Puzzling: A True Crime Podcast
by Tiffany Epp
Sarah, Tiffany, and Bailey take a deep dive into the most puzzling true crime cases, taking you for a wild adventure. Listen along to hear fun friendship banter, some truly insane stories, and facts that will make you question your existence. They try to take on lesser-known cases to bring awareness and justice to those who have been otherwise overlooked. Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/tiffany-epp/support
Episodes
-
57. Tristyn Bailey
This week Sarah talks about the actual senseless murder of 13 year old Tristyn Bailey. All murders are senseless, but this one hits a bit different on the senseless aspect. Listen in to understand what we mean by that! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail:...
-
56. Anthony Allen Shore
Well, this guy SUCKS. Like seriously, royally sucks. They all do so here I am, trying to come up with a description just like every other week. Idk man, just listen and find out why he sucks so bad. You'll hate him as much as we do, for sure. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling...
-
55. Jeff, Jason, and Jesse
Every week we think that we come across the most senseless crime. Every week we are speechless. Every week it's hard to understand what the "worst crime" is because they're all senseless and horrible. Listen in to understand what we mean by this. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook…
more -
54. Rayna Rison
Welcome back! This week Tiffany tells you the tragic story of yet another useless person ending the life of an absolutely beautiful soul. This young woman had already been through enough by the time this monster took her from the world. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast...
-
53. Christina Benjamin and James *Brian* King
This week Sarah talks about yet another absolutely senseless and horrendous crime that happened against 2 young children. Be warned, this is not for the faint of heart, unfortunately. Just like the Tiffany's, we understand if you now hate the name Jason. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook:...
-
52. Terrible Tiffanys
This week Tiffany tells you 2 horrendous stories of murderers named Tiffany. I get if you hate the name now, it's fair. So many lives lost that did not need to be. Listen in to see why even Tiffany is ashamed to have the name! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail:...
-
51. Sinister Sarahs
Sorry for the late episode! Life got ahead of us and we were unable to record on time. This week Sarah brings you 2 tales of 2 different Sarah's who were both murdering during the same time frame in the late 1800's. Both are serial killers who used poison as their weapon of choice. SOCIALS:...
-
50. William Reece
Remember last weeks episode when Sarah talked about the tragic murder of a young woman named Sarah? Well, this week Tiffany took on the task to find the tragic murder of a young girl named Tiffany. Only this weeks.... had a lot more in store for us than expected. Listen in to hear about the...
-
49. Sarah Stern
This week Sarah tells the tragedy of what greed can really bring people to do to not only random people, but even their closest friends. If you see this, hug your friends a little tighter today and let them know how much you truly love (and would never harm) them! Be mad with us, as always, for...
-
48. Dead people.... Or not?
We don't want to ruin the surprise here in the bio for you, but I can assure you it's not about zombies. Listen in to see what wild tale (or tales) Tiffany has in store for you this episode! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Tiffany’s...
-
47. Joseph Edward Duncan III
This week Sarah talks about the absolutely horrendous murders of Anthony Martinez, Brenda Groene, her 2 sons Slade and Dylan, and her boyfriend/fiance' Mark, and the abduction of her daughter, Shasta. He is an absolute monster, and there's no better term to describe him. A senseless act committed...
-
46. The MacDonald Family
This week, Tiffany takes you on a WILD ride of confusing twists and turns. Just when you think it's about to be over, it's not! Listen in and let us know your own opinions because this case could go either way, really. We share our opinions, but would love to know yours! SOCIALS: Instagram:...
-
45. The Murdaugh Family
This week, Sarah tells the rollercoaster of a story that is the Murdaugh family, which includes a tragic murder, boating accident, fraud, and more. At no point did we know what was coming next. Let us know what you think about who did what! Our thoughts go out to the families affected, and we…
more -
44. "The Amazon Review Killer" Todd Kohlhepp
This week Tiffany brings you the cringey case of "The Amazon Review Killer". An actual cold blooded human. It's a shame that someone so smart and seemingly rehabilitated could still turn into what he did. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected]...
-
43. Chris Steiner and Thad Phillips
This week Sarah takes you to Baraboo, Wisconsin for an absolutely heartbreaking tale of two young teens who did not deserve AT ALL what happened to them. If you're ready to get your heart broken, listen in! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected]...
