Le Batard & Friends - Mystery Crate
by Roy Bellamy, Chris Cote, Tony Calatayud, Jeremy Tache, Jessica Smetana, Jonathan Zaslow
Mystery Crate will serve as a random grab bag of weekly topics curated and created by varying members of the "LeBatard & Friends" universe. You'll never know who or what an episode may bring. It's a mystery some would say.
Episodes
-
Episode Four Hundred - Four: Chris Cote, Juju Gotti and a Baseball Disaster
Did Ethan take things too far with seven-time NASCAR champion Jimmie Johnson? After Jimmie showed some love to Ethan’s dog, Percy, Ethan asked the racing legend to pose for a photo—and the Mystery Crate crew cannot agree on whether the moment was adorable or completely embarrassing. Chris Cote…
more -
Episode Four Hundred - Three: Wet Socks All Day or a Phone at 1%? The Crew Debates
Roy’s trip to a Florida Panthers game ends with a flooded parking lot, water in his Mustang and a photo that completely confuses Dan Le Batard. The Mystery Crate crew breaks down what happened and gives Roy’s photographic evidence the attention it deserves. Plus, Jeremy takes a stand against...
-
Episode Four Hundred - Two: Would You Give Up a Year of Your Life for $1 Million?
Would you trade a year of your life for $1 million, and how many years would you give up? Mystery Crate’s Halloween episode gets spooky fast as the crew puts a price on their remaining years and debates how much money it would take to live with ZERO privacy. Plus, Chris Cote declares Halloween…
more -
Episode Four Hundred - One: Late Night Panics, Bad Robbery Theories & Movie Theater
It’s past midnight and things start going wrong! In this episode of Mystery Crate, Tony breaks down the most inconvenient 1 AM situation that kept him up: a back door lock failure that turned into a late-night shed trip with a rusty ax.The crew dives into late-night home security panics, the...
-
Episode Four Hundred: Can You Cheat Death? + Noah Centineo & Nickelodeon Bracket!
In today’s episode, the crew tackles some wild stories and unexpected moments:We A mind-blowing story about surviving a car crash, beating cancer, and a crazy theme park incident. How much risk is too much? We dive into theme park safety, blacking out on roller coasters, and a potential collab…
more -
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety Nine: Top 5 Heinous Sins, Chicken Chaos & The Disney Suit Guy
The crew is back on Mystery Crate with Amin Elhassan joining Chris Cote, Jeremy Tache, Roy Bellamy, Tony Calatayud and Jess Smetana! In this episode, Tony reveals his top 5 most heinous sins spotted at Disney World and Universal Studios—from guys in thong sandals and heavy tracksuits to the viral...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety Eight: Disney Disasters, Sleep Position Fail, & Fantasy Running Back Check-In
The Mystery Crate crew is back, and nobody is sleeping normal! Jess drops a mystery photo in the group chat that has everyone trying to figure out how human limbs work, while Jeremy tries to troubleshoot his leaking air conditioner (and whether to just call a friend). Plus, Tony checks in live…
more -
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety Seven: Chris Cote Is Ditching Thanksgiving—Will Greg Let Him?
Chris Cote reveals his plan to skip the traditional family Thanksgiving and take his wife and daughter to Disney World instead—but is it a brilliant holiday idea or a family betrayal?The Mystery Crate crew also gets an update on Chris’s latest officiating experience, including the embarrassing...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety Six: Chris Cote Is Officiating a Wedding… Is That Legal?!
Football season is finally here! The crew shares their perfect setup for watching Week 1—and the reality of how everyone actually watched the games. Rose also gives Jess her best hacks for secretly watching Netflix, football, or anything else while working in a press box.Jess recaps her US Open...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety Five: The Most Dangerous Running Back Draft
The crew creates a Survivor-style draft where NFL running back injuries could eliminate your team. Who made the smartest picks—and whose season might be over before it even begins? Tony brings a new round of “Would You Rather,” we find out who’s actually a good driver, and Rose tells us about her...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety Four: Jeremy Releases His First Country Song
Jeremy Tache makes his country music debut with the world premiere of “Diary of a Personable Fella,” and the Mystery Crate crew shares their unfiltered reactions! Chris Cody also announces his very own intern program, while Jonathan Zaslow tells an unforgettable Super Bowl Radio Row story…
more -
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety Three: Drafting Our Last Meals & Dream Brothers-in-Law
The Mystery Crate crew is drafting their ultimate last meals and the people they’d most want as their brother-in-law.We also confront our fear of bridges, debate whether we could ever jump off one, and learn from Zaslow that you can put a sticker on your house to tell firefighters there’s a dog...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety Two: Chicken for Life or $40k? Wedding Etiquette, Solo Trips and JFK's Body
Would you rather have chicken for life or $40,000 in cold hard cash? Plus, is JFK's body really where they say it is? Is it weird to take a solo trip? And the unwritten rules of weddings all on this week's Mystery Crate.
