Freshly Squeezed True Crime

Send us Fan MailThis week, we travel to Fort Pierce and discuss Omar Mateen the Pulse nightclub shooter. Let me tell you a story.Shownotes: Omar Mateen - WikipediaOrlando shooting: Gunman Omar Mateen's father reacts to speculation son was gay - CBS NewsOrlando nightclub shooter Omar Mateen was HIV-negative and user of steroids, autopsy shows – New York Daily News50 dead, Islamic terrorism tie eyed in Orlando gay bar shooting - CBS NewsDealer Who Sold Orlando Massacre Guns: 'I Don't Make the Laws'Mateen to News 13 producer: 'I'm the shooter. It's me.'Pulse nightclub shooter Omar Mateen shot eight times, autopsy reveals

Send us Fan MailThis week, we travel back in time and dive into the history of Pride & the Pulse nightclub. Let me tell you a story.Shownotes: The Dangerous Consequences of Florida's "Don't Say Gay" Bill on LGBTQ+ Youth in FloridaLGBTQ+ History TimelinePulse (nightclub) - WikipediaThe Power of Inclusive Spaces: LGBTQIA+ Health and Well-Being - Community CommonsAbout | Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Pride Month | Library of CongressWhy Do We Celebrate LGBTQ+ Pride Month? - Youth In ProgressPride Month - WikipediaThe LGBTQ+ Alphabet - The Diversity Movement

Send us Fan MailThis week we travel to Redlands, a rural area of South Miami Dade County. Let me tell you a story.Shownotes: Murder of Jimmy Ryce - WikipediaJuan Carlos Chavez | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderersMicrosoft Word - 07-952_ans.docJuan Carlos Chavez, Killer of Jimmy Ryce, Executed at Florida State Prison – NBC 6 South FloridaCuban immigrant executed for 1995 murder of Florida boy | ReutersJuan Carlos Chavez (1967-2014) - Find a Grave Memorial

Send us Fan MailThis week we travel to Crestview and i tell you the story of Jeffrey Glenn Hutchinson and the Flaherty family murders.Shownotes: Florida executes Gulf War vet Jeffrey Hutchinson for quadruple murdersService Members & Veterans | NAMIJeffrey Hutchinson - WikipediaCrestview, Florida - Wikipedia

Send us Fan MailThis week, we tell the story of Jared Fogel and the Florida connection.Shownotes:Jared Fogle: 2 Sisters Victimized by Subway Spokesman Speak Out (people.com)Russell Taylor, Associate of Ex-Subway Pitchman Jared Fogle, Gets 27 Years for Child Porn (nbcnews.com)Why Russell Taylor Helped 'Subway Guy' Jared Fogle Abuse Kids (newsweek.com)Jared Fogle - WikipediaSovereign citizen movement - WikipediaWho is Rochelle Herman-Walrond? | The US Sun (the-sun.com)Subway pitchman co-conspirator Russell Taylor to be sentenced - UPI.comRussell Taylor: Sordid new details come to light (wrtv.com)Why Russell Taylor Helped 'Subway Guy' Jared Fogle Abuse Kids (newsweek.com)Subway Jared's accomplice and wife are sentenced to 60 years in prison for child sex abuse | Daily Mail OnlineWoman who recorded Jared Fogle discusses undercover operation on 'Dr. Phil' - Los Angeles Times (latimes.com)Jared Fogle made disgusting confessions to reporter for years and it ruined her life * starcasm.net

Send us Fan MailThis week let's travel to Miami and let me tell you the story of the Sun Gym Gang.Show notesPain & Gain True Story vs. Movie - Real Daniel Lugo, Paul Doyle (historyvshollywood.com)How Danny Lugo's Sun Gym Gang Killed Frank Griga and Krisztina Furton | Crime News (oxygen.com)Pain & Gain: the true story behind the movie | Movies | The GuardianPain & Gain | News | Miami | Miami New Times | The Leading Independent News Source in Miami, FloridaMuscle and mayhem: The real-life story behind Miami's murderous Sun Gym gang - CBS News(261) the Real-Life Sun Gym Gang Muscle and Mayhem - YouTubeSun Gym gang - WikipediaPain & Gain - Wikipedia Michael Bay - Wikipedia

Send us Fan MailThis week, strap in and let's travel through Central Florida as I tell you the story of Aileen Carol Wuornos.Show notes:Aileen Wuornos - WikipediaWuornos, Aileen; Berry-Dee, Christopher (2004). Monster: My True Story. John Blake Publishing. ISBN 978-1844540792.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aileen:_Life_and_Death_of_a_Serial_KillerMonster (2003 film) - Wikipedia

