Skip to content
Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust podcast artwork

PODCAST · true crime

Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust

by Ashley Fletcher

Welcome to a podcast that delves deep into the darkest corners of true crime. We explore the most chilling cold cases, uncover crimes so shocking they seem unreal, and shine a light on the tragic failures of the justice system. Each episode reveals a story that is unsolved, unbelievable, or unjust.

Publisher-supplied feed metadata · PodParley refreshed Sep 5, 2025 · Source feed

Episodes

  1. Unsolved: The Disappearance of Rebecca Reusch

    One moment she was there, the next, she was gone. On February 18, 2019, 15-year-old Rebecca Reusch vanished from her sister’s Berlin home, leaving behind a void that continues to echo through Germany. With no witnesses and no trace of her ever leaving her sister's home, suspicion quickly fell…

    more
  2. Unjust: The Murder of Michelle Savage & Heather Whitbread

    She knew he would come for her. She told the police she was terrified. But no one stopped him. On March 16, 2018, in St. Leonards, East Sussex, Michelle Savage and her mother, Heather Whitbread, were executed in their own home. The man behind the trigger? Michelle’s ex-husband, Craig Savage—a man...

  3. Unbelievable: The Sexual Predators William & Zachary Zulock

    In one of the most disturbing child abuse cases in recent history, Zachary and William Zulock, a married couple from Georgia, adopted two young boys and subjected them to unimaginable cruelty. When a digital trail of child exploitation led investigators to their doorstep, what law enforcement...

  4. Unsolved & Unjust: The Murder of Corryn Rayney

    A crime that sent shockwaves through Western Australia—Corryn Rayney, a devoted mother and respected lawyer, was found buried in a shallow grave in Kings Park in August 2007. Her brutal murder triggered one of the largest criminal investigations in Australian history, but instead of uncovering...

  5. Unjust: Tracy & Robert Latimer, “Mercy Killing”

    A father’s controversial decision to end his daughter’s life ignited a legal and ethical firestorm that shook Canada to its core. Tracy Latimer, a young girl living with one of the most severe forms of cerebral palsy, endured relentless pain and suffering. In 1993, her father, Robert Latimer…

    more
  6. Unbelievable: Virginia McCullough & the Murders of Her Parents

    What if the house next door held a secret too horrifying to imagine? In a quiet English suburb, Virginia McCullough lived an ordinary life—or so it seemed. For four years, she concealed a gruesome truth: the murdered bodies of her parents, John and Lois, hidden in makeshift graves within her…

    more
  7. Unsolved: The Murders of Jane & Cathryn Johnson

    On September 3, 1996, the quiet town of Turner Valley, Alberta, was shaken by a fire that would reveal a horror far worse than anyone could have imagined. When firefighters arrived at the scene, they believed the deaths of 36-year-old Jane Johnson and her 8-year-old daughter Cathryn were the…

    more
  8. Unjust: President Donald Trump - 26 Allegations from Peeping to Groping to Rape

    The phrase “grab ‘em by the pussy” became infamous overnight, but it’s just one chapter in a troubling history of allegations leveled against Donald Trump. Today, we’re pulling back the curtain on accusations from 26 women, detailing experiences from groping to rape. This episode includes…

    more
  9. Unbelievable: The TWO Attempted Murders of Victoria Cilliers

    Falling from 4,000 feet with two failed parachutes, Victoria Cilliers defied death in a terrifying skydiving accident—but what she didn’t know was that this wasn’t an accident at all. Her husband, Emile, had allegedly tampered with her equipment, setting off an investigation that uncovered a dark...

  10. Unsolved: The Mass Murder of Keith, Elaine, Peter & Casey Dardeen AKA The Dardeen Family

    On November 17, 1987, the Dardeen family was brutally murdered in their Illinois home. Elaine Dardeen, seven months pregnant, was beaten to death along with her young son, Peter. In a horrifying twist, she gave birth during the attack, and her newborn daughter was also killed. Initially, her...

  11. Unjust: Disgraced Dr. Charles Smith’s and the 13 Wrongful Convictions He Caused

    Beneath the surface of Canada’s justice system lies a tragic saga of lives upended by a single man’s catastrophic failures. Dr. Charles Smith, once hailed as a leading forensic child pathologist, became the architect of a series of wrongful convictions that haunt the nation. A 2005 Ontario...