-
Episode Three Hundred - Ninety: A 4 A.M. Fishing Trip at a Bachelor Party?!
Should a bachelor party have a detailed itinerary—or should everyone just go with the flow?The Mystery Crate crew debates a chaotic Naples bachelor party schedule featuring a 4 a.m. fishing trip, an 8 a.m. workout, basketball, a sauna, a cold plunge, steak and eggs, and absolutely no concern for...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty Nine: We Were WHAT in High School?! Rose Falls Asleep Mid-Show
This week on Mystery Crate, we’re going back to high school—and some of the revelations genuinely shocked us. We break down exactly who we were as teenagers, the cliques we belonged to, and how we’re slowly becoming our parents whether we like it or not.Plus, Rose takes Midol before recording and...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty Eight: Rose Stole Justin Bieber’s PlayStation… Then Lost It?
Rose stole Justin Bieber’s PlayStation in Guatemala… and then somehow LOST IT. Yes, this story is as chaotic as it sounds.This week on Mystery Crate, Chris tells us about his time in New York, including some unexpected celebrity sightings. We also get into Chris’s eating habits, the Top 100…
more -
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty Seven: The Nolan Movie Draft & The Messi Simulation Theory
On this week's Mystery Crate, things get weird... fast. We debate our Top 3 Christopher Nolan movies, while Chris somehow becomes our resident Nolan expert... despite only really watching the Batman movies. Then we spiral into one of the internet's wildest rabbit holes: the famous photo of baby...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty Six: Chris Reveals His Biggest Fear
What do an old ship in New York, the worst months of the year, Chris' legendary "ass story," Zas' old story, a TV show that disappeared out of nowhere, and the FIFA World Cup have in common? Absolutely nothing... which is exactly why this episode is chaos from start to finish. We debate the most...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty Five: Rose CAN'T Finish These Songs + Our 4th of July Plans
Happy 4th of July! 🇺🇸 This week on Mystery Crate, we're talking all things Independence Day—from our holiday plans to the different types of people you'll find at every 4th of July party. We also introduce a brand-new game where Rose has to finish the lyrics to some iconic songs... and let's…
more -
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty Four: Chris Wants to Go on Love Island… So He Pulled Roy for a Chat
Chris and Zas are back with another edition of Show and Tell, and things only get weirder from there. This week on Mystery Crate: • Chris & Zas bring their latest Show and Tell items.• We check back in on the World Cup teams we were assigned and see how everyone's doing.• We revisit which people...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty Three: World Cup Correspondent, Matzo Chips, and the New Show Draft
Fuentes returns from the World Cup with stories from the stadium, the atmosphere, and everything he saw on the ground. Meanwhile, the rest of us were assigned World Cup teams and had to present our scouting reports... with wildly different levels of preparation and expertise.Plus, we try matzo...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty Two: We Let a Wheel Pick Our World Cup Team And Regretted It Immediately
A brand-new Mystery Crate anthem has arrived! Jeremy unveils the latest Mystery Crate song before the crew dives headfirst into World Cup fever. With some members of the show preparing to attend matches, we decided to assign everyone a national team to support during the World Cup. The catch?...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty One: The Athlete Best Friend Draft | Who Built the Best Squad?
