PODCAST · true crime
Criminally Disturbed
by Criminally Disturbed
Paul and Jamie are a husband and wife team that tell stories of the evil, the wicked, the unexplained, and everything in between. Some content may be disturbing to some so please be advised. Criminally Disturbed is a true crime podcast where we discuss the details surrounding the truly "Disturbed" parts our world like mass/serial murderers and so much more. Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/criminallydisturbed/support
Episodes
-
085 Earl Morris
Welcome back to another episode. We have a special guest sitting with us today, so we are very excited! Join us as we talk about Earl Morris and his family. Remember to reach out to us at [email protected].
-
084 Joe Clark
WE ARE BACK! We know it has been more than a year since our last episode was published, but Jamie is making sure that we pick up where we left off. Make sure and let us know what you think at [email protected].
-
083 Gary Simmons Jr.
We are back everyone and WHOA! Has it been a Hell of a year so far? Well, we persevere and keep on keeping on, as Joe Dirt would say. Jamie has a good one for you guys and gals. Make sure and reach out to us through email, since some idiot decided they wanted our Facebook page more than we did!...
-
082 Dylan Redwine
Hold on to your butts! This episode that Jamie has for us is NASTY! The story of Dylan Redwine is a tragic one but the whole story is disgusting! Let us know what you think by sending us an email to [email protected]. We would also like to say that some douchebag has stolen the…
more -
081 Jody Plauche Part 2
Here it is! Part 2 and the conclusion of the story about Jody Plauche. Jody has so much courage in how he handles this and how he continues his life. The conclusion of the story is famous, but there is more to the story than anyone knows. Let us know how you would react! Send us an email at...
-
080 Jody Plauche
We know that it has been a minute since we have uploaded a new episode, and we apologize for that. We had a hardware issue. Our mixing board is currently on its last leg. I think we were able to put enough band aids on it to keep us going for now. This story is crazy. Jody is a normal pre-teen…
more -
079 Ingrid Escamilla
We are back fresh off of COVID! Jamie has another horrible story for everyone, but it is a good one! Also, we discuss something very special that we have been working on for all of our listeners! Lastly, we want to thank all of the listeners that have sent us messages. Your kind words are so very...
-
078 Elisa Izquierdo
Jamie hit us with a horrible and tragic story. Elisa is a young girl with a very bright future ahead of her. This is your trigger warning. If you hate child violence like we do, you have our permission to skip out on this episode, but Jamie does do a great job in telling this one.
-
077 The Hinterkaifeck Murders
Here we go! Let's do this! This is a crazy one! If you haven't heard this story, there is a small twist at the end. HMMMM! This reminds us of another case we did. Which one is it? Sources: o Germany's Hinterkaifeck Murders Remain Unsolved (historicmysteries.com) o The Creepy Truth About The...
-
076 The Hello Kitty Murder
It has been a minute since we have uploaded a new case. Partly because both of us have been extremely busy with work, and we are sorry for that. BUT! We are back for a brand new episode of Criminally Disturbed and Jamie goes crazy right out of the gate with this nightmare of a tale. Hang on, and...
-
075 Criminally Disturbed 2022 Recap
We are back after a small break for the holidays. In this episode we go over our very first year, which is 2022. Many may not know that our very first episode was uploaded on January 1, 2022. Join us as we discuss some of the episodes that you may not have heard yet. We want to thank all of our...
-
074 Scott and Amber McLaughlin
First and foremost, we would like to wish all of our listeners a VERY MERRY CHRISTMAS!!! We love all of you and hope that you are having a wonderful holiday! This story is currently in the news due to new developments, but it is the backstory that is the real garland and tinsel! At the beginning…
more -
073 Thomas Loden
Our case this week discusses a real piece of something! Leesa Gray was looking at a very bright and promising future before she crossed paths with this monster. Thomas would rob this young lady, and her family, of everything and more. But wait! there's more! Make sure and listen to the end to see...
-
072 Junko Furuta
Trigger warning! This story is brutal. We do start out talking about the very recent tragedy of Kenneth Vineyard and Athena Strand, as if those are not brutal themselves. But then we turn our attention to Japan and Jamie talks about a young lady named Junko Furuta. What happens to her is...
-
071 Double Feature - Maud Crawford and Ruiz Stone
Join us as we both discuss cases in this very special, listener inspired double feature! Two cases, one episode, one Arkansas city! This one is awesome so get ready! And remember, keep reaching out to us at our email address [email protected] because you never know when we will feature...
-
070 Bonus Episode For All - Updates - News - Idiots
That is right! A bonus for all of our listeners! WHY? Because it is Thanksgiving and we are thankful for all of our listeners! Plus, we have some special news to share, and we could not wait to get this out! This is wild!
-
069 Spade Cooley
This one took us both by surprise! Jamie does a great job in telling us the story of Spade Cooley. Paul is still wondering if this man crossed paths with Ronald Reagan! This one gets crazy so grab your Oh Shit Handles!
