Skip to content
PodParley
Murder Before Myths podcast artwork

PODCAST · true crime

Murder Before Myths

by Casey, Quenten

Thank you for joining Let’s Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefull to the best of my knowledge.If you have any case you want me to do just email me at [email protected]

Publisher-supplied feed metadata · PodParley refreshed Dec 22, 2025 · Source feed

Subscribe · 0 Bookmark

Episodes

  1. The wild Story of Ryan Anderson and The lake that doesn't exist

    Murder Before Myth explores the space where real crime ends and legend begins. Each episode, we dive into true murders, historical deaths, myths, and folklore, separating documented facts from speculation, exaggeration, and the stories history refuses to let die. Some cases are grounded in...

  2. Updated

    Updated

  3. The Murder of Gordon Church & The vanishing village of Angikuni lake

    Alleged Inuit village where everyone mysteriously disappeared in 1930.

  4. DNA and the Devil: A Cold Case Solved & a Creature Unleashed

    In this gripping episode of Murder Before Myths, host Casey dives into a haunting cold case from her own hometown—one that went unsolved for decades until a breakthrough in DNA technology brought long-awaited justice. What seemed lost to time is now a chilling reminder that the past never truly...

  5. The Murder of Gordon Church & The Vanishing Village of Angikuni Lake

    I n this haunting episode of Murder Before Myths, Casey takes a deep look into the tragic 1988 murder of Gordon Church—a horrific hate crime that shook the nation and, years later, found justice through advancements in DNA evidence. It's a powerful story of loss, resilience, and long-overdue...

  6. Soap-Maker Killer/ The Nameless Shadow

    In this chilling episode of Murder Before Myths, we explore two tales that blur the line between brutal reality and eerie folklore. 🧼 First, we uncover the twisted true crime of Leonarda Cianciulli, the infamous Soap-Maker of Correggio. A mother obsessed with fate, human sacrifice, and dark...

  7. Killer Karaoke And Wendigo

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  8. Forklift to DewMocracy and Cartoons!!

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  9. Black Widower and a Horny Hippo

    We’re diving into the twisted story of Thomas William Randolph, a man with more than just skeletons in his closet… and then we’re switching gears (hard) to talk about Cuba’s wild problem with cocaine hippos—yes, really. It's dark, it's weird, it's wild... just how we like it.

  10. Mystery Behind Tiffany and that guy's little

    In this video, we delve into two enigmatic stories that have captivated audiences: Part 1: The Enigma of Tiffany and the Mysterious Man Unravel the perplexing tale of Tiffany and her association with a shadowy figure. What secrets lie beneath their story? Join us as we piece together the clues…

    more

  11. The Flora Fire and a perfect murder?

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  12. For Lime jello killing to the pyramids of Wisconsin

    🔍 Welcome to "Let's Tell Their Story" – A True Crime & Legends Podcast 🎙️👻Do you love chilling true crime cases, eerie legends, and mysterious stories that keep you up at night? Then you've come to the right place. "Let's Tell Their Story" dives deep into real-life crimes, unsolved mysteries,...

  13. The murder of murders and the town that when evil

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  14. Please tell me there Animal back there and crayons are chewy

    will be fill later

  15. 3 murders and you followed the rules

    Casey tells you a story about 3 murders in Wisconsin that were in prison and only one lives and becomes infamous for his actions. While Quenten finishes the episode with a Reddit story of convenience store rules that MUST be followed.

  16. Part 2 of the disappearance of Mitrice Richardson and is it fact or legend.

    This week Casey gives you the final part of Mitrice Richardson’s case and whether or not there are answers. Quenten gives you a legend that sends Casey into speechless coma.

  17. Part 1 of the disappearance of Mitrice Richardson and a game that isn't advised to play

    Casey gives you part 1 of Mitrice Richardson disappearance and the strange things that happened along the way towards her disappearance. Quenten gives to an elevator game that you could play but we highly suggest that you don’t. X: https://x.com/Letstheirstory Facebook:...

  18. Headless Pearl Bryan

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  19. The Skeleton in the Canyon

    Mitrice Richardson disappeared after being released from custody in the middle of the night only to have her remains found almost a year later. Sources: uncovered.com/ ID Corbin Daniel Pemberton Long Beach Police Department 562-570-7260 case number 240017385 Mitrice Richardson crimestoppers...

  20. Farm Accident I Think Not

    Woman found on her family farm, Property issue Was this crazy scooby-doo story

  21. Warren Harding

    need dec

  22. ice box

    freeze freeze

  23. Burning Inferno

    A mother and son are found burned to death in their car by the neighbors and there is a possible cover up

  24. From the Weird Village Child to the Errand Running Neighbor

    The worlds youngest serial killer to a man that didn't begin his killing spree until he was in his 60s.

