I've Got Something To Tell You

We’re back LIVE from BottleShop48!This week, Tayler takes us inside the Crescent Hotel, a gorgeous mountaintop resort turned “health resort” with one of the most horrifying backstories imaginable. Somehow, this place became a literal aesthetic dream, but underneath all that charm is a history full of deception, medical nightmares, and ghosts who may have never left.Then Colleen takes us to the 1994 World Cup for the tragic story of Andrés Escobar, the Colombian soccer star behind what’s been called the deadliest goal ever scored. But this story is not just about one Escobar… because hovering over Colombia at the same time was another name you definitely know: Pablo Escobar.This live episode has it all: haunted hotel glamour, medical horror, World Cup heartbreak, cartel connections, and, as always, plenty of laughs from BottleShop48.

Hello old pals, we hope you haven't forgotten us! We took a couple weeks to take a little break and recharge. For this week's episode we decided to do a little revisit and rewind to some of our favorite episode's and next week we will be coming in with FRESH new stories.This week, we're throwing it back to two stories from the podcast archives! Colleen revisits The Elevator Game from Episode 12, the infamous paranormal ritual from Reddit that claims to transport players to another dimension through a specific sequence of elevator rides. Tayler takes a look back at The Keddie Cabin Murders, the brutal and still-unsolved 1981 murders that Colleen originally covered in Episode 18. Join us as we revisit these early episodes and see how they hold up years later.Email us at [email protected] to send us a story or just say hi!

LIVE from Jarrod's! 🎙️This week, we're bringing you one of our favorite live shows yet — and trust us, the giggles were out of control.Tayler kicks things off with the story of Harold the Doll, a creepy little resident of Key West whose reputation for strange happenings has followed him for decades. And please don't insult him.Then Colleen dives into the unbelievable life of Rasputin — the peasant mystic who somehow went from wandering holy man to one of the most influential figures in the Russian Empire. Between the scandals, the rumors, the royal family drama, and one of history's most infamous murder plots, Rasputin proves that sometimes the truth is stranger than fiction.This episode has haunted dolls, Russian history, plenty of laughs, and all the chaos that comes with recording live in front of an audience.

Una mirada inteligente y divertida del mundo que nos rodea, siempre con el acento puesto en Extremadura. Con Antonio León y José Manuel Bañegil.

SPOILER ALERT! We discuss our new found love - Widow's Bay - and will continue discussing until the season is over. Want to join the convo with us, or have any theories? Email us at [email protected]!Then, Tayler dives into the dark history and hauntings of Yuma Territorial Prison in a paranormal-only episode. Built by the very inmates who would later be confined inside its walls, the brutal desert prison became known for its extreme heat, harsh punishments, overcrowded cells, and infamous dark cell. But according to visitors and staff, some prisoners may have never truly left. From ghostly figures and unexplained voices to chilling encounters inside the prison walls, we explore the eerie paranormal stories that continue to surround one of Arizona’s most infamous prisons.

This week’s episode is, once again, centered around men being absolute nightmares — both living and deceased. First, we dive into the story of Rodney Alcala, the “Game Show Killer,” who somehow made it onto national television despite radiating every red flag imaginable. A terrifying reminder that confidence truly carries some men way too far.Then in Part 2, we cover the San Pedro Poltergeist Case, where a woman is still tormented by a persistent male entity that simply refuses to leave her alone. Because apparently being ignored by women wasn’t enough for this man even after death. From unsettling encounters to full paranormal chaos, the story feels less like a haunting and more like spiritual harassment.So whether it’s serial killers on dating shows or ghosts with boundary issues, this episode is really just another case study on men disturbing women’s peace in every dimension possible.

This week, we’re revisiting two stories that have stuck with us long after we first covered them.Colleen brings back Tayler’s telling of Resurrection Mary, the infamous Chicago ghost legend known for eerie sightings, unexplained disappearances, and a story that continues to haunt decades later.Then Tayler revisits Colleen’s deep dive into Mark Twitchell, the so-called “Dexter Killer,” whose calculated crimes and disturbing obsession with the fictional series made this one of the most unsettling cases we’ve covered.Some stories don’t fade with time—and these are two we couldn’t leave behind.