  12. Unbelievable: The Imprisonment, Abuse & Escape of Elisabeth Fritzl

    For over two decades, Elisabeth Fritzl lived a life of unspeakable horror, imprisoned by her own father in a hidden cellar in the basement of her family home. From the age of 18 to 42, she suffered unimaginable sexual abuse and gave birth to eight children in confinement. This chilling story...

  13. Unsolved: The Disappearance of the “Fort Worth Missing Trio”

    For over four decades, the chilling mystery of three missing friends has left investigators and families in a haunting state of uncertainty. On December 23, 1974, Rachel Trlica, Renee Wilson, and Julie Moseley set out for what should have been a routine day of last-minute Christmas shopping at…

    more
  14. Unjust: The Wrongful Conviction of Michael Morton

    Michael Morton spent 25 years behind bars for a crime he did not commit. His harrowing story of wrongful conviction reveals the shocking details of how crucial evidence was deliberately hidden by the very prosecutor charged with seeking justice. As we delve into this miscarriage of justice, we...

  15. Unbelievable: The “Thought Crimes” of Gilberto Valle III AKA the Cannibal Cop

    Imagine discovering that someone close to you harbored sinister intentions — detailed plans to kidnap, rape, and cannibalize you. Now, what if that person was your spouse? In this chilling episode, we delve into the shocking case of Gilberto Valle III, infamously known as the "Cannibal Cop."...

  16. Unsolved: The Investor Massacre

    On September 5, 1982, in Craig, Alaska, the commercial fishing vessel Investor became the scene of a chilling massacre, claiming the lives of eight individuals, including owner Mark Coulthurst, his wife Irene, their two children Kimberly and Johnny, and crew members Dean Moon, Michael Stewart,...

  17. Unsolved: The Long Island Serial Killer

    While searching for missing woman Shannon Gilbert near Oak Beach, Long Island, police stumbled upon a chilling revelation—a serial killer had been preying on the area for years, undetected. Join us as we uncover the haunting twists and turns of this investigation and explore why, even now, the…

    more
  18. Unjust: Robert H. Richards IV’s Lenient Sentence

    In 2009, Robert H. Richards IV, a wealthy heir, confessed to raping his 5-year-old daughter—and walked free without serving a single day in jail. How did the justice system allow such an appalling outcome? Join us as we delve into the shocking details of this case, exposing how privilege can...

  19. Unbelievable: The Cleveland Abductions Part 2

    For over a decade, Ariel Castro’s house concealed unimaginable horrors, while police missed repeated chances to uncover the truth. In Part 2 of our Cleveland Abductions series, we dive into the dark details of Castro’s crimes, the harrowing escape of his victims, and the stunning police…

    more
  20. Unbelievable: The Cleveland Abductions

    For over a decade, Ariel Castro held Michelle Knight, Amanda Berry, and Georgina DeJesus captive in his Cleveland home, hiding unimaginable horrors behind a facade of normalcy. We’ll uncover who Castro really was, how he lured his victims, and the dark path that led to his crimes. In part 2, we...

  21. Unsolved: Toronto Sick Kids Baby Murderer?

    From 1980 to 1981, 43 infants mysteriously died in the cardiac ward of Toronto’s Hospital for Sick Children, sparking one of the most exhaustive investigations Canada had ever seen. When a young nurse was arrested, it seemed justice was within reach—yet no convictions were ever made, leaving the...

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

Welcome to a podcast that delves deep into the darkest corners of true crime. We explore the most chilling cold cases, uncover crimes so shocking they seem unreal, and shine a light on the tragic failures of the justice system. Each episode reveals a story that is unsolved, unbelievable, or unjust.

HOSTED BY

Ashley Fletcher

CATEGORIES

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust have?

Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust currently has 21 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust about?

Welcome to a podcast that delves deep into the darkest corners of true crime. We explore the most chilling cold cases, uncover crimes so shocking they seem unreal, and shine a light on the tragic failures of the justice system. Each episode reveals a story that is unsolved, unbelievable, or unjust.

How often does Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust release new episodes?

Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust has 21 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.

Where can I listen to Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust?

You can listen to Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust?

Unsolved, Unbelievable and Unjust is created and hosted by Ashley Fletcher.
URL copied to clipboard!