The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Chris McMonigle and Nick Kostos evaluate the New York Yankees' chances of winning the division and their postseason rotation depth. They also provide a comprehensive NFL preview covering the Giants' offensive potential, the Jets' backup quarterback search, and division predictions for the upcoming season. 01:58 - Nick Kostos Joins Show 07:10 - Yankees Division Title Race 14:27 - Hip Hop Legend Debate 19:30 - Giants Season Expectations 29:40 - NFL Division Winner Picks 37:36 - Painful Yankees Playoff Losses 45:18 - Top 90s Music Hits 53:44 - Don Imus WFAN Stories 01:05:22 - Will Levis Jets Workout 01:11:30 - Super Bowl Prediction Talk

Big Mac and Nick Kostos break down the New York Yankees' late-inning heroics and Clarke Schmidt's dominant season as they chase the division title. They also examine the New York Giants' coaching and offensive outlook, debating whether Daniel Jones can solidify himself as the franchise quarterback. 01:25 - Nick Kostos Joins McMonigle 06:00 - Yankees Chasing Division Lead 12:50 - Eminem And Hip-Hop Memories 17:05 - Giants Coaching Staff Analysis 20:35 - Aaron Boone Management Critique 23:40 - Daniel Jones Franchise Evaluation

Nick Kostos joins Big Mac to discuss why he believes the New York Giants can secure a 2-0 start by exploiting weaknesses in the Dallas Cowboys and Los Angeles Rams. They evaluate the New York Jets' offensive outlook with Geno Smith and break down why they are fading certain quarterbacks like Justin Fields. The conversation also explores the best uniforms in NFL history and various quarterback ratings. 01:20 - NFL Week 1 Anticipation 04:22 - Giants Potential 2-0 Start 10:22 - Jets Offensive Optimism 17:43 - NFL Uniform History Debate 22:30 - Quarterback Passer Ratings 27:11 - Ravens and Steelers Outlook

McMonigle and Nick Kostos take a nostalgic trip through painful memories of Giants, Yankees, and Knicks defeats, debating whether the 2001 World Series was worse than the 2004 ALCS. They also discuss the history of WFAN, sharing personal stories from their days as interns and an encounter with the legendary Don Imus. 01:20 - Ninja Turtles Debate 05:05 - Animation Style Critiques 06:58 - Painful Sports Memories 11:33 - The Crying Game 16:32 - Aaron Boone Tenure 18:29 - Astros Cheating Scandal 22:30 - Nerdy Music Habits 26:23 - Yacht Rock Metallica 28:10 - Patrick Ewing Era 32:30 - 2001 vs 2004

Nick Costos and Big Mac evaluate the New York Jets' decision to work out Will Levis as a potential backup for Geno Smith. They also discuss the physical durability of Jaxson Dart and Cam Skattebo while debating whether modern NFL offenses are shifting back to heavy personnel sets. 01:21 - Tupac Murder Case Resolution 02:08 - Giants Star Injury Concerns 05:45 - Derek Jeter Rehab Lessons 09:14 - Resurgence Of NFL Fullbacks 12:31 - Top NFL Coaching Hierarchy 15:36 - Will Levis Jets Workout 20:55 - Competitive Pickleball Lifestyle 24:20 - Sports Media Office Culture

Chris McMonigle and Nick Costos debate the best 90s one-hit wonders before sharing personal stories about the emotional power of the Beatles. They analyze the New York Giants' roster and Malik Nabors' health while offering bold predictions for the NFC North and South. They also provide specific fashion advice for men and discuss Bill Belichick's clever stadium tactics. 01:20 - 90s Music Debates 05:38 - Beatles Emotional Stories 08:41 - Giants Season Outlook 12:43 - Fashion and Insecurity 18:14 - NFC South Analysis 21:48 - NFC North Preview 25:12 - Patriots Scoreboard Scandal

ChrisMcMonigle and Nick kostos dive into the weird world of AI-generated Yacht Rock versions of Metallica hits on The Carton Show. They also discuss the emotional weight of sports milestones, like Patrick Ewing's exhale, and debate which Yankees playoff losses stung the most. 01:00 - AI Metallica Yacht Rock 07:31 - Emotional Knicks Championship Memories 10:34 - Painful Yankees Postseason Losses

