WFAN Daily

Craig Carton has had enough! After watching the 2026 MLB All-Star Game, Craig goes OFF on American sports fans for constantly complaining about everything — too much pitching, not enough offense, boring games, bad entertainment and more.Chris McMonigle pushes back as the guys debate whether the All-Star Game exposed a bigger problem with modern baseball — or with the fans watching it. Plus, Craig and C-Mac react to Boyz II Men’s rough performance and discuss encouraging comments from Giants coach John Harbaugh about letting Jaxson Dart use his legs.

Football is already taking over New York, and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber turn their attention to the biggest questions facing the Giants as training camp approaches. At the center of the conversation is Malik Nabers and whether his recovery will allow him to rejoin the offense without being rushed.They also react to a dull MLB All Star Game, the Yankees winning with small ball, and a National League lineup that looked far too much like the struggling Mets. With baseball failing to deliver much excitement, the anticipation for Giants and Jets camp is only getting stronger.

We talked about last night’s All-Star game which ended 4-0 and had a ton of strikeouts. It was simply boring.

Craig Carton has noticed a major change in Jaxson Dart and he believes New York Giants fans should be thrilled.After an offseason filled with celebrity appearances, big events and life in the spotlight, Dart has seemingly disappeared from the public eye as training camp approaches. Craig believes that means the young quarterback is locked in on football and preparing to prove he can become the Giants’ franchise quarterback.Chris McMonigle explains why he never doubted Dart’s commitment and why proving he is the long-term answer at quarterback is the biggest question facing the Giants this season.

Jordan Walker emerged as a breakout star in a Home Run Derby that finally felt fun again. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber explain why the new format worked, how Philadelphia fans added energy to the event and why Major League Baseball delivered a much needed win.The conversation then shifts to Geno Smith and the repeated speeding stories surrounding the Jets quarterback. Shaun and Tiki debate whether the incidents reveal poor decision making and why Smith must become a stabilizing leader instead of another offseason distraction.

Gio and Jerry were not impressed.

Craig Carton is back alongside Chris McMonigle on The Carton Show, and he wastes no time unloading on the Mets after they were swept by the Red Sox and stumbled into the All-Star break at 17 games under .500.

The Mets enter the break buried in frustration after another costly mistake from Francisco Lindor and another late collapse from Devin Williams. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate whether Luke Weaver should immediately become the closer, whether he should be traded, and which young players offer any real hope for the future.The Yankees provide a more encouraging story after four straight wins and a weekend filled with late comebacks. Shaun and Tiki discuss whether the lineup is learning to survive without Aaron Judge, why the offense still feels incomplete, and how the tightening race with the Rays and Red Sox could shape the second half.

Jerry & John Franco breaking down where both teams are as the All-Star break is here.

With Aaron Judge sidelined, Chris McMonigle says the Yankees can't afford to think small at the trade deadline. While Judge's injury is impossible to replace, Chris argues the bigger long-term concern is Giancarlo Stanton's latest setback—and makes the case for Brian Cashman to swing BIG for Rafael Devers.Plus, Chris breaks down why the Yankees' win over the Rays was so important, why the AL is still there for the taking, and why standing pat at the deadline would be a massive mistake.

Aaron Judge’s uncertain recovery has changed the outlook for the Yankees. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine why Brian Cashman’s latest comments are so concerning, whether Judge can return as the same dominant hitter, and how Giancarlo Stanton’s injury adds even more pressure to a struggling offense.They debate how the Yankees should approach the trade deadline when no single player can replace Judge’s production. The conversation also explores which current hitters must improve, how Judge could still provide lineup protection if he returns at less than full strength, and why Ryan McMahon’s long at bat may have sparked a much needed offensive breakout.

Jerry & Gordon are in for Boomer & Gio and start the show talking about the Yanks win and Brian Cashman's presser the status of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.

