dates, and Hannah Ann's jean capris. Will we be able to handle all the twists n' turns that come with the suites? Probably, especially because...
-
Episode 9: Befumbled About the Future of Bachelor Nation
Hailey and Annie return to another week of cracking jokes while the entirety of Bachelor Nation is up in flames — we love a good coping mechanism. This week we dive into the fabled Hometown dates, and discuss how we think our own hometowners would go. There's also some hot takes shared about date...
-
Episode 8: Befumbled About Texas' Power Grid
Annie and Hailey are back with a guest to dive into Chris Harrison’s downfall and Bachelor Nation’s racial reckoning, Texas’ crumbling infrastructure and Heather’s arrival (and quick departure). The ladies were cut more than half in one episode - so how did we get here? Hailey’s college friend...
-
Episode 7: Befumbled About Charcuterie
NOTE: This episode was recorded prior to Rachael K.'s statement and Chris Harrison's statement announcing his break from the show, which is why we don't mention it. The Befumbled pod is back, and Annie and Hailey are still just as confused as ever. How could Matt have a fiance if he has so much...
-
Episode 6: Befumbled About Taxes
Annie and the girls recap the latest episode, discuss how men furnish their homes, review Bachelor Nation’s lukewarm tea, and debate which of Matt’s contestants do their own taxes. While the drama is getting old, Hailey and Annie are happy to finally see a few of the women reaping what they sew.…
more -
Episode 5: Befumbled About the New Girls
Another episode, another night of pointless drama and so little romance. Hailey's roommate and friend, Rebecca, joins the girls to recap the ridiculous drama of this week's episode. The girls discuss the boatload of Bachelor Nation drama, the toxic sex worker slander, the producers' choice to…
more -
Episode 4: Befumbled About Chris Harrison's Hobbies
It's another week of dysfunctional drama and very little love here on Matt's season of The Bachelor! This week Hailey and Annie discuss Episode 3, along with all the highs and lows (mostly lows) of the plot lines that are heating up. From dates interrupted by donkeys to Chris Harrison's romance...
-
Episode 3: Befumbled About Victoria
The drama is finally starting to heat up and so are the relationships - Annie and Hailey are ready to dive in. Annie recaps the episode to Hailey, and Befumbled Hailey one too many times... The girls discuss the one on ones, how Matt and the girls handle tricky conversations, what kind of group...
-
Episode 2: Befumbled About Night One Intros
Annie & Hailey are back with a brand new name and a brand new guest. This week they try to befumble their pal Maria on all the deets of Matt James' night one ladies. Plus they reveal some amazing news about all their future guests (hint: it might involve wedding bells), confess their fave...
-
Episode 1: A Bachelor Nation Podcast
In preparation for Matt James' season, Annie and Hailey dive into his cast and their bios on ABC.com. They already have their favorites, but they speculate how accurately these bios reflect the women they're going to see on television. They discuss their favorites, their picks for villains, and...
About this show
Join Bachelor nation super fans Annie and Hailey as they talk about Bachelor Nation episodes as they happen - with a twist. In a franchise as ridiculous as the Bachelor, some things seem too crazy to be true, and Annie and Hailey are here to capitalize on that. The girls have guests on every week to talk about the episodes with them, and then present their guests with 2 truths and lie (roses and thorns) and their guest to guess which parts of the show are just crazy enough to be true. On The Bachelor or Bachelorette, that task is harder than it seems...
Hosted by
Annie & Hailey
Categories