This week on IGSTTY, Tayler takes us inside the terrifying San Pedro Poltergeist—a case centered around a woman named Jackie, whose home became the site of relentless, unexplained activity. We’re talking objects moving on their own, violent disturbances, and a presence that refused to stay quiet. Is it a true poltergeist… or something even more unsettling?Then Colleen dives into the chilling and infuriating story of the John du Pont and the Foxcatcher murder—the shocking killing of Olympic gold medalist Dave Schultz. What started as an opportunity for elite training at Foxcatcher Farm spiraled into paranoia, control, and ultimately, tragedy. It’s a case of wealth, power, and a man who never should have been allowed to go unchecked.From a house that may not have been empty… to a man who was unraveling in plain sight—this episode is unsettling in all the ways that matter.

This week, we’re heading deep into two of the creepiest corners of North American mystery.Colleen takes us to the shores of the Salish Sea, where severed feet have been washing up for years in one of the Pacific Northwest’s strangest and most unsettling unsolved phenomena. From the first sneaker-clad foot on the beach to the wild theories involving plane crashes, missing persons, suicides, and even serial killer whispers, this story only gets weirder the deeper we go.Then Tayler takes us deep into the Appalachian Mountains—where the rules aren’t written, but they’re always followed.From the eerie legend of the Flatwoods Monster to the haunting presence of the Wampus Cat, this episode dives into the things that lurk in the woods… and the ones you don’t see coming. We also explore the unspoken rules of Appalachia—why you should never whistle at night, never answer when something calls your name, and never ignore footsteps behind you when no one’s there.From the haunted shores of the PNW to the dark heart of the Appalachian mountains, this episode is full of mystery, paranoia, and the exact kind of nightmare fuel we live for. 🌲👣⛰️

This week’s episode takes a hard left from horrifying true crime into straight-up Reddit nightmare fuel.Colleen is covering the twisted and deeply disturbing case of Franklin Delano Floyd — a story filled with stolen identities, abuse, kidnapping, murder, and one of the most chilling webs of deception we’ve ever talked about. It’s one of those cases that somehow gets darker every time you think you’ve reached the bottom.Then Tayler is taking us into the eerie world of The Three Kings Ritual, the infamous Reddit-born paranormal game that promises contact with another realm… if you’re brave enough to play by the rules. Mirrors, candles, 3:30 AM, and a whole lot of “absolutely not.” Whether it’s a psychological experiment, creepypasta, or something much stranger, this one is pure late-night nightmare material.From real monsters to ritual horror, this episode is creepy from start to finish.🎙️ True crime, paranormal, and internet legends collide in this one — so grab your headphones, lock your doors, and let’s get into it.

This week, we’re bringing you a little witchcraft, a little chaos, and a whole lot of “what the actual hell?”Colleen kicks things off with the strange and still-unsolved story of who put Bella in the Wych Elm—a haunting post-war mystery involving graffiti, a hidden skeleton, and questions that have somehow refused to die.Then Tayler takes us into one of the most bizarre paranormal cases ever recorded: the Rosenheim Poltergeist. We’re talking exploding lightbulbs, swinging office equipment, and activity so intense it had engineers, physicists, and parapsychologists all scratching their heads.Is it supernatural? Is it psychological? Is someone—or something—just being wildly productive with their haunting schedule?Either way… we’ve got thoughts.🎙️ Tune in for eerie mysteries, chaotic energy, and just enough skepticism to keep things interesting.

In this episode we chat with one of the lovely people in the audience after one of our live shows, and she told us the spooky story of a haunted house in Tennessee she rented a room in. Are dead birds an omen? Would you stay in a house where you heard knocking within the closet? Grab a blanket, get cozy, and maybe turn a light on.... and tune into this listener story episode!Got a story to tell us? Email us at [email protected]

Recorded live at Jarrod’s, this St. Patrick’s Day episode dives into Irish folklore and history—where luck, legend, and violence collide.Tayler opens with the darker side of fairies and leprechauns, exploring the origins of these figures in Irish folklore, the rules surrounding the fae, and the long-standing belief that these are not creatures to take lightly.Colleen then covers the story of the Molly Maguires, a secretive group tied to labor unrest in 19th-century Pennsylvania coal mines. What followed was a series of violent acts, controversial trials, and a legacy that still raises questions: were they criminals, or were they fighting back against exploitation?This episode blends mythology and true crime, examining how stories of luck and mischief often mask something much more complex.

