Skip to content
Gutting the Sacred Cow podcast artwork

Gutting the Sacred Cow

by MonkeyButt Productions ACPN

TV

Gutting the Sacred Cow invites guests to argue why some of the most financially successful, beloved or acclaimed films are trash or overrated. But here's the twist, the film must meet 1 of these criteria: widely beloved, financial success, or critically acclaimed. Standup comedians Kevin Gootee and Kevin Israel love films and they love arguing about them.. But will they agree with their guests arguments or feed them into a wood chipper?We give a platform with those who have unpopular opinions to be bold enough to voice them. What are some films that have faced scrutiny: Back to the Future, Goodfellas, Shawshank Redemption, the Dark Knight, Toy Story, Ferris Bueller's Day Off, the Matrix, and Die Hard. Can the guests persuade us or do we rip them a new one? Give us a listen and we'll easily prove that we belong on any top movie podcast list. We throw plenty of fun segments in the mix: 5 fun facts, our readers have us ask our guests questions they'd like answered in "Ask a Gutter"

From the show's RSS feed, refreshed Nov 13, 2026. Source feed.

Subscribe Bookmark

Episodes

  1. Gangs of New York: why the film is almost as bad as DiCaprio and Diazs' accents Episode 219 GTSC podcast

    Bill the Butcher is easily one of the top movie villains of all time. And everyone's favorite morning show host, Bill Schulz, returns to explain why Daniel Day Lewis carries the carcass known as Gangs of New York across the finish line. Bill wants to get knuckle deep on the Martin Scorsese film...

  2. Why Iron Man is like an MCU Cybertruck and why Kevin Israel explains how it's overhyped Episode 218 GTSC podcast

    Surprise, we're back! And no better way to re-integrate than having our own Kevin Israel plop back into the Gutter's chair. His selection of Iron Man will shock and amaze everyone as he's the quintessential Marvel fan. Host Kevin Gootee and special guest co-host Bill Schulz (Formerly of Compound...

  3. BONUS EPISODE #39 What Did We Watch?

    Time for more top notch recommendations by 3 suave palettes: Kevin Gootee watched:the Barry Sanders documentary on Amazon Prime Kevin Israel watched "Violent Night", the story of the Santa Claus who kicks ass. Chris Woolsey watched "Nobody" with Bob Oedenkirk. Thanks for having with us every week...

  4. Close Encounters of the Third Kind BANISHED to Area 51 by Chris Woolsey Episode 217 GTSC podcast

    Star Wars, Star Trek, 2001 A Space Odyssey arere probably the most influential science fiction films of all time. Chris Woolsey from Crackle returns to take on arguably THE most influential, iconic, and copied sci-film of all time, Close Encounters of the Third Kind. Richard Dreyfus stars as one…

    more
  5. BONUS episode: What Did We Watch #38

    Well, we have a bunch of recommendations: Kevin Gootee watched: The Offer on Paramount Plus. It's the story about the trials and tribulations of the Godfather was made. Kevin Israel watched May December with Natalie Portman and Julianne Moore on Netflix Alex Hooper watched Leave the World Behind...

  6. Alex Hooper PRESSES RESET on Edge of Tomorrow episode 216 GTSC podcast

    The GREATEST action hero in the last 25 years is without question, Tom Cruise, had a rare underperforming film with Edge of Tomorrow. It underperformed so much in North America, they changed the title to Live, Die, Repeat which was the title of the Manga comic book/graphic novel/whatever you…

    more
  7. BONUS episode: What did We Watch #37

    Another quick mini-sode of...What Did We Watch? Kevin Gootee watched Peanut Butter Falcon Mike Price from The Simpsons watched new season of Fargo and Albert Brooks documentary on HBO/Max Ron Barba of Amazon Prime fame watched a bunch of Woody Allan movies. Bullets over Broadway and Match Point

  8. Rudy Doesn't Make the Playoffs as a Sports Movie Episode 215 GTSC podcast

    Notre Dame football, an underdog story, and Mikey from the Goonies or Sam the Hobbit from Lord of the Rings. Mike Price explains why he likes those 3 things but not all in one movie that ignored facts and fabricated plot lines. You know Mike from previous episodes like Argo, JFK, Batman Returns,...

