Skip to content
Rotten Treasure podcast artwork

PODCAST · tv

Rotten Treasure

by Rotten Treasure

Jim O‘Donnell and Kai Bobbi invite fellow comedians to watch and review movie franchises that arguably went on longer than they should have. Each week will focus on a singular installment of whichever franchise we are covering at that time. You can support the podcast and gain early access to episodes, receive a vote for future franchises, promote yourself/a business/an organization and even get extra episodes. Who knows?! The tier system. That‘s who. https://www.patreon.com/rottentreasurelike/follow @ https://linktr.ee/rottentreasure

Publisher-supplied feed metadata · PodParley refreshed Apr 10, 2026 · Source feed

Episodes

  1. Rotten Recap: The Twilight Saga

    This week, Jim and Kai rank and review The Twilight Saga. Why would anyone lick a CGI baby? Remember when clove cigarettes were a thing? Is Kai a good romantic candidate? “That’s the vibe my guy.” - Jim “I'm a little antagonistic, and I like to play”- Kai Go to linktr.ee/rottentreasure to listen,...

  2. The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn - Part 2 with Haley Steinhilber

    This week, Haley Steinhilber returns for The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn - Part 2. It’s like the other movies, but with a CGI baby. What’s the coolest way to have a head ripped off? Where is Kai not allowed to sit anymore? Why can’t we just let boys be birds? “And boy does she like to edge.” -...

  3. The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 1 with Meghan Walsh and Chris Berg

    This week, Meghan Walsh and Chris Berg return for The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 1. It’s like the other movies, but they have sex in this one. Did Jim kiss the 2nd woman ever? Did we really need to know about the eggs? How long have we been doing bathroom stuff? “What are you guys…

    more
  4. The Twilight Saga: Eclipse with Kelsey Hébert

    This week, Kelsey Hébert returns for The Twilight Saga: Eclipse. It’s like the first two movies, but with back story. What’s Kai’s beef with Bilbo Buttface? Who’s Jim’s favorite woman? We’ve all kissed Nick Kronberger, right? “Wrong. Dumb.” - Kelsey Hébert Celebrate the one-year anniversary of...

  5. The Twilight Saga: New Moon with Emily Murphy

    This week, Emily Murphy joins us for The Twilight Saga: New Moon. It’s like the first movie, but with werewolves. What’s Robin William‘s Big problem? Will the real Mark Wahlberg please stand up? Are you ready for Jim’s Oliver Reed story? “Where are your knives?” - Emily Murphy To stay up-to-date...

  6. Twilight with Katie Taylor and Victoria Tellez

    This week, Katie Taylor and Victoria Tellez join us for Twilight. Is there still time to get into Reddit? What’s Jim’s Pinterest beef? Did you have a Juicy phase? “I was really into like the horny s%&t.” - Katie Taylor “When it’s realistic, ick.” - Victoria Tellez Follow Victoria @victoriatellez...

  7. Rotten Recap: Shrek

    This week, Jim and Kai rank and review the Shrek franchise. Does Jim not care about you? What's Frog Man King Daddy's problem? Are we gonna go intergalactic? “I am right. What I’m saying is correct.” - Jim O’Donnell “What do you think I think you think?” - Kai Bobbi You can catch Jim and Kai...

  8. Puss in Boots: The Last Wish with Eibhleann Clyne and Kelso Blaze

    This week, Eibhleann Clyne and Kelso Blaze return for Puss in Boots: The Last Wish. It’s like the first Puss in Boots, but it looks like the Spider-Verse. Did your bird go to college? Does having superpowers help you become a guitar-playing pervert? For the love of God, will someone please look…

    more
  9. Puss in Boots with Bailey J Hess

    This week, Bailey J Hess returns for Puss in Boots. It’s like Shrek, but with an egg. Is Kai sexy now? Is your bathtub haunted? Should we feel bad for murderers? “I’m not your buddy.” - Bailey J Hess Be sure to follow @baileyonair on Instagram! You can catch Bailey co-hosting on the Dave Ryan in...