McMonigle and Nick Kostos share their favorite Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles before diving into the most emotional moments of their sports fandom on The Carton Show. They recount devastating losses for the Giants, Knicks, and Yankees, including the infamous 2003 playoff collapse against the 49ers. 01:00 - Music and Ninja Turtles 06:12 - Emotional Sports Moments 13:08 - NY Sports Heartbreak 18:02 - Aaron Boone's Future 19:57 - Astros Cheating Scandal

Big Mac and Nick Kostos rank the best uniforms in NFL history, highlighting the New York Giants' legacy sets and the Eagles' Kelly greens. They dive into Lamar Jackson's impressive passer rating and debate his efficiency as a pocket passer compared to public perception. Finally, Costos explains why the NFC North is the most unpredictable division in football with all four teams capable of finishing first or last. 01:32 - Ranking Top NFL Uniforms 06:50 - NFL Quarterback Trivia Challenge 09:19 - Evaluating Lamar Jackson's Greatness 12:18 - NFC North Unpredictable Division

C-Mac and Nick Kostos discuss the intense preparation required for national sports talk and balancing family life during the NFL season on The Carton Show. They engage in a debate over whether Home Alone 2 surpasses the original film before shifting focus to the gridiron. Nick Kostos offers a bold guarantee for the Jets' season opener against the Titans and critiques the quarterback situations in New York and Pittsburgh. 01:03 - National Broadcasting Prep 05:49 - Home Alone Sequel Debate 09:44 - Jets Week 1 Guarantee 13:31 - Justin Fields Discussion 15:58 - Jets Quarterback Depth

Nick Kostos joins the conversation to evaluate the New York Giants' defensive front and their potential to pressure elite quarterbacks this season. They also discuss the optimistic outlook for the New York Jets, highlighting why Geno Smith is positioned for a major bounce-back year with improved protection and playmakers. 01:01 - Giants Pass Rush Discussion 04:44 - Jets Offensive Optimism 08:44 - Studio Banter and Ads

Big Mac and Nick Kostos analyze the potential for a New York Giants resurgence under the leadership of John Harbaugh. They debate the future of Jaxson Dart as a franchise quarterback and evaluate how a new coaching staff can bring respectability back to the organization. 01:05 - New York Baseball Recap 02:14 - Giants Coaching Optimism 09:11 - Jaxson Dart's Future

Big Mac and Nick Kostos analyze the Yankees' postseason chances on The Cardin Show, focusing on Austin Wells' recent heroics. They debate Aaron Boone's managerial DNA compared to figures like Bruce Bochy and discuss the talent gap between the American and National Leagues. 01:00 - Hip-Hop Intro 03:08 - Yankees Performance Analysis 06:03 - Austin Wells' Big Hit 08:18 - World Series Contender Debate 10:45 - Managerial Impact Discussion

Chris McMonigle and Nick Kostos analyze the New York Yankees' chances of overtaking the Tampa Bay Rays in the American League East. They discuss the impact of Aaron Judge's return and Cam Schlittler's bid for the Cy Young Award following a dominant performance. 01:00 - Nick Kostos Joins Big Mac 02:55 - Mets Beat The Rays 03:22 - Cam Schlittler's Cy Young Run 05:13 - Aaron Judge's Impending Return 09:55 - Yankees' AL East Chances

Chris McMonigle and Anthony Gallo analyze the New York Yankees' performance, focusing on Gerrit Cole's durability and the competition between Spencer Jones and Trent Grisham. They also discuss the Los Angeles Clippers' NBA penalties, the sale of the LA Angels, and the New York Jets' backup quarterback situation. 01:50 - Introduction and School Stories 04:32 - Gerrit Cole Durability Concerns 15:25 - Yankees Outfield Debate 29:55 - LA Angels Sale Analysis 24:18 - Clippers NBA Penalties 34:00 - Jets Backup Quarterback Situation 28:10 - Giants Season Expectations

Big Mac and Anthony Gallo analyze the New York Yankees' victory over the Angels, specifically focusing on Gerrit Cole's velocity and his tendency to struggle once his pitch count rises. They discuss whether Spencer Jones has earned a permanent spot in the lineup over Trent Grisham. Between sports segments, they share humorous stories about back-to-school morning chaos and the struggles of being a parent to the tooth fairy. 01:20 - Morning School Routine 04:02 - Gerrit Cole’s Command 08:15 - Bullpen Depth Concerns 16:25 - Spencer Jones’ Impact 23:13 - Parenting and Injuries 29:28 - Tooth Fairy Problems 37:53 - Yankees Rotation Debate