  9. What Did We Watch BONUS Episode 36

    Kevin Gootee watched: Bookie on HBO Max, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, and The Girl Who Played with Fire. JL Cauvin watched Fist (Australian comedy), Monarch: Legacy of Monsters,and Slow Horses on Apple TV, George Neumann watched X and Pearl. The gang discusses some of the goriest scenes in...

  10. Why Inside Out Has 5 Emotions But No Heart Episode 214 GTSC Podcast

    We live in a world that has people find Pixar movies (not including this recent awful batch) overrated and we've now found our 2nd detractor. JL Cauvin returns for the 4th time to share why Inside Out is disappointing and how it's NOT a top tiered Pixar film. JL loves Coco, Toy Story 1-4, and the...

  11. What Did We Watch So You Don't Have To? BONUS Episode 35

    Kevin Gootee rewatched Octopussy, the Roger Moore James Bond film. Ray Stakenas watched You're Next, Lessons in Chemistry with Brie Larson Linette Palladino watched Paw Patrol 2, the Addams Family cartoon on Netflix, Ray Romano's standup special, and old Golden Girls episodes

  12. Why Clerks Isn't Supposed To Be Here in 2023 episode 213 GTSC podcast

    Why Clerks isn't supposed to be here in 2023? The 90's indie comedy juggernaut shuffles in front of the firing squad at the request of Ray Stakenas. Who Would Win's favorite curmudgeon returns to spit water in the face of a treasured Gen X comedy that literally spawned an entire universe…

    more
  13. Want some NEW movie recommendations? We'll check out our latest, "What Did We Watch?" bonus ep 34

    Like it or not, we've got some good and not so good film and tv recommendations for you? Rod Roddy, tell them what's on today's showcase! Kevin Gootee watched: The Covenant (2023) with Jake Gyllenhaal, Guy Ritchie's latest movie. Kevin Israel watched The Marvels (2023) with Brie Larson. He also...

  14. Why Donnie Darko donnie SUCKOS according to Phil Ranta episode 212 GTSC podcast

    Why is Donnie Darko so beloved and why does Phil Ranta feel it's unjustly revered?? We're back and Phil Ranta returns to assail one of the most recently beloved cult classics, Donnie Darko. Phil gets on a soapbox and methodically elucidates why this Jake Gyllenhaal and Maggie Gyllenhaal time…

    more
  15. BONUS episode: What Did We Watch #34 Gutting the Sacred Cow Podcast

    Let's hear about some films that are both fun watches and fun to tell everyone they should hold their nose and walk past. Kevin Gootee watched Old Dads on Netflix (Bill Burr and Bobby Canavale) as well as Diamonds Are Forever (Sean Connery) Lisa Curry watched "Paris 13th District", an interesting...

  16. Lisa Curry EXPELS Rushmore Episode 211 GTSC podcast

    Just as the nerds are sheathing their swords, another Wes Anderson finds itself on the business end of a broad axe. Lisa Curry, opener for Jim Jefferies, gets a megaphone to shout why Rushmore is one of the worst high school comedies ever made. Lisa explains how Bill Murray, Luke Wilson, Owen...

  17. Bonus Episode What Did We Watch #33

    For all of you who need movies or TV shows reviewed, we got you. So it's bonus episode time for What Did We Watch? Kevin Gootee watched: Joe from 1970 with Peter Boyle and Susan Sarandon. Bullitt with Steve McQueen Seynique Smythe watched: In Her Shoes with Cameron Diaz and Toni Collette Uptown...

  18. Seynique Smythe EXORCISES The Amityville Horror episode 210 GTSC podcast

    Hey trick or treaters! Seynique Smythe makes her premier appearance for our Halloween episode and explains why the original Amityville Horror is like finding razor blades in your candy. James Brolin (Mr Barbra Streisand) and Margot Kidder (Lois Lane in the Superman movies) aren't impressing her....