  10. Shrek Forever After with Jackie and Danielle

    This week, Jackie and Danielle of the No More Late Fees podcast return for Shrek Forever After. It's like the first 3 movies, but it's A Wonderful Life. Is Matt Damon really all that important? Do our guests f#@k? Are wet babies relatable? “I mean, my hair’s clean.” - Jackie “Since we’re talking...

  11. Shrek the Third with Anna Neu

    This week, Anna Neu joins us for Shrek The Third. It’s like the other movies, but significantly worse. Why won’t Elmo just leave Andrew Garfield alone? Are our butts just a pocket? Who got neutered? “Make me sound good.” – Anna Neu Follow Anna on Instagram @annacneu! We encourage you to get some...

  12. Shrek 2 with Rob O'Neill

    This week, Rob O’Neill returns for Shrek 2. It’s like the first movie, but with a cat. Who was Jim’s cereal-woman crush? Hey now, are we All Stars? Does Kai want John Cleese dead? “I’m a good 90s boy.” - Rob O’Neill Rob encourages you to check out the movie Swallowed, starring Nightmare on Elm...

  13. Shrek with Dan Higgins

    This week, Dan Higgins returns for Shrek. Please, can I pet that dog? Can you rotate an apple in your head? Why does Kai owe Cameron Diaz an apology? “It's offensive if you’re not a little stupid about it.” - Dan Higgins Be sure to follow and check out Dan’s musical endeavors on SoundCloud and...

  14. The Flintstones in Viva Rock Vegas with Kate Fruhman

    This week, Kate Fruhman returns for The Flintstones in Viva Rock Vegas. It’s like the first movie, but with les horrible rock puns. Are nutritionists allowed to eat pizza? Do you orgasm before you multiply? Have you been systematically poisoning the water supply? “F#@k you Jim!” - Kate Fruhman If...

  15. The Flintstones with Eric Heiberg

    This week, Eric Heiberg joins us for The Flintstones. Do we live in a Brady-Bunch future? Was Jim responsible for the death of Don Pablo’s? Does your mom let you see improv? “The inner Texan in me is getting more and more angry.” - Eric If you’re in the Twin Cities area during the summers, be…

    more
  16. Follow Your Foot with Steve Kleinedler

    This week, join Kai and improv coach, instructor, and performer Steve Kleinedler for a delightful and insightful one-on-one conversation. With 40+ years of experience to draw from, Steve shares their perspective as they explore topics like why we do what we do, managing burnout, the importance of...

  17. Rotten Recap: Spider-Man

    This week, Kai and Jim recap and rank the Spider-Man franchise. It's like the other episodes, but we actually talk about the films. Was Wings your favorite kid show too? Should we all just be lizards? Can you put shells inside of a ghost? “We are judging you, every time we see you.” - Kai Bobbi...

  18. Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse with Jillian Hartman

    This week, Jillian Hartman joins us for Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse. It’s like the other movie, but with more holes. Can you handle two pirate things at once? Did Hank Hill have sexual relations with that woman? Will you ever be cool enough to get invited to our group chat? “Find your own...

  19. Spider-Man: No Way Home with Matt Garren

    This week, Matt Garren returns for Spider-Man: No Way Home. It's like the other movies, but with all the Spider-Men. Does magic kinda suck? Why is Kai trying to make “Bring At On” happen? Does The Winston Man have a really good shape about him? “Why did I come back on?” ”– Matt Garren Be sure to...

