PODCAST · true crime
You Can’t Make This BS Up!
by Joel
Our podcast delves into a variety of true crime cases, including murder mysteries, high-profile investigations, unsolved crimes, courtroom dramas, serial killers, kidnappings, missing persons, cold cases, and more. We aim to provide a captivating collection of stories that will keep you engaged and eager for the next episode. Get bonus content on Patreon Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Episodes
-
THE FIRE ON EAST SEMINOLE: The Tulsa Triple Homicide (64)
Three people. One house. One devastating fire. And a seven-year-old girl caught in the middle of a horrifying Tulsa murder investigation. On October 14, 2018, firefighters responding to a house fire in Tulsa, Oklahoma, discovered the bodies of 27-year-old Ramon Marquis Brown, 27-year-old Hosea...
-
JEREMY TREMAINE WILLIAMS & KAMARIE HOLLAND FROM THE BEGINNING TO THE EXECUTION (63)
Five-year-old Kamarie Holland should have had her entire life ahead of her. Instead, her name became connected to one of the most disturbing child-murder cases in Alabama and Georgia. In this deeply researched episode of You Can’t Make This Bs Up!, we go beyond the headlines to reconstruct the...
-
Patrick Wharen: When Love Turns Deadly (62)
A marriage falls apart. A family is a caught in the middle. And one day in April 2008 changes everything. In this episode of You Can’t Make This BS Up!, we take a deep dive into the tragic case of Patrick Wharen, a Florida man whose family conflict ended in a shocking double homicide that left a...
-
Kelsey Turner; Beauty, Money, and Murder (61)
Former model Kelsey Turner appeared to be living a glamorous life, posing for magazines and building a social media following. Behind the scenes, however, prosecutors alleged she relied heavily on the financial support of 71-year-old California psychiatrist Dr. Thomas Burchard, who reportedly…
more -
Pastor Brodes Perry: Broken Promises (60)
Brodes C. Perry (age 36 at death) was a third-generation preacher and executive pastor at Mississippi Boulevard Christian Church in Memphis. On April 4, 2019, he and his wife Tabatha were shot in their Collierville apartment by Latoshia Daniels, with whom he had been involved in an extramarital...
-
The Shocking Murder of Danielle Marshall (59)
Uncover the harrowing true crime story of the Danielle Marshall murder in Powder Springs, Georgia—a chilling case that shocked a quiet Atlanta suburb. In this episode of “You Can’t Make This BS Up,” host Joel Davis delves into the brutal 2013 homicide of 23-year-old single mom Danielle Marshall,...
-
The Baton Rouge Serial Killer: Derrick Todd Lee’s Reign of Terror (58)
Buckle up for a chilling deep dive into one of Louisiana’s darkest chapters. Host Joel Davis uncovers the twisted life of Derrick Todd Lee, the smooth-talking predator who terrorized Baton Rouge and beyond from 1998-2003. Posing as a charming everyman, he stalked, raped, and brutally murdered at...
-
The Shallow Grave Jealousy Trap (57)
What happens when a single mom of four tries to move on from a toxic ex… and he decides she can’t? In January 2024, 32-year-old Kayla Laray Atwood drops her kids off at daycare and school in Pensacola, Florida—like any normal day. She never comes back. Her phone goes dark. Her family panics.…
more -
Betrayed in the Shadows: The Brutal Murder of Alishah Pointer (56)
Dive into the heart-wrenching true crime story of Alishah Pointer, a vibrant young woman whose life was stolen on the eve of her 22nd birthday in East Cleveland, Ohio. Uncover the twisted web of revenge, betrayal by a trusted friend, and unimaginable torture that led to her tragic end. Join host...
-
A Rising Star Lost: The Tragic Story of Cleveland Rapper Ahlotta (55)
In this emotional episode, we delve into the life and tragic death of Breneisha Lightfoot, the talented Cleveland rapper known as Ahlotta. A resilient young woman dedicated to her music, community, and saving lives from gun violence, Breneisha's bright future was cut short on the eve of her 26th...
-
Onlyfans and her new man took her life. (54)
Delve into the chilling North Texas murder-suicide that exposed how one OnlyFans page can shatter lives. Shady Oaks Shadows uncovers Stephanie Ingram’s fierce rise as a mom-turned-creator, her jealous partner Anthony Thornton’s spiral, and the silence after gunfire—forty-five minutes of family...
