Home Is Where The Murder Is

On the surface, Arthur Gary Bishop appeared to be an ordinary, trusted member of his Utah community. But beneath that façade was a predator responsible for one of the state's most horrifying series of child murders. Between 1979 and 1983, Bishop abducted and murdered five young boys, leaving families and investigators searching for answers as fear spread throughout the Salt Lake City area. His carefully crafted double life allowed him to hide in plain sight—until one final disappearance unraveled years of deception. In this episode, we examine Bishop's background, the warning signs that went unnoticed, the investigation that ultimately exposed him, and the lasting impact his crimes had on the victims' families and the community. We also discuss the psychology behind his offenses, his confession, his decision to forgo appeals, and the lessons this tragic case continues to teach about recognizing and stopping child predators. Listener discretion is strongly advised. This episode contains discussions of child abduction, sexual abuse, and homicide that may be disturbing to some audiences.

In this podcast, we explore the extraordinary and controversial story of Marianne Bachmeier, the German mother whose name became synonymous with one of the most debated acts of vigilante justice in modern history. After the tragic murder of her seven-year-old daughter, Anna, in 1980, Marianne entered a courtroom in Lübeck, Germany, and fatally shot the man accused of the crime during his trial. Through historical context, eyewitness accounts, legal perspectives, and ethical discussion, we examine the events that led to that unforgettable moment and the questions it continues to raise decades later. Was Marianne driven solely by overwhelming grief, or did her actions expose deeper frustrations with the justice system? How did the public, the media, and the courts respond? And why does her story still resonate around the world? This episode offers a balanced look at one of history's most emotionally charged courtroom incidents, exploring the complex intersection of loss, justice, morality, and the limits of human emotion.

The Hunt Family murders remain one of the most haunting and heartbreaking crimes in modern history. In this episode, we examine the tragic events that shattered an entire family, exploring the timeline of the murders, the investigation that followed, and the evidence that led detectives to the truth. We also look at the lasting impact the case had on the community, the victims' loved ones, and the criminal justice system. With careful research and a respectful approach, this episode separates fact from speculation, providing a comprehensive look at a case that continues to fascinate true crime audiences. Listener discretion is advised, as this episode discusses violence, murder, and other disturbing subject matter.

The Dardeen Family murders remain one of the most horrifying and baffling unsolved crimes in American history. In November 1987, the quiet town of Ina, Illinois, was shattered when Keith Dardeen, his wife Elaine, their young son Peter, and their newborn daughter were brutally murdered in a case so shocking that it continues to haunt investigators and true crime enthusiasts decades later. In this episode, we examine the timeline leading up to the murders, the disturbing crime scene, the evidence uncovered by investigators, and the theories that have emerged over the years. Was this the work of a stranger, a serial killer, or someone the family knew? Despite numerous leads and speculation, the truth remains elusive. Join us as we respectfully explore the lives of the Dardeen family, the unanswered questions surrounding their tragic deaths, and why this devastating case remains one of Illinois' greatest unsolved mysteries.

On a quiet summer night in June 1996, a horrific crime shattered the Routier family's home in Rowlett, Texas. Six-year-old Devon Routier and five-year-old Damon Routier were brutally stabbed while they slept beside their mother, Darlie Routier, who survived with injuries of her own. What followed was one of the most controversial murder investigations in modern true crime history. Prosecutors argued that Darlie staged the crime and murdered her own sons, while the defense insisted an unknown intruder was responsible. A string of circumstantial evidence, media scrutiny, forensic questions, and one infamous "Silly String" cemetery video transformed the case into a national sensation that continues to spark debate decades later. In this episode, we examine the events of that tragic night, the investigation, the trial, and the evidence that led to Darlie Routier's conviction. We also explore the lingering questions that have fueled ongoing appeals and divided public opinion: Was justice served, or does reasonable doubt remain?