We hit the stage at Bottle Shop 48 for a live show that had everything: chaos, ghosts, and a 60-ton military tank.Colleen covers the unbelievable 1995 San Diego tank rampage of Shawn Nelson — a former Army tank crewman who stole an M60 Patton tank from a National Guard armory and drove it through city streets in one of the most infamous televised chases in history.Then Tayler takes us across the pond to Borley Rectory, often called “the most haunted house in England.” Phantom nuns, poltergeist activity, mysterious messages on the walls — and decades of paranormal investigation that still spark debate today.From freeway mayhem to ghostly hauntings, this live episode brings the energy.Grab a drink and buckle up.

Join us as we gather once again at one of our favorite spots: Jarrod's! We recorded this episode on February, Friday the 13th aka Galentines day!In this episode, Tayler tells the story of Brocarde, a singer-songwriter from Oxfordshire who is known for her dramatic gothic flair, dark romance, and theatrical aesthetic. But her love life took a very paranormal turn when she revealed she had fallen in love with a Victorian ghost named Edwardo. What started as a spooky rom-com fantasy complete with a gothic wedding and vows to thin air eventually turned into a cautionary tale, as Brocarde later shared that the relationship became intense and unsettling, leading her to end things and seek spiritual help. It’s a love story that proves dating is hard enough...even before you add ghosts.Colleen covers “How To Loose A Guy In 10 Ways,” spotlighting infamous women in true crime and the very final ways they got rid of their men:Melanie McGuire (The Suitcase Killer) – An argument ends with her boyfriend trapped in a suitcase while she… goes to bed. Nightmare fuel with a side of bad decisions.Dalia Dippolito – Hired a hitman to kill her husband, unaware the “hitman” was undercover and the whole thing was caught on camera. True crime meets reality TV.Jodi Arias – A toxic relationship spirals into obsession, lies, and one of the most disturbing crime scenes in modern true crime history.Belle Gunness – Early 1900s serial killer who lured suitors through personal ads, murdered them, and buried them on her farm. Dating apps walked so Belle could run.

Join us for this exciting episode, as we step inside the haunted halls of East Valley Paranormal in the heart of downtown Mesa, to interview owners and paranormal investigators Michelle and Heather.We sit down with them in their seance room, which is located INSIDE their haunted artifact museum. Tune in to hear all about how their friendship and love for the paranormal intuitively led them to what is now their own business, where their love for the paranormal started, how they formed community and so many spooky fun stories!

It’s our ONE-YEAR ANNIVERSARY — and we’re marking it with one of the most infamous studies in psychology: The Stanford Prison Experiment.What began in 1971 as a two-week simulation of prison life inside a Stanford basement spiraled into chaos in just a few days. Ordinary college students were randomly assigned to be “guards” or “prisoners” — and very quickly, power, control, and cruelty took over. What happened next would shock the researchers, traumatize the participants, and forever change how we think about authority, obedience, and human behavior.In this episode, we walk through how the experiment was set up, the key players involved, the chilling breakdown that followed, and why this study remains so controversial today. Was this groundbreaking psychology… or an unethical disaster that went way too far?

Get cozy and join Colleen and Tayler for a laugh-filled dive into the mysterious world of Bigfoot and Sasquatch! In this episode, we explore legendary sightings, share fascinating stories from the Bigfoot community, and even play real audio footage collected by the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization. Whether you’re a believer, a skeptic, or just here for the fun, this episode is packed with laughs, intrigue, and a touch of the unexplained.Got a story to tell? Email us at [email protected]

In this episode, we’re telling two stories that couldn’t be more different — and yet somehow feel eerily connected.Colleen covers the survival story of Alison Botha, a woman who endured one of the most brutal attacks in South African history and lived to tell the story. What happened to Alison is horrifying, heartbreaking, and impossible to forget — but her survival is a testament to resilience, memory, and the will to live when everything says you shouldn’t.Tayler explores the infamous alien abduction case of Betty and Barney Hill — a story that shaped modern UFO lore and raised uncomfortable questions about belief, fear, and how society treats people who experience the unexplainable.Together, these cases reveal something deeper than crime or conspiracy: the ways systems fail victims, the way truth gets doubted, and the cost of not listening when it matters most.This episode isn’t just about survival or starships.It’s about accountability.It’s about belief.It’s about the quiet, devastating truth that sometimes the world needs to do better.🎙️ Topics covered: true crime, survivor stories, alien abductions, justice systems, trauma, resilience, and the legacy of Betty and Barney Hill.#truecrimepodcast #survivorstories #paranormal #alienabduction #truecrimecommunity #bettyandbarneyhill #alisanbotha #darkhistory #unsolvedmysteries

