Skip to content
Return to Eerie, Indiana podcast artwork

PODCAST · tv

Return to Eerie, Indiana

by Becky Darke

A rewatch podcast by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks.

Publisher-supplied feed metadata · PodParley refreshed Apr 14, 2026 · Source feed

Episodes

  1. CHRISTMAS SPECIAL: Gremlins (1984)

    Becky and Josh take a deep dive into Joe Dante's 1984 Christmas horror classic GREMLINS. Follow us to Kingston Falls as we spend the holidays with Gizmo, Billy, Kate, Mr Futterman, Mrs Deagle, Barney and the Peltzers. PLUS play along as Becky tests Josh's knowledge with a Gremlins quiz! If you…

    more
  2. HALLOWEEN SPECIAL: Hocus Pocus with Jill Nolan

    We're joined by podcaster and DJ Jill Nolan to chat about the 1993 Disney classic Hocus Pocus. Eerie stars Omri Katz and Jason Marsden team up once again - sort of - to defeat the Sanderson sisters, three Salem witches back from beyond the grave and bent on stealing the town's children. There's...

  3. Eerie, Indiana: the round-up

    Becky and Josh look back at Eerie, Indiana - 19 episodes of weird and wonderful 90s joy. We chat favourite characters, guest appearances, key themes, top episodes... and more! If you like what you hear, support our podcast and spread the word by leaving us a nice review and a five-star rating....

  4. Reality Takes a Holiday with Karl Schaefer

    As our favourite show reaches its conclusion, Marshall is forced to question whether his life in Eerie is actually the elaborate imagining of a TV show writer called Jose Schaefer. But when Dash X is around, it's even harder to know what's real and what's make-believe. Becky and Josh discuss...

  5. Zombies in PJs with Zena Dixon

    When capitalism has you in its grip, the charming stranger offering to solve your problems can be too good to resist - even if he does have a ponytail and his first name is 'The'. Luckily Marshall and Simon are on hand to spot the Eerie weirdness and call out the bad guys. Plus Dash X gets up to...

  6. Interview with Jason Marsden

    Josh and Becky are joined by the grey-haired kid, AKA Dash X, AKA Jason Marsden! We had so much fun chatting to Jason about Eerie, Hocus Pocus, his online variety show, quarantine recommendations... and more! If you like what you hear, support our podcast and spread the word by leaving us a nice...

  7. The Loyal Order of Corn with Michael Varrati

    Marshall, Simon and the newly-named Dash X get wrapped up with some alien weirdness involving lots of corn, crystals and, most alarmingly, the patriarchy. Mysteries and novelty hats abound! If you like what you hear, support our podcast and spread the word by leaving us a nice review and a...

  8. No Brain, No Pain

    Marshall and Simon encounter a homeless man/axe murderer/liberal/genius and a woman with so many names and looks we can't keep up. The kid with the grey hair is still causing mischief and then proving he's alright after all. Oh and, is it just destiny, destiny? Or is it just a game in my mind,...

  9. Mr Chaney with Adam Robinson

    It's a full moon and it's all getting a bit hairy. If the Harvest King isn't sacrificed to the wolf, the crops will fail. Also, whose side is the Grey Haired Kid on anyway?! If you like what you hear, support our podcast and spread the word by leaving us a nice review and a five-star rating.…

    more
  10. The Hole in the Head Gang with Ryan Larson

    Marshall and Simon are investigating their 51st haunted structure in Eerie, and find more than they bargained for: a pale-haired stranger with a gruff voice and no memory. Plus an actual cowboy ghost. And what's going on with Radford?! If you like what you hear, support our podcast and spread the...

  11. Tornado Days

    Old Bob hits town and brings with him a Tornado Rider and plenty of laughs. Plus Syndi is THRIVING. If you like what you hear, support our podcast and spread the word by leaving us a nice review and a five-star rating. Thank you! Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks. Follow @eerieindianapod on...

  12. Marshall's Theory of Believability

    Finally, someone has rolled into Eerie who may believe Marshall and Simon about the town's weird goings-on. Professor Zirchon is the hero these boys need, but is he all he appears? And what has really landed in the woods that has got the townsfolk so excited? Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks....

  13. Interview with Joe Dante

    Becky and Josh are joined by the legend Joe Dante, the Creative Consultant of Eerie, Indiana and director of five episodes. But it's his career as a film director that may have your jaw dropping into your decomposed sandwich: Piranha, The Howling, Innerspace, The 'Burbs, Gremlins and Gremlins 2:...