Big Mac reacts to the Yankees' much-needed series finale victory over the Rays and explains why this wasn't just another win. From Ryan McMahon's game-changing 12-pitch at-bat to Ben Rice's monster series, Chris breaks down the biggest positives and why Yankees fans shouldn't dismiss them. He also clashes with callers who insist the Yankees still aren't contenders, discusses the bullpen, Aaron Judge's injury update from Brian Cashman, and why the upcoming series in Washington is now critical.

The Yankees offense has reached a new low, with strikeouts piling up, scoring opportunities disappearing, and no obvious solution available. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the problem is strategy, mentality, fatigue, or simply a lineup full of players who need to perform better.Cody Bellinger takes center stage as his dramatic slump raises questions about Aaron Judge’s impact on the entire lineup. With trades unlikely to provide an instant cure, Evan embraces an unconventional idea and pulls a completely new Yankees batting order out of a hat.

We opened with the Yankees shutout loss to the Rays and all the bad things about that game. Paul Goldschmidt is now 0 for his last 34. Aaron Boone got tossed last night and Boomer thinks he’s trying to wake up his listless team.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and unloads on the Yankees after another frustrating loss. While everyone is focused on the team's record-setting strikeout totals, Chris says they're missing the real problems. He also dives into the latest Anthony Volpe controversy after reports surfaced that Volpe allegedly refused to play second base before Michael Kay walked back the story. Has the Yankees-Volpe relationship reached the point of no return?

The Yankees struck out at an alarming rate, but Evan argues that their problems go far beyond missed swings. Will Warren struggled against the bottom of Tampa Bay’s lineup, Cody Bellinger made another costly mistake, and the uncertainty surrounding Aaron Judge has left the offense without an obvious solution.Instead of trying to patch every weakness, Evan believes the Yankees should make one aggressive move and trade for Tarik Skubal. Pairing him with Gerrit Cole and Max Fried could give New York the dominant rotation it needs to survive a flawed American League and make a serious championship run.

Boomer said there had to be something else going on in the locker room for the Mets to get rid of Alonso, Nimmo and McNeil. The Yankees lost to the Rays and struck out 17 times again.

The Yankees striking out 17 times for the second straight game, The Mets, specifically their pitching situation, a disaster. What's even going on with baseball in this city anymore?

Chris McMonigle reacts to the New York Yankees' recent performance and the growing debate over the starting shortstop position. He critiques Aaron Boone's 'day-to-day' approach with Jose Caballero and Anthony Volpe, while also highlighting a dominant outing from the pitching staff. The discussion on The Carton Show explores the tension between team analytics and on-field results during a pivotal stretch of the season.01:00 - McMonigle Breaks Down Yankees Victory03:43 - Jose Caballero Shortstop Debate07:31 - Aaron Boone's Management Critique12:53 - Analyzing Anthony Volpe's Struggles17:31 - Previewing Upcoming Sports News

Team USA failed to rise to the moment against Belgium, leaving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber frustrated by the lack of aggression, defensive mistakes, and inability to match the intensity of a superior opponent. They also question whether American fans truly feel the same emotional investment in international soccer that they do with their favorite local teams.The conversation then shifts to renewed optimism around the Yankees after a crucial win over Tampa Bay. Cam Schlittler looked like an emerging ace, Jose Caballero strengthened his case to become the everyday shortstop, and the Rays lineup gave Evan even more confidence that the American League East remains within reach.

Former soccer player Jimmy Conrad from CBS joins us to talk about the U.S. getting eliminated from the World Cup in their loss to Belgium.

It wasn't the outcome we wanted for Team USA but it is what it is. We also talked about Juan Soto who continues to be the brightest spot on the Mets roster.

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' recent series loss to the Minnesota Twins and the team's overall lack of focus on The Carton Show. He argues that the roster issues fall on Brian Cashman rather than Aaron Boone and highlights the necessity of a division title to ensure a deep postseason run.01:00 - Yankees Struggle Against Twins06:39 - Crucial Rays Series Preview09:10 - Evaluating Boone and Cashman15:29 - Shortstop Depth Chart Debate20:06 - Cam Schlittler's Key Start

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the controversy surrounding FIFA’s decision to suspend Flo Balogun’s red card ban, clearing him to play for Team USA against Belgium. The debate centers on whether this was a rare case of justice being served, or a strange example of political influence entering the sports world. The conversation dives into the VAR process, why the original red card was so disputed, and how American fans may view due process differently than the global soccer community.

