PODCAST · true crime
The Paranoia Pair
by Anna and Jessica
Join two friends, Jessica and Anna, as they explore the strange, the spooky, and the downright bizarre in this out of this world podcast. From chilling true crime cases to mind-bending conspiracy theories, urban legends, and more, The Paranoia Pair is your place for all things weird and unexplainable. Whether it’s creepy cryptids or government cover-ups, these curious pals bring light and laughs and new perspectives to Earth's mysteries. Buckle up for a journey into the unknown, it’s going to be a wild ride!
Episodes
-
The City Under Lake Lanier
In this episode we learn about the forgotten city of Oscarville. A once thriving black community that was eradicated by a white mob fueled by racism and violence. It was either refuse to leave and die or die running for your life. Decades later the land was bought out by the government and…
more -
Ellen Greenberg
On January 26, 2011 Philadelphia prepared for a massive snowstorm. Later that day, Ellen Greenberg, a local school teacher, was found stabbed in her apartment by her fiancé. She had been stabbed 20 times but despite this, her death was ruled a suicide. The it was ruled a homicide before being...
-
The Fatal Attraction
In this episode we dive into the case that inspired the movie Fatal Attraction. Carolyn Warmus, a New York school teacher, was convicted of killing the wife of Paul Solomon, a man she's having an affair with. Evidence becomes complicated and Carolyn can't seem to help her obsession with Paul....
-
The Pillowcase Murders
Dozens of elderly women start dying in their homes across Dallas and Collin County Texas. Authorities said it was natural. Families knew something was wrong. Their concerns were dismissed and management at the senior living facilities keep the deaths under wraps. All it takes is 1 survivor for...
-
Lady of the Dunes
The discovery of a woman's body in Provincetown, Massachusetts sends the town into a panic. Various theories surrounding her identity start circulating, a mob hit, a serial killer, a ufo? Three detectives devote their lives on finding out who the Lady of the Dunes is and the person responsible.…
more -
Kenneth Fandrich
After getting a call from his concerned wife, Kenneth Fandrich is found dead in his car at his work's parking garage in Hillsboro, Oregon. At first, it looks like a medical emergency but detectives quickly notice things don't add up. Spray painted cameras. Strange vehicles. A stalker. And a love...
-
The Mormon Manson Part 2
In Part 2 of the Mormon Manson we pick up after Ervil slips through the raid in Mexico and things only get darker from here. We follow the fallout, the tightening grip of Ervil’s control, the escalating violence, and the creation of the infamous hit list he left behind after his death. From...
-
The Mormon Manson Part 1
In part 1 we cover how Ervil LeBaron went from "fundamentalist royalty" to "unhinged cult leader," earning the nickname 'The Mormon Manson". We cover family drama, blood atonement nonsense, the murder of Ervil's brother Joel, and the chaos that followed. And then we end on a raid in Mexico where...
-
Paranoia Files: Turkey Day Crimes
The true stars of this week's episode? Turkeys. In this episode we break down their crimes, chaos, their surprisingly aggressive personalities, and even being used as a weapon in one story. Sources:...
-
Caught by Karaoke
After getting a letter from the US Attorney for possible check fraud charges and the personal shame that came with it, Joe Crouch decides there's only one thing he can do... murder his wife, Betsy, and flee the state. He creates a new identity and tries to blend in. But his old habits follow him...
-
Eiffel Tower For Sale (Again)
He was charming, smart and full of lies. Victor Lustig was a con artist who didn't know how to rest. From selling Rumanian boxes, scamming a bank out of thousands of dollars to selling the Eiffel Tower... TWICE. In this episode we walk through the crimes, charm, and my favorite part, the petty...
-
Gef the Talking Mongoose
Join us in this short but fun episode where we go back to the 1930's where a family claimed to be haunted by a talking mongoose named Gef. He sang, swore and loved to gossip. Neighbors were skeptical and newspapers had a field day. Was Gef a spirit? A hoax? Or maybe this was just a case of a…
more -
Paranoia Files: Halloween Crimes
In this episode, we explore true crime stories that occurred on Halloween, including the poisoning of Timothy O'Bryan, the murder of Peter Fabiano, the Liske family tragedy, and the unsolved case of Martha Moxley. Sources: 🦇https://people.com/candy-man-killer-timothy-obryan-murder-8732896\...