Who would YOU choose as your athlete best friend?This week on Mystery Crate, the crew holds the ultimate Athlete Best Friend Draft. The rules are simple: pick professional athletes you'd actually want in your friend group. No fantasy teams, no championships, just vibes.From Caitlin Clark and Tom...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Eighty: Tony's One-Star Review Was SAVAGE
Tony refuses to leave bad reviews online... but after this restaurant experience, he may have changed his mind. From surprise fees and automatic gratuity to one-star reviews and food debates, this episode goes completely off the rails. Featuring: Restaurant horror stories Viral AI music Movie...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy Nine: We Exposed Everyone’s High School Photos
The Mystery Crate crew digs up old high school photos… and immediately regrets it. In this episode: Everyone gets roasted over their teenage years Jess survives a giant flying cockroach encounter A surprisingly heated sushi debate Wedding etiquette arguments Rose explains Off Campus in a way only...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy Eight: Illegal Littering, Drunk Deer & Pandemic Trauma
Tony is moving into his new house and desperately needs help… but nobody on Mystery Crate wants to lift a single box. Then Rose casually admits she once dumped an entire couch at a construction site and LEFT IT THERE. This episode spirals into: Illegal couch littering confessions The worst moving...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy Seven: Mystery Crate’s Most Unhinged “I’m The Kind of Guy” Confessions
On today’s episode of Mystery Crate, we somehow went from discussing Matthew McConaughey’s disgusting tuna recipe… to debating the greatest fictional houses ever… to fully tier-ranking LETTERS of the alphabet. Yes. Actual letters. Along the way: Chris Cote reveals a truly disturbing shower habit...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy Six: The Saddest Songs Ever Debate + Rose's Awkward Mike Schur Story
On today’s episode of Mystery Crate, Chris Cote reveals how his DraftKings joke completely fell apart live on-air, Rose tells the most awkward Dan Le Batard / Mike Schur story imaginable, and the crew debates the saddest songs of all time. We also get into celebrity sightings at LaGuardia, elite...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy Five: Is Jeremy an Ally? How Many Times Do YOU Cook in a Week + 2000 MLB Logos Tier List
Is Jeremy an Ally? How Many Times Do YOU Cook in a Week, Chris Cote is snuggled up af, an we dig into 2000 MLB Logos Tier List all on this week’s Mystery Crate.
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy Four: Chris Looks Good + Zas's Microplastics
This week on Mystery Crate, commenters call Chris Cote skinny so he celebrates by eating like crap. Zas has microplastics in his balls and we get a newly minted, Cote's New Ass Story of the Day to pair with Zas's Old Ass Story of the Day.
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy Three: We Sent Rose to Applebee’s… in Guatemala 🇬🇹
On today’s episode of Mystery Crate, things go completely off the rails… We start with a very heated debate about tuna (yes… tuna), somehow transition into Masters menus, Larry Bird stories, and then—out of nowhere—Rose takes us on a LIVE tour of Guatemala City 🇬🇹… all the way to an Applebee’s....
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy Two: We Have A New Song, Sort Of
Things got completely out of hand on this episode of Mystery Crate.We kick things off with the murder of the cold open, followed by a wild negotiation over $200, an original song debut, and then… absolute chaos.The main event: a 2v2 trivia showdown featuring buzzers, confusion, cheating...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy One: We Tried a Simple Game… It Turned Into Chaos
On today’s episode of Mystery Crate, we officially enter a new era… and it immediately goes off the rails.We debut our first official game from the new team draft format — Roy vs Tony in a head-to-head “name the category” battle — and let’s just say… rules were broken, arguments were made, and...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Seventy: We Let Rose Pick a Perfect Bracket for $1 Billion
On today’s episode of Mystery Crate, we attempt the impossible: win $1 billion with a perfect March Madness bracket… by letting Rose make every pick with pure vibes and almost no college basketball knowledge.Before that, Zaz’s Old-Ass Story Time takes us back to one of the most iconic moments in...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty Nine: Zas’ Big Ass Story Time + Bam Debate + Tarantino Tier List
Today on Mystery Crate, we’ve got a loaded show.Zas debuts Big Ass Story Time with an emotional trip back to Magic Johnson’s unforgettable 1992 NBA All-Star Game moment. Jeremy finally gets the floor to defend his Bam Adebayo superstar take after Bam’s wild 83-point performance sparks chaos,...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty Eight: Drafting Captains for Mystery Crate
A new era of Mystery Crate officially begins — and it starts the only way we know how: arguing about the cold open, bullying each other’s “sexy voice,” and accidentally creating a year-long competition that will absolutely ruin friendships.In this episode, we introduce Zas Storytime…