Chris McMonigle and Sal Gallo weigh the merits of sticking with the veteran Trent Grisham versus starting the rookie sensation Spencer Jones in centerfield as the postseason approaches. They also analyze Gerrit Cole's recent performance and discuss the impact of Stan Kroenke's potential purchase of the Los Angeles Angels on MLB's financial landscape. 01:20 - Jones vs. Grisham Debate 02:31 - Cole's Recent Performance 07:57 - The Postseason Threat 11:50 - Ben Rice's Slump 14:49 - Centerfield Defensive Comparison 18:13 - Goldschmidt's Limited Role 23:34 - Hoff's Music Taste 28:44 - Angels Sale Ramifications 36:15 - MLB Spending Habits 46:35 - Mike Trout's Legacy

Big Mac and Gallo analyze the severe NBA penalties handed down to the Los Angeles Clippers in their simulation, including the loss of five draft picks. They shift focus to the gridiron to examine the New York Jets' quarterback depth and the decision to rely on Geno Smith and Cade Klubnik. The conversation also explores personal traditions like scoring baseball games by hand and celebrity sightings on Disney cruises. 01:20 - Gallo's AS Roma Shirt 05:20 - Disney Cruise Celebrity Miss 14:30 - Yankees Junior Name Trivia 18:00 - Art Of Scoring Games 23:48 - Clippers Receive Massive Penalties 35:30 - Jets Backup Quarterback Concerns 53:05 - Traffic Report

Chris McMonigle and Gallo evaluate the New York Jets' roster, focusing on the urgent need for a franchise quarterback in the 2025 draft. They discuss the potential of Geno Smith, the validity of tanking for a high pick, and the rumors surrounding Mike Tomlin as a future head coach. The conversation also features a lighter segment on personal collections and childhood nostalgia. 01:20 - Giants Season Expectations 06:00 - Backup Quarterback Concerns 12:14 - 2025 Draft Scenarios 17:23 - Potential Burrow Trade 23:30 - Nostalgic Childhood Hobbies 27:30 - Evaluating Draft Needs 35:00 - Mike Tomlin Rumors

Chris McMonigle and the crew share stories from their summer vacations, discussing why they still feel like children when it comes to food, video games, and bingo. They also analyze the New York Giants' roster and the optimism surrounding the team's outlook heading into the season. 02:10 - Childhood Food Takes 05:15 - Chicken Tender Obsession 10:15 - Retiring From Shoelaces 15:15 - Video Game Excitement 19:45 - Fast Food Desserts 23:45 - Black Coffee Debate 27:30 - Giants Roster Analysis

Will Malik Nabers be ready to go? Who will get the credit or blame: John Harbaugh or Joe Schoen?

C-Mac and Gallo go through the NFL teams and discuss which would potentially allow the Jets to trade into the top 5 of the 2027 draft for a quarterback.

C-Mac and Gallo debate on how the Jets should approach trying to get their quarterback of the future.

C-Mac and Gallo discuss the Jets' QB room beyond starter Geno Smith and how it can improve.

Instant reactions from C-Mac and Gallo on the news about the Clippers being forced to give up multiple draft picks while members of the organization are fined and suspended.

Does the sale of the Los Angeles Angels being $4 billion prove that the issue with MLB's competitive balance stems from the small market teams not spending enough?

C-Mac and Gallo debate on who should be playing when Aaron Judge comes back: Trent Grisham or Spencer Jones

C-Mac and Gallo have concerns about the Yankees starters not being able to go deep in games, putting more stress on the bullpen.