-
Recorded Rage: The Murder of Rahim Grant by Ciera Harp (53)
Summary This episode delves into the tragic story of Raheem Grant, a talented rapper known as Red Beazzy, who was murdered by his ex-girlfriend Sierra Harp. The narrative explores the complexities of their relationship, the events leading up to the murder, and the subsequent investigation and...
-
Nancy "Nannie" Doss: The Grandmother that will kill by making you ill PT 2 (52)
Summary This podcast episode delves into the chilling story of Nancy Doss, also known as the Giggling Granny, who allegedly killed at least 11 people, including her husbands and family members. The host, Joel, narrates her life, marriages, and the dark events that led to her becoming a notorious...
-
Nancy "Nannie" Doss: The Grandmother that will kill by making you ill PT 1 (51)
Takeaways Joel expresses gratitude for listener support and engagement. Nancy Doss, known as Nanny, had a troubled childhood with an abusive father. Nanny's early life was marked by hardship and limited education. She married Charlie Braggs at a young age, escaping her father's control. Nanny's...
-
Murder, Love, and Betrayal: The Alicia "Shayne" Mills Lovera Story (50)
Summary In this episode, Joel discusses the tragic story of Alicia Shane Mills-Lavera and her lover Brett Ray, who conspired to murder her husband, Kelly Lavera. The conversation covers the background of the individuals involved, the investigation that followed Kelly's suspicious death, and the...
-
Euri Jenkins aka Mr. Too Good To Be True pt 3 (49)
Summary In this episode, Joel shares personal updates and dives into the tragic case of Yuri Jenkins, who orchestrated the murder of his wife, Makeeva. The conversation explores the complexities of the trial, the motivations behind the crime, and the eventual sentencing of Jenkins and his...
-
Euri Jenkins aka Mr. Too Good To Be True pt 2 (48)
Summary In this episode, Joel reflects on the growth of his podcast and expresses gratitude to his listeners. He delves into the tragic case of Makaiva Jenkins, a young mother who was murdered in her home. The investigation reveals a complex web of suspects and motives, raising questions about…
more -
Euri Jenkins aka Mr. Too good to be true PT 1 (47)
Summary This conversation delves into the tragic story of Makava Jenkins, a vibrant entrepreneur and mother whose life was cut short by a violent crime. The host reflects on her background, the community of Belle Glade, and the circumstances surrounding her murder. The discussion highlights the...
-
The Murder Case of Sasha Skare (46)
Summary In this episode, Joel discusses the tragic case of Martell DeRoyan, a rising music producer and cousin of Beyoncé, who was murdered by Sasha Scared, a woman with a troubled past. The conversation explores Martell's life, his career in the music industry, and the complexities of his...
-
Robert "Terry" Ellison - Evil Is Inside of Me (45)
Summary The episode delves into the life of Terry Ellis, exploring his troubled past, family dynamics, and the impact of his actions on those around him. It covers his early behavior, family background, violent tendencies, military and legal troubles, and the eventual consequences of his actions....
-
The House Party Killer – The Tyler Hadley Case (44)
In July 2011, 17-year-old Tyler Hadley of Port St. Lucie, Florida, did the unthinkable. After weeks of planning, he brutally murdered his parents, Blake and Mary-Jo Hadley, in their own home. Hours later, he threw a wild house party with dozens of classmates—while his parents’ bodies lay hidden…
more -
Bumpy Johnson: Harlem's Notorious Gangster (43)
Summary In this episode, Joel shares personal updates and transitions into the captivating story of Bumpy Johnson, a notorious gangster from Harlem. The conversation explores Johnson's early life, rise to power, and the challenges he faced in the criminal underworld. Joel reflects on Johnson's...
-
A Friendship Turned Deadly: The Story of Jimella and Tiffany (42)
Takeaways The podcast introduces a tragic story of betrayal and murder. Jamila and Tiffany were lifelong friends with a complicated relationship. Tiffany's jealousy led to a horrific crime against her best friend. The story highlights the impact of mental health and unresolved issues. Tiffany's...
-
From Fame to Infamy: Jennifer Mee's Journey (41)
Takeaways Jennifer Mee's story highlights the impact of childhood trauma. Fame can have unexpected consequences on mental health. The influence of relationships can lead to poor decision-making. Jennifer's hiccups brought her fame but also led to her downfall. The importance of addressing mental...
