Episodes
-
24- The Disappearance of Madeline McCann
This week, Carlie tells us all about the mysterious disappearance of 3-year-old Madeleine McCann. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Wikipedia https://bit.ly/2QLGZ60 McCann's Website: https://bit.ly/2NiZsES Praia De Luz Resort:...
-
23- The Unsolved Murder of William Desmond Taylor
Have a 20’s-themed episode for 2020! This week, Megan is covering the unsolved murder of Hollywood silent-film director William Desmond Taylor. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Wikipedia https://bit.ly/39nCuWz Timeline...
-
22- The Double Trouble Holiday Special!
It’s a Double Trouble Christmas Special! First, Carlie tells us about creepy Claus-like figure Belsnickel. Then Megan gives us the lowdown on the authorship controversy of A Visit from St. Nicholas. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast...
-
21- The Westfield Watcher
Buckle up, pals - this week Carlie’s bringing you the terrifying tale of the Westfield Watcher. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Sources: Reddit https://bit.ly/38Jy63J NY Times https://nyti.ms/2syYahm The Cut https://bit.ly/34pJyOO...
-
20- The Mysterious Death of Peter Bergmann
This week, Megan brings you the story of an unidentified man who suddenly appeared in Sligo, Ireland just days before his death. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Sources: Wikipedia https://bit.ly/2P5ilww Vice https://bit.ly/2qzlkDN…
more -
19- Who Put Bella in the Wych Elm
We’re back from our unexpected hiatus! This week, Carlie discusses some possible answers to the admittedly convoluted question that’s haunted Hagley, England since 1943: Who put Bella in the wych elm? Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast...
-
18- The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum Heist
It’s the largest-value theft of private property in history, and you’ve probably never heard of it. We love a heist - so get ready for Megan to talk you through the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum theft. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast...
-
17- The Gunpowder Plot (Alternate Title: OH FAWK!)
Four hundred and fifteen years ago tomorrow, an attempted attack on England’s Parliament was thwarted just in time. Today, Megan is talking about Guy Fawkes and the Gunpowder Plot. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Wikipedia article...
-
Mini Myth #3: Embers and Echoes
Mini Myths Episode 3: Embers and Echoes Happy Halloween! To celebrate spooky season, we’ve teamed up with sound designer Kasey Trouba to bring you three rounds of mini myths. These stories that might cross over a little more into the legendary or supernatural than our normal episodes, but don’t...
-
16- Halloween Double Trouble Special
Happy Halloween, kids! We’re bringing you a double feature this week for the occasion! Settle in to hear Carlie tell you all about the ghosts of Pfeiffer Hall, then learn about the Salem Witch Trials from Megan. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter...
-
Mini Myth #2: Phantoms and Footsteps
Mini Myths Episode 2: Phantoms and Footsteps We’re doing something a little different for the next couple of weeks. To celebrate spooky season, we’ve teamed up with sound designer Kasey Trouba to bring you three rounds of mini myths. These stories that might cross over a little more into the...
-
15- Lizzie Borden
Keeping with our extra-spooky theme of the past few weeks - settle in to hear Megan tell us the tale of how and why Lizzie Borden may or may not have killed her parents. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Space video https://bit.ly/2Wo7wGK...
-
Mini Myth #1: A Curse and A Countess
Mini Myths Episode 1: A Curse and A Countess We’re doing something a little different for the next couple of weeks. To celebrate spooky season, we’ve teamed up with sound designer Kasey Trouba to bring you three rounds of Mini Myths. These stories that might cross over a little more into the...
-
14- The Tri-State Crematory Scandal
We’re creeping into spooky season now. . . This week the Birthday Bitch (that’s Carlie) is telling us all about the mystery surrounding the Tri-State Crematory. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Aerial view of Tri-State Crematory...
-
13- The Flannan Isles Lighthouse Disappearances
Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Mental Floss article https://bit.ly/2mUrsF5 Wikipedia article https://bit.ly/2YneT2j Flannan Isles Lighthouse https://bit.ly/2mhmjqd Aerial view of Eilean Mor https://bit.ly/2otKWk3 Map showing Scottish...
-
12- The Fall of the Romanovs Part III
We’ve reached the end of our series on the Romanovs - this week Carlie tells us about their unfortunate demise. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Olga and Tatiana in their nurses’ uniforms: https://bit.ly/2oibzs7 The Romanov daughters…
more -
11- Minnie Dean, The Baby Farmer
Here’s a murder you’ve probably never heard of. Megan tells the tale of the only woman to be receive the death penalty in New Zealand: Minnie Dean, the baby farmer. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast NZ History Article…
more -
10- The Fall of the Romanovs: Part II
We’re back for Part 2 of our multi-part series on the Romanovs! This week things go from bad to worse for the czar as Carlie takes us aaalllll the way up to the beginning of World War I. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Episode of Irish...
-
9- Double History Mystery: The Grand Canyon & H.H. Holmes
Megan kicks this episode off with three mini-mysteries from the Grand Canyon. Then we feature our very first guest storyteller - the incomparably spooky Kasey Trouba! Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Mysterious Universe on Kincaid’s Cave...
-
8- The Fall of the Romanovs: Part I
It’s time to dive into our first multi-part story! Carlie is going to take us way back to the beginning of a story you’re probably familiar with, but in way more depth and creepy detail: the fall of the Romanovs! Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter...
-
7- The Radium Girls
In this episode, Megan talks us through what happens when you ingest tiny amounts of radioactive material repeatedly over a long period of time, and a couple of court cases that helped pave the way for workplace safety regulations as we know them. We’re talking about the Radium Girls. Email...
-
6- The Disappearance of Rebecca Coriam
Content warning for discussions of suicide This is the one where Carlie tells us about missing Disney cruise ship employee Rebecca Coriam, and the possible cover-up surrounding her mysterious disappearance. Please visit rebecca-coriam.com if you have any information about Rebecca that might help...
-
5- Rabies Disease and the Origins of the Western Vampire Myth
In this episode, Megan talks us through a double whammy of terror: one of the scariest diseases we should all be talking about more, and the supernatural legends it may have inspired. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast...
-
4- Odd Fellow's Home
Third time's the charm! Thank you so much for your patience while we sorted out those technical difficulties. Enjoy episode four! Get ready to learn about a spooky site with a personal connection for Megan and Carlie. Odd Fellows home has it all: secret societies, ghosts of orphans, and a literal...
-
3- Richard III: The King in the Car Park
In this episode, Megan dives into her favorite solved historical mystery: the burial of King Richard III. Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast King Richard III Visitor Centre website https://kriii.com/ Syphilis skull (skeleton warning!)...
-
2- Number Stations
Carlie tells us about the inexplicably unsettling mystery of numbers stations while slurping back a Starbucks iced chai. Youtube video referenced: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_GjT4V_apdI&t=196s Email [email protected] Instagram @sisterlypodcast Twitter @sisterlypodcast Find...
-
1- Tales From Across The Pond
Megan and Carlie kick off the first ever episode of Sisterly History Mysteries by each telling a true, odd tale from their respective places of residence: Naperville, Illinois and Dublin, Ireland! Get ready to learn about the Lemak family murders and the theft of the Irish Crown Jewels. Email...
Topics in this show
About this show
Two sisters living across the world from each other bond over their love of weird history, sharing delightful true (or mostly true) tales of the unusual, the scary, and the macabre.
Hosted by
Sisterly History Mysteries
Categories