  19. BONUS EPISODE #32 What Did We Watch?

    You want recommendations? We have answers in a brand new WHAT DID WE WATCH episode. Kevin Gootee rewatched the first and last George Lazenby James Bond film, On Her Majesty Secret's Service Sophia Benoit watched Past Lives and Midnight Run with Robert DeNiro Amy Taylor watched The Machine with…

    more
  20. Sophia Benoit THROWS GLADIATOR TO THE LIONS episode 209

    Ever see a movie about gladiators? Sophia Benoit (Well, This Is Exhausting) has and she thinks a certain film called Gladiator is just hogwash. She explains why Russell Crowe and Joaquin Phoenix are less entertaining than Roman orgies and why this should never won the Oscar for Best Picture.…

    more
  21. What Did We Watch BONUS episode #31

    Kevin Gootee watched Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny, Guardians of the Galaxy 3, The Saint of the Second Chances (the story of Bill Veeck's son who created the St Paul Saints) and Burt Kreischer's, The Machine. Kevin Israel watched the Barbie, Blue Beetle, (The new DC superhero film)…

    more
  22. Don Jamieson WHACKS Goodfellas Episode 208 GTSC podcast

    A fan favorite gutter returns and picks THE film many thought would never be attacked. Don Jamieson (That Jamieson Show on Compound Media, That Metal Show, Comedy Central) has picked arguably the GOAT of mob movies, Goodfellas. You have to been as flummoxed as Kevin Gootee and Kevin Israel were...

  23. BONUS episode of What Did We Watch #30

    Kevin Gootee watched: It Ain't Over, the Yogi Berra documentary. The Lords of Flatbush with Henry Winkler and Sylvester Stallone, License to Kill (the 2nd Timothy Daulton James Bond film), and No Escape with Ray Liotta. Scotty Landes watched: Talk To Me (horror film), Joy Ride (2023), and…

    more
  24. Scotty Landes DISSOLVES the Royal Tenenbaums Episode 207 GTSC podcast

    The Citizen Kane of quirky, nerd comedies is possibly about to get its comeuppance. The Royal Tenenbaums is debatably the best of Wes Anderson films. Gene Hackman, Owen Wilson, Luke Wilson (thankfully they have different hair color and noses), Gwyneth Paltrow (I hate that I had to google her...

  25. BONUS episode What Did We Watch #29

    Kevin Gootee watched: (1947) The Drunken Angel Bucky Isotope watched: Winning Time, the LA Lakers documentary on HBO Dennis DiClaudio also watched a Japanese film, Lady Snowblood BONUS episode What Did We Watch #29

  26. Bucky Isotope DRIES OUT Singing in the Rain episode 206 GTSC podcast

    First Grease, then the Sound of Music, followed by Rocky Horror Picture Show. Now, Singing in the Rain. Bucky Isotope caught the word that Kevin Gootee hates musicals. He's dead set against Debbie Reynolds, Gene Kelly, Rita Moreno, and Donald O'Connor jumping around. This film is labeled as an…

    more
  27. BONUS minisode #28 What Did We Watch

    Kevin Gootee watched: Heavy Metal (1980) the Harold Ramis cartoon and Blood Diamond with Leonardo DiCaprio and Jennifer Connelly Bill Schulz watched: Winning Showtime, the Los Angeles Lakers show on HBO Abbie Barr watched Strange Planet on Apple TV BONUS minisode #28 What Did We Watch

  28. Abby Barr KICKS Old School off campus episode 205 GTSC podcast

    Many will argue that Old School is one of the greatest fraternity college films in the last 20 years as well as all time. You get Vince Vaughn post Swingers, Psycho, and Made. Will Ferrall gets his coming out party. Luke Wilson is...Luke Wilson. Scientologist Leah Remini before she was…

    more
  29. What Did We Watch BONUS EPISODE #27

    Kevin Gootee watched Tar with Cate Blanchett, Wedding Crashers with Vince Vaughn and Owen Wilson, and Surviving the Game with Ice T, John C McGinley, F Murray Abraham, and Rutger Hauer. Delvin Cox watched the new Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2023 Rob Patrick watched Renfield with Nicholas Cage

  30. Rob Patrick DEFANGS Blade episode 204 GTSC podcast

    What's the first African-American comic book movie that opened the door for the MCU and DCEU? It's not Meteor Man, Kazaam, or Steel...it's Blade! The man who refused to pay taxes, Wesley Snipes, slays vampires and the dialogue. We also get Tracey Lords in a non-porno film where she's NOT…

    more
  31. What Did We Watch BONUS MINISODE #26

    Kevin Gootee watched Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2023), Fletch (1984), and Bad Santa (2003) Juliette Miranda watched Evil Dead Rise (2023) David the Producer watched Oppenheimer What did you watch? let's hear your thoughts on our social medias: @gtscpodcast, @guttingthesacredcowpodcast...