-
The Dark Side of Love: The Laura Ackerson Case (40)
Takeaways Joel shares his personal struggles with his AC and financial issues. The story revolves around Laura Ackerman and her tumultuous relationships. Grant Hayes is depicted as an abusive partner with a victim mentality. Laura's journey highlights the challenges of escaping an abusive...
-
Unraveling the Tragic Case of Jonelle Melton (39)
Summary In this episode, Joel discusses the tragic case of Janelle Melton, a dedicated teacher who was murdered in her home. The conversation covers the investigation, the suspects involved, and the eventual resolution of the case. Joel reflects on the impact of the crime, the challenges faced by...
-
Maurice Fayne: From Reality Star to Federal Prison (38)
Keywords PPP loans, Maurice Fane, Love and Hip Hop, scamming, federal prison, fraud, Black Friday, podcast, financial crime, reality TV Summary In this episode, Joel Davis discusses the story of Maurice Fane, a reality TV star who became embroiled in a major PPP loan fraud scheme. The…
more -
Unmasking a Con Artist: The Sabrina Taylor (37)
Summary This podcast episode delves into the case of Sabrina Taylor, a con artist who deceived her friends and community by fabricating a story about suffering from multiple sclerosis. Through emotional manipulation and a web of lies, she exploited the generosity of others, leading to significant...
-
Love, Lust, and Betrayal: Marjorie Orbin (36)
Summary This episode delves into the chilling true crime story of Jay and Marjorie Orban, exploring themes of love, betrayal, and murder. It recounts Jay's disappearance, the discovery of his remains, and Marjorie's subsequent trial and conviction for his murder. The narrative highlights…
more -
Samuel Little the Most Prolific Serial Killer in USA History (35)
SummaryThis episode delves into the life and crimes of Samuel Little, the most prolific serial killer in U.S. history. From his troubled childhood to his manipulative tactics and eventual capture, the conversation explores the psychological aspects of his criminal behavior and the societal…
more -
The Chilling Case of Niels Högel (34)
Summary In this episode, Joel discusses the chilling case of Niels Högel, a nurse who became one of the most prolific serial killers in modern medical history. The conversation explores Högel's background, his methods of killing patients under his care, and the systemic failures within the...
-
Unmasking William Jennings Choice (33)
Summary In this episode, Joel Davis delves into the chilling story of William Jennings Choice, a serial killer who led a double life as a family man while committing heinous crimes against vulnerable women in California. The conversation explores the psychological background of Choice, his…
more -
Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins: The Meanest Man in the US PT 5 (31)
Summary In this episode, Joel Davis explores the life and crimes of Pee Wee Gaskins, a notorious serial killer known as 'The Meanest Man in America.' The conversation delves into Gaskins' early life, his manipulative nature, and the chilling details of his murders, including the infamous case of...
-
Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins: The Meanest Man in the US PT 4
Summary In this episode, host Joel Davis delves into the life and crimes of Pee Wee Gaskins, one of America's most notorious serial killers. The conversation begins with an introduction and an overview of the episode, followed by housekeeping notes and audience engagement strategies. The…
more -
The Rise and Fall of Sidney Dorsey
Summary This episode explores the rise and fall of Sidney Dorsey, a former police officer who became the first black sheriff of DeKalb County, Georgia. Dorsey's story is marked by his initial success in law enforcement, his involvement in the Atlanta child murders investigation, and his eventual...
-
Betrayal in Beaufort: The George Young Case
Summary This conversation delves into the tragic murder of George Young, exploring themes of betrayal, community support, and the complexities of human relationships. It highlights the investigation, trial, and the aftermath of the crime, revealing the emotional impact on the community and the...
-
Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins: The Meanest Man in the US PT 3
Summary This podcast episode delves into the chilling life and crimes of Pee Wee Gaskins, a notorious serial killer from South Carolina. The host, Joel, shares personal reflections and insights into Gaskins' brutal actions, his victims, and the psychological aspects of his criminal behavior. The...
-
Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins: The Meanest Man in the US PT 2
Summary This episode delves into the life of Henry 'Pee Wee' Gaskins, a notorious serial killer known for his violent crimes and chaotic life. The conversation explores his early life, criminal beginnings, relationships, time in prison, and the infamous coastal killings he claimed responsibility...
-
Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins: The Meanest Man in the US PT 2 (Trailer)
The second part of Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins. We will talk about his prison escape and his destructive path to become the most dangerous serial killer on the planet! Tune in 6/11/2025.
