Let The Good Crimes Roll

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey and Sarah as they discuss the case of Tara Baker. Years after a law student is murdered, renewed attention leads to an arrest and a courtroom twist.Source: DatelineSupport the show

Send us Fan MailWe kid, we kid. On this week's episode we finally finish the covering the case from the documentary, Trust Me: The False Prophet.Support the show

Send us Fan MailIn this episode, One Bowling Ball of a Man, we dive into the first two episodes of Trust Me: A False Prophet and unpack the unsettling story at the center of it all. Join us as we react to the shocking details introduced in episodes one and two. This is just the beginning, and already, there’s a lot to unravel.Support the show

Send us Fan MailIn this episode, we dive into the haunting and complex case of Jenny Pandos, as explored in the HBO documentary Burden of Proof. When Jenny disappeared without a trace, the story left behind raised more questions than answers—and decades later, those questions still linger.Using Burden of Proof as our guide, we unpack the timeline of Jenny’s disappearance, examine the evidence, and explore the emotional journey of a family searching for the truth. We also take a closer look at how the case was handled and the lasting impact it has had on those closest to it.Support the show

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Casey and Husband Derek dive into the chilling true story behind the documentary The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story. We discuss the shocking crime that rocked a small community, the influence of horror culture on the case, and the disturbing line between fiction and reality. Join us as we unpack the details of the investigation, the psychology behind the teens involved, and the questions the documentary leaves lingering. It’s a haunting conversation about obsession, influence, and how a love of horror took a terrifying turn in real life. Support the show

Send us Fan MailSarah and Casey discuss the case of Aileen Wuornos, using the Netflix documentary, Aileen, Queen of the Serial Killers, as a source.Support the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Sarah and Casey as they interview Stephanie and her best friend, Elizabeth, discuss the conclusion of Season 1 of the Podcast, "Everything They Missed."https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/everything-they-missed/id1834984809Support the show

Send us Fan MailDo you like true-crime stories? Do you like thrillers? Well, I like them both, but I also love to write. In the weeks ahead, join me, Casey Forbes, as I venture into a new project, where I’m Inspired By a True Crime.Support the show

Send us Fan MailWe're going international, ya'll. Join Sarah, Casey, and Husband Derek as they discuss Netflix's documentary, Murder in Monaco. When billionaire Banker Edmond Safra dies in a safe room, the question isn't who started the fire that took his life, it's why.Just when you think you've figured it out, there's another crazy turn of events.Support the show

Send us Fan MailWe didn't want to, but we have to...talk about Casey Anthony's three-part documentary. It's bananas. Support the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey with Cousin Amber and Husband Derek as they discuss the case of Nada Altantawi, Casey Anthony's documentary, and how to pronounce basic words.Support the show

Send us Fan MailNatalie Wood's death remains a mystery to this day. Sarah and Casey discuss the mysterious circumstances surrounding the day she died.Support the show

Send us Fan MailIn December, 2000, a young father and husband went hunting one morning in Florida and never returned. It took 18 years, but when it was discovered what truly happened to him, it was a tough pill to swallow.Source:Mr. & Mrs. Murder on HuluSupport the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey & Sarah as they discuss the case of Lynn Stomps. When Jerry Stomps goes missing and his wife is found by a bridge, police fear the worse, But, is the culprit inside the Stomps home?Killer GranniesSeason 1, Episode 4Streamed on HuluSupport the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey and Sarah as they discuss the case of Brandon Johnson, who's controlling behavior was brought to light thanks to his two ex wives and their podcast.Source:Don't Date Brandon on Paramount PlusSupport the show

Send us Fan MailWe had to re-record (thanks Riverside), Join Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Cousin Celeste as they discuss the case of Kelly-Anne Bates.The Case of Kelly Ann BatesSource: PrimeBritain’s Darkest TaboosSeason 4Episodes 12Can be Streamed on: PrimeSupport the show

Send us Fan MailWe have questions for Derek! Tune in for another unhinged episode.Support the show

Send us Fan MailToday's originally scheduled episode was supposed to be about Kelly-Anne Bates, but due to technical difficulties, we will have to re-record it. In the meantime, enjoy this replay of "Wait, He's From England?"Happy Monday, ya'll!Support the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Friend Celeste as we discuss everything that happened this week.I apologize about the sound! There was a button I didn't press and did my best to fix it, if it sounds like I'm (Casey) is yelling.Support the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey and Sarah as they discuss the death of Ellen Greenburg in Hulu's documentary, "Death in Apartment 603."Support the show