In this chilling episode, we travel to Baraboo, Wisconsin, to examine the horrifying crimes of the man who became known as the "Baraboo Bone Crusher." Behind the quiet streets of a small Midwestern town lurked a predator whose acts of violence shocked investigators and left an unforgettable mark on the community. We'll explore who he was, how his crimes unfolded, the investigation that ultimately brought him to justice, and the lasting impact his case had on Wisconsin. Separating fact from rumor, we'll take a closer look at the evidence, the victims, and the disturbing psychology behind one of the state's most infamous murder cases. Join us as we uncover the truth behind the legend of the Baraboo Bone Crusher—a case that proves unimaginable evil can exist in the most unexpected places. Listener discretion is strongly advised. This episode contains discussions of murder, graphic violence, and other disturbing subject matter that may not be suitable for all audiences.

EDIT: I am aware I was incorrect about how many children were killed by the hands of Diane Downs. I confused her with another case I am working on. She still sucks.   In this episode we continue on our states series that we started for one summer ago that has now lasted two years LOL. Robyn covers the cases of serial killer Randall Woodfield and Molly covers the very sad murder of Dawn Wagner. 

In this chilling episode, we explore the legend of Billy the Axeman, a shadowy figure tied to a string of brutal attacks in the early 1900s. As fear spread through the streets and families locked their doors at night, rumors swirled about a killer who struck without warning and vanished into the darkness. The mystery surrounding his identity and motives turned him into one of the era’s most unsettling figures. Who was Billy the Axeman? What drove the attacks that terrified an entire community? And how did the legend of this early 20th-century killer endure for so long? Join us as we examine the stories, the investigation, the victims, and the lasting legacy of a name that still sends a chill through true crime history. This episode contains discussions of murder and violence that may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

In this heartbreaking episode, we examine the tragic abduction and murder of Denise Amber Lee, a young Florida mother whose desperate fight to survive exposed critical failures within the 911 emergency response system. On January 17, 2008, Denise was kidnapped from her home in broad daylight. During the terrifying ordeal, multiple 911 calls—including one from Denise herself—provided opportunities for law enforcement to intervene. Yet a series of communication breakdowns and procedural failures prevented responders from locating her in time. We follow the timeline of Denise's final hours, the investigation that led to her killer, Michael King, and the trial that brought him to justice. We also explore the lasting legacy of Denise's case, which prompted significant reforms in emergency dispatch procedures and inspired her family to advocate for improvements that continue to save lives today.

In one of the most disturbing criminal cases in American history, Gary Heidnik turned an ordinary Philadelphia rowhouse into a place of unimaginable terror. During the late 1980s, Heidnik abducted, imprisoned, and brutally abused multiple women in a series of crimes that shocked the nation and exposed failures that allowed his violence to continue. In this episode, we examine Heidnik's troubled upbringing, his descent into violent crime, the harrowing experiences of the women he held captive, and the extraordinary courage of the survivor whose escape ultimately led police to uncover the horrifying truth hidden behind closed doors. We'll also explore the investigation, the trial that followed, and the lasting impact this case had on law enforcement, public awareness, and the victims' families. This is a story of manipulation, survival, and resilience in the face of unimaginable cruelty. Listener discretion is strongly advised. This episode contains discussions of kidnapping, torture, sexual violence, murder, and other disturbing subject matter that may not be suitable for all audiences.

His name is Wade Wilson—but unlike the comic book antihero, there's nothing fictional about the violence that made him infamous. In this episode, we examine the shocking case of Wade Wilson, the Florida man convicted of the brutal 2019 murders of Kristine Melton and Diane Ruiz. We'll trace the events leading up to the killings, the investigation that quickly closed in on him, and the disturbing courtroom testimony that revealed a pattern of manipulation, violence, and a chilling lack of remorse. We'll also explore the media attention surrounding the case, including the social media fascination with Wilson's appearance that sparked controversy while the victims' stories were often overshadowed. Most importantly, we remember the lives of Kristine Melton and Diane Ruiz and the devastating impact their murders had on their loved ones.

Continuing on with our state series, we cover murders that happen in Ohio and Oklahoma. Robyn covers the downfall of Judge Lance Mason who brutally murders his ex wife in a jealous rage and Molly covers the unsolved murders of Paul and Melody Jones.

