All Episodes

TBB 85: Am I Missing Something? Fiance Cheated and I want a Hallpass.

293: The Tunguska Event & A Secret in South Philly

TBB 84: New "Friend" is Actually CREEPY & STALKING ME!!! AIMS???

292: Ellen Sadler & Maryann Measles

TBB 83: Tea Time w/ Tay

291: Milledgeville State Hospital & Charles "Chuck" Morgan

TBB 82: Taylar's Talk Show (Solo Ep | AMA)

290: Spartanburg Serial Killer

TBB 81: Am I Missing Something? Fiancé's Ex Upset Over Boundaries & Exclusion From Our Life

289: Creepy Accounts Vol. 62

TBB 80: Artemis II & Lies We Would Tell About the Moon

288: Nyleen Kay Marshall (Part 2) & The Cranmer Family Haunting

TBB 79: Am I Missing Something? Boyfriend Lying To Me About His Job??

287: Betty Ann Andreasson-Luca Abduction & Nyleen Kay Marshall

TBB 78: Harmless Things That Drive Us CRAZY!!

286: The Mad Gasser of Mattoon & Evelyn "Evie" Hartley

TBB 77: St. Patrick's Day Through the Years

285: ST. PATRICK'S DAY SPECIAL 6.0

TBB 76: Unanswered Questions - What's the Truth About Everything?

284: Creepy Accounts Vol. 61 w/ National Park After Dark's Cassie & Danielle

TBB 75: IS MY BESTIE USING ME FOR MONEY or AIMS? ft. Cassie & Danielle (National Park After Dark Podcast)

283: The Mysterious Death of Kathleen Peterson (The Staircase Murders)

TBB 74: HAPPY BIRTHDAY MORGY-POO

282: Carl Tänzler AKA Count Carl von Cosel & Sherri Malarik

TBB 73: Manager Calls Natural Hair "Unprofessional" - Am I Missing Something? (AIMS)

281: Creepy Accounts Vol. 60 (Spooky & Spiritual Love Stories)

TBB 72: Stupid Cupid & ParaPods Speed Dating w/ Morgan & Jeri

280: Franklin's Lost Expedition & Elizabeth Smart

TBB 71: Hospital Hauntings

279: The Dagg Demon & Aaron Davis

TBB 70: Ins/Outs of 2026 & Random Topic Talk Show

278: Creepy Accounts Vol. 59

TBB 69: Advice Column

277: Margaret Backhouse (Part 2) & The Dodleston Messages

TBB 68: Am I Missing Something? (AIMS)

276: Emanuel Swedenborg & Margaret Backhouse

TBB 67: Enter*TEA*ment Pop News

275: 37th Parallel & Matthew Wiser

TBB 66: 2026 Goals & 2025 Recap

274: Christmas Creepy Accounts Vol. 58

TBB 65: Confession Files (Naughty or Nice List)

273: Creepy Accounts Vol. 57 (Shared Death Experiences)

TBB 64: Am I Missing Something? Family Secrets

272: Louis Le Prince & Mermaids

TBB 63: Shared Death Experiences (SDE - Taylar's Spiral)

271: The Case of Patrice Endres

TBB 62: Am I Missing Something? Previous Employee is Harassing Me!!!

270: Creepy Accounts Vol. 56

TBB 61: Thanksgiving 2025 Survival Guide

269: Kristen Modafferi (pt 2) & Houska Castle

TBB 60: Advice Column

268: Pensacola Sea Monster & Kristen Modafferi

TBB 59: Am I Missing Something?

267: Peyton Randolph House & April Barber

TBB 58: Enter*TEA*ment (TAY IS BACK!!)

266. Halloween Creepy Accounts Vol 55 (w/ Em from ATWWD)

TBB 57: 20 Paranormal Questions (w/ Em from ATWWD)

265. The Horrors of Reddit (w/ Ciara from Ladies and Tangents)

TBB 56: This or That (Halloween edition)

264. Vanishing Village of Angikuni Lake & Bobby Dunbar

TBB 55: "That's Not Human!!!" (Morgan's Spiral)

263: Heidi Firkus Pt.2 & The Leap Castle

TBB 54: Am I Missing Something?