Send us Fan MailHappy Halloween! Enjoy this out-of-control Friday Follies.Support the show

Send us Fan MailEveryone's talking about it, so we decided to give it a go! That's right, Netflix's "The Perfect Neighbor." A seemingly idyllic neighborhood becomes the scene of a horrific crime. Was it self-defense? We will discuss!We get a little unhinged in this one with Husband Derek, too.Support the show

Send us Fan MailTune in as Cousin Dawn, Husband Derek, and Casey listen to Cousin Amber catches us up on her love life.Support the show

Send us Fan MailEnjoy part 1 of 2 Friday Follies as we discuss our unhinged lives! Support the show

Send us Fan MailWe have three special co-hosts today! Join Cousin Amber, Cousin Dawn, and Husband Derek as they discuss the case of Cliff Lambert. Cliff was a retired art dealer who went missing. It takes over a decade to discover what happened to him.Source:Dateline, Season 34, Episode 3Support the show

Send us Fan MailCasey reluctantly brings her husband and two of four kids to Barnes and Noble just before closing time, and chaos ensues. Sarah's Disney trip stories never disappoint.Support the show

Send us Fan MailJames Glass was a dedicated Marine, husband, and father. When a coworker asks him to check on suspicious behavior in a bunker, he agrees. A grenade goes off and, to his surprise, it's not the first time someone has tried to take his life. Secrets come out and they're shocking.Source:Cold HeartedSeason 1, Episode 1Support the show

Send us Fan Mail🎙️ Surprise! We’ve got a guest! This week on Let The Good Crimes Roll, Sarah and Casey sit down with Stephanie Tinsley, host of Everything They Missed — a gripping new true crime podcast investigating the forgotten Memphis murder of Dan ny Harris and, despite a conviction, there are still so many unanswered questions.It’s an active case, new evidence is on the table, and the Tennessee Innocence Project is involved. 👀 🎧 Listen to “Surprise! Guest Interview with Stephanie Tinsley” — out now wherever you get your podcasts!#LetTheGoodCrimesRoll #EverythingTheyMissed #TrueCrime #PodcastInterview #TennesseeInnocenceProjectListen to the trailer here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/introducing-everything-they-missed-a-true-crime/id1834984809?i=1000725068264Support the show

Send us Fan MailCasey and her son, Cannon, talk about how fun being a big brother to someone with Down Syndrome is!Support the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey and Sarah as they discuss weekly events and trick Husband Derek into doing random Tik Tok trends.Support the show

Send us Fan MailJoin us as we discuss the case of Kristil Krug. When Kristil begins receiving alarming texts and emails from an ex-boyfriend, she goes to police for help. Her worst fear happens as the investigation is going on. When the culprit is discovered, no one can believe it.Listen to the end for last Friday's Follies (that Casey forgot to publish).The Case of Kristil KrugSource: Dateline NBCSeason 34Episodes 1The Phantom Can be Streamed on: HuluSupport the show

Send us Fan MailWhen a socialite goes missing, Charlston police run into a dead end in search of her. The family, growing concerned, hires an A-Team of lawyers and investigators to find her. What they discover blows everyone's minds.Support the show

Send us Fan Mail  Join Casey and Sarah as they discuss weekly events, this week is a bit somber.Support the show

Send us Fan MailWarning: this episode contains quite a bit of explicit content.If you haven't seen it, then you've surely heard about it. Two teens are stalked and harassed via text for over two years and when the truth comes out about the perpetrator, everyone is left stunned.The case of Lauryn Licari and Owen McKennySource: Unknown Number: The High School CatfishCan be Streamed on: NetflixSupport the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey and Husband Derek as they discuss the birth of the fourth child, Cade as it is the week of his birthday!Support the show

Send us Fan MailYall are getting a two-fer in this episode. First, Casey and Husband Derek discuss the case of Pamela Carnahan from Louisiana, then Sarah and Casey are going to discuss the case of Carmen Montelongo from California.Sources: Southern GothicSeason 1, Episodes 5 (Bloodshed in the Bayou)Can be Streamed on: HuluSnappedSeason 16, Episodes 4 (Bloodshed in the Bayou)Can be Streamed on: Hulu (Carmen Montelongo)Support the show