-
42. Elisabeth Fritzel
WELCOME to the possibly most horrendous case we've done so far. Are you ready to take medieval punishments to someone? You will be after this case! Tiffany takes you on a roller coaster with this horrendous tale of incest and what can come from a very smart, and manipulative MONSTER. Tune in to...
-
BONUS: Virginia City!
Our Friday the 13th bonus episode is finally here! We had such a blast in Virginia City and if you want to hear about the history of VC, a couple of our own spooky encounters, Tiffany's involving VC, and what we caught on audio, listen in! We had so much fun doing this episode and can't wait to...
-
41. The Sun Gym Gang
This week Sarah tells the true story of the Sun Gym Gang. It's truly a WILD ride full of greed and absolute idiots. If you think this story may sound familiar, Sarah will let you know why you probably think that at the end. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail:...
-
40. Roberta "Maude" Moorman
This week Tiffany takes you on a very confusing and conflicting timeframe through the murder of Roberta "Maude" Moorman who was murdered by...... Listen to find out! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's...
-
39. Juan Vallejo Corona
This one is a request to Sarah from Esteban! This week Sarah tells the story of serial killer Juan Vallejo Corona who killed at least 25 men, and possibly even more is a short time span. How!? We don't get it either. Due to recording at Sarah's house this week, sorry but also not so sorry about...
-
38. Vance V. Judas Priest
This week we have a surprise guest who talks about the suing of a very popular metal band, Judas Priest. Listen in to see who tells us this story! Also, it was a hectic episode full of pausing and restarting due to interruptions we did not plan for. It may be a bit splotchy, so please bear with…
more -
37. The Eastburn Family Murders
This week Tiffany takes you on another roller coaster of a case discussing a young military wife and her two young children being take from this world far too early. Listen in to hear all the twists and turns of this wild case! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail:...
-
36. The Donner Party
Sorry about the delay! It has been a hectic week with puppies, work trips, and power outages due to over 2' of snow! This week Sarah takes you on an adventure through the Sierra Nevada Mountains and discusses the well-known Donner Party. Even if you think you know it, you may not! Listen in to…
more -
35. DiAnne Keidel
This week Tiffany talks about the sad case of a loving mother who was wrongfully taken from this earth far too early. It took 27 years to crack open her case. Listen in and send us some name suggestions for Sarah's new puppy!!! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail:...
-
33. Gerry Largay
This week is a bit of a switch up for you guys! Sarah brings you an absolutely heart-wrenching story of 66 year old Gerry Largay and the circumstances of her death. Try not to cry like Tiffany did! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Website:...
-
32: The List Family Murders
This week, Tiff shares the story of family annihilator John List, who murdered his family in cold blood and used his faith as a scapegoat. He lived freely or 18 years and remarried before he was eventually caught. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail:...
-
30: The True Story of the Watcher House
Happy Halloween!!!! This week, Sarah gives us the interesting and slightly spooky case of The Watcher House. We have our opinions on who it is. What are your thoughts? SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Website: puzzlingpod.wixsite.com…
more -
29. Alison Botha
TRIGGER WARNING. This week Tiffany brings you the absolutely PUZZLING case of 27 y/o Alison Botha. This is a wild ride, and also a tough one to listen to. It is completely worth it though so listen in and let us know how we did! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail:...
-
27. Jennifer Schuett
This week Sarah covers the incredible survival story of Jennifer Schuett. She was 8 years old when the attack happened, and it took almost 20 years for her to find answers. Also, still not sorry about baby babble. She just wants to be a part of it too! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook:...
-
26. Shari Smith and Debra Helmick
This week Tiffany takes you on a roller coaster of a case involving the extremely senseless abduction and murder of 17 year old Shari Smith and 9 year old Debra Helmick. We also have a special guest star so tune in and see who it is! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast...
-
25: Richardson Murders
Sarah covers the tragic murder of the Richardson family, in which their daughter and her boyfriend try to recreate the movie “Natural Born Killers”. SOURCES: The book "Runaway Devil" by Robert Remington SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected]...
-
23: Sheri, Garrett, and Gavin Coleman
This week, Tiffany discusses the murder of loving mother Sheri Coleman, and her two young sons Garrett and Gavin. This murder was planned for months, and resulted in the death of 3 wonderful people. CASE SOURCES: The book "True Crime Case Histories Volume 1" by Jason Neal...
-
22: Josh Maddux
This week, Sarah tells the peculiar case of Josh Maddux, an 18-year-old boy who went missing. For years, his sister held onto the hope that he had just started a new life in the woods writing novels and playing music. 7 years later that hope was crushed when his body was found in... suspicious...