Send us Fan MailThis week, we take a road trip through Florida as we unpack the crimes of two women whose crimes are still as unbelievable today as they were when they were committed. This is Judy Buenoano & Christine Falling. Shownotes:Judy Buenoano - Wikipedia92522ans.pdfThe Black Widow | Middle District of Florida | United States District Courtwww.peacocktv.com (World's most evil killers, season 6 episode 14).Buenoano v. State :: 1988 :: Florida Supreme Court Decisions :: Florida Case Law :: Florida Law :: U.S. Law :: JustiaJudy Buenoano - Alcatraz East Pigeon ForgeJudy Buenoano, the "Black Widow," Took Her Paralyzed Son Out in a Canoe and Flipped ItChristine Falling - WikipediaChristine Falling | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderersChristine Falling | Deadly Women Wiki | FandomFlorida Man Murders: Story Of Killer Babysitter Christine Falling | Crime News (oxygen.com)The casual horror behind Christine Falling, the Florida baby-sitter from hell   – New York Daily News (nydailynews.com)Christine Falling Teen Killer And Serial Killer (mycrimelibrary.com)

Send us Fan MailToday, we travel to Levy County and tell the story of the Rosewood Massacre. Show Notes: Rosewood massacre a harrowing tale of racism and the road toward reparations | Florida | The GuardianRosewood Massacre - Overview, Facts & Legacy | HISTORYLessons of RosewoodRosewood massacre - WikipediaThe Real Rosewood Foundation | Rosewood, FL, USAOn Jan 05, 1923: White Mob Destroys Black Community of Rosewood, Florida

Send us Fan MailThis week we travel to Orange County Florida and discuss the Ocoee Massacre.Shownotes:Block the Vote: How Politicians are Trying to Block Voters from the Ballot Box | American Civil Liberties UnionList of race riots and massacres in the United States | BritannicaOcoee massacre of 1920 | History, Race Riot, Election Day, Death Toll, & Facts | BritannicaOn Nov 02, 1920: White Mobs Destroy Black Community of Ocoee, FloridaYesterday, This Was Home: The Ocoee Massacre of 1920 – Orange County Regional History CenterOcoee massacre - WikipediaNov. 2, 1920: The Ocoee Massacre - Zinn Education ProjectFor one survivor, the 1920 Election Day massacre in Florida was ‘the night the devil got loose’Ocoee, Florida - WikipediaBending Toward Justice Chapter 5: The Ocoee Massacre, November 2-3, 1920Ocoee-BHM-Updated.pdfThe Little-Known Story of America's Deadliest Election Day Massacre

Send us Fan MailThis week, we take a roadtrip through Florida and tell the story of Gary Bowles.Show notes:Gary Ray Bowles - WikipediaGary Ray Bowles: Florida executes Jacksonville serial killer who preyed on gay menSLAYING OF GAY MAN LINKED TO FLA. SUSPECT - The Washington PostGary Ray Bowles | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderersNo Court Has Reviewed the Evidence that Gary Bowles May Be Intellectually Disabled; Florida Plans to Execute Him Anyway. | Death Penalty Information CenterGary Ray Bowles, Florida killer who targeted gay men, set for execution Thursday (theledger.com)'I Didn't Want To Kill Nobody,' Serial Killer Says After Murdering 6 Men And Shoving Items In Their Mouths (yahoo.com)Don't ask, don't tell - WikipediaDon't Ask, Don't Tell Repeal Act of 2010 - WikipediaQUEER CRIME: How Homophobia Helped 4 Gay Serial Killers Continue To Kill   - IN Magazine

Send us Fan MailThis week we travel to Gibsonton & tell the story of Grady Stiles Jr.Shownotes: John Ringling - WikipediaRingling brothers - WikipediaRingling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus - WikipediaMeet Grady Stiles, The Murderous Lobster Boy Who Killed His Daughter's Fiance (ranker.com)Grady Stiles - WikipediaGrady Stiles Jr. - The Murderous Lobster Man (thehumanmarvels.com)Murder on the Midway: Sordid Life and Death of Lobster Boy : Crime: Family supports wife's claims of familial abuse, citing incident in which carnival attraction killed daughter's beau. - Los Angeles Times (latimes.com)Lobster Boy - Some Kind of MomentGrady Stiles Murder: Where Are Chris Wyant, Harry Glenn Newman Jr, and Mary Teresa Now? Update (thecinemaholic.com)Gibsonton, Florida - WikipediaCircus - Animal Rights Foundation of FloridaGrady Stiles Murder: Where Are Chris Wyant, Harry Glenn Newman Jr, and Mary Teresa Today?Sideshow - WikipediaFreak show - WikipediaGrady Stiles Jr. – The Murderous Lobster Man | KickassFacts