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' recent series of embarrassing losses and discusses the instability within the team's bullpen. They review Tony Romo’s official statement regarding his health and examine Stan Kroenke’s newest acquisition of the Los Angeles Angels. Pop culture headlines, including a music debate and a look at upcoming New York Giants expectations, are also covered. 01:50 - Yankees Collapse In Anaheim 05:27 - Bullpen Management And Depth 14:37 - New York Mets Future 21:07 - Tony Romo CBS Update 24:34 - Stan Kroenke Buys Angels 30:44 - Will Fleming Broadcast Controversy 12:15 - Duane Keffe D Davis 23:50 - Traffic Report 27:40 - Sydney Sweeney Lingerie Line

Big Mac analyzes the Yankees' lifeless effort in Anaheim and the dilemma of prioritizing the division title over player health during The Carton Show. They also react to news of Stanley Kroenke purchasing the Angels and debate whether the team possesses the same championship DNA as the Knicks. 01:20 - Yankees Fall In Anaheim 04:41 - Chasing The Rays 08:41 - Roster And Bullpen Flux 12:22 - Strategy For Postseason 18:08 - Movie And Music Banter 22:14 - Yankee Bullpen Debate 26:57 - Knicks DNA Comparison 24:01 - Kroenke Buys The Angels 29:56 - Red Sox Replay Debate

Chris McMonigle reacts to the conviction of Duane Davis in the Tupac Shakur murder case and debates the early arrival of Sam Adams Oktoberfest. He evaluates the Yankees' offensive struggles and the potential of Spencer Jones while addressing Tony Romo's statement on his health and CBS broadcasting future. 01:38 - Tupac Shakur Murder Case 05:28 - Sam Adams Oktoberfest Debate 12:39 - Yankees Postseason Offense Concerns 16:30 - Grisham Versus Spencer Jones 22:13 - Tony Romo Health Statement 29:35 - NFL Pre-Game Show Value 39:08 - Jazz Chisholm Retaliation Debate 41:10 - Cookie Puss Origin Story

McMonigle and Hoffman analyze the New York Giants' upcoming season, focusing on the urgency of winning early and the critical health of rookie Malik Nabors. They debate the team's potential for an upset against the Rams while also discussing the New York Mets' roster management and the possibility of pursuing Tarik Skubal. 01:48 - Hoffman's Inheritance Scam Call 04:35 - Rick's Beatles Nostalgia Call 07:10 - Giants Early Season Pressure 14:15 - Rams Trap Game Potential 20:35 - Nabors And Dart Connection 29:15 - Debating NFL's Unlikable Teams 31:55 - Position Players Pitching Issues 37:00 - Mets Bullpen Future Roles 40:45 - Pursuing Tarik Skubal Trade

Big Mac addresses the skepticism surrounding the Giants' Week 1 matchup against the Dallas Cowboys, questioning if Dallas is actually an NFC juggernaut. He also discusses Sidney Sweeney’s new lingerie line, Mets pitching matchups, and the controversy surrounding Tua Tagovailoa’s social media posts. Finally, he shares personal stories about high school sports awards and memories of Franklin Square. 02:10 - Sidney Sweeney Lingerie Line 09:30 - Giants vs Cowboys Preview 13:41 - Jackson Dart QB Discussion 19:34 - Dexter Lawrence Impact Analysis 25:08 - Yankees Roster Update News 29:30 - Chris McMonigle Award Story 36:56 - Franklin Square Neighborhood Memories 15:43 - Mets vs Brewers Preview 22:00 - Tua Tagovailoa Twitter Controversy

C-Mac and Anthony Gallo discuss whether Notre Dame can thrive without a conference schedule and debate the realistic expectations for Jackson Dart and the Giants this season. They take calls from passionate fans regarding the team's difficult schedule and the impact of the new coaching staff. 01:20 - Nostalgic TV Talk 07:17 - Callers Connect with Hosts 08:38 - Notre Dame Season Outlook 10:54 - Debating Giants Reality 16:46 - Music and Steve Miller 17:50 - Giants Schedule Debate 20:30 - Evaluating Jackson Dart 23:20 - Traffic Report 24:50 - Tom Hanks Film Rankings

C-Mac reviews Sydney Sweeney's new lingerie collection before diving into New York Giants football. He discusses the high stakes of the Week 1 game against the Dallas Cowboys and takes calls regarding the performance of Jaxson Dart and Dexter Lawrence. 01:48 - Sydney Sweeney's Lingerie 05:11 - Dick's Logo Discussion 07:17 - Giants Opening Game Debate 14:01 - Analyzing Jaxson Dart 20:49 - Dexter Lawrence's Impact