  32. Juliette Miranda CLOSES THE BOOK on The NeverEnding Story episode 203 GTSC podcast

    The most Gen-X fantasy/fairy tale film finally meets its executioner and her name is Juliette Miranda. The NeverEnding Story sucked in kids to live through a book that had a horse drawn in mud, a wolf who liked children a little too much, a dad who drank raw eggs and orange juice, and a furry…

    more
  33. What Did We Watch MINI-SODE Episode 25 GTSC Podcast

    A bunch of recommendations to keep pass the time while you hop on a plane or ignore the last few weeks of hot weather? Why not?! We tell you what's good, what's meh, and what's terrible to watch on the aptly titled, What Did We Watch? Kevin Gootee watched The Woman King and 48 Hrs Britty Migs...

  34. Brittany Migs BOOTS OUT Annie Hall Episode 202 GTSC podcast

    It took 3.5 years and over 200 episodes and we FINALLY got someone sacking up to attack a Woody Allan film. Britty Migs wants an explanation how nebbishy and not so handsome Woody Allan is able to be a TWO TIME divorcee AND land Diane Keaton in Annie Hall. Inspired by Alvie, Woody Allen's...

  35. Mini-sode! What Did We Watch #24 GTSC podcast

    Looking for some new and old stuff to watch in the movie theater, streaming services, or dust off the DVDs Kevin Gootee watched Violent Night (the Santa Claus action movie) and Winning Time (Lakers championship run on HBO) Kevin Israel watched Marvel: Secret Invasion and rewatched Wedding…

    more
  36. Maura Quint THROWS Fargo IN A WOODCHIPPER Episode 201 GTSC podcast

    Another Coen brothers film that has another gutter volunteer as tribute? Oh Yah! You betcha! Maura Quint chose violence from some of you as she plays takes a tactician approach to why Fargo is overrated and is memorable for just 2 things: a wood chipper death scene and awful accent. Sure, Frances...

  37. What Did We Watch mini-sode #23

    Any idea what you should add to your watch lists? Well hell, we're more than happy to offer some suggestions. You can Venmo your thanks. Kevin Gootee watched Quarterbacks on Netflix Kevin Israel watched Jack Ryan on Amazon Prime Chase Mitchell watched Speak No Evil (Dutch horror film),

  38. Chase Mitchell FARTS ALL OVER Blazing Saddles episode 200 GTSC podcast

    Hey, it's milestone time, we're celebrating our 200th episode! Kevin Gootee and Kevin Israel thank you all for being part of our weekly sojourn. THANK YOU for sharing this podcast with your friends and family. Last week, Jackie Kashian came on to attack The Godfather, one of the greatest films of...

  39. What Did We Watch BONUS mini-sode #22

    Kevin Gootee watched John Wick 4, Scream 6, Mystery Alaska, and the Exam. Dave Quist watched Wes Anderson's Asteroid City, Righteous Gemstones, Joe Pickett, and What They Do In the Shadows Jackie Kashian watched Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle, Poker Face with Natasha Lyonne, Foil's War on Amazon...

  40. Jackie Kashian SHOOTS The Godfather At The Tollbooth episode 199 GTSC podcast

    No mincing words here. Jackie Kashian is metaphorically strapping on a suicide vest and attacking arguably, the greatest film ever made. The Godfather is not only beloved, financially successful, and acclaimed; it's probably most people's opinion of the best movie. She explains why Michael...

  41. BONUS episode: What Did We Watch #21

    What did we watch? Well, we're here to tell you what's fantastic and what's worse than being stuck in Union Square in NYC for a Playstation 5 Twitch/youtuber giveaway Kevin Gootee watched Oppenheimer, Creed 3, and the Whale Kevin Israel watched Transformers: Rise of the Beasts and Corvette Summer...

  42. Django Gold CLIPS The Crow's Wings Episode 198 GTSC podcast

    Brandon Lee accidentally died for his art while making the Crow. Django Gold would love to bring back Brandon AND Bruce Lee if the Crow would die the same death. One of the most imitated Halloween costumes that every goth guy and goth girl embraced for YEARS. Also, one of the most popular movie...

  43. Bonus Episode What Did We Watched #20

    We're giving you TV/movie recommendations that are 2 weeks old but nonetheless, valuable as hell. Kevin Gootee watched Mission Impossible: Dead Reckoning Part 1 with Tom Cruise Jeb Lund watched Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny with Harrison Ford and no one else worth mentioning Bill Schulz...