Send us Fan MailThis week we discuss the origins of Freshly Squeezed, Florida, & Florida Man... Let me tell you a story.Shownotes:Top 8 Wildest Florida Man Arrests And The Laws They BrokeLIST: Top 10 wackiest Florida Man (and Woman) headlines of 2024 | CBS 42Florida Man - The Official Site of The Legendary Florida ManBest Florida Man (and Woman) Stories of 2022

Send us Fan MailThis week we travel around the state as we discuss Florida dismembermentShownotes:https://people.com/grindr-lawsuit-murder-florida-miranda-corsette-teenager-torture-dismemeber-1175173 Meth Murder Mom Has Convicted Sex Offender Dad, Drug Dealer Husband | Inside EditionThe Psychology of Murder Concealment Acts - PMCMurder of Shad Thyrion - WikipediaOscar Solis could get death in stabbing of Randall Cooke (lawandcrime.com)Woman Whose Remains Were Found in 3 Suitcases Is ID'd, Husband Arrested (people.com)Penny Rebecca Pospisil gets life for killing boyfriend (lawandcrime.com)Fla. Couple Facing Charges in 4 Deaths in Two States (people.com)Winter Haven man takes plea deal for life in prison (theledger.com)Jefferson man arrested in death and dismemberment of Florida partner and "friend" (ktalnews.com)Man, 44, gets life sentence for murder of Belleview woman (ocala.com)The Story Of Florida's "Nub City," Where Residents Cut Off Their Own Appendages For Insurance Money (allthatsinteresting.com)

Send us Fan MailThis week we travel to Tallahassee and tell the story of Jerry Michael Williams.Shownotes:Murder of Mike Williams - Wikipedia'Partners in crime': Florida couple's affair leads to husband's murder - ABC NewsHe Vanished While Duck Hunting — and Everyone Blamed the Gators. But His Wife Knew Exactly What HappenedWhere is Denise Williams now? All about the 'Mr. & Mrs. Murder' subjectThe Murder Of Mike Williams — By His Best Friend And His WifeDenise Williams, Convicted Of Conspiring To Kill Her First Husband, Is Resentenced To 30 Years In Prison. | WFSU NewsMind of Madness, episode #41, Jerry Michael Williams, 01-20-2019.Crime Junkie, episode: Jerry Williams, 04-08-2019 Hulu, Mr. & Mrs Murder, 07-30-2025Mother a driving force as jury finds answers to Florida man's 2000 disappearance - CBS NewsMike Williams’ Wife and Friend Killed Him to Be Together

Send us Fan MailThis week, we travel to Winter Park and tell the story of Sarah Boone.Show notes:Alleged "Suitcase Killer" Sarah Boone on Lawyer Number 9Sarah Boone sentenced to life in prison for zipping her boyfriend in a suitcase for hours until he died | CNNMurder of Jorge Torres - WikipediaSarah Boone case: What to know about Winter Park woman facing murder charge after boyfriend dies in suitcase | FOX 35 OrlandoEight is enough: Judge rules Sarah Boone forfeits right to attorney | Court TVBattered woman syndrome - WikipediaSarah Boone trial: Orlando suitcase murder suspect guiltysarah boone sentencing transcript - Google Search

Send us Fan MailThis week, we travel to Palm Beach and tell the story of Paul Michael Merhige.Shownotes:Familicide - WikipediaInmate Population Information DetailPalm Beach, Florida - WikipediaPaul Merhige | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderersPaul Merhige Murder - Sitton Family Recovers After 10 Years (vizaca.com)The mind of Paul Merhige: Trying to unravel a mental mystery (palmbeachpost.com)New documents paint chilling portrait of accused Thanksgiving killer – Sun Sentinel (sun-sentinel.com)Police arrest man suspected of Thanksgiving massacre (nypost.com)Lawsuit Against Paul Merhige Kin Falls Through (clarkfountain.com)Gulliver Preparatory School - WikipediaObsessive–compulsive disorder - WikipediaA Thanksgiving Massacre In 2009 Highlights Today's True Mass Shooting CrisisA History of Violence – NBC 6 South Florida 