C-Mac evaluates the New York Giants' offensive potential and the importance of health for Malik Nabors. The discussion includes a debate on Major League Baseball's blowout games and the possible implementation of a forfeit rule. Finally, they look ahead to the New York Mets' offseason and the potential pursuit of Tarik Skubal. 01:00 - The Wheel and The Duke 02:45 - Giants Offensive Potential 09:06 - Seahawks and Rams Analysis 12:54 - MLB Blowout Forfeit Debate 17:02 - Mets Offseason and Skubal

Chris McMonigle reacts to Mad Dog Russo's claim that the Giants are guaranteed to start the season 0-2. He emphasizes the critical importance of Malik Nabers being healthy for Week 1 and discusses why the Rams matchup could be a trap game for Los Angeles. They also revisit a bizarre phone call Pete Hoffman received regarding an inheritance scam. 01:09 - Hoffman's Bizarre Texas Call 05:40 - Smoking Doctors And Beatles 08:03 - Malik Nabers Injury Status 10:56 - Rams Giants Trap Game 14:08 - Giants Slow Start Concerns

McMonigle explores Tony Romo's recent statement addressing his health issues and the likelihood of his return to the broadcast booth. They also discuss the value of high-profile announcers compared to pregame studio shows and share anecdotes from the Giants locker room involving Odell Beckham Jr. and Dexter Lawrence. Additionally, callers weigh in on the Jazz Chisholm Jr. controversy and the surprising history of Cookie Puss. 02:37 - Tony Romo Health Statement 06:38 - Future Of NFL Broadcasting 12:00 - Giants Locker Room Stories 17:16 - Jazz Chisholm Base Stealing 20:29 - Cookie Puss Alien Origins

C-Mac discusses the recent legal developments in the Tupac Shakur case and laments the arrival of seasonal items like Oktoberfest beer in early August. He also evaluates the New York Yankees' roster, debating the future of Trent Grisham in the lineup compared to Spencer Jones. 01:31 - Tupac Case Update 03:55 - Seasonal Items Rant 11:47 - Yankees' Offensive Concerns 14:07 - Grisham Versus Jones

Big Mac discusses the news of Stanley Kroenke and Kroenke Sports and Entertainment purchasing the Los Angeles Angels from Arte Moreno. He explores the franchise's history of expensive contract failures and takes a call regarding the recent Red Sox broadcast controversy involving Will Fleming. 01:12 - Kroenke Buys Angels 04:40 - Angels Ownership History 08:06 - Red Sox-Yankees Debate

The Carton Show analyzes the New York Yankees' organizational philosophy following a frustrating loss to the Angels. They compare the Yankees' DNA to the New York Knicks' recent success and debate whether 95-win seasons satisfy the franchise's championship expectations. The discussion also touches on Long Island's music scene and the questionable quality of the movie Teen Wolf 2. 01:00 - Long Island Bands 03:01 - Teen Wolf Discussion 06:55 - Yankees Reliever Strategy 13:11 - Yankees Versus Knicks 20:31 - Winning Standard Debate

Big Mac criticizes the New York Yankees for their lackluster performance against the Los Angeles Angels following a high-energy series against the Red Sox. The discussion covers the team's struggling bullpen, the division race against the Rays, and the return of Aaron Judge. 01:07 - Yankees' Disappointing Loss to Angels 05:38 - Chasing the Tampa Bay Rays 10:16 - Revamping the Yankees' Bullpen 15:00 - Mets and NFL News

Big Mac analyzes the New York Yankees' dominant series win against the Boston Red Sox and the subsequent fallout from the Boston broadcast booth. He evaluates the New York Giants' roster cuts, labeling Evan Neal and Jalen Hyatt as major busts while discussing the impact of Odell Beckham Jr.'s return. Additionally, they project the long-term outlook for the Knicks following potential contract discounts from Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges. 02:05 - Yankees Crush Red Sox 16:59 - Red Sox Broadcaster Controversy 22:23 - Aaron Boone Management Strategy 30:18 - Giants Roster Disappointments 37:44 - Rams Roster Construction Envy 45:08 - Dramatic MLB Catch Replays 09:27 - Knicks Contract Extension Talk