more -
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty Seven: Officially “Dorky”? + George R.R. Martin Conspiracy + 6 Burgers
On this episode of Mystery Crate, things spiral immediately.Mike Fuentes attempts to defeat Chris Cote by taking on the 6 McDonald’s cheeseburger challenge — can he actually finish six McDonald’s cheeseburgers in one sitting? From there, the show derails into a full-blown argument about the...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty Six: GREG Is Here… (and It Gets Naughty)
GREG COTE IS HERE on Mystery Crate — and we put him to work immediately: a full-on Frank’s RedHot taste test (original, buffalo, garlic parm, pineapple Hawaiian, ghost pepper ranch, spicy maple and more) to rank his top 3 hot sauces like it’s a “Hot Ones” episode… but with chips and a very loud...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty Five: Chris vs. 6 McDonald’s Cheeseburgers (O/U 5.5)
Chris Cote attempts the ultimate McDonald’s cheeseburger challenge — how many plain McDonald’s cheeseburgers can he eat in one show? We set the over/under at 5.5 burgers, the burgers hit the table, and Chris hits the wall (with the mic paying the price).Then we jump into the viral ChatGPT…
more -
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty Four: Roy Tries Mexican Wedding Cookies
After the show's successful experiment of having Zas try different sodas, Roy is forced to try a random item from the studio's kitchen. The show then explores the ghosts of Super Bowls past as they remember moments from the last few Super Bowls the show has traveled too. Chris Cote then questions...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty Three: Zaslow Tries Root Beer
Zaslow joins Mystery Crate to do something he has never done as a 45 year old man, try different sodas including a dreaded root beer. He also wants you to know that 'Sinners' is just a great movie and not the greatest movie of all time. Jessica got engaged and the group is excited to hear exactly...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty Two: Proper House Guest Etiquette
On a lean episode if Mystery Crate, the crew discusses the proper way to be a house guest when you take a trip or the best way to not be one at all. Chris Cote believes he is on a hot streak when it comes to ordering good food and suggests he can manipulate his daughter into ordering things he...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty One: Don't Sleep on Dominoes
The boys bring Rose in on an impromptu game of Dominoes annoying Mike Fuentes who is just trying to do a podcast. The crew then quickly gives their takes on the finale of Netflix's "Stranger Things" before diving in to Chipotle's new ridiculous high protein menu. Chris Cote then figures out what...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Sixty: Heated Rivalry, eh?
The crew breaks down the conclusion of Stranger Things, agreeing that no matter how it ended, people were going to hate it anyway. From there, they zoom out and celebrate the fact that we’re living in a rare moment with a lot of genuinely good TV to watch, including Heated Rivalry on HBO. The...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Fifty Nine: Merry PLUR1BUS!
The crew starts by unpacking Apple TV’s PLUR1BUS and asking the only question that really matters: are the spiney trees real? From there, they argue that people are doing Christmas gifts all wrong by telling their families exactly what they want, before getting nostalgic about why celebrating New...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Fifty Eight: The Future of Mystery Crate
The crew kicks things off with Chris Cote trying to get out the door to head to Fort Myers for an important family movie screening. From there, they dive into the world of social media and why certain trends have become downright terrible content. They also break down the conclusion of Tim...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Fifty Seven: Spotify Wrapped Season!
The studio is in crisis after Jeremy microwaved his brussel sprouts — though, to be fair, it wasn’t entirely his fault. From there, everyone nominates what they believe is the best possible nights of the year. The crew then dives into their thoughts on "Wicked: For Good" before closing things out...
-
Episode Three Hundred - Fifty Six: Stranger Things is BACK!
The crew can’t contain their excitement for the upcoming final season of Stranger Things, talking fan theories, predictions, and goodbyes for their favorite characters. But after all the Upside Down talk, the craters dive into the first ever draft of what they’re most thankful for and pie draft....
-
Episode Three Hundred - Fifty Five: Goodbye Pennies, Hello Benny
Tensions are high as the crew revisits who’s brave enough to say they don’t want turkey this year for Thanksgiving. Chris Cote introduces his new dog, Samantha Bennett. Then it’s a spirited argument about when it’s actually acceptable to put up Christmas decorations, followed by a Jess sharing a...
About this show
Mystery Crate will serve as a random grab bag of weekly topics curated and created by varying members of the "LeBatard & Friends" universe. You'll never know who or what an episode may bring. It's a mystery some would say.
Hosted by
Roy Bellamy, Chris Cote, Tony Calatayud, Jeremy Tache, Jessica Smetana, Jonathan Zaslow
Categories