Send us Fan MailLet's take a road trip throughout Florida and discuss why Florida remains a sunny place for shady people. Show notes:Florida Crime Rate By City [2025 Updated]Most dangerous cities in Florida Florida Crime Rate By City 2025 - Latest StatisticsFBI — Florida2025 Top 12 Most Dangerous Cities in FloridTop 20 Most Dangerous Cities in Florida: High Crime RatesSentenced to death, man paroled after 1977 Sandy Creek murdersDeception Detection — Murder and a Movie: The Jeffrey Lamb Case — Crime LibraryCathy Lamb Murder: Where is Jeff Lamb Today?The Triangle - Opa-Locka, FloridaFlorida's Most Dangerous Town Is Also A Surprising Gateway To The KeysOn the Boardwalk: Kosta Fotopoulos and Deidre Hunt - HubPagesNotorious Daytona Beach killer Kosta Fotopoulos will remain on death rowTeen charged as adult in deadly Florida City shooting possibly tied to marijuana exchangehttps://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/crime/article297402333.htmlMiami men convicted in deadly 2020 kidnapping plot | Miami HeraldShocking details emerge as Miami duo convicted of kidnapping and murder in drug heistKidnappers who tortured, stuffed victims in U-Haul sentencedConvicted Miami Murderer Recaptured in Georgia After Erroneous JailFugitive killer James Daniels caught in Georgia arrest - Corrections1

Send us Fan MailIn honor of spooky season, let's take a ride across the Skyway Bridge and learn about its history, including the murder of Phoebe Jonchuck. Shownotes:Sunshine Skyway Bridge | Description, Disaster, Cable-Stayed, & Facts | BritannicaSunshine Skyway Bridge - WikipediaThe Haunted Sunshine Skyway Bridge in Tampa - Nightly SpiritsTampa Florida most haunted locationsSunshine Skyway: – Urban LegendsSunshine Skyway Bridge collapse | The Haunted LibrarianSuspect arrested 2 years after Sunshine Skyway Fishing Pier murder, deputies say | FOX 13 Tampa BaySuspect arrested in 2022 Sunshine Skyway fishing pier murderArrest of 2022 murder suspect Jonchuck Guilty Of Murder In Death Of Daughter | WUSFBefore girl’s death on Tampa Bay bridge, a family in chaos - Florida Children First

Send us Fan MailThis week we stay in Key West and finish the story of Carl and his bride.Shownotes:Carl Tanzler - Wikipediahttp://www.crimelibrary.com/serial_killers/notorious/necrophiles/story_6.htmlCarl Tanzler And His Creepy Key West Love Story | Lethbridge News NowGhosts of East Martello | Key West Art & Historical SocietyUndying Love: The Shocking True Story of a Passion That Defied Death by Ben Harrison

Send us Fan MailThis week we travel to Key West and tell the story of Carl Tanzler and his bride.Shownotes:Carl Tanzler - Wikipediahttp://www.crimelibrary.com/serial_killers/notorious/necrophiles/story_6.htmlCarl Tanzler And His Creepy Key West Love Story | Lethbridge News NowGhosts of East Martello | Key West Art & Historical SocietyUndying Love: The Shocking True Story of a Passion That Defied Death by Ben Harrison

Send us Fan MailThis week we travel to Orlando and tell the story of Lou Pearlman.Shownotes:Mad About the Boys | Vanity FairLou Pearlman - Crime Museum'The great untold scandal': the sordid tale of boyband mogul Lou Pearlman | Pop and rock | The GuardianBackstreet Boys, 'N Sync detail how Lou Pearlman stole millions (usatoday.com)Lou Pearlman True Story - Who Is the Backstreet Boys Founder and Criminal Lou Pearlman (esquire.com)What Did Lou Pearlman Do? The Man Behind the Longest-Running Ponzi Scheme (distractify.com)

Send us Fan MailThis week let's take a trip to Ensley and discuss the Audreana Zimmerman case.Shownotes:Murder of Audreanna Zimmerman - WikipediaTina Brown | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers20210409094436691_Brown SCOTUS Appendix.pdf12-2159_InitialBriefMerits_42213.pdfBurned teen treated in Mobile dies; 3 females charged with premeditated murder - al.comWoman that received life in prison as teen may get new sentencingBritnee Millers life sentence will stand in fatal beating, burningDeath row inmate Tina Brown claims her attorneys were ineffectiveTina Brown Pensacola denied chance to overturn death sentence

