Skip to content
Phantom Island podcast artwork

Phantom Island

by Steven Godfrey & Ryan Nanni

Every week, Steven Godfrey and Ryan Nanni walk you (and one another) through a question from the sports world. While they don't promise any conclusive answers, you'll get an interesting and thoughtful look at topics from a variety of perspectives. This feed is also home to Steven and Ryan's other work, including The Single Wing, where Godfrey answers listener questions, We're Not All Like This, Ryan's interview series profiling different sports fanbases, and more. Find out more at https://www.falconscottproductions.com/

From the show's RSS feed, refreshed Nov 13, 2026. Source feed.

Subscribe Bookmark

Episodes

  1. The Single Wing: November Means Northern Football Talk (PREVIEW)

    Ryan Nanni takes over for Steven Godfrey in this special edition of the Single Wing, tackling listener questions on the coaching jobs at Ohio State, Michigan, Rutgers, and Nebraska, assessing the chances of a New Year's Six bowl in a northern city, and reviewing the highlights of conference...

  2. Should your college football program go independent?

    Jessica Smetana joins Ryan Nanni to talk about the pros and cons of being an independent in college football, with some bonus Remembering Some Schedules and some speculation with Steven Godfrey on whether the route Miami has teased would make a superleague entirely unnecessary. Phantom Island is...

  3. Not-An-Emergency Discussion: Three Possible One and Dones (PREVIEW)

    While things have gone great for some coaches in their first year at a new job in 2026 (hi, Bob Chesney!), others are finding themselves sinking deeper and deeper into trouble. Steven Godfrey, fresh from the source mines, joins Ryan Nanni to run down three first-year coaches who may not make it…

    more
  4. Disassembling the binary of NFL quarterbacks (PREVIEW)

    Ryan Nanni and Steven Godfrey examine the quarterbacks in the NFL's narratively confusing middle class, stuck somewhere between unquestioned superstar and ready to be cut in the offseason. What should teams do when they have the 12th or 15th best QB in the league, how does the media talk about...

  5. Did the men's gold medal game lead to a major NHL trade?

    Steven Godfrey is joined by ESPN's Greg Wyshynski to connect the dots between the US beating Canada in the men's ice hockey gold medal game, a major trade between Winnipeg and New Jersey, movement trends within the NHL, and the politics looming over everything between the two countries. Phantom...

  6. BONUS: The College Football History Book 2026 Pop Quiz

    With the help of several different conference media guides, Ryan Nanni concocts a surprise trivia game for Steven Godfrey that spans the ACC, Big 10, SEC, Big 12, Pac-12, MAC, and Mountain West, and you can play along and see if you can beat Godfrey's score. Phantom Island is presented by…

    more
  7. Not-An-Emergency Discussion: The Final Defeat of Mike Norvell (PREVIEW)

    The worst kept secret in the coaching carousel finally becomes real as Florida State moves on from Mike Norvell, so Steven Godfrey and Ryan Nanni sit down to discuss what the possible candidates say about the status of the Noles, with some bonus discussion around the growing distance between P4...

  8. The Single Wing: Hot Seats, Old Stadiums, Small Houses (PREVIEW)

    On this episode of the Single Wing, Steven Godfrey tells you what offseason red flags to watch out for if you're not happy with this season, considers the future of college football stadium design, looks at if a Dan Lanning Hot Seat can even be real right now, and shares some advice on being a...

  9. WNBA Finals Doubleheader: The Case of the Weekday Afternoon Game Six and The Curious Golden State Roster

    We're giving you TWO discussions on this episode of Phantom Island; first, Marisa Ingemi of Valkyries Beat joins Ryan Nanni to discuss the unorthodox construction and deployment of the Golden State roster. Then, Andy Tulin of The Post Presence hops on to review how Game Six wound up moved to a...

  10. Numbers and Words: Playoff Ain't Played Nobody (PREVIEW)

    ESPN's Bill Connelly joins Steven Godfrey to discuss the 24-team playoff, including what "expanded access" will actually look like, the impact of losing conference title games, the shifting sympathies for the first team out, and much more. This is a preview of the full episode, which is available...

  11. Numbers and Words: The Depth of the 2026 Candidate Pool (PREVIEW)

    With Maryland parting ways with Mike Locksley, Steven Godfrey and Ryan Nanni ring the opening bell on the 2026 coaching carousel by examining the theory that a shallow candidate pool has made schools more patient. Which names should you expect to see on early lists as jobs open, how much do those...