  20. Spider-Man: Far From Home with Max Beverly

    This week, Max Beverly joins us for Spider-Man: Far From Home. It’s like the other movies, but in Europe. Is Letterboxd the new Tinder? Should we all be coming at Jake Gyllenhaal? What are we sluts for? Hallucinogation? - Max Beverly Be sure to keep up with Max’s improv endeavors by following…

    more
  21. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse with The 7th Guest

    This week, The 7th Guest returns for Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse. It’s like the other movies, but with a talking pig. Is drowning really all that bad? Does being likable get you murdered? Why did Jim throw a baseball at a horse? Go to linktr.ee/rottentreasure to listen, like, follow, rate…

    more
  22. Spider-Man: Homecoming with Sam Abrams and Joe Tuzzi

    This week, Sam Abrams and Joe Tuzzi return for Spider-Man: Homecoming. It’s like the other movies, but with that guy from Multiplicity. Is Tom Holland a little champ scamp? Is Kai big-timing Chris Hemsworth? Who’s the new old cat in town? You can catch Sam and Joe performing in ‘No Diggity…

    more
  23. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 with Noah Levine and Michael Savitski

    This week, Noah Levine and Michael Savitski return for The Amazing Spider-Man 2. Can you CGI sexinesss? Is Dan Corkery the worst? Why won’t Jim share his thoughts about 70s jazz? “I’m on the Wikipedia for Nominative determinism.” - Noah Levine “Yeah, determinerminism.” - Michael Savitski As…

    more
  24. The Amazing Spider-Man with Megan Colombo

    This week, Megan Colombo joins us for The Amazing Spider-Man. It’s like the other movies, but with a lizard man. Is Andrew Garfeild biblically hot? Which base is under-the-shirt-Tobey-Maguire-boob-touch? Do hot girls like mezcal? “Wow. I have a lot to say.” - Megan Colombo Megan would like to…

    more
  25. Spider-Man 3 with Sofya Piro

    This week, Sofya Piro joins us for Spider-Man 3. It’s like the first two movies, but campy. Have you experimented with the Lord? Who’s in trouble with Kai for stealing monkeys? Do we have to talk to each other? “My dog has been getting bullied by a bird.” - Sofya Piro Keep up with Sofya’s...

  26. Deadpool & Wolverine with Tom Hannigan & Andrew Nealis

    This week, Tom Hannigan & Andrew Nealis return for Deadpool & Wolverine. It’s like Deadpool 3. Because it is.Is Kai bouttamakeastimeforthemselfere? Does Kyra Sedgwick close out Kevin Bacon’s self-doubt? Is Ryan Reynolds a real person? “Well I’m not on my phone right now, so I’m definitely…

    more
  27. Spider-Man 2 with Steve Kleinedler

    This week, Steve Kleinedler joins us for Spider-Man 2. It’s like the first movie, but with a train fight. Has Kai graduated from therapy? What do soup and banking have in common? Are Jim’s thoughts not worth it? “If you’re not going to tell anyone, go away.” - Steve Kleinedler Go to...

  28. Spider-Man with Frank Farrell

    This week, Frank Farrell returns for Spider-Man. If all your molecules are taken apart and put back together, are you still you on the other end? Kai totally didn’t lose this episode’s trivia prize, right? What about Barb? “The ozone isn’t as effective as it used to be.”- Frank Farrell Go to...

  29. John Wick 4 with Matt Garren

    This week, Matt Garren joins us for John Wick 4. It’s like the other movies, but he falls down the stairs. Who can’t you touch? Where did Jim pull that Bobcat out from? Have you checked out Kai’s dad? “He’s the baddest ass.” - Matt Garren Be sure to check out Matt’s and past Rotten Treasure guest...

  30. Rotten Recap: X-Men with Andrew Nealis

    This week, Andrew Nealis and Cooper the dog return to rank and review the X-Men franchise. How come no one is throwing up bees? Are goo-men robbing people of their accents? Is Kai a fucked up person? Be sure to check out Andrew’s podcast Sean & Andrew Talk About Movies (And Sometimes Other…

    more
  31. The New Mutants with Dom Arp

    This week, Dom Arp returns for New Mutants. It’s like the other movies, but emo. Do any of the bears inside of you know how to love? Are Russian mobsters Saturday-night-sexy? Is The Breakfast Club indoctrinating mutants to dance? “Buffy is the better version of what this movie wanted to be.”…

    more
  32. Dark Phoenix with Joe Jiggs

    This week, Joe Jiggs joins us for Dark Phoenix. It’s like the other movies, but with a big train fight. Are spreadsheets fun? Which birthday unlocks the patience to watch Burn Notice? Is Cyclops totally a Ross? “If Skywalker can kill hundreds of Jedi kids, I think I could take a couple fourth...