262: Mother God (Love Has Won Cult) & Heidi Firkus

TBB 53: WELCOME TO SEASON 6!!!!

261: Creepy Accounts Vol 54

TBB 52: SEASON 5 WRAPPED

260: Smurl Family Haunting & Dartmouth College Murders Part 2 (feat. And That's Why We Drink)

TBB 51: Tea Time Tuesday (ft. And That's Why We Drink)

259: Creepy Accounts Vol. 53

TBB 50: Local Urban Legends & Lore

258: Tallman Bunk Beds & George Smith Pt 2

TBB 49: Am I Missing Something??

257: Solway Spaceman & George Allen Smith IV

TBB 48: Grudge-Holding-Ghost Locked Me in a Portal & a Susan Story (Creepy Account)

TBB 47: Niche Bestie Sh*t

256: Dancing Plague of 1518 & Polly Klaas

TBB 46: Am I Missing Something???

255: Creepy Accounts Vol. 52

TBB 45: Enter*TEA*ment

254: Letta The Doll & The Fast Food Killer

253: The Carnival Cult & Sasha Samsudean

TBB 44: This or That?

252: Creepy Accounts Vol. 51

TBB 43: Jodi Huisentruit Docuseries Discussion

251: Peter Khoury & The DC Sniper

TBB 42: Valid Crashouts (Seth's Crashout)

250: Jodi Huisentruit (Pt2) & The Skirvin Hotel

TBB 41: Death of 74 y/o Man in Monroe County Custody - LESTER ISBILL (Tennessee)

249: SaltAir & Jodi Huisentruit

TBB 40: My Ex-Fiance Cheated On Me when Pregnant (AIMS/ATIA)

248: Creepy Accounts Vol. 50

TBB 39: Ask Taylar Anything!!

247: Adrienne Salinas (pt 2) & Mandy the Doll

TBB 38: Vacation Horror Stories

246: Adrienne Salinas & The Ackley House

TBB 37: The Bucky & Chip Special (Father's Day)

245: Agartha & Ted Conrad

TBB 36: Enter*TEA*ment News

244: Mount Kailash & Mandy Stavik

TBB 35 (PT 2): My Sister Won't Speak To or Look At Me, AIMS?

TBB 35: Husband Needs "ALONE TIME" w/ Girl BFF (AIMS/AITA)

243: CIA Project Sunstreak & The Grandpa Robbery Heist

TBB 34: Type A vs Type B

242: Behind the Lens of Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt (Part 2: The Truth of their Fall from Grace)

TBB 33: Advice Column

241: The Rise of Ruby Franke & Jodi Hildebrandt In Front of the Lens (Part 1)

TBB 32: Mother's Intuition

240: Creepy Accounts Vol. 49

TBB 31: Hypnosis

239: The Lancashire Seven & Kyron Horman

TBB 30: Rapid Fire Topics (Talk Show)

238: Reincarnation of Dorothy Eady & Mysterious Death of Joshua Maddux

TBB 29: The Murder of Bugsy Siegel

237: Creepy Accounts Vol. 48

TBB 28: Hauntings from Our Childhood

236: The Haunting of Bill Vaile & Jennifer Kesse

PIPIN' HOT GOSS: Tay's Villain Origin Story

manifestation meditation experiment

235: Philip Experiment & Lauren Giddings

TBB 26: Hot Juicy Goss

234: Creepy Accounts Vol. 47

TBB 25: Irish Encounters (Reddit Stories)

233: ST PATRICK'S DAY SPECIAL 5.0

TBB 24: Star Children (Morgan's Spiral)

232: The Beaumont Children Pt 2

TBB 23: Am I Missing Something? (Family Secrets)

231: Quaker Oats Experiment & The Beaumont Children

TBB 22: Ask Morgan Anything!

230: MORGAN'S BDAY EP!!! (Reddit Stories)

TBB 21: Let's Talk About Love!