  12. Where does wrestling stand amidst the shifting world of college sports?

    FloWrestling's Jon Kozak joins Ryan Nanni to discuss how 5-for-5/NIL/the transfer portal/the Protect College Sports Act have altered the landscape of men's collegiate wrestling, what the future looks like for women's wrestling in the NCAA, and the best way to get your start as a fan of the sport....

  13. Why does this UConn fan want you to watch Digger?

    The recent major motion picture Digger has provoked backlash from critics and generated disappointing box office numbers. It has also inspired social media user No Escalators, who usually spends his time advocating on behalf of UConn sports, to campaign on behalf of the film with incredible…

    more
  14. Deshaun Watson and the foundational football story of "overcoming adversity" (PREVIEW)

    Ryan Nanni and Steven Godfrey review the discussion surrounding Deshaun Watson's early success on the field this season, examine the baseline narrative football embraces compared to basketball and baseball, and consider why some of the league's media partners lump everything under the adversity...

  15. What should college football do about early season heat waves?

    Matt Stahl of AL.com joins Ryan Nanni to discuss his recent stories on college football's problem with extreme heat, what teams and conferences can do to address warmer games early in the season, why NFL fixes prove harder to apply to this level, and whether anything will actually change moving...

  16. Numbers and Words: Your College Football Team Needs Your Financial Support! (PREVIEW)

    David Covucci, founder and proprietor of FOIAball, joins Steven Godfrey to discuss the growing push to tap fans as sources of revenue for college athletic departments, from rising ticket prices to pleas to donate your grocery store rewards points. How does the new era of fundraising change the...

  17. How can we fix the broken market for sports and music tickets?

    Brian Shearer, the Director of Competition and Regulatory Policy at the Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator, joins Ryan Nanni to discuss a recent paper put out by his team titled "How to Save Audiences $11 Billion on Live Events." They discuss the differences between sports crowds and concert…

    more
  18. The Single Wing: Appreciating Northwestern and Good Coffee (PREVIEW)

    Members of the Phantom Island community send Steven Godfrey questions, and, on this episode, he answers them on topics ranging from what USC really wants from a coach, what the trajectories look like for a couple of previously hot coaching prospects off to slow starts, why things are working so...

  19. Numbers and Words: Sourcing and Using Football Explosives (PREVIEW)

    Parker Fleming joins Steven Godfrey to discuss explosive plays in college football, why they matter more in a game where tempo has started to fade, the differences between explosive runs and explosive passes, how to possibly find more explosives in the portal, and much more. This is a preview of...

  20. Numbers & Words: Coach Gossip from USC to USC (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey returns from a long day on the phone to talk with Ryan Nanni about possible rumblings all over college football. Listen if you'd like to compare Lincoln Riley's current school and his old one, hear about the North Carolina coaches that aren't Bill Belichick, and see if Ryan can...

  21. What does the Women's Pro Baseball League need to fix next season?

    Jen Ramos-Eisen, freelance baseball and labor writer for Defector (amongst other places) joins Ryan Nanni for a review of Year One of the WPBL. How was the actual baseball? What were the pros and cons of holding all the games in Illinois? Why was the television production so uneven? And what's...

  22. Numbers and Words: The Folly of Coach Reunions (PREVIEW)

    ESPN's Bill Connelly joins Steven Godfrey to review the history of college football coaches returning to their old, successful stomping grounds. Get ready to hear about Greg Schiano, Scott Frost, and Mack Brown (but also Jeff Tedford and Bill Snyder!) and the common patterns that explain why this...

  23. PI Book Club: Unthinkable to Unstoppable with Zach Osterman and Mike Niziolek

    Zach Osterman and Mike Niziolek combined their experience on the Indiana football beat to write Unthinkable to Unstoppable: How Curt Cignetti and the Indiana Hoosiers Stunned College Football, and they sat down with Ryan Nanni to talk about the decision to write this book after the 2025 season…

    more
  24. Numbers and Words: Butch Jones and Sustainability in Modern College Football (PREVIEW)

    Arkansas State Head Coach Butch Jones sat down with Steven Godfrey before the start of this football season to discuss the realities of building and sustaining a program in the world of the transfer portal and NIL. How do you build culture when your roster turns over so frequently? Have coaches...

  25. A Cultural Examination of LSU-Ole Miss (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey has football opinions about the LSU-Ole Miss showdown in Week 3, but what he really wants to talk about with Ryan Nanni on this episode is the cultural history of this rivalry, how Lane Kiffin distracts from it, and whether this game will lead to the kind of anger and chaos lots of...