-
20: Cathy Paternoster & Carl Fuerst
This week, Tiffany tells the case of Cathy Paternoster, 32-year-old woman whose murder received no justice until 23 years later. CASE SOURCES: https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/sdut-lawyer-arrested-womans-1989-slaying-victorville-2009oct22-story.html...
-
19: Travis the Chimp
This week, Sarah brings you the... interesting case of Travis the Chimp. CASE SOURCES: SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Website: puzzlingpod.wixsite.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce Bailey's Instagram:...
-
17: Jan Scott and Henry Caneva
This week Tiffany talks about the senseless murder of Henry Caneva and the survivor story of his girlfriend, Jan Scott. Tune in to hear about the absolute idiocy of the crimes. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Website…
more -
16: Charles Cullen PART 2
Sarah finishes off the 2nd part of the wild story of Charles Cullen SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Website: puzzlingpod.wixsite.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce Bailey's Instagram: @bailmcq EMAIL: to...
-
15: Charles Cullen Part 1
Another 2-parter for you guys! This week brought to you by Sarah, Charles Cullen, aka Charlie, was known as a “good nurse” who had a dark secret. During his 16 year career, it’s estimated that he killed at least 40 of his patients. SOCIALS: Instagram & Twitter: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling...
-
13: Henry Louis Wallace PART 2
The second part of our first ever two-parter! Tiffany tells about the last few murders of Henry Louis Wallace. So sorry for the delay in the episode as Bailey's laptop wanted to crash out on us. Thank you for continuing to support us and we love you! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook:...
-
12: Henry Louis Wallace: Part 1
In this week's episode, Tiffany takes us on a deep dive into the sad life and first few victims of Henry Louis Wallace. This is a two parter so sty tuned for next week's finale! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Website…
more -
11: Dyatlov Pass
This week, Sarah tells about the puzzling case of the Dyatlov Pass. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Website: puzzlingpod.wixsite.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce Bailey's Instagram: @bailmcq EMAIL: to...
-
9. Jerry Brudos
TRIGGER WARNING: This episode contains talk of sexual assault, rape, and necrophilia. Please be advised while listening. This week Tiffany brings you the story of the infamous serial killer Jerry Brudos. There is also a special announcement that we think you all will love so stay tuned! Don't...
-
8: Polly Klaas
This week, Sarah The Assistant guest stars to tell the story of Polly Klaas, which occurred in STA's hometown of Petaluma, California. CASE SOURCES: Coming soon! SOCIALS: Instagram & Twitter: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: [email protected] Website: puzzlingpod.wixsite.com...
-
6: Ron Sauvageau
SURPRISE! We have a very special guest star on this week's episode. That's right, it's Sarah the Assistant! As Bailey is enjoying her vacation, Sarah put together a story from her hometown about the murder of Ron Sauvageau and tells it to Tiffany. Yes, we already acknowledge the amount of times…
more -
5: Blake and Mary Jo Hadley (Tyler Hadley)
ANNOUNCEMENT: Both Bailey and Tiffany will be traveling in the coming weeks, so episodes may sound slightly different! This week Tiffany takes a deep dive into the brutal murders of Blake and Mary Jo Hadley by their own son, Tyler Hadley, and the party that happened afterward with their bodies...
-
3: Brianna Denison & Caitlin Denison
UPDATE: We are, in fact, not receiving donations through our website. If you feel inclined to donate to us, here is our Venmo link. Thank you! https://venmo.com/code?user_id=3524601913017601588 This week, Tiffany discusses the cases of Brianna Denison and Caitlin Denison. SOCIALS: Instagram &...
-
1: Ashley Patterson
Welcome to Puzzling: A True Crime Podcast WARNING: This episode briefly mentions sexual assault of a minor. Case starts at 15:30 Thanks for listening! Our goal with this podcast is to talk about some lesser known cases as well as more well known cases that truly puzzle us. We are definitely open…
more
About this show
Sarah, Tiffany, and Bailey take a deep dive into the most puzzling true crime cases, taking you for a wild adventure. Listen along to hear fun friendship banter, some truly insane stories, and facts that will make you question your existence. They try to take on lesser-known cases to bring awareness and justice to those who have been otherwise overlooked. Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/tiffany-epp/support
Hosted by
Tiffany Epp
Categories