-
068 Starr Faithful
Starr Faithful was the typical Twenty-Something in 1931. Or was she? Things about her secret life only start to come out AFTER Starr goes missing one day. Who is responsible for her disappearance? Boyfriend(s)? Family? Who knows? Let us know what you think by sending us an email at...
-
067 Brandon Pettit
Be very careful! This one has a twist as big as the state of California, which is where this case takes place. I got emotional telling this story and Jamie got emotional hearing it. Why? You will just have to listen.
-
065 The Tragic Story of Chris Benoit - The Canadian Crippler
Jamie tells us one Hell of a story about Chris Benoit, known as the Canadian Crippler in the professional wrestling world. Our 19-year-old, Gavin, joins the conversation as we discuss an ongoing injury to athletes in contact sports that has claimed the lives of some. Let us know your thoughts on...
-
063 Stephen Barbee
This is the story of Stephen Barbee and Lisa Underwood and her son Jayden. A very tragic end to beautiful lives, taken by a true monster. Will justice be served on a platter? Or will another monster be set free by a technicality? Stay tuned and mark your calendars for an upcoming event! Sources:...
-
062 Tate Rowland
Tate Rowland was the typical teenage boy growing up in the 80's. His death was labeled a suicide. But rumors swirled that his death could have been caused by something more sinister. Were the rumors true or was the town caught up in the Satanic Panic.
-
061 Sandy Jenkins
In this episode, Jamie discusses the story of Sandy Jenkins, an accounting professional turned criminal. Listen to this crazy story and let us know what your thoughts are.
-
060 Adolfo Constanzo and Sara Aldrete
We have covered several deadly cults since we started Criminally Disturbed. All of them share some characteristics. Most of them have a leader who claims to be Jesus or has spoken to Jesus. This cult is a little different. Jamie introduces all of us to Adolfo Constanzo. His claims are insane!…
more -
058 The Mysterious Disappearance of Josh Maddux
This case has a weird twist to it. The story of Josh Maddux is crazy and when you think you know what happened, just hold on. There's more!
-
057 Sinedu Tadesse
Welcome back fans! This week's episode does not turn out like you might think. Sinedu Tadesse has risen from poverty solely based on her intellect, but does intellect alone give you everything? Is that all this promising student of one of the most prominent universities in the US needs to make it...
-
056 The Officer and the Criminal
Grab your "Oh Shit Handles"! This is a crazy story with a huge twist! This is the story of a police officer with a huge secret double life that will shock you! Let us know your thoughts on this one. Send your comments to our email address [email protected].
-
055 The Followers of Christ Part 2
If you thought the Oregon FoC was bad, wait to you hear about the FoC in Idaho. More specifically, the laws that protect those that neglect the most vulnerable humans. Please let us know your thoughts on this subject through our email address, [email protected].
-
054 The Followers of Christ
You all have heard us discuss and/or comment on religious beliefs and interpretation of scripture within the vast publications of religion. Well, there is a group, The Followers of Christ, that takes "misinterpretation" to a level of insanity. Join us as we discuss the True Crime behind the...
-
053 **BONUS EPISODE** True Crime Short Stories - Idiot Edition #2
OOPS! We did it again! Another True Crime Short Stories episode for our listeners! Please enjoy and do not do as these people did!
-
052 The Lavish Lifestyle of Anna
If you haven't heard the true life story of Anna Sorokin, A.K.A. Anna Delvey, then you have got to hear this! You might as well throw that Criminally Disturbed "Oh Shit Handle" out the freakin window because this ride is insane!
-
051 The Crescent Hotel Listener Experience and The Story of Joe Ball
We start off by telling a chilling story of a listener's experience at The 1886 Crescent Hotel in Eureka Springs, AR. If you have not heard our coverage of this story, please go back and listen to this story. Like the story sent in from our listener, it will chill you to your core. Jamie then…
more -
049 Criminally Disturbed Double Feature
We have two stories for you in this "Double Disturbed" episode! Paul discusses the tragedy of the Tulsa, Oklahoma Mass Shooting. Sources for his episode include: www.newspapers.com https://www.npr.org/2022/06/02/1102612939/tulsa-gunmans-doctor-among-those-killed-in-the-mass-shooting...
-
048 The Tale of Two Jimmys
We wanted to let everyone know that we now have a Patreon Page. All Patreon subscribers will have early access to episodes and going forward, all Bonus Episodes will only be available with a Patreon subscription. Search for us at www.patreon.com. We appreciate all of our listeners and please...
-
047 Roch Theriault
Roch Theriault is the poster child for evil. He named his followers the Ant Hill Kids and they were subjected to horrific abuse. This episode is not for the faint of heart.
-
**BONUS EPISODE** True Crime Short Stories
That's right folks! This is a Bonus Episode and a break from the dark and dreary! This is our very first True Crime Short Stories! This is the "Idiot" Edition, so buckle up and grab your "Oh Shit Handles" as we talk about some funny stuff!