Send us Fan MailThis week on Freshly Squeezed, we travel to Miami (Liberty City) and study the case of Yahweh Ben Yahweh. Shownotes:Yahweh ben Yahweh - Wikipedia https://www.yahwehbenyahweh.comYahweh ben Yahweh, Leader of Separatist Sect, Dies at 71 - The New York Times (nytimes.com)Nation of Yahweh Mourns Loss of Leader, Shows Signs of New Life | Southern Poverty Law Center (splcenter.org)Uncovered: The Cult of Yahweh Ben Yahweh - NBC.comCult Leader Yahweh Ben Yahweh Promised Black Salvation Then Served Time for Murder (thedailybeast.com)Nation of Yahweh: Denver man's life inside violent separatist cult (denverpost.com)Yahweh Ben Yahweh: Murderous Cult Leader Dispatched 'Death Angels' (people.com)The Murderous Cult Of Nation Of Yahweh | The FBI Files | Real Crime - YouTubeFormer cult member says he stood watch at beheading - UPI ArchivesMurder victims | Miami HeraldCult Leader Convicted of Murder Conspiracy : Crime: Yahweh ben Yahweh and six of his followers are found guilty in a Miami trial marked by testimony of beheadings, mutilation. - Los Angeles Times

Send us Fan MailThis week on Freshly Squeezed, we travel to Ft Lauderdale and study the case of Eddie Lee Mosely.Shownotes:South Florida serial killer Eddie Lee Mosley, accused of raping and killing dozens of women, dies in Panhandle hospital – Sun Sentinel (sun-sentinel.com)Eddie Lee Mosley | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderersEddie Lee Mosley Archives - Florida BulldogA Devilish Deal | News | South Florida | Broward Palm Beach New Times | The Leading Independent News Source in Broward-Palm Beach, FloridaFlorida serial killer eluded conviction, but not COVID-19 | Fred Grimm – Sun Sentinel (sun-sentinel.com)Eddie Lee Mosley | Jackson County TimesEddie Mosley - Wikipediatubitv.com

Send us Fan MailThis week on Freshly Squeezed, we travel to Miami and study the case of Ana Maria Cordona. Shownotes:Ana Maria Cardona found guilty in third 'Baby Lollipops' murder trial (clickorlando.com)Mother in ‘Baby Lollipops’ murder trial found guilty by jury – WSVN 7News | Miami News, Weather, Sports | Fort LauderdaleInmate Population Information Detail (state.fl.us)"Baby Lollipops" murder - Wikipedia Inside Baby Lollipops Murder Case That Shook South Florida – Rolling StoneAna Maria Cardona | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers"Baby Lollipops" murder trial: Florida jury finds mother guilty for 3rd time - CBS News01-1056_petition.pdfANA MARIA CARDONA vs THE STATE OF FLORIDA :: 2020 :: Florida Third District Court of Appeal Decisions :: Florida Case Law :: Florida Law :: U.S. Law :: JustiaAna Maria Cardona v. State of FloridaCover

Send us Fan MailThis week on Freshly Squeezed, we travel to Deltona and study the case of the Deltona Murders. Shownotes:10th anniversary of ‘Xbox murders’ that shocked Deltona – Orlando SentinelBlood-soaked Florida nightmare comes alive – Lowell Sun‘Dumpster fire:’ Mistrial declared in resentencing of 2 men convicted in Deltona Xbox murders (clickorlando.com)Deltona's Xbox Murders: What you need to know before the April trial (news-journalonline.com)2 men convicted in Deltona 'Xbox murders' in resentencing (wesh.com)Four Men Arrested In Deltona Killings (theledger.com)Terror on Telford Lane: The Grisly Scene Inside (news-journalonline.com)Xbox Murders (cbsnews.com)Deltona massacre - WikipediaA life of crime; the magnetism of Troy Victorino (news-journalonline.com)

Send us Fan MailThis week on Freshly Squeezed, we travel to Sanford and study the case of Trayvon Martin. Shownotes:Trayvon Martin - WikipediaThe George Zimmerman Trial: An AccountTrayvon Martin, 10 years later: Teen's death changes nation | AP NewsGeorge Zimmerman - WikipediaA Look Back At Trayvon Martin's Death, And The Movement It Inspired : Code Switch : NPRGeorge Zimmerman: A Case Study in Motivated Reasoning | Institution for Social and Policy StudiesThe George Zimmerman Trial: An Examination of Legal, Social, and Cultural ImpactTrial of George Zimmerman - WikipediaShooting of Trayvon Martin | Racial Injustice, US History | BritannicaHome - Black Lives MatterBlack Lives Matter - WikipediaThe George Zimmerman Trial: A Chronology