  33. Deadpool 2 with Haley Steinhilber

    This week, Haley Steinhilber joins us for Deadpool 2. It’s like the first Deadpool movie, but with jokes. What’s got Jim so popular with bisexuals? When’s the worst time to give Jesus a foot massage? You know what you like? “That’s why I’m gay.” - Haley Steinhilber Check out Haley’s podcast…

    more
  34. Logan with Michael Savitski

    This week, Michael Savitski returns for Logan. It’s like the other movies, but a good western. What rumor is Kai spreading about crows? Do tanks have personalities? Did Professor X catch Wolverine on the counter and bangin’ on the sofa? “Don't quote me on this, but I think that’s where they...

  35. X-Men: Apocalypse with Cara Hammer

    This week, Cara Hammer joins us for X-Men: Apocalypse. It’s like the other movies, but meta and unfunny. Is everyone a human to Jim now? What are dinosaurs and Napoleon doing in the library? What makes James McAvoy a silly little dirty boy? “I love fantastical things.” - Cara Hammer Be sure to...

  36. Deadpool with Leticia Viloria

    This week, Leticia Viloria returns for Deadpool. Does it pay to let the rage fill your soul? Did Kai get Toy Storied by their TalkBoy? Should we trust Tom Hannigan? “How am I a thing? - Leticia Viloria Go to linktr.ee/rottentreasure to listen, like, follow, rate and review. It really helps the...

  37. X-Men: Days of Future Past with Cassy Alban

    This week, The 7th Guest, Cassy Alban, returns for X-Men: Days of Future Past. It’s like the other movies, but in this one, they try to kill a politician. Why do hedgehogs want parties to end? How long can water live without Hugh Jackman? Do Kai’s knees not matter? “Sweaty palms, I’m in.” - Cassy...

  38. The Wolverine with Jacob Todd

    This week, Jacob Todd returns for The Wolverine. It’s like the other movies, but in Japan. Are retired magician cops qualified to speak on train physics? Are belly buttons the way to Hugh Jackman’s heart? Do you find Mars sexy? "The Tortoise on top and the Hare on the bottom” - Jacob Todd Go to...

  39. X-Men: First Class with Elena Hunt and Bill Reick

    This week, Elena Hunt and Bill Reick return for X-Men: First Class. It’s like the other movies, but they’re young now. Is Florida the France of America? Does a tree sh*t in the woods? Do you want more movies in your movies? “I thought it was gonna be like pew pew.” - Elena Hunt “Here’s my...

  40. X-Men Origins: Wolverine with Nate May

    This week, Nate May returns for X-Men Origins: Wolverine. It’s Will.we.are? Did Kai ever get those pictures of Spiderman to their therapist? Is being dehydrated cool? "You went from like casual klepto to leet hacker." - Nate May Go to linktr.ee/rottentreasure to listen, like, follow, rate and...

  41. X-Men: The Last Stand with Andrew Coppola

    This Week, Andrew Coppola joins us for X-Men: The Last Stand! It’s like the first two movies, but way too much is going on. Does Hugh Juckman mousse himself? Do you f&%king love chainsaws? Who is being mean to Heidi Klum? “He’s pretty good despite having no taste”- Andrew Coppola Go to...

  42. X2: X-Men United with Tom Hannigan

    Tom Hannigan joins us for X2: X-Men United. It’s like the first movie, but better in every way. Is Visor Guy a cop? Do you gush about Albert Brooks? Did Wolverine's curiosity catch the cat's tongue? “But can you do it twice though? That’s my question.” - Tom Hannigan Be sure to check out and…

    more
  43. X-Men with Kelsey Hébert (feat. Beverly the Cat)

    This week, Kelsey Hébert returns for X-Men! Should dogs have hammocks? Is William Shatner really just a tired Randy Newman? Do cats relate to X-men? “Oh no. I was going to get us back on track; you go.”- Kelsey Hébert Be sure to check out SideQuest Theater, Philadelphia’s home for adventurous...