The Pike County Shootings: A Family Annihilated   In the quiet hills of Pike County, Ohio, eight members of the Rhoden family were brutally murdered in a single night—an act of violence so calculated it stunned investigators and shattered a rural community. What initially appeared to be an unsolvable massacre slowly unraveled into one of the most complex and disturbing criminal cases in Ohio history.   In this episode, we examine the events leading up to the 2016 Pike County shootings, the painstaking investigation that followed, and the shocking truth behind who was responsible. From deeply rooted family conflicts and custody battles to years of secrecy, planning, and betrayal, this case reveals how obsession and control escalated into unimaginable violence.   This is a story about justice, grief, and the long road toward accountability.   Listener discretion advised.

Sue Sharp moved herself and her five kids across the country for a fresh start in the California, only for her dream to end in a bloodbath in Cabin 28. Sue and two others were found bound and slaughtered in the living room, her youngest daughter was nowhere to be found—and three other children somehow slept through the entire nightmare in the room next door. Decades later, with a botched investigation and maybe a local cover-up, the question remains: who was waiting for them in the dark...or is it a question at all? Case starts at 12:30 mark.

We are BACK, reunited and it feels so good! Robyn has today's case that she told back at our Live show in October. Paul Durousseau, often called the “Jacksonville Strangler,” targeted young women across Florida and Georgia in the late 1990s. He blended into everyday life while committing a series of quiet, calculated murders that left communities on edge. When he was finally caught, the scope of what he’d done shocked everyone. Starts around 11:00 minutes in.  

Episode 120: Christian Charles Nielsen - Black Bear Bed & Breakfast Murders Christian Charles Nielsen turned a quiet Labor Day weekend in 2006 at the Black Bear Bed & Breakfast in Maine into something out of a nightmare. What began as a seemingly ordinary stay spiraled into a string of chilling deaths. By the time the truth came to light, the peaceful mountain getaway had become the setting for one of Maine’s most unsettling murder sprees. Episode starts at 3:45

Thomas Grasso also known as "The Holiday Killer," was convicted of murdering two elderly victims in 1990 and 1991, one in Oklahoma and one in New York. After being extradited to Oklahoma, he was executed by lethal injection in 1995, just hours after making headlines for complaining about his final meal. His case remains infamous for its brutality and for his darkly memorable final words, which captured national attention. Don't forget to get your tickets to our Live Show on October 28th at Driftless Social in Mount Horeb, WI!

The case of Helle Crafts is one of the most infamous true crime stories in Connecticut history. In 1986, Helle, a flight attendant, disappeared, and her husband Richard Crafts was later convicted of her murder—despite her body never being fully recovered. Known as the “Woodchipper Murder,” the case became the first in Connecticut to secure a murder conviction without a complete body. Don’t forget to grab your tickets for our live show on October 28th at Driftless Social—available now on EventBrite!   https://www.eventbrite.com/e/home-is-where-the-murder-is-a-true-crime-podcast-live-tickets-1740577116009?utm-campaign=social&utm-content=attendeeshare&utm-medium=discovery&utm-term=listing&utm-source=cp&aff=ebdsshcopyurl

In 2019, a former NFL player and his wife were found dead in their Minnesota home, leaving a community in shock. Who could have done this to this beloved couple? This episode unpacks a chilling case where love, loss, and mental health collide with tragic consequences. 

We're back!!! After a bit of a break we are back with out state series. Join us as we cover North Carolina and the hearbreaking story of The Eastburn Family followed by North Dakota and the tragic case of the murder of Savanna Greywind. 

In 2013 in Wisbech, 86-year-old Una Crown was found dead in her bungalow, her body partially burned and bloodied—but investigators quickly ruled it an accident. What they missed were the stab wounds, the suspicious fire, and the man who lived just down the road. Over a decade later, DNA beneath her fingernails would finally speak—and expose a murderer hiding in plain sight.

Trapped in a coffin-sized box for seven years, Colleen Stan endured unimaginable abuse after being kidnapped by a seemingly ordinary couple. The Girl in the Box is a chilling true crime story of survival, manipulation, and the resilience of the human spirit.

Australia! Karen Ristevski vanished from her Melbourne home in 2016, sparking a nationwide search and intense media attention. As suspicions mounted, shocking revelations about her husband Borce's involvement would ultimately lead to his conviction for her manslaughter. This episode unpacks the timeline, investigation, and unanswered questions surrounding one of Australia’s most haunting true crime cases. Then we talk about a case suggested by listener Beck Smith - the murder of Nicholas Moore. 