-
The UFO Rebrand
UFOs got a glow up! Now they’re UAPs and the government’s been quietly chasing them across air, sea, and space. In this episode, we dig into decades of sightings, secret programs, and one whistleblower who says we’ve had alien tech since the 1930s. We’re talking pyramid shaped objects over...
-
The Yogurt Shop Murders
The Yogurt Shop Murders went unsolved for 30 years. After several false confessions, damaged evidence we finally have an answer. Thanks to forensic advancements, the case is solved. A man named Robert Brashers. Who is he? What lead us here? Join us as we figure it out! Sources:...
-
The Pike County Murders
Join us as we explore the motives, the investigation, and the haunting aftermath of the Pike County Murders. Uncover the tangled web of family ties, custody battles, and a meticulously planned crime that left a community in shock. Sources: 🦇Peacock Series: Pike County Murders...
-
The Murder of Pamela Pitts
This week we uncover the murder of Pamela Pitts, a young woman from Prescott, Arizona. Her brutal murder went cold for decades until a shocking twist involving her roommate and a second murder revealed the truth. From burned evidence to suspicious alibi's and a plea deal that left her family...
-
The Sinking of the Sultana
In this episode we tell the horrifying fate of the Sultana and its passengers. What began as a steamboat mainly used for the cotton trade ended in a night of disaster due to carelessness. Join us as we uncover a forgotten chapter in American history and explore one of the most deadly maritime...
-
The Vampire of Düsseldorf
Join us as we dive into the twisted tale of Peter Kürten, the infamous "Vampire of Düsseldorf." From his chaotic upbringing in a cramped one bedroom apartment to his long history of crimes. Get ready for a rollercoaster of shocking stories. 1:00 - Peter Kürten's Childhood 5:00 - Early Crimes...
-
Paranoia Files: Eerie Experiences and Disc Golf
This month's Paranoia Files takes you down eerie backroads, through haunted mansions and face to face with unsettling humanoid figures and even disc golf. 2:01 - I don't know what just happened 7:12 - Something is stalking my house 13:56 - I worked at a haunted mansion 16:50 - Disco Golf 20:30 -...
-
Annabelle: Haunted and Horrifying
Join us as we unravel the spine-tingling stories surrounding Annabelle and the controversial figures of Ed and Lorraine Warren. Brace yourself for a journey into the unknown, where reality blurs with the supernatural. From mysterious notes to unsettling paranormal activities, discover how a...
-
Fatal Obsession: The Murder of Jamie Faith
In this episode, Anna leads us through the shocking story of Jamie Faith. What looked like a random act of violence quickly spiraled into one of the most twisted plots we’ve ever covered. Complete with fake emails, a long distance affair, and a murder for hire. Discover how love, lies, and...
-
The Rake: Creepypasta Come to Life
It's Tall! Skinny! Pale! And its hands are WET! This week Jessica's cracking open the creepy vault of internet urban legends for "The Rake". You know, the pale, lurking figure that’s been haunting creepypasta forums and nightmares since the early 2000s. Is it a modern myth? A misunderstood…
more -
Paranoia Files: Ghosts, Mirrors, and Mysterious Voices
Join us for this month's Paranoia Files, where we read stories from Reddit. From eerie mirror reflections to unsettling encounters in the Appalachian woods, to the story of a friend turned murderer and a haunting that defies explanation, and a ghostly husband who had hidden secrets. 01:15 Mirror...
-
Inside the Buddhafield Cult
Join us as we venture into the truth behind the Buddhafield cult led by Jamie Gomez. From Hollywood dreams to spiritual manipulation, discover how he captivated his followers with promises of salvation and the dark secrets that lay beneath. Explore the bizarre rituals, the power dynamics, and the...
-
The Atrocities of Unit 731
This episode Jessica introduces us to the dark history of Unit 731, a covert biological and chemical warfare research facility operated by the Imperial Japanese Army during World War II. We discuss the horrific human experiments conducted under the leadership of Shiro Ishii, including…
more -
Return to Nature: Ashes and Lies
In this episode, Anna takes us into the shocking case of the Return to Nature Funeral Home, where the Hallford couple was found to have neglected the bodies of deceased individuals. We discuss the discovery of the facility's horrific conditions, the investigation that followed, and the emotional...
