Weirder After Dark
by WeirderAfterDark
Think you know New England? Think again. Join three cousins—Sean, Cathy, and Chris—as they uncover the region’s darkest, weirdest secrets. From haunted mansions and ancient artifacts to cryptids, cults, and murderous mysteries, Weirder After Dark is where humor meets history, and the eerie meets the unexplained. It’s New England like you’ve never imagined.
Episodes
-
78. Madame Sherri’s Staircase to Nowhere
In the woods of West Chesterfield, New Hampshire, a lone stone staircase climbs toward a castle that no longer exists. This week, we dig into the story of Madame Sherri, the flamboyant Broadway costume designer who built a hillside mansion for her legendary parties, and trace how her glamorous…
more -
77. The Ward House: Salem’s Most Haunted Location
The Ward House gets called Salem’s most haunted attraction, and in a town with this much competition, that’s a big claim. This week we go through the history of the house, including the High Sheriff’s body being kept there for ten years, and how it all connects back to the witch trials. Then we…
more -
Summer Break
Gang, it's been such an honor to drop this weekly podcast for over a year and a half. Seriously, in ways it's heartbreaking to do this.... However, we're going to be reducing our episode drops over the summer with the hopes of picking back up this fall! thank you for this wild ride!!! We hope you...
-
76. From the Vault: Rt 44's Redheaded Hitchhiker
April showers bring May..... IDK what May has brought, but it's been a lot! This will be our last 'FTV' episode with a new episode dropping next week! Thank you so much for your patience as we take some time off! Like Candles? Check out our collaboration with Ghost Poppy! Contact us:...
-
75: Crossover: The Allagash Four with Paranormal Directive 13
The "Allagash Four" refers to twin brothers Jack and Jim Weiner, Chuck Rak, and Charlie Foltz, who claimed aliens abducted them during a 1976 camping trip in Maine's Allagash Wilderness. We covered the story briefly in Chris's episode, 'Missing Time. But today, we are deep diving into the entire...
-
74. From the Vault: The Legend of Northfield, VTs Pigman
Hey Gang! We're having a bit of a squeeze and some health issues have popped up, preventing us from recording this week. We decided to play one of our favorite episodes from the vault! We hope you enjoy revisiting this hilarious/lighthearted episode! Catch you next week. In the shadowy hills of...
-
73. The Erased Researchers: Secret Projects, War Crimes, or Corporate Violence?
Over the last 6 months, 5 researchers, government officials, and scientists have either gone missing OR been found murdered in cold blood. Some with ties to New England. Is this a coincidence? Or could there be something underlying that connects all these murders? Tonight, we're diving into a...
-
72. The Wakefield, NH Incident
During the winter of 1977, something very strange happened in Wakefield, NH. A local horse farmer woke up to find a perfect circle carved into 18 inches of ice on the pond he used to feed his horses. Even stranger, as he inspected the perfect circle he could see a small black cube at the bottom…
more -
71. The Jumping Frenchmen in Maine
Imagine you're deep in the woods of northern Maine. It's the 1870s. The air smells like pine and cold mud, and you're living in a bunkhouse with thirty other lumberjacks, miles from the nearest town. You've been swinging an ax since before sunrise, and the only entertainment you've got is each...
-
70. Taken: The Betty and Barney Hill Incident
It was a quiet September night in 1961 when Betty and Barney Hill made the fateful decision to abandon their honeymoon and drive home from Montreal to Portsmouth, NH. What should have been a smooth 6-hour drive turned into America's first abduction stories. Join us as we dive into 3 hours of...
-
69. The Possession of Elizabeth Knapp: The Devil Visits Groton
More than twenty years before Salem, the quiet Puritan town of Groton, Massachusetts, became the center of a terrifying mystery. Sixteen-year-old Elizabeth Knapp began suffering violent fits, screaming strange guttural voices, lashing out at caregivers, actions she claimed came from the Devil...
-
68. The Eddy Brothers: Vermont's Spirit Summoners
In the late 1800s, deep in the Green Mountains of Vermont, two brothers claimed to do the impossible. They claimed to be able to bring back the dead. William and Horatio Eddy became the most talked-about mediums in America. Night after night, full-bodied apparitions allegedly materialized from…
more -
67. The Chinese Curse of Naples, Maine
This week, we're heading to Naples, Maine, where one man's greed led him to make a decision that would change everything. Sure, he got filthy rich.... but at what cost? For decades, the land he once called home was claimed to carry a curse that led to a half dozen deaths, a dozen businesses to go...
