Skip to content
Murders in Paradise podcast artwork

Murders in Paradise

by Mysteries in Paradise

True crime podcast about mysteries and murders in the Florida Keys

From the show's RSS feed, refreshed Mar 31, 2026. Source feed.

Subscribe Bookmark

Episodes

  1. Jailbreak

    We're back with a story from Terry Schmida's True Crime of key west Volume 2!

  2. 35. Jason Heath

    A man missing from our key since November 22, 2021. Lots of info at http://findjasonheath.org

  3. 34. Jan Sykora

    We're BACK!!!!! This episode is the wild story of random vioence by Jan Sykora (plus a cameo from a blow up doll)

  4. 33. The Chicken Episode

    Historical stories of the Key West Chickens

  5. 32. Valentine Doe: SOLVED!

    The 1991 unsolved case of Valentine Doe has been solved! Both victim an murderer have been identified using DNA!

  6. 31. Ghosts in Bars

    A few "stories" of ghosts in bars plus a good dog named Groot!

  7. 30. Roger Foster

    A wild tale of murder on a charter boat in the 1960s

  8. 29. Jewish Refugees in Key West

    We go through Smuggling Jewish Refugees in Key West How the Caribbean became a stopping point for the American journey of so many Jews by Arlo Haskell https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/jewish-refugees-in-key-west

  9. 28. La Concha

    Let's talk about gHoOoOsTs again - this time, the haunted La Concha Hotel in Key West!

  10. 27. Cyne

    A murder and some stupid graffiti

  11. 26. Big Pine & Sugarloaf Crimes

    An internationally hunted sex trafficker found basically in our backyard and a murder suicide on Big Pine Key

  12. 25. Two Unsolved Murders

    A duo of unsolved murders from the mid-1970s

  13. 24. The Treehouse Murder

    SO MUCH INTRIGUE HERE! Audio of the neo-nazi comments https://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/community/florida-keys/article238145954.html Kevin gets a fire hydrant https://www.thedodo.com/sick-pit-bull-fire-hydrant-2344619395.html Other good sources...

  14. 23. Frank Fontis

    This week we discuss the unsolved murder of Frank Fontis in 1979. Dog Palette Cleanser https://www.thedodo.com/close-to-home/dog-wanders-into-philadelphia-home-during-storm Shout out to True Crime Garage!

  15. 22. Key West Bloody Christmas

    The Ku Klux Klan is in town and nothing good can possibly happen. Fuckers.

  16. 21. Haunted Hemingway

    The final Spooky October Ghost Episode, we cover stories of hauntings surrounding Key West's most famous resident, Ernest Hemingway. Source: Haunted Key West https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0978992156/j16t3i5j15-20 Dog Palette Cleanser:...

  17. 20. gHoOoOoOsTs!!!

    Week 2 of sPoOoOkY gHoSt sToRiEs!!! But first: a better source for the Jeremy Mcauley Case: https://www.flkeysnews.com/news/local/article190633014.html Haunted Key West, our source book: https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0978992156/j16t3i5j15-20 Dog saves owner from house fire:...

  18. 19. Robert the Doll

    Just in time for spOoOoOky HalloweEeEeEn season, it's the story of the very haunted Robert the Doll! Pics on twitter @MurdersParadise and instagram @MurdersInParadise!

  19. 18. Ducky Bennett

    A very rambling way to tell the story of Ducky Bennett and a deadly love triangle! twitter.com/MurdersParadise instagram.com/MurdersInParadise

  20. 17. Clarance Till

    This week we discuss the murder of Clarance Till, taken from Terry Schmida's True Crime Stories of Key West and the Florida Keys https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0967449871/j16t3i5j15-20

  21. 16. Dr. Tucker

    A wild story of a murder-suicide and vicious doctor. Our main source is this excellent article https://www.miaminewtimes.com/news/murder-suicide-in-the-keys-unravels-a-doctors-decades-long-mystery-6389264 And happy dog story...

  22. 15. 1906 Hurricane

    MOTHER NATURE IS A MURDERER! This week, we talk about the 1906 Hurricane and the role it played in the development of the Keys. If you want to read the first hand account, you can get it here: http://digitalcollections.fiu.edu/tequesta/files/1959/59_1_02.pdf

  23. 14. Betty Neumar

    This week we discuss Betty Neumar, possible black widow killer! Murderpedia entry: https://murderpedia.org/female.N/n/neumar-betty.htm

  24. 13. Thomas Overton

    This week we cover the brutal, twisted case of Thomas Overton. Warning: sexual violence Body of Evidence Episode: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1xenpArRUPQ Murderpedia: https://murderpedia.org/male.O/o/overton-thomas.htm Happy dog story of the week...