Boomer went to the Norway match and had a great time of it. We also talked about Donald Trump calling President of FIFA and having him reverse a US players red card suspension.

On this episode of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Aaron Boone deserves to be fired or if fans are overreacting to one brutal week of baseball. They discuss the Yankees' offensive collapse, defensive mistakes, injuries piling up, and why Boone has historically been able to pull the team out of these midseason swoons.

Yankees temperature check after a historically ugly stretch of baseball. With the team sliding and frustration building, the focus turns to Aaron Boone, the decisions that helped cost them another game, and whether Yankee fans are justified in talking seriously about a managerial change.Evan and Shaun break down the bunt call, the failure to use Paul Goldschmidt, the bullpen issues with Camilo Doval, and Brian Cashman’s role in keeping the wrong arms around. They also call out Cody Bellinger and Ben Rice for struggling without Aaron Judge, making it clear that the Yankees’ problems go far beyond one bad night.

With start the show with USA's win over Bosnia-Herzegovina and a controversial red card penalty given to the US.

On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Mets owner's podcast appearance where he confirmed there was tension between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto during the 2025 season. Cohen also made it clear that David Stearns will remain the Mets' President of Baseball Operations through his full five-year plan, even as the team spirals.

The New York Yankees have officially entered a full-blown June swoon after dropping their 7th straight game, and Chris McMonigle has had enough. From blown opportunities to Aaron Boone's decisions, Cody Bellinger's struggles, and another frustrating extra-inning loss, Craig Carton and Big Mac break down everything that's gone wrong in the Bronx.Plus, Mitchell Robinson leaves the Knicks to sign with the Boston Celtics, ending his championship run in New York. Was letting Mitch walk the right move? Can Leon Rose replace his rebounding and defense, or will Knicks fans regret this decision?

The Yankees lineup, concern over Jazz Chisholm returning so quickly, and a strange food poisoning situation involving Spencer Jones and Ryan McMahon. With the Yankees trying to stop the bleeding, Shaun questions whether the team is being cautious enough and what this latest mess could mean as they look to get back on track.The bigger fireworks come from Steve Cohen’s comments about David Stearns, Juan Soto, and Francisco Lindor. Shaun breaks down why Cohen’s words raise real questions about the Mets’ front office, last year’s clubhouse issues, and whether the team’s offseason moves were more about keeping its biggest stars comfortable than actually building the best roster.

Shaun Morash reacts in real time as Mitchell Robinson leaves the Knicks for the Boston Celtics, turning a beloved championship piece into a rival overnight. The move is painful for Knicks fans, especially because Robinson was a homegrown favorite who stuck around through the franchise’s lowest points before helping deliver a title.The conversation also digs into whether the Knicks can survive without Robinson, why his free throw struggles and injury history made his future complicated, and how Boston adds another emotional layer to the loss. Shaun also continues the Yankees debate with callers questioning Brian Cashman, the lineup’s lack of contact, and whether the front office has the urgency to fix a struggling roster at the deadline.

The Yankees are suddenly spiraling, and Shaun Morash is no longer trying to talk himself out of panic. After a historically bad offensive stretch, fresh injury concerns, and a brutal showing against Detroit, the frustration around this team has reached a new level.Shaun digs into the warning signs that make this feel bigger than a typical slump, from Cam Schlittler looking human to the uncertainty around Aaron Judge’s return. With the trade deadline approaching, he questions whether the Yankees can afford to wait for injured stars or if the front office needs to act before the season slips away.

We started the morning with a little World Cup excitement, LeBron leaving the Lakers news, and talked about the future of Mitchell Robinson.

As Craig and Big Mac rip into the New York Mets 2026 season, Darryl Strawberry calls in to defend the entire team and organization.

