Skip to content
Two Girls and Caution Tape podcast artwork

PODCAST · true crime

Two Girls and Caution Tape

by TAYRA J EIDENBENZ

Hi! We know that if you are reading this that you are probably kinda weird, and you know what, we are too! We created this podcast to try and find other weirdos just like you and me who love the nitty gritty details of true crime. So a little about us, we are two college girls who are true crime obsessed. Out podcast goes through cases and provides just the right amount of humor as our young adult brains learn about all the weird things in the world. We laugh, we cry, we discuss all the things we are too afraid to bring up to our "normal" friends. True Crime Baby! That's what we are all about!

Publisher-supplied feed metadata · PodParley refreshed Apr 9, 2026 · Source feed

Episodes

  1. Genene Jones: Killer Nurse

    This case is bad. And when we mean bad, we mean killing over 60 children and some babies using poison bad. Genene Jones is the worst of the worst and she seems to feel little remorse. Two faced does not even begin to describe her. Genene was the nicest nurse to take care of your child when they…

    more
  2. James French: French Fries

    This case is will put you through a ringer of emotions. First, James French is an absolute comedian with a dark side. Having gone through several mental institutions himself and having come out as mostly sane, he has had his fair share of trouble with fitting into society. He figures a way in…

    more
  3. Malaysia Airlines Flight 370: Calamity or Conspiracy?

    Missing Malaysia Flight 370 is the modern aircraft mystery. It just disappeared off of radar from its scheduled path from Kuala Lumpur Airport in Malaysia to Beijing, China. With little debris showing up and very limited communication in the last hours of the plane's life, people cannot help but...

  4. Beltway Killers: DC Snipers

    You guys, this case is absolutely bonkers! This case goes through so many true crime aspects. First, two people meet at the exact right time. One ex-military with a desire to win his kids back, and the other desperate for a father figure. When they find each other, it seems like a match made in...

  5. Bellevue Murders: Role Play Gone too Far

    Alex Baranyi and David Anderson are the best of friends. But maybe their loyalty to each other has gone just a little too far. David has a complicated history with far too many girlfriends and Alex, a social outcast, is obsessed with David and will do anything to please him. The desire to kill is...

  6. Brittany Norwood: The Lululemon Murderer

    Brittany Norwood is living her best life; she and her co-worker, Jayna Murray, are closing up their Lululemon Store when things suddenly go awry. The next day, the two women are found to have appeared badly beaten and raped. Brittany is lucky to survive while Jayna died from her injuries. The…

    more
  7. The Hart Case: The Not-So-Perfect Insta-Family

    When Jennifer and Sarah adopt 6 children from underprivileged homes, they are seen as heroes. Their presence on Instagram and Facebook highlighting their perfect family is the modern day dream. All this changes when the children start coming forward, one by one, with signs of abuse. It all...

  8. Anna Mae Aquash: A Twisted Inside Job

    Anna Mae Aquash is living her best life. Known for her rank in the American Indian Movement (AIM) Anna rose from poverty to defend Native rights. However all goes wrong when the FBI and AIM become far too intertwined. Perhaps it was AIM? Or maybe the FBI? Or could it just possibly be a...

  9. Teresa Lewis: For Money or For Love?

    Teresa Lewis grew up in a poor situation to say the least. Her mental state does not help her situation when she constantly needs to depend on others to feel validation and survive. When Teresa meets a new man she discovers her first encounter with a lot money. So her plan is to use her secret...

  10. Bella Bond: the Boston Baby Doe

    **Fair warning, this case is rough.** Its not normal when a body floats up on a shore in a plastic bag, it’s more strange when that body is an unidentifiable toddler. Nicknamed “Baby Doe” this little girl becomes famous for remaining unidentifiable. With the culprit/culprits comes forward the…

    more
  11. Part 2-Robert Hansen: the Butcher Baker

    Part 2 of this case is thrilling. Not only do we learn more about Robert’s victims and his hobbies, we also learn about the aftermath of the whole affair. The trail is quick and smooth, but his prison life is not so. Hansen revealed only the tip of the iceberg when it comes to his victims.