  44. Real Genius with Neil Bardhan

    This week Neil Bardhan returns for Real Genius! Do you and your friends measure bridges for a good time? Is that a bagel in your pants or are you just Sean Penn wandering onto a movie set? Does Kai need to be stopped? “My lips are fine.” - Neil Bardhan Be sure to subscribe to Neil's occasional...

  45. Final Destination 5 with Kyle Hanlon

    This week, Kyle Hanlon returns for Final Destination 5. It’s like other sequels, but secretly a prequel. How much weed does a Big Mac get you? Why did Jensen Ackles punch Kai in middle school? Why are we avoiding Jon Voight? “No, I've never gotten an omelet.” - Kyle Hanlon Follow Kyle on…

    more
  46. The Final Destination with Ryan T. Barlow

    This week, Ryan T. Barlow joins us for The Final Destination. It’s like the other sequels, but more porny. Is Death pronoun indifferent? Will someone please give Mick Jagger attention? Why can’t we be friends? Be sure to follow @meanwendyband on Instagram and check out Ryan performing original...

  47. Final Destination 3 with Noah Levine

    This week, Noah Levine returns for Final Destination 3. Why did Kai Bikini Bottom out? What happens after you lose the luck of the Irish? Where do tattoos go when we die? “How many eggs would you have to throw at a car before it becomes undrivable?” - Noah Levine Be sure to check out and follow...

  48. Final Destination 2 with Nate May

    This week, Nate May returns for Final Destination 2. It’s the like first movie, but more emotionally scarring. Is Kai the new Edgar Allen Poe? Is Kai out here just stealing jokes now? Is Kai being demoted? “My house was built by idiots.” - Nate May Be sure to follow Nate and Jim’m improv team,...

  49. Final Destination with Jessica Snow

    This week, Jessica Snow returns for Final Destination. When did Shrek become a cop? Do French people know how birthdays work? Is Kai turning people into dinosaurs? “Did the premonition just not throw another D at him?” - Jessica Snow Be sure to follow @jessisnow on Instagram and @SnowJessi on...

  50. Nicolas Treasure: And His Book of Secrets with Jackie and Danielle

    This week, Jackie and Danielle of the No More Late Fees podcast return for National Treasure: Book of Secrets. It’s like the first movie, but more secretive. Does your BFF provide safe spaces for your Dolphin facts? Do you believe the bees? Why won't the Queen share her swans? “She was obsessed...

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

Jim O‘Donnell and Kai Bobbi invite fellow comedians to watch and review movie franchises that arguably went on longer than they should have. Each week will focus on a singular installment of whichever franchise we are covering at that time. You can support the podcast and gain early access to episodes, receive a vote for future franchises, promote yourself/a business/an organization and even get extra episodes. Who knows?! The tier system. That‘s who. https://www.patreon.com/rottentreasurelike/follow @ https://linktr.ee/rottentreasure

HOSTED BY

Rotten Treasure

CATEGORIES

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Rotten Treasure have?

Rotten Treasure currently has 178 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is Rotten Treasure about?

Jim O‘Donnell and Kai Bobbi invite fellow comedians to watch and review movie franchises that arguably went on longer than they should have. Each week will focus on a singular installment of whichever franchise we are covering at that time. You can support the podcast and gain early access to...

How often does Rotten Treasure release new episodes?

Rotten Treasure publishes regularly with 178 episodes available. Check the episode list for the typical release schedule.

Where can I listen to Rotten Treasure?

You can listen to Rotten Treasure on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts Rotten Treasure?

Rotten Treasure is created and hosted by Rotten Treasure.
URL copied to clipboard!