-
Paranoia Files: Creepy Encounters
In this episode, Anna and Jessica delve into a series of Reddit stories. From a terrifying encounter with a mysterious red trailer to eerie voices calling from the darkness, the conversation weaves through personal experiences and urban legends that haunt the mind. 00:53 The Red Trailer Mystery...
-
History of the Ouija Board
This episode explores the history and cultural significance of Ouija boards, tracing their origins from the spiritualism movement in the 19th century to their modern-day perception as tools for communicating with the dead. Jessica touches on the evolution of the Ouija board, its connection with...
-
Operation Mongoose: The CIA's Secret War on Castro
In this episode, we explore the events surrounding Operation Mongoose, a covert CIA operation aimed at assassinating Fidel Castro during the Cold War. Including the CIA's collaboration with the mob, the various assassination attempts on Castro, and the investigations that revealed the extent of...
-
The Legend of Mothman
This episode explores the legend of the Mothman, a mysterious creature first sighted in Point Pleasant, West Virginia, in 1966. Anna and Jessica discuss the initial sightings, the eerie history of the TNT area, and the connection between the Mothman and the tragic Silver Bridge collapse. We get...
-
Paranoia Files: Haunted Water Parks and Ouija Boards
In this episode of Paranoia Files, Anna and Jessica read chilling paranormal experiences, including a haunting at the Great Wolf Lodge, ghostly encounters, and the consequences of playing with Ouija boards. 01:09 The Haunting at Great Wolf Lodge 07:19 My Friend Sees Ghosts 12:52 Hiking and the...
-
The Stanford Prison Experiment
In this episode, Anna and Jessica discuss the Stanford Prison Experiment, exploring its background, setup, and the psychological effects on participants. They delve into the dynamics of power and control between guards and prisoners, the rapid escalation of dehumanization, and the eventual...
-
Who Was the Somerton Man?
In this episode, we get into the mysterious case of the Somerton Man, an unidentified individual found dead on a beach in South Australia in 1948. Anna and Jessica explore the circumstances surrounding his death, the investigation that followed, and the various theories regarding his identity and...
-
Legend of the Melon Heads
In this episode of The Paranoia Pair, hosts Anna and Jessica delve into the urban legend of Melon Heads, exploring their origins, variations across different states, and the eerie encounters reported by locals. We cover the Melon Heads' characteristics, their backstories in Ohio, Michigan, and...
-
Heaven's Gate: Away Team
This week, Anna and Jessica dive into the infamous Heaven's Gate cult, unpacking where it all started, what they believed, and the tragic mass suicide that shook everyone. They chat about the founders, Marshall Applewhite and Bonnie Nettles, and how their ideas about aliens and spirituality…
more -
Paranoia Files: Ghost stories, Squatters, and Cannibalism
In this Paranoia Files episode, Anna and Jessica share chilling stories, including military ghost encounters in Iraq, a gruesome tale from World War II, and unsettling experiences with squatters. 02:57 Military Ghost Stories: Encounters in Iraq 06:13 The Haunting of Camp Babylon 10:04 A Gruesome...
-
The Baraboo Bone Breaker
This episode Jessica tells the harrowing story of Thad Phillips, who was abducted and tortured at the age of 13 by a teenager named Joe. The conversation explores the events leading up to Thad's abduction, the brutal torture he endured, and his miraculous escape. It also highlights the tragic…
more -
The Caylee Anthony Case
This week Anna leads the episode on the case of Caylee Anthony. We're exploring the timeline of her disappearance, the investigation that followed, the trial of her mother Casey Anthony, and the public's reaction to the verdict. Including the evidence presented, the defense's arguments, cussing,...
-
The Mystery of Black Eyed Kids
This week, Jessica takes us into the spine-tingling world of Black Eyed Kids. First reported in 1996, these mysterious, black-eyed visitors have become the stuff of modern legends. Are they supernatural creatures, figments of imagination, or something else entirely? We'll explore where they came...