McMonigle recaps the New York Yankees' series win over the Boston Red Sox, focusing on the mental edge established during their 16-1 blowout. On The Carton Show, he critiques the WEEI radio broadcast that labeled Jazz Chisholm "Bush League" for stealing bases. The discussion also evaluates the New York Giants' roster cuts, including the status of Jalin Hyatt and Evan Neal. 01:31 - Giants Roster Moves 05:03 - Yankees Statement Series 08:51 - Will Warren's Dominance 15:32 - Red Sox Radio Outrage 20:06 - Jazz Chisholm Controversy 24:46 - Platoon Lineup Debate 33:56 - Yankees Series Edge

Chris McMonigle and Pete Hoffman break down the Baltimore Orioles claiming Luis Robert Jr. off waivers and what it means for the New York Mets' financial future. They also debate the postseason impact of Jazz Chisholm Jr., analyze Carlos Beltran’s legacy, and argue over whether Stan Lee or Steven Spielberg has a greater cultural footprint. 01:20 - Luis Robert Jr. Claimed 05:15 - Pete Alonso Performance Debate 10:00 - Jazz Chisholm Playoff Expectations 14:00 - Pedro Martinez Dominance 17:15 - Carlos Beltran Legacy Documentary 21:00 - Yankees Red Sox Series Recap 26:00 - Yankees Playoff Bullpen Strategy 30:00 - Al Pacino Classic Movies 38:20 - Stan Lee Versus Spielberg 43:30 - Bear Encounter In Warwick

Chris McMonigle reacts to the New York Giants' decision to bring back Odell Beckham Jr. while moving on from major draft disappointments like Evan Neal. The Carton Show explores the New York Yankees' current lineup strategy and debates the best movie sequels and old-school candy. They also weigh in on the New York Jets' quarterback depth and the challenges of watching every NFL game on Sundays. 02:21 - Beckham Jr. Rejoins Giants 05:54 - Giants Recent Draft Busts 12:11 - New York Sports Update 15:27 - Yankees Lineup Debate 19:46 - Legacy of Odell Beckham 24:08 - 80s Movies and Candy 30:02 - Jets Quarterback Options 37:44 - Giants Defensive Expectations 45:05 - NFL Sunday Ticket Debate

McMonigle recaps a dominant series win for the New York Yankees over the Boston Red Sox on The Carton Show, highlighting Aaron Boone's role in Jazz Chisholm Jr. stealing bases. He analyzes the Los Angeles Rams' unique approach to roster management and the NFL's 'fungible' salary cap. The conversation also explores the New York Giants' draft struggles under general manager Joe Shane. 01:21 - Jalen Brunson Birthday Song 04:45 - Heussler's Yankee Hate 12:11 - Rams Salary Cap Magic 16:59 - Giants Draft History Analysis 25:16 - Yankees Crush Red Sox 41:27 - Boone Defends Jazz Chisholm 46:29 - Savannah Bananas Entertainment

Anthony Gallo analyzes the Yankees' recent dominance over the Red Sox and argues why they are the primary World Series contender in a weak American League. He and DJ Hoff also discuss the Mets' pitching struggles and evaluate David Stearns' roster management. 01:35 - Yankees Dominance Over Boston 07:24 - American League Playoff Field 09:15 - Mets Pitching Rotation Struggles 15:30 - Cubs World Series Hopes 21:43 - Aaron Judge Return Update

Chris McMonigle expresses frustration over the Los Angeles Rams' ability to consistently manipulate the salary cap to retain superstars like Aaron Donald. He also recounts legendary stories of Bob Heussler's disdain for the Yankees and discusses the hit-or-miss draft record of Giants GM Joe Schoen. 01:01 - Celebrating Jalen Brunson 04:06 - Bob Heussler Yankee Hate 10:15 - Rams Cap Management Issues 15:21 - Joe Schoen Draft Critique 23:11 - On-Air Parenting Banter

Big Mac ridicules Craig Carton's questionable movie takes and his preference for "old person" candies like bottle caps and spice drops. They transition into a debate regarding the New York Jets' quarterback depth and the necessity of a multi-TV setup for the upcoming NFL season. 01:00 - Debating 80s Movie Sequels 04:26 - Craig's Bizarre Candy Tastes 06:40 - Jets Quarterback Room Concerns 16:21 - Giants Defensive Matchup Analysis 19:41 - The Ultimate Sunday Setup