  25. 12. Derek David

    This week we talk about the twists and turns of the Derek David case Video of the whole mess! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1CDvARGfuo8&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JIpXpAnz054&feature=youtu.be Happy dog story...

  26. 11. Jeffrey Sundwall

    This week's case is that of Jeffrey Sundwall. Warning: sexual violence Dog story of the week: https://www.thedodo.com/close-to-home/cyclists-stop-to-change-flat-save-dog-brazil Follow us at @murdersParadise on Twitter or @MurdersInParadise on instagram for pics

  27. 10. Quickies

    Four short cases for a little anthology of Murder in Paradise this week. Michelle Osborne, baby doe, Thomas Rafferty, and 2 cats. Follow us on instagram @MurdersInParadise or twitter @murdersParadise for pictures from the episode And thanks for your patience with the wonky audio and edits in…

    more
  28. 9. Jonathan Alvarado

    This week, we cover the 2011 Fantasy Fest murder. Dog palette cleanser: https://www.thedodo.com/close-to-home/family-finds-lost-dog-living-as-stray-turkey

  29. 8. Jeremy Macauley

    A square grouper, double murder, and crazy case from Islamorada https://www.miaminewtimes.com/news/carlos-ortiz-and-tara-rosado-murdered-in-florida-keys-most-brutal-homicide-in-25-years-9234920 JAXON! https://www.thedodo.com/amphtml/close-to-home/twitter-helps-dog-jaxon-find-chew-toy

  30. 7. Deputy Joshua Gordon

    This week, we bring you a dramatic story of Deputy Josh Gordon with audio of the crime as it happened! You can watch the video from two angles here: http://thebluepaper.com/video-of-shootout-released-heroic-deputy-shot-in-chest/ Follow us on Twitter @MurdersParadise and Instagram at...

  31. 6. Kenneth Palicki

    6. Kenneth Palicki by Mysteries in Paradise

  32. 5. Carl Tanzler

    Oh lawd, this guy is cray. The NON murder yet oh-so-disturbing story of Carl Tanzler of Key West. The Studios of Key West even went and made a musical about this called Undying Love! https://tskw.org/undying-love/ Be sure to follow us on twitter @murdersparadise and instagram @murdersinparadise…

    more
  33. 4. Valentine Doe

    Our first unsolved case is the relatively well known Valentine Doe. A young woman was seen walking along route 1 and her body was found murdered the next day. She and her killer remain unidentified.

  34. 3. Shirley Garvin

    Our first Forensic Files case - the murder of Shirley Garvin! Twitter: http://twitter.com/MurdersParadise Instagram: http://instagram.com/murdersinparadise email: [email protected]

  35. 2. Charlie Brandt

    Our highest body count yet (though to be honest, we've only had 1 body count total so far). This is the story of Charlie Brandt of Big Pine Key. Also, GR Dad's audio is messed up. Sorry! We'll do better next week. Twitter: http://twitter.com/MurdersParadise Instagram:...

  36. 1. Mark Brann

    In our kickoff episode, we detail the brutal 2017 murder of Mark Brann in Key West. Plus, a happy dog story to send you off into the world feeling a little better. You can follow us on Twitter @MurdersParadise or Instagram @MurdersInParadise for pictures and links to content we discuss in the...

  37. 0. Murders in Paradise Teaser

    Join us for a new true crime podcast of both infamous and unsolved murders from the Florida keys!

About this show

True crime podcast about mysteries and murders in the Florida Keys

Hosted by

Mysteries in Paradise

Categories

Frequently asked questions

How many episodes does Murders in Paradise have?

Murders in Paradise has 37 episodes on PodParley. The most recent episode was published on August 5, 2022.

What is Murders in Paradise about?

True crime podcast about mysteries and murders in the Florida Keys

How often does Murders in Paradise release new episodes?

Murders in Paradise publishes monthly, based on its 37 episodes since April 2019.

Who hosts Murders in Paradise?

Murders in Paradise is created and hosted by Mysteries in Paradise.
Link copied