-
Paranoia Files: The Whistler, the Hitchhiker, and Other Nightmares
Strange encounters, eerie curses, and chilling discoveries—this month's Paranoia Files is packed with unsettling tales that will leave you questioning reality. A husband watches in terror as his wife’s behavior takes a disturbing turn. A late-night trip into the woods leads to a terrifying...
-
Susan Smith: A Path from Pain to Horror
In this weeks episode we go into the tragic life of Susan Smith, exploring her troubled childhood, the trauma she faced, and the events leading to the disappearance of her two children. We cover her relationships, mental health struggles, and the eventual confession of her crimes. Jessica and…
more -
The Ripper Revealed? Investigating the Latest Break in the Case
In this episode, Anna and Jessica delve into the infamous case of Jack the Ripper, exploring the historical context, the canonical five victims, and the brutal nature of the murders. They discuss the backgrounds of the victims, the societal conditions of Victorian London, and the chilling letters...
-
Teke Teke: The Vengeful Spirit That Crawls the Night
In this episode, we are diving into a few topics starting with the chilling urban legend of the Teke Teke, a vengeful spirit from Japanese folklore, detailing its origin stories, characteristics, and the moral lessons embedded in such tales. The conversation includes personal anecdotes and Reddit...
-
Paranoia Files: Unexplainable Experiences
In this episode of Paranoia Files, the hosts delve into chilling stories sourced from Reddit, exploring the paranormal experiences of individuals who have encountered the unexplainable. From ghostly encounters at the Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum to a terrifying childhood adventure in the woods,...
-
The Murder of Candice Parchment
This weeks episode is the tragic case of Candice, a 15-year-old girl from Georgia who went missing in 2010. Jessica and Anna discuss her background, the circumstances surrounding her disappearance, the investigation that followed, and the eventual discovery of her body. They explore the various...
-
The Tragic Case of James Bulger
This week the girls cover the tragic case of James Bulger. James was a two-year-old boy who was abducted and murdered by two ten-year-old boys, Jon Venables and Robert Thompson, in Liverpool, England. Jessica and Anna discuss the events leading up to the abduction, the horrific details of the...
-
The Dark History of the Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment
In todays episode Anna and Jessica discuss the Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment, a notorious study conducted by the U.S. Public Health Service that lasted from 1932 to 1972. It explores the unethical treatment of African American men who were misled about their health status and denied effective...
-
Paranoia Files: Spooked by Reddit
Today we are diving into the depths of Reddit's spooky stories. Stories that make you check over your shoulder, double lock your doors and wonder if you truly are alone. Grab your blanket, get comfortable and maybe... leave a light on. You never know what's lurking in the dark. Sources:...
-
The Dark History of the Manila Film Center
This conversation delves into the tragic events surrounding the Manila Film Center in the Philippines, focusing on the construction disaster that occurred during its rapid build under the regime of Ferdinand Marcos. Anna and Jessica discuss the historical context, the horrific collapse that led…
more
We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.
No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.
No topics indexed yet for this podcast.
Loading reviews...
ABOUT THIS SHOW
Join two friends, Jessica and Anna, as they explore the strange, the spooky, and the downright bizarre in this out of this world podcast. From chilling true crime cases to mind-bending conspiracy theories, urban legends, and more, The Paranoia Pair is your place for all things weird and unexplainable. Whether it’s creepy cryptids or government cover-ups, these curious pals bring light and laughs and new perspectives to Earth's mysteries. Buckle up for a journey into the unknown, it’s going to be a wild ride!
HOSTED BY
Anna and Jessica
CATEGORIES
Loading similar podcasts...
Frequently Asked Questions
How many episodes does The Paranoia Pair have?
The Paranoia Pair currently has 53 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.
What is The Paranoia Pair about?
Join two friends, Jessica and Anna, as they explore the strange, the spooky, and the downright bizarre in this out of this world podcast. From chilling true crime cases to mind-bending conspiracy theories, urban legends, and more, The Paranoia Pair is your place for all things weird and...
How often does The Paranoia Pair release new episodes?
The Paranoia Pair has 53 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.
Where can I listen to The Paranoia Pair?
You can listen to The Paranoia Pair on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.
Who hosts The Paranoia Pair?
The Paranoia Pair is created and hosted by Anna and Jessica.
URL copied to clipboard!