This week on I’ve Got Something To Tell You, we’re diving into two stories that live at the intersection of obsession, conspiracy, and control.Tayler takes us deep into the Montauk Project — a long-running conspiracy theory involving secret government experiments, alleged mind control, time travel, and psychological warfare. From Camp Hero to the darkest corners of Cold War paranoia, she breaks down where the story came from, why it persists, and how much of it might be rooted in real government experimentation.Meanwhile, Colleen covers the tragic and disturbing story of Chris Benoit — one of the most shocking cases in professional wrestling history. This segment examines Benoit’s rise in WWE, the brutal murders that ended his family’s lives, and the role chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) may have played, while also confronting the complicated legacy he left behind.Together, these stories explore what happens when power, secrecy, and unchecked damage collide — whether in alleged government programs or inside the human brain.True crime. Conspiracy theories. Psychological horror. And a whole lot to unpack.

In this episode, we play another round of Top 5, counting down the places you’d absolutely refuse to go at night. From unsettling late-night locations to places that feel wrong the moment you step inside, we rank the spots that trigger pure fear, unease, and that instinctual need to leave immediately. Some are creepy because of what might be there… and others because of what used to be. Grab a blanket, get cozy and get ready to get creeped out! Or laugh at our answers. Either one.Got a story to tell us? Email us at [email protected]

Our first live show of 2026 — and we’re taking it back to where it all began: Jarrod’s Coffee Shop 🖤☕️In this live recording, Colleen covers one of Arizona’s most disturbing modern tragedies — the Sedona sweat lodge deaths and self-help guru James Arthur Ray, whose “Spiritual Warrior” retreat ended in multiple fatalities and a criminal conviction. We break down how wellness culture, manipulation, and unchecked power collided with devastating consequences.Then Tayler takes us across the country into the eerie history of Eastern State Penitentiary — a former prison turned paranormal hotspot with a legacy of isolation, suffering, and lingering spirits. From its radical design to the ghost stories that refuse to fade, this place has earned its reputation as one of the most haunted locations in the U.S.Recorded live with our favorite audience, plenty of caffeine, and just the right amount of chaos, this episode is equal parts true crime, history, and paranormal — and the perfect way to kick off 2026.

For our 50th episode, we’re going back to where it all began — literally and figuratively.This week, we’re celebrating the stories, the places, and the moments that shaped I’ve Got Something To Tell You from the very beginning.Tayler is covering the Rosson House — one of the first haunted locations we ever visited together on a ghost tour with our podcast crew, and a place forever tied to our earliest shared paranormal experiences.Colleen is covering The Baseline Killer, a case that unfolded right here in Phoenix and the story that sparked her lifelong obsession with true crime. It was the case she followed in real time, the one that pulled her in completely — and ultimately led her down the path that created this podcast.To make it even more full-circle, this episode was recorded on location at Hanny’s in downtown Phoenix — another stop from that same ghost tour, and a place famously known for the unsettling dolls hidden in its basement.This episode is part love letter to Phoenix, part reflection on 50 episodes of true crime and paranormal storytelling, and part reminder that sometimes the stories that change you most are the ones closest to home.

To close out 2025, we’re doing something a little different. In this New Year’s Eve episode, we’re each picking our favorite story the other one told this year. Taylor chooses her favorite episode Colleen covered, and Colleen picks her favorite story Taylor told — the ones that stuck with us, that we still reference, and that honestly shaped how we think about this year of the podcast.This episode is part reflection, part recap, and part love letter to the stories that made 2025 what it was. We talk about why these cases stood out, what made them so memorable, and why they continue to live rent-free in our brains long after recording.If you’re new here, this is a great place to jump in. And if you’ve been with us all year, consider this our way of closing out 2025 with the stories that meant the most to us.

In this Christmas Eve episode, Colleen and Tayler explore the darker side of the holiday season through true crime and folklore.Colleen covers the murder of JonBenét Ramsey, examining the events surrounding her death on Christmas night in Boulder, Colorado, the early investigation, and how the case became one of the most infamous and controversial unsolved crimes in American history.Tayler dives into Christmas folklore and holiday cryptids from around the world, moving beyond familiar figures like Santa Claus and Krampus. This segment explores lesser-known legends including mischievous underground creatures, winter witches who punish bad behavior, eerie bearded figures tied to holiday traditions, and other dark folklore associated with Christmas and the winter season.