Send us Fan MailJoin us as we discuss our lives and laugh away our woes!Support the show

Send us Fan MailIn March, 1998, the Bradley stepped aboard a cruise ship. Four family members sailed away, but only three would return home. 23-year-old Amy seemed to vanish in thin air. Join Casey and Sarah as they dive down numerous rabbit holes to see it they can find Alice in Wonderland.Source: Amy Bradley is MissingEpisodes 1, 2, 3 (Vanished at Sea; I Saw Her; Message in a Bottle)Can be Streamed on: Netflixwww.foxnews.com “Brother of woman who vanished from cruise 27 years ago reveals critical third witness,” by Peter D’Abroscawww.pajiba.com “Netflix’s ‘Amy Bradley is Missing’ Leaves Out a Damning Revelation,” by Dustin RowlesSupport the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Captain Ron (Casey's Dad and Sarah's Uncle) as they interview Fire Chief Ronnie Carrier during his time of Hurricane Katrina.August 29, 2025 marks the 20th anniversary of Hurricane Katrina.Support the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey and Sarah as they conclude the harrowing story that was Hurricane Katrina in this second part podcast. If you haven't listened to last week's episode, go back and listen to that one first.The source for this episode is Hulu's Hurricane Katrine: Race Against TimeSupport the show

Send us Fan MailJoin Casey and Sarah as they discuss everything from the book Casey desperately needs Beta readers for to Husband Derek's theory about Karen Read.Support the show

Send us Fan MailIt helps to hit publish, so, because I (Casey) forgot to check, you're getting a two-fer today. Join us as we discuss life.Support the show

Send us Fan MailThis is Part 1 of 2. Tune in next week for Part 2!Join Sarah and Casey as they discuss the mishaps of 2005's Hurricane Katrina. Only an hour and a half away from where they live, Hurricane Katrina struck like a thief in the night and when all seemed clear, the worst happened: the levees that acted as barriers gave way.  In a matter of hours, citizens desperately mounted their roofs, praying for aid. The source for this episode is Hulu's Hurricane Katrina: Race Against Time, episodes 1-: The Coming Storm and Worst-Case ScenarioSupport the show

Send us Fan MailWhat happened to John O'Keefe? In this episode, we conclude the case of Karen Read. Was he killed by Karen? Or the people in the house party they were at? What more could possibly come out in trial.Tune in for the conclusion that just took place in June of this year.If you want to watch our source, you can check out "A Body in the Snow, The Trial of Karen Read," on HBO Max.If you like this episode or the podcast in general, please give us a rating anywhere you listen to your podcasts!Support the show

Send us Fan MailWhat have we been up to over the last year? Tune in and find out! This is a mini episode where we discuss our personal lives.Support the show

Send us Fan MailWelcome back! It sure feels good. In our official re-launch, we discuss the case of Karen Read through HBO Max's documentary, "A Body in the Snow, The Trial of Karen Read." In January, 2022, police officer John O'Keefe was discovered in the snow, later dying from his injuries. The questions begin to roll as we all wonder what happened? Was it Karen Read? His girlfriend who left him at the house? Was it the homeowners, one of which also was a police officer? This is a two-part episode, catch the conclusion next week.Support the show

Send us Fan MailDave was starting over after a divorce. After trying his hand at online dating, he thought he met a casual, nice lady. When cupid's arrow hits him with a second lady, things become a bit crazy. Lady number two begins harassing and stalking Dave and all of the people in his life. How far will his date go?Reference:Lover, Stalker, KillerNetflixSupport the show

Send us Fan MailWhen Lyntell Washington meets Dr. Robert Marks she thinks she has found her the true love that will take care of her and her 3-year-old daughter. After a year of dating, the shocking truth behind his intentions come to life in the crazy story.Reference:Fatal AffairsSeason 1Episode 1: Lessons in LustSupport the show

Send us Fan MailBrittany Smith was charged with murder after she experienced, what she said, was a traumatic night. Was she justified in shooting her assailant or did the justice system get it right? You decide....you know we will!!Reference:Alabama vs. Brittany SmithNetflixSupport the show

Send us Fan MailNicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman were brutally murdered outside Nicole's home in June, 1994. All evidence leads to one person....O.J. Simpson.  Join us as we re-visit the evidence and that infamous court case.Reference:ID's "O.J. & Nicole: An American Tragedy"Peacock's "O.J. Simpson: Blood, Lies, & Murder"Support the show