-
Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins: The Meanest Man in the US PT 1
Summary In this episode, Joel celebrates the milestone of 25 episodes of his true crime podcast, discussing the diverse aspects of crime he covers. He introduces the infamous Donald Henry Pee Wee Gaskins, detailing his early life, childhood trauma, and the development of his criminal behavior.…
more -
Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins (Trailer)
Please stay tuned for the multiple part series of the life of Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins.
-
Betrayal in the Church: The Randy Stone Case PT 2
Summary This podcast episode delves into the complex and tragic case of Brandi Stone, exploring the intertwining relationships, the affair with Pastor David Love, and the subsequent murder investigation. The host discusses the dynamics of the investigation, the evidence collected, and the trial's...
-
Betrayal in the Church: The Randy Stone Case PT 1
Summary In this episode, host Joel Davis delves into the tragic story of Randy and Teresa Stone, exploring themes of betrayal, friendship, and the complexities of human relationships. The narrative unfolds with Randy's mysterious death, the investigation led by Detective Keith Rosewood, and the...
-
Love, Betrayal, and Murder: Maliek Kearney Case
Summary In this episode, Joel delves into the tragic case of Carla Ramirez, who was murdered by her husband Malik Kearney. The conversation explores the dynamics of their relationship, the events leading up to the murder, and the subsequent investigation that revealed Malik's infidelity and…
more -
Maliek Kearney Murder Case Trailer!
Trailer for Maliek Kearney Murder Case.
-
The Tragic Case of Brianna Williams
Summary The conversation delves into the tragic case of Brianna Williams and her daughter Taylor Rose Williams, exploring the events leading to Taylor's disappearance, the police investigation, and the subsequent trial. It highlights the inconsistencies in Brianna's story, the evidence found, and...
-
The Erin Caffey Case: A Tragic Tale of Teenage Rebellion and Familial Betrayal
On March 1, 2008, the quiet town of Alba, Texas, was shaken by a horrifying crime. Erin Caffey, a 16-year-old girl, orchestrated the brutal murder of her family in response to her parents' disapproval of her relationship with 18-year-old Charlie Wilkinson.
-
The Iceman: A Deep Dive into Richard Kuklinski PT 2
Summary This episode delves into the life of Richard Kuklinski, a notorious contract killer known as 'The Iceman.' It explores his dual existence as a family man and a ruthless murderer, detailing his methods, partnerships, and the eventual unraveling of his criminal empire. The narrative...
-
The Iceman: A Deep Dive into Richard Kuklinski PT 1
Summary This episode delves into the dark history of organized crime, focusing on Richard Kuklinski, known as the Iceman, a notorious contract killer. The conversation explores his dual life as a family man and a ruthless assassin, his traumatic childhood, and the events that shaped him into one…
more -
The Tragic Tale of Grant Amato
Summary The conversation delves into the tragic story of Grant Amato, who struggled with addiction and mental health issues, leading to the devastating murder of his family. It explores the dynamics of his family relationships, the impact of his addiction to a cam girl, and the subsequent events...
We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.
No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.
No topics indexed yet for this podcast.
Loading reviews...
ABOUT THIS SHOW
Our podcast delves into a variety of true crime cases, including murder mysteries, high-profile investigations, unsolved crimes, courtroom dramas, serial killers, kidnappings, missing persons, cold cases, and more. We aim to provide a captivating collection of stories that will keep you engaged and eager for the next episode. Get bonus content on Patreon
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
HOSTED BY
Joel
CATEGORIES
Loading similar podcasts...
Frequently Asked Questions
How many episodes does You Can’t Make This BS Up! have?
You Can’t Make This BS Up! currently has 65 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.
What is You Can’t Make This BS Up! about?
Our podcast delves into a variety of true crime cases, including murder mysteries, high-profile investigations, unsolved crimes, courtroom dramas, serial killers, kidnappings, missing persons, cold cases, and more. We aim to provide a captivating collection of stories that will keep you engaged and...
How often does You Can’t Make This BS Up! release new episodes?
You Can’t Make This BS Up! has 65 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.
Where can I listen to You Can’t Make This BS Up!?
You can listen to You Can’t Make This BS Up! on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.
Who hosts You Can’t Make This BS Up!?
You Can’t Make This BS Up! is created and hosted by Joel.
URL copied to clipboard!