We bring back our chaotic Top 5 segment — and this time, we’re digging through the most haunted objects ever sold on eBay. From cursed wedding rings and whispering teddy bears to journals that seem to write themselves, each reveal somehow gets worse than the last. The competition heats up, the reactions get louder, and by the time we hit the number one spot, we’re questioning why anyone would ever click “Buy It Now” again, but we're also questioning ourselves on why we both got the answer wrong. Tune in to find out what #1 was!Got a story to tell us? Email us at [email protected]

This week, we’re leaning into the darker side of the holidays — the kind that looks festive on the surface and deeply unsafe once you scratch it.Tayler kicks things off with the infamous Dybbuk Box, the object that went viral after being sold on eBay and quickly earned a reputation as one of the most “haunted” items on the internet. We dig into where the story came from, how it spread, and how a piece of folklore became a full-blown paranormal phenomenon through resale listings, media attention, and a lot of very bad decisions.Then Colleen takes us back to Victorian Christmas, a time when the holidays were beautiful, elaborate… and quietly lethal. From arsenic-laden dresses and toxic decorations to traditions that were actively dangerous, we break down how celebrating Christmas in the 1800s often meant exposing yourself to poisons, hazards, and risks people didn’t fully understand — and why so many festive traditions were, historically speaking, a terrible idea.It’s a holiday episode about cursed objects, deadly fashion, and the unsettling realization that Christmas has been trying to kill us for much longer than we’d like to admit.

Grab a blanket, a warm beverage and maybe a flashlight because this listener story is sweet but a little spooky. Tune in and get ready to hear this listener's childhood story of how she befriended a ghost girl. Got a story to tell us? Email us at [email protected]

We’re back at Bottleshop 48 for another live show, and this one might be our most chaotic pairing yet. Tayler digs into the dark folklore of Krampus — the horned, holiday menace who shows up when Santa’s had enough. Then Colleen takes us into the unbelievable real-life kidnapping of Frank Sinatra Jr., a case so strange she ended up telling it on its anniversary without even realizing it.It’s winter folklore, true crime, a few accidental coincidences, and a crowd that came ready for the weird.Settle in and enjoy the live energy.

This week on I’ve Got Something to Tell You, we’re taking you from the icy slopes of the Ural Mountains to the strange streets of Fresno.Colleen dives into one of the most puzzling and debated mysteries in true-crime history: The Dyatlov Pass Incident.Nine experienced hikers, a violent and unexplained night in the snow, baffling injuries, abandoned gear, and decades of theories trying to piece together what really happened. It’s cold, it’s chaotic, and it’s one of the wildest cases we’ve ever covered.Then Tayler brings the paranormal energy with a modern cryptid classic: The Fresno Nightcrawlers.Caught on grainy surveillance footage and forever burned into internet lore, these long-legged little weirdos have inspired debates, memes, merch, and maybe a few nightmares. We break down the sightings, the theories, and why they’ve become one of the most iconic cryptids of the last 20 years.If you love true crime, the unexplained, and stories that make you say “wait… what?”, this episode is for you.Available now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and all major podcast platforms.

In this special bonus episode, we dive back into our new favorite chaos generator — Top 5! This time, we wandered through the dusty aisles of a haunted antique store and things got unhinged fast. From self-rocking chairs to violin solos no one asked for, to mirrors with a mind of their own, every reveal had us screaming, laughing, and arguing over what should (or definitely should NOT) make the list. And of course, the #1 spot went to the one thing every antique store employee dreads… tune in to find out. It’s spooky, silly, competitive, and exactly the kind of haunted ridiculousness we live for.

In this week’s episode of I’ve Got Something to Tell You, Tayler and Colleen each bring a story guaranteed to haunt you in totally different ways.Tayler dives into the eerie legend of The Crying Boy — the infamous painting blamed for house fires, curses, and decades of unexplained bad luck. From tabloids to terrified homeowners, urban legend to alleged paranormal evidence, we unpack why a single image became one of the most feared art pieces of the 20th century.Then Colleen takes us into the true story that inspired the film Open Water: Tom and Eileen Lonergan, the married couple accidentally left behind in the open ocean during a routine scuba excursion on the Great Barrier Reef. Miscounts, cover-ups, unanswered questions, a chilling diver’s slate, and the mystery that still divides investigators, experts, and the public.