-
66. Owls Head Lighthouse: Maine's Most Haunted Beacon
It's been standing since 1825, but some of the keepers at Owls Head Lighthouse in Rockland, Maine, never really left. Rated the #1 most haunted lighthouse in America, this little stone tower has its share of ghost stories. A phantom keeper readying the fog horn, a "Little Lady" haunting the...
-
65. The Haunting of Nelly Butler: America’s First Documented Ghost
In 1799, a family in Maine reported nightly visits from the spirit of a deceased woman. The apparition didn’t float through walls or stand at the end of beds. Instead, she would stand before dozens of people and talk for hours. She would appear at any time of day or night and could even appear in...
-
64. The Oracle of Lynn: The Prophecies of Molly Pitcher
Molly Pitcher was known as a psychic, a seer, and an oracle. So well known that George Washington and other revolutionary leaders regularly sought her guidance while drafting their war plans. Cool, right? But when you look up Molly Pitcher, this isn't the story you'll find in the history books.…
more -
63. Wallace Tillinghast's Mystery Machine
In the early 1900s, a wealthy Boston inventor named Wallace Tillinghast made an unbelievable claim: he had built and successfully flown a secret airplane over New England! However, this was years before most people thought it was even possible. Then, just as suddenly, he vanished from the…
more -
62. New Hampshire's Tilton Inn: Built to Burn
On busy Main Street in Tilton, New Hampshire, thousands of cars pass a stately Victorian building every day without realizing how many times it’s been nearly erased. The Tilton Inn has welcomed travelers for more than a century, but its history is marked by repeated fires and tragic deaths. In…
more -
61. The Witches of Bristol Connecticut
Fueled by fear, religion, and personal grudges. Ordinary neighbors were suddenly suspected of consorting with the devil. In this episode, we dig into the documented cases, the people accused, the banned trials turned into witch hunts, and talk about how they fit into Connecticut’s often…
more -
60. The McDonald Family Fires
A house fire is supposed to leave answers behind. However, for the McDonald family, fires left only questions. What was first labeled a tragic accident quickly unraveled into something far stranger... multiple fires, conflicting timelines, and a story that never fully made sense. As investigators...
-
59. Fort Adams: Rhode Island’s Most Haunted Stronghold
Fort Adams towers over Newport Harbor like a relic of war frozen in time. Built to defend against enemies that never came, it instead became home to something else entirely. In this episode, we explore the dark history and enduring hauntings of Fort Adams, one of the largest coastal…
more -
58. Nightmare in Cumberland: Freddy Fingernails & Hot-Shot Charlie
For decades in Cumberland, RI, there have been legends of a hermit man with a disfigured, burned body and sharpened fingernails who roams the woods. It's said that you hear him coming before you see him.... but when he does come, he slashes your body with his razor-sharp nails. In these parts he...
-
57. New Hampshire's Devil Monkey (Ft. Paranormal Directive 13)
In the early 2000s, something strange was reported moving through the woods of Danville, New Hampshire. Not a bear. Not a dog. Witnesses described a small, fast, monkey-like creature with glowing eyes.....something that didn’t make sense for New England. Locals called it the Devil Monkey. In this...
-
56. The Melon Heads of Connecticut
Deep in Connecticut, local legends mention small, pale figures with abnormally large heads said to stalk the woods, chase cars, and emerge from abandoned institutions after dark. They go by the name Melon Heads. The stories have been passed around campfires, school buses, and internet forums for...
-
55. The Golden Eagle: Maine's Christine
In this episode of Weirder After Dark, we dive deep into the chilling lore of The Golden Eagle! A custom car from Maine that is accused of being cursed, dangerous, and maybe even alive. This car murders with lightening, crushes people in the seat of its car, and when it gets bored can even just…
more -
54. The Wolves of Palmyra: The Martin Cabin Incident
Deep in the woods of rural Maine, the Martin family thought they were settling in for a quiet weekend at their remote cabin… until something started circling the tree line. In this episode, we dig into one of Maine’s strangest modern legends: the Skinwalker-like entity said to stalk the northern...