Are the Yankees officially in a June swoon? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether New York's five-game skid is just a rough stretch or the beginning of something much worse. With Aaron Judge still out, Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger struggling, and the offense completely disappearing, Craig says the Yankees "stink right now" while Big Mac isn't ready to panic just yet.

Shaun and Tiki react to Jazz Chisholm’s scary collision and turn it into a bigger conversation about trust, urgency, and the Yankees’ handling of injuries. What starts as a debate over dugout habits and a lollipop scare quickly becomes a serious question about whether the team should play it safe with one of its most important players.The conversation expands into Aaron Boone’s future, Brian Cashman’s deadline pressure, and whether the Yankees are built well enough to dominate a weak American League. Shaun and Tiki also dig into the roster holes, Ben Rice’s recent slump, the need for real additions, and why this Yankees season may ultimately be judged by whether they finally get back to the World Series.

The Yankees are stumbling through another June swoon, and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber are asking whether this is just a rough patch or a sign of a much bigger problem. With the offense disappearing, mistakes piling up, and Tampa Bay moving back in front, the pressure around the Yankees is starting to feel impossible to ignore.Shaun and Tiki dig into the injuries, fatigue, poor fundamentals, and leadership questions surrounding Aaron Boone as the same concerns keep resurfacing year after year. The conversation turns to whether Boone’s messaging is enough, why Giancarlo Stanton’s presence feels missed, and what another season without a championship could mean for the Yankees manager.

The question is, what about Mitchell Robinson?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Yankees getting swept by the Red Sox, falling out of first place, and the growing concerns surrounding their postseason hopes. But according to Craig, the Mets somehow managed to have an even WORSE weekend.From Steve Cohen's controversial comments and fan backlash to the firing of Carlos Mendoza, Juan Soto clubhouse drama, and why Craig believes Cohen should take advice from James Dolan, nothing is off limits in this fiery opening segment of The Carton Show.

Shaun and Tiki talk about the Yankees getting swept against the Red Sox and why Boone sounded so positive at the end of the game.

Sad news that Chris Johnson, a former running back for the Tennessee Titans, contracts ALS at the age of 39.

We talk some Mets disaster including when Steve Gelbs was talking seriously to Gary, Keith & Ron in the pre-game about the Mendoza firing, Mr. Met was dancing right behind him.

Cookie and Pete Hoffman break down the New York Knicks re-signing Jose Alvarado and the financial logistics of keeping Mitchell Robinson on the roster. They examine the fallout from the New York Mets firing Carlos Mendoza and brainstorm ways to keep fans engaged at Citi Field on WFAN. The duo also reacts to a caller's huge gambling win and critiques staff attendance during major news days.01:54 - Alvarado Re-Signs With Knicks07:53 - Historic Knicks Betting Win13:18 - Mendoza Firing and Mets Woes19:45 - Anthony Gallo’s Pink Eye22:51 - Advice For Chris McMonigle

Former Mets manager Terry Collins joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to react to Carlos Mendoza's firing and doesn't hold back. Collins explains why managers have to demand accountability, why today's Mets need to get back to baseball fundamentals, and why he still believes this team has enough talent to turn things around.

Carlos Mendoza is OUT as Mets manager, but was he really the problem? Todd Zeile joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to deliver a powerful defense of Mendoza, saying he was sent into battle with "no weapons" and that the front office deserves far more blame. Zeile also questions David Stearns' roster construction, discusses Steve Cohen's role in the firing, and reveals what really happens inside a clubhouse after a manager gets fired.

Friend of the Carton Show comedian Paul Virzi joins Craig to catch up on life including how the Knicks changed the way he viewed the world and how he views the Mets firing of Carlos Mendoza through a Yankees fans lens.

Carton explains why Steve Cohen actually did Mendoza a favor, shifts the blame squarely onto David Stearns, questions the future of the Mets organization, and breaks down what happens next with Andy Green taking over as interim manager.

Evan, Tiki, and Shaun react to the news of Carlos Mendoza's firing and discuss the Mets' mess.