  26. What should the conversation about transgender athletes sound like?

    Freelance writer Sydney Bauer joins Ryan Nanni to review the WNBA's summer tumult over transgender athletes, what those stories revealed about the media's ability to provide necessary context and nuance to a complex topic, why the discussion always seems to focus on hypotheticals and not real...

  27. What Ted Cruz's appearance on College GameDay signals (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey and Ryan Nanni discuss the extensive opportunity Ted Cruz was given this weekend on College GameDay to rally support for the Protect College Sports Act. What does that moment say about GameDay as an entertainment vehicle, ESPN as a political force, and the absence of a cohesive…

    more
  28. Numbers and Words: The Mysterious Art of Valuing College Football Talent (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey is joined by Parker Fleming to break down the far from transparent world of player valuation in college football. How do teams analyze a player's worth in a sport with so many teams and options? What's the best way to prioritize development versus immediate returns? Does the job of...

  29. What does the absence of the Tennessee-Florida game mean?

    Holly Anderson, of the Shutdown Fullcast and Channel 6, joins Ryan Nanni to talk about the meaning of the Florida-Tennessee game, which won't be played at all in 2026. How did a rivalry that didn't exist before 1990 achieve such prominence? What does college football's willingness to abandon this...

  30. Almost-an-Emergency Discussion: ExpeLSU? (PREVIEW)

    The SEC wants a federal court to confirm that it has the power to eject LSU from the league, which means Ryan Nanni and Steven Godfrey turned on the mics to try to contextualize 1) what the ideal outcome for the conference looks like 2) why expulsion is both the headline and the penalty sources…

    more
  31. Not-An-Emergency Discussion: Is Lane Kiffin proving the NCAA of old was right? (PREVIEW)

    For years, the NCAA insisted that amateurism was one of the business foundations of college sports, and that people didn't want to see semi-professional players in their beloved university colors. As LSU and Lane Kiffin fight with the SEC about whether a limited exception should permit a handful…

    more
  32. The Single Wing: From Anxiety Bowls to Football Casuals (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey once again takes questions from Phantom Island subscribers on topics including the latest in Lane Kiffin, early Anxiety Bowls to watch out for (hi, Rutgers!), what it means to get outcoached, whether the constant off-field news about lawsuits and legislation is diminishing interest...

  33. What's the goal of international college football games?

    Rodger Sherman, author of the Sports! newsletter, joins Ryan Nanni to talk about the history of college football games played outside the United States, how their strategies differ from the NFL's international games, and whether the Big 12's London event will break the mold for what college...

  34. Numbers and Words: The Weakness in Strength of Schedule (PREVIEW)

    Bill Connelly joins Steven Godfrey after an offseason of schedule arguments to look at what teams actually control about this metric, why preseason measures automatically punish playing a Group of 6 team, where strength of schedule fails to meet narrative expectations, and what college football...

  35. How's everyone feeling heading into the 2026 college football season?

    This week, Steven Godfrey and Ryan Nanni review the hundreds of responses they got from Phantom Island subscribers on a few key questions before the 2026 college football season starts. Who's eager to show their coach the door? Which opponents do you really want to beat - and really not want to…

    more
  36. Our Next Big Projects (PREVIEW)

    If you've listened to this show for a while, you've probably heard Steven Godfrey and Ryan Nanni talking about some larger projects in the works. Today, we're ready to tell you more about what those look like and when you'll get to hear them, and there's also some bonus discussion of Ryan…

    more
  37. Numbers and Words: How To Spend $20,000,000 (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey is joined by Parker Fleming to tackle one task: take $20 million (the NIL amount widely believed to have been spent by Ohio State in 2024 en route to a national title), show how a college football team can and should spend it to build a roster, and then analyze how far that money...

  38. Why can't anyone catch Jerry Rice?

    Jerry Rice holds the NFL's career records for receptions, receiving touchdowns, and receiving yards, and nobody's really come close to challenging him for any of those marks. Ryan Nanni is joined by ESPN's Ben Solak to discuss what skills Rice had that helped him play so well for so long, why the...

  39. The Single Wing: Return of Ryan (PREVIEW)

    Ryan Nanni does his best Steven Godfrey impression on this episode of the Single Wing, taking questions from Phantom Island subscribers on Pete Golding expectations, NC State floating forever in "good, not great," which teams Ryan truly hates, and what the REAL story is behind Ryan leaving the...