We’re back with another live show at Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa, where the caffeine is strong and the stories are even stronger. Tayler kicks things off with one of the most unsettling paranormal legends out there: the Black-Eyed Children. Creepy encounters, eerie folklore, and the kind of urban legend that leaves you double-checking your front door.Then Colleen dives into true-crime history with the life and murders of Nannie Doss, better known as The Giggling Granny. From toxic relationships to poison-laced endings, she remains one of America’s most notorious female serial killers.If you’re searching for true crime, paranormal stories, creepy folklore, haunted legends, or cases involving female killers, this episode covers it all.

This week’s episode takes a hilarious turn with our brand new segment...... Top 5!!! We dive into the “Most Haunted Foods,” and things get chaotic fast, partially because I (Tayler) forgets part of the rules before we begin. Between the wild guesses, unexpected answers, and competitive energy, this game had us laughing way harder than we expected. Who knew bread, meat pies, and ice cream trucks could be this spooky? Tune in for a mix of chaos, competition, and comedy — it’s the Top 5 debut you didn’t know you needed! ORDER UP! 👻🍴Got scary stories to tell us? Get featured on our next Listener Stories bonus episode. Email us [email protected]

In this episode, Tayler shares the haunting legend of Resurrection Mary, one of Chicago’s most enduring ghost stories — a restless spirit said to wander Archer Avenue, searching for her way home. Then, Colleen tells the heartbreaking story of Jayna Troxel Murray, whose life was tragically cut short in an unthinkable act of violence. 

We’re kicking off our first official listener stories segment — and it’s a wild one! Collected by an awesome friend from Bottleshop 48, this eerie tale follows a woman who starts noticing something strange about the guy she’s dating… he always seems to be around. Like, always. But the reason why will make your skin crawl. Grab a blanket, get cozy and tune in!PS. For more listener stories, check out our Short Stories segments that feature Kilee, and hear all about her spooky skinwalker encounters! 😱 PSS. Have a story to tell us? Email us at [email protected]

This week, we’re coming to you live from BottleShop 48, where the drinks were cold, the ghosts were active, and the stories were absolutely unhinged.Tayler kicks things off with the infamous Bobby Mackey’s Music World—a haunted Kentucky honky-tonk packed with murder, mayhem, and more basement demons than any bar really needs.Then Colleen dives into the unbelievable true-crime legend of Michael Malloy, the man who simply refused to die. It’s got bootleg booze, bad decisions, and the most incompetent murder plot in history.Two stories. One chaotic live show. 100% hauntingly hilarious.

This week, Tayler uncovers the real story behind The Exorcist — the chilling 1949 case of a boy whose terrifying possession and church-documented exorcism shocked the nation and inspired one of the most infamous horror films of all time.Then Colleen dives into the chaos that followed when Hollywood tried to bring that story to life — from mysterious fires and on-set injuries to unexplained deaths and a so-called curse that still haunts the film fifty years later.It’s faith, fear, and filmmaking gone wrong — the true story that became a legend, and the movie that may have taken the word “possession” a little too literally.

The Sallie House + Karl Tanzler, "The Corpse Bride" This week, Tayler takes us to Atchison, Kansas — inside one of the most famously haunted homes in America: The Sallie House. From flickering lights to ghostly scratches, it’s a story that blurs the line between haunting and possession… and proves some spirits don’t like uninvited guests.Then Colleen dives into the macabre love story of Karl Tanzler — a radiologist so obsessed with a patient that even death couldn’t stop him. What follows is one of the strangest, most disturbing tales of devotion ever told.It’s obsession. It’s possession. It’s love gone way, way too far.

The Salem Witch TrialsSpooky Season continues — and we’ve got another special episode where we tackle a big story together.This week, Colleen covers the Salem Witch Trials — the true story of hysteria, accusations, and executions that turned a quiet Puritan village into a nightmare. From the “lil gurls” whose claims sparked mass panic to the haunting legacy left behind, it’s one of history’s darkest moments.Then Tayler heads to modern-day Salem, exploring haunted inns, cursed cemeteries, and the lingering energy that still surrounds this infamous town. 👻🎧 Listen now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your shows — and don’t forget to rate, review, and share if you’re bewitched by the story.