-
53. The Fernald State School: Forgotten Children, Forbidden Experiments
Hidden behind the quiet streets of Waltham lies the haunting legacy of the Fernald State School. An institution built on cruelty, exploitation, and experiments no one was supposed to know about. This week, we dig into the stories of the children forgotten by the state, the infamous “Science Club”...
-
Crossover: The Winstead Wildman (Ft. Paranormal Directive 13)
We’re off this week for Thanksgiving, but the weird doesn’t take holidays. So we’re sharing a crossover episode we did with Paranormal Directive 13, where Matt walked us through the bizarre case of the Winsted Wildman, Connecticut’s very own 19th-century cryptid. Eyewitnesses claimed it was...
-
52. The Red-Headed Hitchhiker of Route 44
Tonight, we’re heading to one of New England’s most infamous stretches of asphalt,one that once ranked the scariest road in Massachusetts. Route 44, between Seekonk and Taunton, where drivers swear they’ve encountered a ghost that doesn’t just appear, he asks for a ride. For decades, people have...
-
51. Empty Frames: The Gardner Museum Heist (Ft. Intuitive Nichole Duncan)
In the early hours of March 18th, 1990, two men disguised as Boston police officers walked into the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum and walked out with thirteen priceless works of art. Rembrandt. Vermeer. Degas. Gone. More than thirty years later, the frames still hang empty, the suspects are…
more -
50. The Black Dog of Hanging Hill
They say the first time you see the Black Dog of Hanging Hill, it brings good fortune. The second time, bad luck. And the third? Certain death. Even weirder, this dog doesn't bark, and it doesn't leave footprints. Tonight, we dig into one of Connecticut's weirdest stories and prepare you for your...
-
49. The Palatine Light: Rhode Island’s Eternal Fire
They say a burning ship still haunts the waters off Block Island. A ghostly flame that flickers across the waves, appearing each year around Christmas. But before the legend of the Palatine Light, there was a real ship: The Princess Augusta. A doomed voyage that ended in starvation, betrayal, and...
-
48. The Curse of Harry Maine: Buried by the Sea
In the 1600s, Harry Main was a fisherman in Ipswich, Massachusetts, and he was a man consumed by greed and cruelty. But when he finally died, the townspeople buried him close to the tide line so the Devil, or the sea, could claim him. Centuries later, locals still swear that during coastal…
more -
47. Doc Benton: New Hampshire’s Immortal Madman
High in New Hampshire’s White Mountains, locals still whisper the name Doc Benton. After the death of his family, he became obsessed with unlocking the secret to eternal life. But then his research took a dark and deadly turn. Benton’s name became tied to strange deaths, missing hikers, and…
more -
46. The Andreasson Affair: New England’s Most Detailed Alien Abduction (Ft. Paranormal Directive 13)
It’s January 25th, 1967, in Ashburnham, Massachusetts. The Andreasson family has just finished dinner when the lights go out and the night sky begins to glow red and pink. Moments later, strange beings appear outside the windows. What followed would become one of New England’s most detailed and...
-
45. The Moodus Noises: Rumbles from the Deep
Deep in the quiet hills of Moodus, Connecticut, the ground groans, rumbles, and roars. For centuries, locals have heard the infamous “Moodus Noises”, phantom booms that shake the earth without warning. To the Indigenous people, they were the voice of angry spirits. To early colonists, they were a...
-
44. The Hanging of Alice Young: America’s First Witch Trial
In 1647, decades before Salem, Connecticut made history with its first witch execution. Her name was Alice Young of Windsor. Little survives about her trial, but her death marked the beginning of New England’s witch panic—decades of fear, accusations, and hangings that would leave deep scars…
more -
43. The Voynich Manuscript: New England’s Uncrackable Code
Locked away at Yale’s Beinecke Library is the world’s most mysterious book—the Voynich Manuscript. Packed with unknown symbols, bizarre plants, and cosmic charts, it’s baffled scholars, spies, and codebreakers for centuries. Can anyone crack its code? Email Us: [email protected]…
more -
42. The Mount: Edith Wharton’s Ghostly Estate (Ft. Medium Stephanie Jacquier)
Join us as Cathy, Chris, Sean and special guest medium Stephanie Jacquier explore The Mount. Nestled in the Berkshires, The Mount isn’t just Edith Wharton’s architectural masterpiece—it’s one of the most haunted homes in New England. In this episode, the gang dives into the life of Pulitzer...