  25. Bejeweled, Bedazzled, Thieves, Gangs, This is going to get Cheezy!!!

    This week we are heading away from murdered, missing, unsolved people. And giving you crime of a different kind. There's heist, gangs, thievery, and a much needed pallet cleanser. Discord: https://discord.gg/vAs8JSRY6M

  26. 🧀 🍷

    Explanation of why there won't be an episode this week. But will definitely be worth the wait for a much needed palate cleanser.

  27. Is there a connection NOPE NUN

    Two Stories of women that were in their own peaceful times. Only to meet brutal endings. Both women Catherine Cesnik and Roberta Elam followed their faiths to live their lives following God.

  28. Kayla Berg

    Kayla Berg was a 15 year old that went on a road trip with her older brother's best friend to only never be seen again. Multiple different searches went into finding Kayla only to have more questions than answers. Discord Link: https://discord.gg/vAs8JSRY6M

  29. Oh, The Brutal Heat of a Road Trip

    In 1996 a German family of four ventured to the United States for a family vacation. While they were possibly headed to Yellowstone National Park, they traveled through Death Valley believing there may be some shortcut only to be on a road not suitable for the vehicle they were driving. It…

    more

  30. 36 Hours of Hell on the cold place on the planet

    An astrophysicist has symptoms of poisoning while working in the South Pole. After 36 hours of agonizing pain he succumbs to his illness and it would be months before an autopsy that details his cause of death. And a jurisdictional nightmare between 4 countries and why there will never be a true...

  31. Lipstick Murder

    The story about an accused serial killer that never was William Heirens

  32. Amber Alert

    How much do you really know about the Amber Alert system? When just googling Amber Alert you get everything about the system that makes us all cringe a little when we hear that specific noise, but you really don't get anything on the story that led to the alert system. And if you know the system...

  33. Joan Lawrence

    An elderly woman goes missing while she's in the process of turning her landlords in for some shady doings and it takes a former limo driver to report her as a missing persons.

  34. Enrique Roman Martinez

    Eight Army soldier head out on a Memorial Day camping trip during the height of a covid pandemic and during a no travel ban and only 7 soldiers return.Sources: uncovered.com, wunc.org

  35. Don't Trust the Circus coming to town

    A young girl with brand new stockings, a dime for two rides on the merry-go-round at the circus and is brutally murdered on her way home.

  36. August MMM

    August Mid month missing

  37. Bardstown Murders

    A mother and daughter brutally attacked in their home, and officer ambushed on the side of the road, a missing daughter and a father shot while hunting was he getting to close to answers? sources: ucovered.com, unresolved.com Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a...

  38. July MMM

    July 15 Mid month Missing

  39. Danniella Nickole Vian

    A young lady starts to turn her life around and a night out with friends and a lost phone turns into a possible accident, a possible foul play incident until a dive team reveals a disturbing site. Source: uncovered.com, casefile episode 155, and unresolve.me Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their...

  40. 20 30 almost 40 whats my name

    Jane Doe cases are usually the hardest ones to solve and ended up even harder to solve when the case goes cold. Even with scientific advancements sometimes Jane Doe stays Jane Doe. Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I…

    more

  41. Big Horn WTF Part 4. The final episode

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  42. Mid Month Missing (MMM) June

    June 15th 2023 most recent missing persons

  43. Big Horn WTF Part 3 Kaysera Stops Pretty Places

    18 year old Kaysera Stops Pretty Places disappears only to found a few days later almost exactly where she was last seen. Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the...

  44. How did everyone not see me Big Horn Part 2

    This week I go into part 2, where I bring you the cases of Henny Scott and Selena Not Afraid. How/when they went missing, the searches, and the unfortunate aftermath. Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the...

  45. Big Horn WTF part 1

    The horrible things that are happening to our indigenous people, highlighting Henny Scott, Selena Not afraid, and Kaycera Stops Pretty Places. But first a history of who and how the tribes came to be part of Montana. Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true…

    more

  46. Dorothy Arnold is she the original Gone Girl

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  47. The solved unsolved case of the south

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  48. Childless Childers and wouldn't know a cave man

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  49. The little lost boy at Timber Creek

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

  50. The Whistle of Regret Pt 2

    Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at...

View all 53 episodes →

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

Thank you for joining Let’s Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefull to the best of my knowledge.If you have any case you want me to do just email me at [email protected]

HOSTED BY

Casey, Quenten

CATEGORIES

true crime

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Murder Before Myths have?

Murder Before Myths currently has 53 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is Murder Before Myths about?

Thank you for joining Let’s Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefull to the best of my knowledge.If you have any case you want me to do just email me at...

How often does Murder Before Myths release new episodes?

Murder Before Myths has 53 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.

Where can I listen to Murder Before Myths?

You can listen to Murder Before Myths on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts Murder Before Myths?

Murder Before Myths is created and hosted by Casey, Quenten.
URL copied to clipboard!