In this spooky bonus episode, Colleen kicks things off with one of her dad’s eerie real-life ghost stories before diving into a recap of her recent San Diego trip — where she bravely visits the famously haunted Whaley House. Tayler follows up with a chilling Reddit tale that’ll have you double-checking the shadows. Cozy up, light a candle, and get ready for some ghostly fun!Have a story to tell us? Email us at [email protected]

Our first LIVE SHOW!!  Recorded live at Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa, this episode dives into the real story behind The Amityville Horror. Colleen and Tayler trace the 1974 DeFeo family murders at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, Long Island, and unpack how a tragic true crime case turned into one of America’s most famous haunted-house legends. We cover Ronald DeFeo Jr.’s conviction, the Lutz family’s 28 days in the house, the claims of demonic activity, and the media frenzy that followed—from book deals and movie adaptations to the paranormal investigations (hello, Ed and Lorraine Warren). Along the way, we separate documented facts from sensational myths, explore the town’s complicated relationship with its most infamous address, and ask: what, if anything, still lingers behind those quarter-moon windows?

In this chilling episode, Colleen dives into the disturbing true story of Dean Corll, infamously known as “The Candy Man,” whose crimes in the 1970s left Houston shaken. Then, Tayler takes us to Harrisville, Rhode Island, to explore the haunting true events behind The Conjuring — the story of the Perron family and their terrifying experiences that inspired one of the most iconic paranormal films of all time. Grab a blanket and a cup of tea, because this one’s equal parts true crime and supernatural horror.

Get ready for another bonus episode, where Tayler and Colleen tell stories they pull from the tops of their noggins, and from the eerie depths of reddit. And in this episode, we have another skinwalker encounter story from Kilee! Grab a blanket, get cozy and get ready to embrace spooky season with us!Have a story to tell? Email us at [email protected]!

Back by popular demand — we got a whole lot spookier this week! We packed up our gear and headed to the famously haunted Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa for a special bonus episode. Armed with our spirit box, we tried to make contact with whoever might still be lingering in the café.From unexplained knocks to eerie voices coming through the static, this one had us looking over our shoulders the whole time. Grab your headphones, your coffee, and maybe some sage — because Jarrod’s doesn’t disappoint.

On July 15, 1976, a summer school bus in Chowchilla, California, vanished with 26 children and their driver. Hours later, the bus was found abandoned — the kids and Ed Ray were gone without a trace. What followed was one of the largest child abductions in U.S. history, a nightmare that led to the victims being buried alive underground in a moving truck.In this week’s solo episode, Colleen takes you inside the story: the terrifying hijacking, the frantic parents and FBI search above ground, the impossible fight for survival below, and the shocking truth about the men who orchestrated it all.This is a case of resilience, community, and a bus ride that became a national nightmare.

This week on I’ve Got Something To Tell You, Tayler guides us through the eerie legends of Bachelor’s Grove, Chicago’s famously haunted cemetery where phantom cars, vanishing houses, and ghostly mourners still roam. Then Colleen pulls us across the Atlantic for the chilling true-crime tale of the Beast of Jersey, the masked predator who stalked the Channel Island for over a decade.

This week on I’ve Got Something to Tell You, we’re diving into both true crime and the paranormal. Colleen unpacks the haunting case of Tent Girl—a young woman discovered in a canvas bag off a Kentucky roadside in 1968, whose identity remained a mystery for decades. Then Tayler brings the spine-tingling story of Robert the Doll, one of the world’s most infamous haunted dolls, feared for his curses and chilling encounters in Key West.If you love true crime podcasts, unsolved mysteries, and paranormal legends, “Dolls and Does” has it all—murder, mystery, and the kind of cursed energy that’ll have you questioning your camping trips and your childhood toys.

On this bonus episode, Colleen and Tayler talk near death experiences, ouija board stories + a personal one! And a true crime involving murder by mushrooms. Get cozy, and tune in!Got a scary story? Email us at [email protected]

This week, Colleen dives into the chilling and still-unsolved case of Cindy James, a nurse from British Columbia who reported years of stalking, threatening phone calls, and terrifying attacks before her mysterious death in 1989. Was Cindy truly the target of a relentless stalker—or was there something darker happening behind the scenes? We explore the evidence, theories, and lingering questions in one of Canada’s most haunting true crime cases.Then, Tayler takes us out to sea with the eerie legends of ghost ships—from vessels found mysteriously abandoned to maritime tales of phantom crews and cursed waters. From the Mary Celeste to modern nautical mysteries, these stories prove that the ocean holds more secrets than we’ll ever know.Join us for a mix of true crime, paranormal history, and WTF mysteries in this episode of I’ve Got Something to Tell You.