-
41. The Amityville Horror (Ft. Slashback Cinema)
Join us and Shanny & Ryan from Slashback Cinema as we explore the story of the Amityville Horror! In 1974, a brutal family murder shook a quiet Long Island town. Just one year later, the new owners of 112 Ocean Avenue claimed something even darker was living inside the house: footsteps in empty...
-
40. The Glastonbury Glawackus: Connecticut’s Mystery Beast
n the winter of 1939, the quiet town of Glastonbury, Connecticut, was gripped by fear. Farmers found livestock torn apart. Strange paw prints were discovered in the snow. And locals swore a howling, shadowy beast was stalking the woods. Reporters called it the “Glawackus”—a creature said to be…
more -
39. The Mount Washington Hotel: A Princess, A Haunting, A Legend
High in the White Mountains sits the grand Mount Washington Hotel — a place of luxury, scandal, and lingering spirits. Guests have long whispered about a “princess” who never truly checked out, her presence still felt in the halls and, most famously, in Room 314. But who was she? Why does her…
more -
38. The Wood Devil of Coös County: NH’s Elusive Cryptid
Deep in New Hampshire’s remote Coös County, a towering, shadowy figure is said to stalk the forests. Locals call it the Wood Devil—a lanky, gray-skinned cryptid that’s been slipping between trees and dodging human eyes for over a century. But what exactly is haunting the White Mountains? A cousin...
-
37. The Leatherman: The 365-Mile, 10-Miles-a-Day, 30-Year Mystery
For over 30 years, a man wrapped head to toe in patched leather walked a perfect 365-mile loop through New England. Always clockwise, always every 34 days. Towns left pies on fence posts like offerings. Kids would drop everything to watch him pass. And yet, no one ever really knew who he was…
more -
36. The Dash: Maine's Ghost Ship
They called her fast. Unstoppable. Untouchable. But in January 1815, The Dash—a sleek Maine schooner fresh off privateering duty—sailed into the Atlantic and vanished without a trace. Sixty men aboard. No wreckage. No survivors. Just a legend. For over two centuries, coastal Mainers have claimed…
more -
35. The Brattleboro Retreat Tower: Legends of the Asylum Watchtower
It was built as a place of peace—an escape into nature for the patients of a Victorian-era asylum. But today, the Brattleboro Retreat Tower is sealed shut, fenced off, and whispered about in the same breath as ghost stories and local tragedy. What happened inside? And why does this lonely tower…
more -
34. The Specter Moose: Maine’s Ghostly Giant of the North Woods
For over a century, hunters, loggers, and hikers have reported a massive, ghostly-white moose—eight feet tall at the shoulder, with antlers like tree limbs and eyes that seem… not quite alive. Is it a spirit? A cryptid? A warning? This week, Sean takes the gang deep into the haunted woods to...
-
33. Boon Island: Shipwreck, Starvation, and the Haunting That Followed
Just off the coast of Maine lies a jagged, wind-battered rock called Boon Island. In 1710, a British ship wrecked there in the dead of winter. The survivors—freezing, starving, and surrounded by nothing but ocean—were pushed past the brink. What happened next became one of the darkest survival...
-
32. The Lady in Black: How Melanie Lanier Became Fort Warren’s Legendary Ghost
Think you know Civil War history? Think again. When Melanie Lanier set out to rescue her captured husband from Fort Warren, she wasn’t expecting her mission to end in tragedy… or that her final request—to be buried in a black dress—would spark one of New England’s most enduring ghost stories. In...
-
31. Stone’s Public House: Ghosts, Murder, and the Underground Railroad
Nestled beside the tracks in Ashland, Massachusetts, sits one of the most haunted pubs in New England—Stone’s Public House. Built in the 1830s by a railroad tycoon with a dark past, this tavern has seen it all: unexplained deaths, ghost sightings, secret basement chambers, and even rumored ties…
more
About this show
Think you know New England? Think again. Join three cousins—Sean, Cathy, and Chris—as they uncover the region’s darkest, weirdest secrets. From haunted mansions and ancient artifacts to cryptids, cults, and murderous mysteries, Weirder After Dark is where humor meets history, and the eerie meets the unexplained. It’s New England like you’ve never imagined.
Hosted by
WeirderAfterDark
Categories