  12. Part 1 - Robert Hansen: the Butcher Baker

    Robert Hansen is a seemingly normal guy with a not so normal background. As a baker in Anchorage, Alaska he is well liked by almost everyone. When it comes to his free time, however, he is obsessed with hunting and not just hunting animals. In this episode we go over his background, how he got...

  13. Amanda Lewis: The Kinda Killer Mom

    A single mom of three suffers the biggest tragedy on a hot summer day as she finds her older child 7 year Adrianna face down in the family.However it would be her younger son 6 year old A.J who would turn what seemed to be a complete accident into a murder case as he reveals some secrets.

  14. Martin MacNeill: The Man Who Almost Got Away

    Martin MacNiell is a self prescribed genius, both a doctor and a lawyer, he unfortunately doesn’t have the most honest past. With his ego rapidly inflating, the balloon around his perfect life bursts when his wife and daughter discovers his affair. Suddenly Michele, his wife, is found dead in a...

  15. Betty Broderick: Battered Ex Wife or Crazy Narcissist

    Betty Broderick is considered a victim of domestic abuse by some. By others she is considered a crazy, jealous, narcissist. She planned the ideal marriage and supported her husband all throughout medical and law school. But when her husband starts to make a seven figure income and trades her in…

    more
  16. Richard Farley: The Stalking Nutjob

    Richard Farley is that creep that you just never want to know even though he seems normal. No one thought he had it in him despite his extensive gun collection. But all this changes when he meets Laura Black, who he claims is the love of his life. Laura Black does not agree and tries to turn him...

  17. Carla Hughes: Murder Mystery or Love Triangle Revenge

    Carla Hughes and Avis Banks have quite a bit in common. Both are teachers, both are mothers or soon to be moms, and most of all they are both romantically involved with the same guy. When one of the two women gets murdered the other is suddenly in question. Did they even know about each other? Or...

  18. Katherine Knight: the Slaughterhouse Gal

    Katherine Knight is one crazy gal. Her childhood was characterized by abuse and depression. Her violent streak grew as her jealousy began to fume with all her partners. Not to mention her dream job was a butcher. Her violence, obsession with butcher knives, her violence again, and her jealousy…

    more
  19. Lauren McCluskey: the Murder of a College Athlete

    A young college athlete by the name of Lauren McCluskey tries to prevent her untimely death after meeting a man who was not who he said he was. Unfortunately, her attempts to get help from the police were not met in a timely manner. Listen to us ramble on as we attempt to give justice to Lauren’…

    more

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

Hi! We know that if you are reading this that you are probably kinda weird, and you know what, we are too! We created this podcast to try and find other weirdos just like you and me who love the nitty gritty details of true crime. So a little about us, we are two college girls who are true crime obsessed. Out podcast goes through cases and provides just the right amount of humor as our young adult brains learn about all the weird things in the world. We laugh, we cry, we discuss all the things we are too afraid to bring up to our "normal" friends. True Crime Baby! That's what we are all about!

HOSTED BY

TAYRA J EIDENBENZ

CATEGORIES

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Two Girls and Caution Tape have?

Two Girls and Caution Tape currently has 19 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is Two Girls and Caution Tape about?

Hi! We know that if you are reading this that you are probably kinda weird, and you know what, we are too! We created this podcast to try and find other weirdos just like you and me who love the nitty gritty details of true crime. So a little about us, we are two college girls who are true crime...

How often does Two Girls and Caution Tape release new episodes?

Two Girls and Caution Tape has 19 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.

Where can I listen to Two Girls and Caution Tape?

You can listen to Two Girls and Caution Tape on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts Two Girls and Caution Tape?

Two Girls and Caution Tape is created and hosted by TAYRA J EIDENBENZ.
URL copied to clipboard!