  14. The 'Burbs with Mike Muncer

    Becky and Josh are joined by their pal Mike Muncer, host of the brilliant The Evolution of Horror podcast, to chat about Joe Dante's 1989 film The 'Burbs. *SPOILER WARNING* WE DISCUSS THE FILM IN DETAIL FROM THE BEGINNING OF THIS EPISODE SO IF YOU HAVEN'T SEEN IT AND DON'T WANT TO KNOW WHAT…

    more
  15. The Lost Hour

    Grumpy about being denied an extra hour by Eerie's lack of daylight saving, Marshall decides to take the ultimate step in teenage rebellion... he sets his watch back anyway! Thrown into another timeline, our hero only has so long to avoid the creepy garbage men, solve the mystery of the elderly...

  16. Interview with Karl Schaefer

    Becky and Josh have the huge privilege of welcoming to this week's show the executive producer and co-creator of Eerie, Indiana: Karl Schaefer! Karl's work as a writer and producer has created some of the most thrilling and imaginative genre television of the last three decades. Not only the...

  17. Who's Who

    What if you could draw life how you wanted it to be and it actually came true?! This week, Marshall and Simon discover exactly what that kind of power can bring - some laughs, and some scary possibilities for the Tellers. Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks. Follow @eerieindianapod on Twitter…

    more
  18. The Dead Letter

    An old book holds a surprise for Marshall and Simon, and that surprise is Tobey Maguire! Ghost love, Spielberg nods, and plot inconsistencies are on the cards in this week's episode. Will romance win out, or will the milk truck of death get in the way once again? Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh...

  19. Broken Record

    Eerie weirdness has even infected the show schedule now... where should this one even go?! A kid called Todd McNulty is having a tough time at home and turns to punk music as an escape. Are the effects really down to subliminal messaging on Todd's records, or is something more sinister to blame?...

  20. Heart on a Chain

    It's a matter of love and death this week. Marshall has a crush and there's tragedy looming. A change of pace, but just as weird as ever. This is Eerie, Indiana after all. Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks. Follow @eerieindianapod on Twitter and Instagram. Music by Jason Read. Logo design by…

    more
  21. Interview with Justin Shenkarow

    Becky and Josh speak to actor and producer Justin Shenkarow, who plays (our favourite) Simon Holmes in Eerie, Indiana. We chat about casting, Justin's #1 episode of the show, what it was like to work with the other actors, true crime podcasts, The 'Burbs, Simon potentially running for Mayor of...

  22. Just Say No Fun

    Time for your eye exam! Nurse Nancy is turning the school kids of Eerie into mindless, funless zombies and only Marshall can stop her. Where's Simon, you ask? He's a zombie too! But maybe the oldest joke in the book can snap him out of the desire to study and back to his funloving self. Hosted by...

  23. Scariest Home Videos

    It's Halloween! And what better way to spend the best night of the year than... inside babysitting a troublesome toddler? But fear not, dear listener, the weirdness of Eerie will always find Marshall and Simon, even when they're stuck indoors. Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks. Follow...

  24. The Losers

    Things keep going missing and with this being Eerie, Indiana there must be something weird going on. A biker gang, some suspicious laundry and some banana goop are all clues this week, as we pay a visit to the Bureau of Lost. Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks. Follow @eerieindianapod on…

    more
  25. ATM With A Heart Of Gold

    Simon has a new friend and is living the high life, but can a friendship with a cash machine ever really work out? And what effect will this new bond have on the town of Eerie, Indiana?! Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks. Follow @eerieindianapod on Twitter and Instagram. Music by Jason Read....

  26. The Retainer

    We get some orthodontic work done and meet Steve, a new buddy for Marshall and Simon... but something tells us they're not going to be lifelong friends. Ooh and doesn't that French poodle look familiar? Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks. Follow @eerieindianapod on Twitter and Instagram. Music…

    more
  27. Forever Ware

    We're introduced to the 'centre of weirdness for the universe' and some of its unusual inhabitants. Like a woman with a particular passion for food storage and her twin boys who seem somehow stuck in the past... but what's their secret? Hosted by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks. Follow…

    more
  28. TEASER: RETURN TO EERIE, INDIANA

    Becky and Josh watch the iconic opening credits of the classic 90s TV show Eerie, Indiana and chat Marshall and the Teller family, Simon, Elvis, Bigfoot, the twins, the mummy, the paper route, and MORE! Return to Eerie, Indiana starts Friday 13 March. SUBSCRIBE NOW to get all upcoming episodes....

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

A rewatch podcast by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks.

HOSTED BY

Becky Darke

CATEGORIES

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Return to Eerie, Indiana have?

Return to Eerie, Indiana currently has 28 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is Return to Eerie, Indiana about?

A rewatch podcast by Becky Darke and Josh Tonks.

How often does Return to Eerie, Indiana release new episodes?

Return to Eerie, Indiana has 28 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.

Where can I listen to Return to Eerie, Indiana?

You can listen to Return to Eerie, Indiana on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts Return to Eerie, Indiana?

Return to Eerie, Indiana is created and hosted by Becky Darke.
URL copied to clipboard!