PS You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast

The Odyssey is already one of the biggest movies of the year. Matt and Shelby are here to discuss Christopher Nolan's Greek epic, his female characters, and who turned in good performances. Spoiler alert: Matt and Shelby do not agree. 

The World Cup is over, and Matt and Shelby are now both soccer experts (not really), and they've also got thoughts on the halftime show. Plus, there's still more news trickling out about Taylor Swift's wedding. 

Shelby and Matt talk dinner parties, loud neighbors, and divorce rates in this episode about The Invite, a new comedy from Olivia Wilde starring the hottest neighbors you've never had and the marital reckoning they'll never agree on. But it's fun! We promise!  

While we wait for Taylor Swift to drop some wedding photos, Matt and Shelby are back to dissect the Love Island finale, the Big Brother premiere, and the Emmy nominations. 

After an editorial note from Shelby regarding Taylor Swift's wedding, she and Matt are here to discuss their top ten movies of the year so far. Will Sheep Detectives and The Bride make the cut? You'll have to listen to find out. 

Matt and Shelby have broken with tradition and are bringing you a Pop Culture Roundup that is solely about Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's Madison Square Garden wedding. We could talk about this for 500 hours (and quite possibly will), but these are our initial thoughts. 

Due to scheduling conflicts (aka Matt was getting drunk near a red sun and Shelby was stranded and trying to connect to the internet through a potty training device), Matt and Shelby are doubling up to discuss Toy Story 5 and Supergirl. Did we need either of these movies? Let's discuss. 

Shelby and Matt break down Steven Spielberg's latest alien flick, Disclosure Day. Was Emily Blunt's performance good? Did the ending make sense? Why was Colman Domingo building a house? These questions and more will be answered if you just listen. 

After five wonderful seasons, Hacks has finally aired its last episode. Matt and Shelby are here to unpack the final season, the final episode, and the state of television in general. Matt will, of course, also discuss having cancer again, which is his favorite topic to talk about. 

From Taylor Swift's new Toy Story song to the Summer House reunion, Matt and Shelby are breaking down the latest current events before pivoting to Matt's impassioned plea for more people to watch For All Mankind. 

"I love unions. I'd love to be a part of one some day." - Shelby and Matt talking about the power of collective action AND high fashion as they discuss Boots Riley's new maximasocialist movie starring everyone who's anyone. So get in losers, we're going microlooting. 

After cracking a One Wish Willow and wishing for Matt to be her podcast co-host forever, Shelby is back this week for the 335th episode that Matt is recording against his will trapped in his body. They will be discussing Obsession. 

Shelby and Matt are baaaaaaaaaaaack to investigate the sheep, the townspeople, and the American accents in The Sheep Detectives. 

Matt (the Andy of the podcast) and Shelby (the Emily of the podcast) are back to discuss The Devil Wears Prada 2, along with the state of journalism, Andy's new boyfriend, and Jeff Bezos.

Is Taylor Swift writing a song for Toy Story? Is Beyonce going to release Act III at the Met Gala? What will happen with Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni's trial? Some of these questions have since been answered, but only after we pondered about them.

The Year of Anne Hathaway has begun, and we're starting out by discussing her pop star thriller Mother Mary. Shelby and Matt break down the dress barn, the concert choreo, and of course, the ending. 

For a record-breaking second week in a row, Matt & Shelby are back to discuss the latest pop culture gossip, including the leaked recording of the Summer House reunion and Harry Styles' supposed engagement to Zoe Kravitz. Plus, the pair breaks down Michael and Apex. 

Matt & Shelby are here to save the rom-com via pointing out the good, the bad, and the Italian portions of You, Me & Tuscany. 

From Alex Cooper vs. Alix Earle to Taylor Swift's upcoming wedding, Matt and Shelby break down all the latest news. Plus, they discuss Hacks and The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins for their Love It or Hate Its. 

Shelby's back from vacation and ready to discuss the marital woes of Zendaya and Robert Pattinson in The Drama with Matt. Did they like the twist? Did they like the ending? Did they like Alana Haim's acting? All answers are revealed. 

With no solid films heading to theaters this week, Matt and Shelby braved the world of Netflix releases, dragging themselves through the time-travel mobster movie Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice. Was it good? No. How bad was it? Listen to find out. 

Shelby and Matt are back to discuss Ryan Gosling's new film Project Hail Mary. Together, the pair discusses whether this is a kid's movie, how amnesia works, and why Sandra Huller deserves an Oscar nomination for this role. 

Chappell Roan is yelling at kids, Taylor Frankie Paul is throwing chairs at kids, and one kid exploded into a pile of blood during Ready or Not 2: Here I Come. Matt & Shelby are here to discuss it all as well as Company Retreat during this week's PCR. 

For the 8th year in a row, Matt and Shelby are breaking down the Academy Awards. From the snubs and surprises to the red carpet looks, PSYW is here to let you know the real winners and losers of the night. 

Back for their eighth year in a row, Matt and Shelby are ranking every single movie they saw in 2025 from Oscar darlings to box office bombs. What will claim the coveted top spot and will it be Ella McCay? 