-
045 Aaron Quinn and Denise Huskins
Paul tells the story of two young lovers as they begin their life together. Like almost all other new relationships, their beginning is not without struggles. But their struggles are far worse than yours or ours. Will love reign over all? Sources: Watch 20/20 Season 43 Episode 27 Taken Online...
-
044 Jesse Pomeroy Part 2
We begin part 2 with Jesse being released from the reformatory. You'd think he would've been somewhat reformed when he was released, but he wasn't. You thought part 1 was rough? Jesse was just getting started.
-
043 The Tragic Story of Two Children
This is the very sad story of Devan Duniver. Devan, the blonde and blue eyed 5-year-old, had her whole life to look forward to when it was snatched from her in a cowardly way. Who was responsible for such a horrific crime? Was it a relative right in her own home? Or maybe it was someone in the...
-
042 Jesse Pomeroy Part 1
In 1872, Jesse Pomeroy was arrested for the mutilation and torture of young boys. He was described by newspapers as "A Youthful Monster" and "A Young Villain". What about this case makes you want to grab your "oh shit handle"? Jesse was 12!
-
041 The Coast-To-Coast Killer
Get ready! This one is bad! ****TRIGGER WARNING**** This case involves extreme violence towards women and children that even brings Paul to tears as he is telling it. You will not be the same after hearing this story! Sources: Tommy Lynn Sells | Criminal Minds Wiki | Fandom Tommy Lynn Sells #1374...
-
040 The Mysterious Story of the SS Ourang Medan
Paul has another spooky story for you, our loyal "Disturbed" listeners. Besides ocean water, the SS Ourang Medan has a ton of controversy surrounding it. We have a special surprise guest to help tell this story. Gavin, one of our own and our "In-House" history expert, describes the gruesome…
more -
039 Steven Pladl
Jamie tells us the very bizarre and disturbing tale of Steven Pladl and his relationship with his daughter. Grab your "Oh Shit!" handles and hold on. This monster is a different kind of messed up.
-
038 The Austin, Texas Axe Murders
Paul takes us way back in time to 1884 Austin, Texas. At this point in the young town's life, Austin was beginning to grow into what it is known as today. The new Capitol building is beginning construction, enrollment was up at UT Austin, and there was an axe murderer on the loose. Yes, that's...
-
037 Andre Thomas Part 2
We are back! It has been a while but for good reason. There has been a lot going on. Nevertheless, we are bringing you Part 2 and the conclusion of Andre Thomas. Jamie gets into detail about the trial and jury for Andre, and though the trial is tragic in itself, it doesn't take away the fact that...
-
036 The Crescent Hotel - Eureka Springs, Arkansas
Well, we have teased it, and here it is. This is the story of arguably one of the most haunted hotels in the United States. This was our very special Mother's Day episode, so we are sorry that is one week behind being uploaded. This one has it all, so grab your favorite drink, your favorite...
-
035 Andre Thomas Part 1
Are you ready for this one? We were not! This tragic story may make you cry. It may make you mad. Let us know what emotions this Part 1 of 2 about Andre Thomas stirs up in you.
-
034 Mary McElroy
The sad case of Mary McElroy. Was it Stockholm Syndrome or was she a victim of the views of society?
-
033 The Tragic Death of Deana Bowdoin
The title says it all! This very bright and driven young woman had a wonderful life ahead of her, but it was stolen, and the case goes cold for decades! Thanks to the advancement of technology, Deana's killer is brought to justice, but has justice been served? Sources: www.eastvalleytribune.com...
-
032 The Senseless Murder of Jeanne Dominico Part 2
The jaw dropping, blood pressure raising, conclusion to the very senseless murder of Jeanne Dominico.
We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.
No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.
No topics indexed yet for this podcast.
Loading reviews...
ABOUT THIS SHOW
Paul and Jamie are a husband and wife team that tell stories of the evil, the wicked, the unexplained, and everything in between. Some content may be disturbing to some so please be advised. Criminally Disturbed is a true crime podcast where we discuss the details surrounding the truly "Disturbed" parts our world like mass/serial murderers and so much more. Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/criminallydisturbed/support
HOSTED BY
Criminally Disturbed
CATEGORIES
Loading similar podcasts...
Frequently Asked Questions
How many episodes does Criminally Disturbed have?
Criminally Disturbed currently has 79 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.
What is Criminally Disturbed about?
Paul and Jamie are a husband and wife team that tell stories of the evil, the wicked, the unexplained, and everything in between. Some content may be disturbing to some so please be advised. Criminally Disturbed is a true crime podcast where we discuss the details surrounding the truly "Disturbed"...
How often does Criminally Disturbed release new episodes?
Criminally Disturbed has 79 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.
Where can I listen to Criminally Disturbed?
You can listen to Criminally Disturbed on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.
Who hosts Criminally Disturbed?
Criminally Disturbed is created and hosted by Criminally Disturbed.
URL copied to clipboard!