Skip to content
Totally NOTstalgic podcast artwork

PODCAST · tv

Totally NOTstalgic

by Jamie Yelton

Sisters Andrea and Jamie recap shows, movies, and otherphonomenon from their childhoods, and get sidetracked along the way.

Publisher-supplied feed metadata · PodParley refreshed Jul 5, 2025 · Source feed

Episodes

  1. Too Much Ass Not Enough Space||Grease: Rise of the Pink Ladies Ep1

    “I just really like Cynthia ok?!” This week Andrea and Jamie discuss theatre kid trauma, inappropriate productions of family-marketed shows and episode 1 of Paramount+’s Grease: Rise of the Pink Ladies.

  2. NBB S1 EP1 "VMA'S" (?)

    “I would rather have watched Law and Order SVU with our grandma than watch rock-a-doodle”This week Andrea and Jamie embark on The Naked Brothers Band, but this time the series premiere titled "VMAs" as well as some movies that scared the absolute crap out of them as children.

  3. The Naked Brothers Band Movie

    Andrea and Jamie never want to stop referencing the 2000's Nickolodeon tv show The Naked Brothers Band, so for the 10th episode of the Totally NOTstalgic podcast, they actually discuss the movie that started it all.

  4. The One Direction bracket

    Andrea and Jamie decide once and for all what the best One Direction song is.

  5. Totally NOTstalgic podcast (trailer)

    Sisters Andrea and Jamie recap movies and shows from their childhoods, and get sidetracked along the way.

  6. What’s the best Big Time Rush song?

    It’s just Jamie in this episode as she does a bracket showdown of every BTR song to discover what is the definitive best Big Time Rush song.

  7. Dan and Phil pt 2

    Jamie and Andrea talk about theatre kid trauma, sexuality, the best night one their lives, and finish talking about Dan and Phil (for now...)

  8. Dan and Phil Part 1

    This week, Andrea and Jamie talk about Tumblr, conspiracies and go absolutely feral for two 30 year old men (what else is new?). So draw on your cat whiskers, grab your nearest Susan, and put up your ladder hands because this episode's about Dan and Phil! Follow Andrea: Instagram: Msandrealynn...

  9. My Friend Dahmer//Actually NOTstalgic

    In this weeks episode, episode 1 of a new series “actually NOTstalgic” where the girls talk about movies that aren’t necessarily From their childhoods but maybe have some connection, Andrea and Jamie discuss the book and movie My friend Dahmer, harmful true crime fanatics, and all things Ross…

    more
  10. Random rambles #1

    Jamie and Andrea fully went into this with the intention of recapping 2 episodes of big time rush. But one thing led to another and they ended up talking about sharkboy and lavagirl, twilight, akward experiences going to see a musical written by their high school band director, and more! The...

  11. We’re going to school… AT THE PALM WOODSII Big Time Rush episodes 2 & 3

    In today’s episode, Jamie and Andrea recap episodes 2 and 3 of big time rush- and keep getting side tracked.

  12. 13: The Musical: The Movie: The disappointment

    In todays episode, Andrea and Jamie discuss a pivotal show in every theatre kid’s life and the movie that destroyed it.

  13. BTR cured my depression|| Big Time Rush S1 Ep1: Big Time Audition

    In the first episode of totally NOTstolgic, Andrea gets her first look at big time rush, Jamie thirsts over Kendall and the sisters learn that it’s the only life you got so you gotta live it big time.

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

Sisters Andrea and Jamie recap shows, movies, and otherphonomenon from their childhoods, and get sidetracked along the way.

HOSTED BY

Jamie Yelton

CATEGORIES

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Totally NOTstalgic have?

Totally NOTstalgic currently has 13 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is Totally NOTstalgic about?

Sisters Andrea and Jamie recap shows, movies, and otherphonomenon from their childhoods, and get sidetracked along the way.

How often does Totally NOTstalgic release new episodes?

Totally NOTstalgic has 13 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.

Where can I listen to Totally NOTstalgic?

You can listen to Totally NOTstalgic on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts Totally NOTstalgic?

Totally NOTstalgic is created and hosted by Jamie Yelton.
URL copied to clipboard!