  40. Do World Cup hosts see a long term boost in their soccer fortunes?

    Rodger Sherman, writer of Sports!, joins Ryan Nanni to talk about whether history supports the idea that US men's soccer will benefit down the line from cohosting the 2026 World Cup, and Ryan flips some Olympic research on Rodger in return. Phantom Island is presented by Homefield and produced by...

  41. Numbers and Words: Who's Getting a Coach Carousel Seat? (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey talk to people in the college football coaching world. Then he chats with Ryan Nanni on this episode, who asks Steven which candidates will be mentioned as the up and coming trendy picks as jobs open, how the ladder of these jobs has changed, and whether last year's aggressive…

    more
  42. Announcing Numbers and Words (PREVIEW)

    In the same way that all squares are rectangles but not all rectangles are squares, Phantom Island has college football but isn't a college football podcast. That's why we're announcing Numbers & Words, a new public podcast feed coming soon featuring some of our evergreen conversations with smart...

  43. What does the future hold for the Portland Trail Blazers and Tom Dundon?

    Sean Highkin, author of The Rose Garden Report, joins Ryan Nanni to discuss the dueling summers of Tom Dundon, owner of both the Carolina Hurricanes and the Portland Trail Blazers. What do the parallels of his early days in Raleigh suggest about how things will go in Portland? Can Dundon's NHL...

  44. The Single Wing: Oops! All Group of Six (PREVIEW)

    To be clear: nobody told Steven Godfrey he had to record almost an entire episode about the Group of Six, taking questions from listeners about programs jumping up or down the college football ladder or coaches that might become hot commodities or what these conferences need to do to improve…

    more
  45. Can college football learn from the 2026 World Cup?

    ESPN's Bill Connelly wrote about the potential for the College Football Playoff to take lessons from the expanded men's World Cup, so Ryan Nanni brought him on this episode to discuss what it will take for college fans to accept a tournament with teams that probably can't win a title, why...

  46. Predicting the Aftermath of the 2026 World Cup (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey's feeling a soccer-filled future for U.S. sports fans, but he wants to talk about that path with Ryan Nanni first. (Somehow, this leads to a brief discussion of famous NYU graduates.) What are the indicators that would show this World Cup impacted the American audience long-term?...

  47. Where is the SEC Turkey Tape?

    Matt Stahl, Alabama beat writer for AL.com, was not present at the SEC's 2010 Media Days when Vanderbilt's coach told the assembled reporters about his days inseminating turkeys, but he's been working to find audio or video of the moment for some time. Steven Godfrey was in the room, and Ryan...

  48. The Single Wing: Of Superleagues and Walkmen (PREVIEW)

    Steven Godfrey opens up the listener mailbag once again to answer questions from Phantom Island subscribers on topics including how to tell if your head coach hates one of his assistants, who might be placed at the top of a theoretical super league, how to approach getting into physical media…

    more
  49. Will sports ever grow bigger than we actually want them to be?

    Rodger Sherman, author of the Sports! newsletter, joins Ryan Nanni on this episode to talk about the continued growth and expansion of almost every professional sport. Can our most popular leagues ever approach oversaturation of their audiences? What do lengthier schedules mean for…

    more
  50. The NFL team that nearly perfected third down (PREVIEW)

    Sometimes, Ryan Nanni becomes excessively intrigued by an oddball sports occurrence. On this episode, he's bringing one such instance to Steven Godfrey to discuss: the time Drew Brees and the Saints nearly finished a game perfect on third down. What made this feat possible, why is it unlikely to...

About this show

Every week, Steven Godfrey and Ryan Nanni walk you (and one another) through a question from the sports world. While they don't promise any conclusive answers, you'll get an interesting and thoughtful look at topics from a variety of perspectives. This feed is also home to Steven and Ryan's other work, including The Single Wing, where Godfrey answers listener questions, We're Not All Like This, Ryan's interview series profiling different sports fanbases, and more. Find out more at https://www.falconscottproductions.com/

Hosted by

Steven Godfrey & Ryan Nanni

Categories

Frequently asked questions

How many episodes does Phantom Island have?

Phantom Island has 192 episodes on PodParley. The most recent episode was published on November 13, 2026.

What is Phantom Island about?

Every week, Steven Godfrey and Ryan Nanni walk you (and one another) through a question from the sports world. While they don't promise any conclusive answers, you'll get an interesting and thoughtful look at topics from a variety of perspectives. This feed is also home to Steven and Ryan's other...

How often does Phantom Island release new episodes?

Phantom Island publishes a few times a week, based on its 192 episodes since May 2025.

Who hosts Phantom Island?

Phantom Island is created and hosted by Steven Godfrey & Ryan Nanni.
Link copied