All episodes
The Great Bicycle Panic with Gabe Henry
The Damsel in Distress Problem with Daniel Peña
Bloody Mary (rewind)
MYSTERY BLOOD
Pennywise and the IT Girls (1990) with This Ends at Prom
The Cat in the Hat Serial Killer Panic with Guide to the Unknown
Halloween Newspapers.com Dive pt. 2 with Sarah Marshall
Halloween Newspapers.com Dive pt. 1 with Sarah Marshall
Let's Talk About Sex (Ed) with Margaret Grace Myers
Baby Got Backstory with Heather Radke
Ye Olde Cleanse Diet with Zoë Rom of 'Your Diet Sucks'
Solar Storms and the Carrington Event with Ben Bradford of 'Are We Doomed?'
KU KLUX SCAM pt. 2
KU KLUX SCAM pt. 1
Rednecks (rewind)
The Aggressive Christianity Missionary Training Corps with Harrison Hill
Hobby Lobby: Crafting a Christian Nation with Michael Blanding
90s Angel Craze with Christine Laskowski
FIREWORKS pt. 2 with Sarah Marshall
FIREWORKS pt. 1 with Sarah Marshall
Playing Indian with Rebecca Nagle
In Defense of Queer Villains with BJ Colangelo
DATING APPS
THE GAY AGENDA (Pride Rewind)
Our 300th Episode with Sarah Marshall
The Voyager Golden Record with Riley Swedelius-Smith and Miranda Zickler
The Disturbing World of Cute Cat AI with Panic World
Introducing: No Such Thing
THE BENNINGTON TRIANGLE pt. 2 with Sarah Marshall
THE BENNINGTON TRIANGLE pt. 1 with Sarah Marshall
Introducing: History Daily
Blowing Up the Georgia Guidestones with Tyler McBrien
Black Magic with Gruff Webb
Hysteria Home Companion: The Berners Street Hoax
DINOSAURS pt. 2
DINOSAURS pt. 1
The Spooky Side of Pokémon with Guide to the Unknown
The Corporate Takeover of Caring with Dr. Mara Einstein
BUGS!!!!!! with Akilah Hughes
Talking to the Future: Nuclear Semiotics (rerun)
JINGLES pt. 2 with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
Introducing Mind Games
JINGLES pt. 1 with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
A Cult by Any Other Name with Joseph Laycock
The Art of (Psychological) War with Annalee Newitz
Celebrity Clone Conspiracies with 'No Such Thing' Podcast
JESUS TOAST
Party (and Panic) Like It's 1999 with Ross Benes
MALL SANTAS pt. 2 with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
MALL SANTAS pt. 1 with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
Three or More Is a Riot with Jelani Cobb
The Rocky Horror Picture Show with 'This Ends At Prom'
Listen Now: American Scandal | The West Memphis Three
THE MACY'S THANKSGIVING DAY PARADE (rewind)
The Devil We Know with Sarah Marshall
Disneyland’s Disastrous Opening Day with Riley Swedelius-Smith and Miranda Zickler
Bot Farms and the Troll Toll with Perry Carpenter
BLOODY MARY
SPONTANEOUS HUMAN COMBUSTION with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
12 Ft Skeleton (rewind)
Horror Movie Curses with 'What Went Wrong' Podcast
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark with Liz "Cosbrarian" Gotauco
The Kennedy Curse with George Civeris
HOUDINI'S AFTERLIFE with Sarah Marshall and Tim Harford
#Elsagate (rewind)
Introducing: Conspiracy Theories, Cults, and Crimes
The Disturbing World of Mobile Game Ads with 'Panic World' Podcast
Dear Chelsey and Ask Sarah Marshall
DEAR ABBY AND ANN LANDERS
Titanic in Real Time with Riley Swedelius-Smith
Polybius: The Arcade Conspiracy
Not Just a Phase: Goths Through History with Christine Laskowski
The Imaginary Gods of ChatGPT with Journalist Miles Klee
The FBI's White Christian Nation with Lerone A. Martin
Listen Now: American Scandal
STARING AT THE SUN ON LSD with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
THE CALL IS COMING FROM INSIDE THE HOUSE with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
THE HIPPIE BABYSITTER BABY ROAST
Context Clues: Don't Tell Mom the Babysitter's High
GENDER REVEAL PARTIES: Pride Rewind
The Last Prison Rodeo with Journalist Adam Mahoney
Mayhem! at the Minecraft Movie with BJ Colangelo
Lost Boy Larry with Producer Miranda Zickler
BALLOON BOY
New Context: Gang Accusations and Initiations
HOAX DIARY SPECTACULAR with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
THE RUNAWAY NUN HOAX pt. 2 with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
THE RUNAWAY NUN HOAX pt. 1 with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'
Luxury Doomsday with 'This is Propaganda'
HOAX SPECTACULAR! with You're Wrong About
Burlesque This Mess with Comic Stripper Woody Shticks
THONGS
Context Clues: Let Me See That Thong
Erasing History with Philosopher Jason Stanley
David Lynch's Mulholland Drive with 'You Are Good' Podcast
Invasion of the Drones with Podcaster Gabe Lenners
THE JERSEY DEVIL
Context Clues: The Devil Went Down to Jersey
You Just Lost The Game with 'Spirits' Podcast
CHICKEN SOUP FOR THE SOUL pt. 2 with Sarah Marshall of 'You're Wrong About'