All Episodes
Burning Butterflies — 99 episodes
The Finale
Free At Last! Free At Last! Melissa Is Free At Last!
Full Circle: Back To Where We First Started Our Story
Deconstruction and Confidence Are Fanned Into Flames
You Girls Morphs Into Jezebels: Let The Shit Talking Begin
Ding Dong, Froggy's Gone!
The Edgy Problem Children vs The Prim and Propper
Finding Our Voices: So This Is What Confidence Feels Like
The Tale of Two Visits: Miss America Under Orders
Daddy Issues & Near Death Trauma: Amanda Finally Quits
Come to the Table and Out Form Under the Umbrella of Authority
Amanda's Long Awaited Second Meeting With Barry
Miss America and the Four T's of Charlette's Women's Ministry
Thursday Nights: Melissa Has Enough
Men Up For Eldership: Tom Presents His Own Downfall
Hope 2020: Melissa's Women's Ministry Debut
Melissa Plans Her Escape
Seeing Red: The Infamous Color Levels
We're Growing on Purpose: Make Come As You Are Great Again
Chapter 7 Trailer
People Start Asking Questions: The Family Wasn't the Same
The Regathering: Barry Leads the Way
Froggy During Covid: Melissa Finds Herself Again
The Doctor and The Dead Mice
The Week That Seemed Like a Year
Burnout or Breakdown: Amanda's on the Edge
Ten People or Less: Where's Your Faith?
It's Just the Flu: God Will Protect Us
The Girls Were Gonna Bring Women into the Red Tent
Hear Y, Hear Ye: We Shall Now Have Elders!
Distraction Tactics: Don't Be Upset Sweetie
Performative Prayers: Tom Puts On a Show
The Most Awkward Banquet Ever
Chapter 6: There's No Cure For This
The Time The Girls Blew It All Up
Happy Holidays: Dishes, Worship and Lies
Meetings From Hell: Tom Has An Agenda
This Ain't Your Mama's Women's Ministry
40 Days of Community: Campaigning for Tom
This Is It: Tom's All In!
Georgia on My Mind: Amanda's Idea, Tom's Trip
Run HIS Race: Tom Leads a VBS
The Time Amanda Threw Miss America a Funeral
Tithes & Serving: Tom Needed Control
Emotional Manipulation: The Good Friday Facade
Love Is More Than Just a Word...It's a Control Tactic
Go: A Conference to Prove Charlette Wrong
Amanda Gets Played: But Also Gets a Ministry
Divided Loyalties: You Must Choose a Pastor
Chapter 5 Trailer
The Play Will Save Us All!
The Aftermath: Picking Up the Pieces After Time Out
When it All Falls Apart: Amanda Goes on Time Out
The 20th Anniversary: A Family Reunion
Tom The Crooked Real Estate Mogul
Trouble is a Brewing: We Should Have Been So Happy
The New Wing: The Sale, the Spin, and the Wish List
The Christmas Amanda Got All She Ever Wanted
The Time a Church Bought a Church
Double Standards: The Foundation of Come As You Are
Just Drink The Kool-Aid So We Can Teach Kids About Jesus
Melissa's Jubilee: It Was Never About Froggy
Hopeful Beginnings: Amanda's Affirmation
Melissa Living in Fear: Froggy Throws the Mask Away
Chapter 4: The Re-Tweet
Months of Insanity: The End of Chapter 3
Marriages on Fire: The Flames We Didn't Ask For
The Price of Ignorance: Melissa’s Hell, Amanda’s Detachment
Celebrate Sisterhood: The Retreat That Broke Us
Marriage Conference Madness: Moms Gone Wild
New Leaders, New Struggles, Same Narcissism
The Weight of Perfection: Amanda's Dark Path
The Phantom Conference: A Misleading Pilgrimage to Saddleback
From Controlling to Calling: The Rise of Pastor Young Gun
Fragile Bonds: Women Desperate for Connection
Sweet Summertime: 2015 is the Year of Inconsistency
Ruins to Redemption: Real Healing or Gaslighting?
Death Becomes Us: When The Call To Be Near The Brokenhearted Goes Unanswered
Discipleship Double Standard: Women's Ministry vs Beer Ministry
Celebrate Good Times: Melissa Accidentally Throws Tom a Party
Called to Lead: A Deep Dive Into The Pastors of Come As You Are
Chapter 3: Ruins to Redemption
Christmas Chaos: Traditions, Expectations & Baby Jesus
Forced & Fractured Friendships: Tales From the Fall Campaign
Marriage Nightmare: Melissa Breaks the Silence
Searching for Connection: The Reality of Mom's Group
Brandi Drinks the Kool-Aid: The Aftermath of VBS
Agency D3: Discover, Decide, Defend!
Brandi's Origin Story: Part 2
Brandi's Origin Story: Part 1
Reality Check
Unwrapping Tradition: Breaking Free from the Christmas Tea
The Flood of Generosity: Giving Beyond the Tithe
The Summer of Insanity: Exhaustion in the Name of Evangelism
Controlling Belonging: Inside Church Membership
From Pilgrims to Pulpits: Forging the Evangelical Identity in America
Chapter 2 Minisode
Worlds Collide: The End of Chapter One
So, the Nightmare Begins: Froggy's True Colors Are Revealed