  44. Jeb Lund gives Shawshank Redemption A LETHAL INJECTION episode 197

    Some of you are complaining that this recent stretch of films aren't up to snuff but today, I dare you to agree Jeb Lund's (Vice, Gawker, Rolling Stone)choice...The Shawshank Redemption. Yep, the bromance story of Tim Robbins, Morgan Freeman, and the warden who was also in Demolition Man. Stephen...

  45. What Did We Watch minisode #19

    3 dudes giving unsolicited opinions on what to watch. And we're gonna keep on saving you time or advising what's good to check out. Joe Canale watched Extraction 2 on Netflix and the Bill Walton 30 for 30 doc Kevin Israel also watched Extraction 2 and Silo on Apple TV Kevin Gootee rewatched…

    more
  46. Joe Canale BANISHES Rocky Horror Picture Show Episode 196

    One of the longest running films of all time is the Rocky Horror Picture Show, over 45 years old. @KevinGootee has broken his Cal Ripken-esque streak of NOT seeing Rocky Horror Picture Show. Joe Canale wants to explain why the musical tale of Tim Curry, Susan Sarandon, and Meat Loaf are worse…

    more
  47. What Did We Watch #18

    Paul Tweeder (Heavy Spoilers) rewatched Terminator 3: Kevin Gootee watched the American Gladiators doc on Netflix as well as the 30 for 30 on ESPN. He also watched Event Horizon and the Getaway with Steve McQueen and Ali McGraw. Jeff Paul watched the doc on Journey. Also, he rewatched My Cousin...

  48. Paul Tweeder SENDS Platoon TO THE BRIG episode 195 GTSC podcast

    The Vietnam War kind of sucked. Oliver Stone was there and wrote a little film about it called Platoon and here it goes! Fire up Adiago for Strings and get ready for Paul Tweeder from Heavy Spoilers on youtube to begin the Tet offensive against Platoon. Paul explains why Tom Berenger, Charlie...

  49. What Did We Watch Bonus episode 17

    Dań Szymborski watched The Swarm Delvin Cox watched Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny Kevin Gootee (finally) watched Doc Hollywood, the latest Guy Ritchie film, Operation Fortune: Ruse de Guerre, The Invitation, O' Lucky Man with Malcolm McDowell Don't forget, you can find us on all podcasts...

  50. Dan Szymborski MICROWAVES Frozen episode 194 GTSC podcast

    Want to get your daughter to hate your guts before she turns 12? Dan Szymborski (Fangraphs and ESPN) will gladly hold your hand as he gives the step by step manual reasoning why you should hate Frozen. Dan says Elsa and Anna's cutesy poo adventures are masked by a weaker than normal Disney/Pixar...

About this show

Gutting the Sacred Cow invites guests to argue why some of the most financially successful, beloved or acclaimed films are trash or overrated. But here's the twist, the film must meet 1 of these criteria: widely beloved, financial success, or critically acclaimed. Standup comedians Kevin Gootee and Kevin Israel love films and they love arguing about them.. But will they agree with their guests arguments or feed them into a wood chipper?We give a platform with those who have unpopular opinions to be bold enough to voice them. What are some films that have faced scrutiny: Back to the Future, Goodfellas, Shawshank Redemption, the Dark Knight, Toy Story, Ferris Bueller's Day Off, the Matrix, and Die Hard. Can the guests persuade us or do we rip them a new one? Give us a listen and we'll easily prove that we belong on any top movie podcast list. We throw plenty of fun segments in the mix: 5 fun facts, our readers have us ask our guests questions they'd like answered in "Ask a Gutter"

Hosted by

MonkeyButt Productions ACPN

Categories

Frequently asked questions

How many episodes does Gutting the Sacred Cow have?

Gutting the Sacred Cow has 259 episodes on PodParley. The most recent episode was published on July 8, 2024.

What is Gutting the Sacred Cow about?

Gutting the Sacred Cow invites guests to argue why some of the most financially successful, beloved or acclaimed films are trash or overrated. But here's the twist, the film must meet 1 of these criteria: widely beloved, financial success, or critically acclaimed. Standup comedians Kevin Gootee and...

How often does Gutting the Sacred Cow release new episodes?

Gutting the Sacred Cow publishes weekly, based on its 259 episodes since October 2019.

Who hosts Gutting the Sacred Cow?

Gutting the Sacred Cow is created and hosted by MonkeyButt Productions ACPN.
Link copied