Israel Keyes - The worst serial killer you may or may not have ever heard of. He was an American serial killer, rapist and burglar known for his calculated and diabolical crimes. Active between 2001-2012, he traveled across the entire U.S, burying "kill-kits" in various locations years in advance and chose his victims at random to avoid detection. But, he made one huge mistake that would ultimately lead to his arrest.  Listen here or watch our Facebook Live on our Facebook Group Page!

Robyn is BACK and we are doing the next states in our travel around the USA! New Mexico with serial killer Clifton Bloomfield and then New York with the murder of Kelly Ann Tinyes.    Join us as we catch up, talk about some true crime and Matt says a quick hello.

Today we have a special guest join us as Molly tells you about The Boise Murder House. This case takes place back on June 29th, 1987 on a hot summer day in Boise, Idaho, where a murder would take place that would give the house the nickname, The Chop Chop House. 

On Thursday, May 10th, 2001 in New York City above the famous Carnegie Deli in midtown Manhattan, Jennifer Stahl got two visitors she wasn't expecting and 911 would respond to 5 people being shot. Robyn takes us through everything that happened that night and how this case would be solved...and of course how Bon Jovi fits into it all as usual. 

Becky Bliefnick was shot 14 times inside her home in Quincy, IL and left behind her three sons who were her absolute world. Who did it and why? Thanks to video footage, they found the killer. 

In this episode, Molly covers the terrible case of how Richard Speck murders 8 young women in their townhouse in Chicago in what would be called, "The Crime of the Century."

On July 19, 2019 in Florida, a son does a bad bad thing. Robyn tells us about the Amato Family Murders.

In this episode we get back to our 50 state series and we cover New Hampshire and Bon Jovi's home state of New Jersey!

In this episode, we talk forever to get you caught up on our hectic ass lives and then we tell you the story of how Peter Porco lost his life in his New York home.

In this episode, Molly takes a page from Robyn's book and covers a serial killer! Join us as we head overseas to hear about the Camden Ripper.

Continuing on our State series and today we covered Nebraska and Nevada! The tragic murder of Brandon Tinna and The First Elvis Impersonator and his Beauty Queen Girlfirend!

In this episode we talk about the history of Pentridge Prison in Australia and some of the interesting inmates who called it home!

In this episode we celebrate our 100th episode! We recap some of our favorite episodes, our most listened episodes, and Molly tells us the story of the ridiculous, Weepy Voiced Killer. 

In this episode, Robyn covers the story of the Skidrow Slasher

Continuing on through our never-ending state series, today we cover Missouri and Montana

In this episode, Molly takes us down under and tells us about the horrible murders of the De Gruchy Family. Not to mention the complete injustice that came with it.  Lot's of WTF's so buckle up!

Continuing on our state series, today we cover Minnesota and Mississippi 

In this episode, Robyn covers the gruesome killings of murderer Jerry Brudos. 

Continuing on our Summer State Series (even though it totally isn't summer anymore), today we hit up Massachusetts and Michigan! Warning...Michigan makes Robyn REAL mad.

In this episode, Molly tells us the extremely sad story of how a daughter's motivation for money leads her to wipe out her entire family. You will be leaving 2024 on an angry note, but remember, you love us!

In this episode we travel back to 1984 and cover the horrible crimes committed by serial killer, Alex Ewing.

Continuing on our 50 state series, today we covered Maine and Maryland. 

In this episode, Robyn reads her Halloween Live show murder that was read at the Driftless Social on October 28th! This one takes place in Ohio and is one tragedy after the other.

In this episode Molly tells the sad yet heroic case of the Tiede family in Utah. 

In this episode we continue on our 50 State Series. We stop in Kentucky and Louisiana which is interesting because Kentucky is a rather safe state and Louisiana is a shit show. It's also the first episode back since Robyn was crowned USOA Ms. Wisconsin 2025! Lots to discuss in this show that you won't want to miss!

In this episode we cover the horrific murder spree of Louisiana serial killer, Derrick Todd Lee. 

In this episode, Molly tells the paranormal story of how Teresita Basa solves her own murder!