Shelby and Matt (chained to the fireplace) are back to discuss/bark about the new Wuthering Heights adaptation from Emerald Fennell. Is it a good adaptation? No. But is it fun? Also no. But does it have an interesting point of view? No, again. BUT is it memorable? We shall see, but probably not. Did Shelby like it, though? Yes. 

Shelby and Matt are using all their best pop girl knowledge to unpack Charli XCX's new film The Moment (which may or may not be about Taylor Swift). There's plenty to unpack, including the cameos, the fans, and Charli's career post-Brat. 

Matt and Shelby revel in Sam Raimi's latest horror comedy, Send Help. If these two got stuck on a desert island it would probably go something like this anyways.

Since there weren't any great new releases playing in theaters this week, Matt and Shelby turned their attention to the 2026 Oscar nominations. The pair unpack the snubs and surprises catagory by catagory. 

Oh no! Matt and Shelby's text messages have been confiscated by the court and it turns out they're calling everyone a "little bitch." This week the pair are discussing Blake Lively and Taylor Swift's texts, Colton Underwood crashing out on The Traitors, the new animated movie Arco and Kate Hudson's Oscar-nominated turn in Song Sung Blue. 

Matt and Shelby are back with one of their signature unhinged double-feature episodes. This week they'll be discussing the creature horror film Primate as well as Netflix's latest rom-com People We Meet on Vacation. Both were bad, but which was worse? That's up for debate. 

Shelby and Matt are back to discuss all the movies coming out this year, while predicting their Rotten Tomatoes scores. Are they excited about The Devil Wears Prada 2? Avengers: Doomsday? Wuthering Heights? Find out here.

It's awards season baby! Matt and Shelby break down everything that happened at the 2026 Golden Globes before pivoting to The Traitors, RuPaul's Drag Race, and Heated Rivalry. Then Matt discusses old Oscar winners, and Shelby discusses a rabid monkey for love it or hate it.

SURPRISE! This is actually the secret bonus episode of Stranger Things Season 5! Matt and Shelby venture into the Upside Down one final time (at least until the reboot) to break down the end of Stranger Things. 

Happy New Year PSers! We've got coverage on Critics Choice Awards, Este Haim's wedding, and all the millionaire yacht antics you never knew about. It's a roundup for the books as we kick off a brand new year  

Benoit Blanc is back, and Matt and Shelby are here to talk about it! Your favorite podcast hosts discuss Wake Up Dead Man, the third Knives Out film, along with its ensemble cast and Oscar chances.

This is mostly a TV recap with Shelby and Matt catching up on Stranger Things, The Real Housewives, I Love LA, and, of course, the Taylor Swift documentary. 

Matt and Shelby break down the many versions of the afterlife, including the complicated Mormon structure, the vague Christian one, and the version in Eternity.

Matt and Shelby took the Thanksgiving break to process everything that happened in Wicked: For Good and as you can imagine, they've got some thoughts on the matter. The pair discuss the new songs, Elphaba's sex cardigan, and if Wicked should have been split into two films in the end. 

Matt and Shelby discuss Dancing With the Stars, Beyonce's Act II rollout, and why Taylor Swift is letting Donald Trump use her music at rallys. 

Matt and Shelby are back to discuss running, men, Glen Powell, Stephen King, and where they'd hide from the law. 

Two nerds arguing about the merits of Frankenstein? No, it's not your English 101 course but it might as well be!! Matt and Shelby are at odds as they discuss the themes, motifs, and visual hang ups with Guillermo del Toro's new monster flick.

Matt and Shelby have a lot of thoughts on conspiracy theories, aliens and Emma Stone's net worth on this episode focusing on Yorgos Lanthimos's new film Bugonia.

Kathryn Bigelow has returned with another stressful movie about America, only this time it's focused on a fictional missile strike on Chicago. Matt and Shelby have a lot of opinions, but don't share that many.

Obviously there is more Taylor Swift news to disect, but we've also got Lily Allen's new album, a horror film named after Shelby and our nemesis Colleen Hoover.

It's the moment you've all been waiting for! Matt and Shelby are back to discuss Travis Kelce's redwood, Elizabeth Taylor's husbands and or course Taylor Swift's feud with Charli XCX. Your favorite Swiftie and your favorite Swiftie Hater are here to break down The Life of a Showgirl track by track. 

We're back and ready to discuss Taylor Swift's upcoming video project, the premiere of Marty Supreme and whether or not Amy Poehler needs a project to host SNL.

Matt and Shelby are unpacking one of the best movies of 2025 and pondering the question of if this is actually a good title for the movie. 

Shelby and Matt break down the biology, the script and the nihilism at play in The Long Walk, as well as which of them would fare better in an apocalypse. 

It's our 200th Pop Culture Roundup, but in true PSYW fashion, we didn't remember that and so make no mention of it in this episode. Instead we talk about Taylor Swift's new movie-ish thing that's coming to theaters as well as Jimmy Kimmel, Downton Abbey and freedom of speech.