True Crime in Real Estate™
by Sandi Lyn
So you passed the exam, bought the lockbox, and found a blazer that makes you look trustworthy. Nobody in pre-license brought up Beverly Carter, who went to show a house outside Little Rock in 2014 and never came home. Or Ashley Okland, shot inside a model home in West Des Moines in 2011. That’s the side of real estate this show covers. We get into agents hurt on the job, vacant houses that turned into crime scenes, brokers who disappeared with everyone’s earnest money, and wire fraud that drains a family’s down payment right before closing. Then the bigger picture, honestly, like redlining, Cabrini-Green, Pruitt-Igoe, slumlords who own entire ZIP codes, and cartels parking cash in luxury condos. Some of it is history and some of it is still happening right now. True Crime in Real Estate™ is made for agents. If you’re just here for the true crime and want to know why your REALTOR® won’t meet you alone at a vacant house after dark, this is why.
Episodes
-
Ep 17: The Bender Overlook Inn: Dinner and a Hammer to the Head
The Bender family established a small roadside inn and grocery store on a 160-acre homestead in southeast Kansas around 1870, positioning themselves along the Osage Mission Road, the main route west for settlers traveling with money and valuables. The family consisted of John Bender Sr., his son...
-
Ep 16: The Conjuring House - The Real Estate Story Crazier than the Hauntings
The episode revisits the story behind the Rhode Island farmhouse that inspired The Conjuring, beginning with the Perron family, who moved into the 1736 property on Round Top Road in 1971. The family described unexplained disturbances, frightening encounters, and increasingly violent supernatural...
-
Ep 15: "The Watcher" - Creepy Letters Sent to New Owners of $1.3 Million Dollar House
The episode examines the true story behind the infamous “Watcher” case involving Derek and Maria Broaddus, who purchased 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey, in 2014 for $1,355,657. The family planned to renovate the grand Dutch Colonial before moving in, but just days after closing, Derek...
-
Ep 14: Realtor to the Stars Bludgeoned by Her Assistant
The episode examines the 2007 murder of Linda Stein, a former co-manager of the Ramones who became a successful Manhattan real estate agent known for selling multimillion-dollar apartments to celebrities. Stein was found beaten to death in her Fifth Avenue penthouse after her personal assistant,...
-
Ep 13: Suzy Lamplugh, the UK Agent who Vanished at Lunch
The episode examines the 1986 disappearance of 25-year-old British estate agent Suzy Lamplugh, who left her London office to show a house to a man identified in her diary as “Mr. Kipper.” Witnesses saw Suzy with a man outside the property, but she never returned to the office. Her company car was...
-
Ep 12: Flock Around and Find Out - Why is There a Camera Pointed at My Community Swimming Pool?
In this episode Sandi Lyn examines automated license plate reader systems like Flock Safety, and the ways the technology can be misused by law enforcement, private organizations, and homeowners associations. It opens with the case of former police chief Michael Steffman, who allegedly searched…
more -
Ep 11: Realtor Mayra Velasquez: How Ancestry DNA (maybe) Solved the 2012 Murder of Irasema Chavez
Today’s episode examines the 2012 murder of Irasema Chavez in Arlington, Texas, where she was found stabbed more than 100 times inside her apartment. Surveillance footage captured a hooded figure entering after Chavez opened the door, but the video was too low quality to identify the person....
-
Ep 10: M***** F***ing Killdozer - Marvin Heemeyer's 2004 Rampage and the Real Estate Implications
The episode examines the 2004 Killdozer incident through the lens of commercial real estate rather than simply as a notorious crime. It follows the exploits of Marvin Heemeyer, who bought a two-acre commercial lot in Granby, Colorado, in 1992 to use as a muffler repair shop, before becoming...
-
Ep 9: The 40 Year Scam Disguised as Free Money. Red Flags and Warning Signs To Look Out For
MV Realty's "Homeowner Benefit Program" promised homeowners quick cash (typically anywhere from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars) in exchange for agreeing to use the company as their listing agent if they ever sold their home. According to multiple state attorneys general, the sales pitch...
-
Ep 8: Fraudulent Instinct - The $20mil Real Estate Scam That Happened BEFORE "Maternal Instinct"
The episode examines the case of Taylor Parker through the lens of real estate fraud rather than focusing solely on the widely publicized murder. Before killing 21-year-old Reagan Simmons Hancock and abducting her unborn child, Parker spent more than a year posing as an heiress with a completely...
-
Ep 7: Building a Case - The Bricks & Minifigs LEGO Controversy and Reckless Ben's Battle for Justice
An 83-year-old Oregon collector consigned one of the world's largest private Star Wars LEGO collection (worth more than $200,000) to a Bricks & Minifigs franchise, with a contract stating the family retained ownership until each set sold. After corporate repossessed the franchise in 2024,...
-
Ep 6: When Cops Fail, Rangers Lead the Way. The 1989 Ash Street Shootout #TrueCrime
Bill Foulk, an Army Ranger stationed near Tacoma, Washington, purchased a condemned home in the Hilltop neighborhood in 1987 for $10,000, believing the area was poised for revitalization. Instead, the crack epidemic and expanding gang activity transformed the neighborhood into one of the state's...
-
Ep 5: Inspiration for "Candyman" - The Violent History of Cabrini-Green
Sandi Lyn starts this episode with a deeply personal childhood story recalling growing up near violent housing towers in Rockford, Illinois, with the larger-scale history of Chicago’s Cabrini-Green projects as a backdrop. She uses her experience witnessing normalized street-level violence, drug...
-
Ep 4: The Davenport Building Collapse: Unanswered Questions
The episode opens describing the moments leading up to the collapse of the historic Davenport Hotel apartment building at 324 Main St. on Memorial Day weekend in 2023. Residents were living normal lives when the building’s west wall suddenly failed, causing six stories to crumble. Three tenants...
-
Ep 3: Alex Murdaugh Conviction Overturned, Brennan v Brian
The murders of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh became one of the most infamous criminal cases in South Carolina history because of the Murdaugh family’s decades-long influence over the Lowcountry legal system. For nearly a century, the family held enormous legal and political power in South Carolina...
-
Ep 1: Booked, Paid, Nowhere to Stay (STR Scams)
True Crime in Real Estate™ is reported journalism. Every name, charge, and figure is sourced from federal court filings, public records, law enforcement statements, and verified reporting. Pending cases are treated as allegations and the accused are presumed innocent until proven guilty. Nothing...
About this show
So you passed the exam, bought the lockbox, and found a blazer that makes you look trustworthy. Nobody in pre-license brought up Beverly Carter, who went to show a house outside Little Rock in 2014 and never came home. Or Ashley Okland, shot inside a model home in West Des Moines in 2011. That’s the side of real estate this show covers.
We get into agents hurt on the job, vacant houses that turned into crime scenes, brokers who disappeared with everyone’s earnest money, and wire fraud that drains a family’s down payment right before closing. Then the bigger picture, honestly, like redlining, Cabrini-Green, Pruitt-Igoe, slumlords who own entire ZIP codes, and cartels parking cash in luxury condos. Some of it is history and some of it is still happening right now.
True Crime in Real Estate™ is made for agents. If you’re just here for the true crime and want to know why your REALTOR® won’t meet you alone at a vacant house after dark, this is why.
Hosted by
Sandi Lyn
Categories