All episodes

E505 Board Beliebers and Polar Express Pranks (featuring Guest Host Morgan from Creeps & Crimes)

Listener Stories: Vol. 121 (featuring Guest Host Amy Bruni)

E504 Hash-Slinging Specters and Villainous Lemons

E503 Psychic String Dixie Cups and a Christineception

E502 Haunted Jellyfish and a Brothel Ego Death

E501 A Trapdoor Balloon Saloon and Inside Outside Murders

Listener Stories: Vol. 120

E500 Immortal Hallway Portals and Incriminating Insects

E499 Symbiotic Snack Partners and Peppermint Pattie Problems (feat. Guest Host Bethany Watson)

E498 Glossy Grinch Lips and Ghost Escape Rooms

E497 An Everlasting Lemon Haunting and a Levitating Glitter Pinecone Phone

Listener Stories: Vol. 119 (featuring Guest Host Xandy Schiefer)

E496 Honeymoon Hamburgers and Whale Princes

E495 Triple Trampoline Entendres and Juniper Hauntings

E494 The Butt Curtain Speakeasy and the Batman Hatman

E493 Wiffle Ball Whimsy and Tastebud Tickling Treats (featuring Guest Host Bethany Watson)

E492 Peanut Butter Relationships and Bagel Traumas

Listener Stories: Vol. 118 featuring. Amy Bruni

E491 Medical Melodrama and a Shark Shanctuary

BONUS EPISODE: Homicide 360 - 'Where the Truth Lies (Nicole VanderHeyden)'

E490 Reverse Victorian Child Trauma and Skeleton Touching Collaborations

E489 Cartwheel Trauma and an Oenophile Ghost

Listener Stories: Vol. 117 featuring. For Better And Worse

E488 The Esophagus Woes and a Hatchet Granny

E487 A Non-Squatting Sasquatch and Skreeonk Facts (featuring Guest Host Steven Ray Morris)

E486 Bisexual Muscle Tanks and a Mother Goose Ghost

Listener Stories: Vol. 116

E485 A Biblically Accurate Batman and a Birthday Bark Mitzvah

E484 A Ghost Ensemble and a Witch Magnate

E483 Caterpillar Surprises and Tamagotchi Funerals

E482 A Haunted Coffee and a Propaganda Theatre - featuring That's Pretty Dark

E481 Pizza Payments and Original Coffee Thoughts

Listener Stories: Vol. 115 featuring. Nichole Bigley

E480 Clown Bags and Accidental Witchcraft

E479 Tonsil Hockey Olympics and Flying Pig Yoga

E478 Yesterday's Mail and Salad Days

E477 Rat Directions and Pantsless Ghost Hunts

Listener Stories: Vol. 114

E476 Country Ghost Songs and Produce Shirt Mandela Effects

E475 Adventures in Lunacy and Birthday Butterfly Effects

E474 Amelia Bedelia Math and Iced Tea Pranks

E473 Phantom Punchlines and a Top Hat Tater

E472 Milkshake Tears and a Lego Hair Wig

Listener Stories: Vol. 113

E471 Crop Top Capes and a Beatles Ghost

E470 Leatha Weatha and Dirty Santa Texts

E469 Nostalgic Lip Landlines and Dancing Ghosts

Listener Stories: Vol. 112 featuring. Aliza Kelly

E468 MySpace Siren Calls and Sit Down Comedians

E467 Croissant Crop Circles and Thumb Drive Rick Rolls

E466 Haunted Toilets and Frozen Jail

E465 Non-Parallel Traumas and Neighborhood App Ghosts

Listener Stories: Vol. 111

E464 Cats at Holidays Parties and Movie Magic Milkshakes

E463 The Santa Dilemma and Our Haunted One-Man Show

E462 Dream Mall Rats and Whistleblowing Dogs

E461 Houdini Hat Men and Intertwined Ghost Toes

Listener Stories: Vol. 110 featuring. Sarah Marshall

E460 Haunting Snap Chats and Screening Calls from Space

E459 Radioactive Acorns and Chicken Tricks

E458 Rat Slaps and Sklorching Demons

E457 Segway Fun Facts and Inflatable Birthday Tiaras

E456 Town Hall Friends and Costume Condom-gate

Listener Stories: Vol. 109 with Roz Hernandez

BONUS EPISODE: The History of Queer-Coded Villains with Yvette Gentile and Rasha Pecoraro

E455 Halloween Boy Math and Jerry Springer Ghosts

E454 Graveyard Kids and Barney Scandals

E453 Corporate Birthday Winks and Designated Pony Drivers

E452 Sleep Paralysis Fashion and Pick Me Ghosts

Listener Stories: Vol. 108 (ft. Amanda from Live, Laugh, Larceny)

E451 Labubu Covens and Immortal Butt Portals

E450 Estate Sale Unboxings and Open-Eyed Naps

E449 Emotionally Damaged Water Bottles and Ghost Marriage Fights - featuring Creeps and Crimes

E448 Swimfluencer Celebrations and Microphone Zits

Listener Stories: Vol. 107

E447 Home Appliance Hauntings and Narcissists in White

E446 Erratic Earthquake Cocktails and Ghostly Gay Icons

Introducing: CONSPIRACY THEORIES, CULTS, AND CRIMES

E445 Fish Beneficiaries and Croissant Redemption Societies

E444 A Long Island Iced Tea Bit and a Kaleidoscope of Jewelry

E443 A Chicken Run Playlist and a License to Clown - featuring Ladies & Tangents

Listener Stories: Vol. 106

E442 Interdimensional Naps and Synchronicity Seafood Dinners

E441 Canada’s Sweetheart and Wingman of the Century

E440 WeWorking with Ghosts and Devil’s Lettuce Friend Tattoos

E439 Office Ghosts and Haunted Desk Drinks

Listener Stories: Vol. 105

E438 The Mighty S.S. Leona and an Unexpected Pasta Experience

E437 A Crisis Mode Twisted Tea and a Clumsy Guardian Angel

E436 Mayoral Messages and a Lemonade Haunting

E435 The Schnapps Age and the Little Chicken Man

Listener Stories: Vol. 104

E434 A Haunted Pamphlet Collection and the Invention of Forensic Husbandry

E433 Tee Shirt Abs and Moving Fonts

E432 A Techno Western Hotel and a Moonlit Bobcat Crime

E431 Mr. Glitter Shoes and a Mystery Vortex

E430 Opening Night Haunts and Scamaroonies - Live Show at The Brooklyn Bell House, Brooklyn, NY

Listener Stories: Vol. 103

E429 A Personal Pug Nightmare and a Driving School Lore

E428 A Smuggled Cream Soda and a Vibin' Lady in White