229: The Case of Sara Jane Manker

Introducing BLINK - Jake Haendel’s Story. Heroin, Secrets. Deadly Betrayal.

TBB 20: Super Bowl Recap & Halftime Breakdown

228: Creepy Accounts Vol. 46

TBB 19: Galentine's AITA (Bestie Edition)

227: Popper’s Poltergeist, Ashley Freeman & Lauria Bible

TBB 18: Wanda Holloway (The Pom Pom Mom)

226: Henry The Wizard & William Bradford Bishop Jr.

TBB 17: Am I Missing Something? (AIMS)

225: Moon Eyed People & The Dardeen Family Murder

TBB 16: Q&A

224: Baba Vanga Predictions & Howard Witkin

TBB 15: Lessons for the Zodiacs in 2025

223: Creepy Accounts Vol 45

TBB 14: NYE Special

222: Creepy Accounts Vol. 44

TBB 13: Christmas Traditions

PART 2: Patricia Viola

221: The Internet is Dead & Patricia Viola

TBB 12: The Talk Show

220: Phi Mae Mai & Tania Head

TBB 11: Am I Missing Something? (AIMS)

219: The Guinness Family Curse & Carla Walker

TBB 10: American Dollar Princesses

218: Creepy Accounts Vol. 43

TBB 9: Friendship Quiz

217: Immaculate Constellation & The Rogers Girls

TBB 8: The SCP Foundation

216: Zanfretta UFO Incident & Sherri Rasmussen Pt. 2

TBB 7: Dinner Party Questions

215: The Augustine Steward House & Sherri Rasmussen

TBB 6: Am I Missing Something? (AIMS)

214: AHS & Elizabeth Bathory

TBB 5: The Dream Man

Playlist of the Dead: An All-Star Halloween Special

213: Creepy Accounts Vol. 42 with Susan!!!

TBB 4. For The Girls (ft. Noodle)

212: Catskills Crone & Missy Bevers

TBB 3: AITA?

211: Leigh Occhi (pt 2) & "The Family" Cult

TBB 2: FBI Operation Trojan Shield

210: Chinatown San Fransisco Ghost Marriages & Leigh Occhi

TBB 1: WELCOME TO SEASON 5!!!!

209: Creepy Accounts Vol. 41 (Season 4 Finale)

208: Creepy Accounts Vol. 40

207: The Dating Game Killer

206: The Rendlesham Forest Incident

205. Not-Deer & Holly K. Dunn

204: Back to School Special (ft. Noodle!!)

203. Doris McGowan-Bither & Jana Carpenter-Koklich

202. Creepy Accounts Vol. 39

201. El Paso High School & Jonathan Luna

200. The Red Barn Murder & The Greenbrier Ghost

199. The Colonial Parkway Murders

198. Megalodon (aka Big Tooth) & Russell and Shirley Dermond

197. Creepy Accounts Vol. 38

196. Dark Secrets & Scandals of Old Hollywood

The Bluebelle (part 2)

195. The Bermuda Triangle & The Bluebelle

194. Creepy Accounts Vol.37

193. The Gainesville Murders & Chase Street Haunting

192. The Springfield Three (Pt. 2) & The Midnight Bus 375

191. The Sleep Rooms & The Springfield Three

190. Sergei Ponomarenko & Minerva Cantu

189. Lindley St. House & Sun Gym Gang

188. Creepy Accounts Vol. 36

187. The Melting Man & Debbie Wilson

186. Chandra Levy

185. The Eclipse & Joyce Chiang

184. Creepy Accounts Vol. 35

183. Rose Hall & Alfred Loewenstein

182. Anunnaki Artifacts & Reesa Trexler

181. ST. PATRICK'S DAY SPECIAL 4.0 (Giants Causeway, Bridget Boland Cleary, & Children of Lir)

180. Creepy Accounts Vol. 34

179. The Allen House w/ Mark Spencer (Author of "A Haunted Love Story: The Ghosts of the Allen House")

The Intro (179)

178. Creepy Accounts Vol. 33

177. Holly Williams & Bill Lanway

176. REDDIT STORIES

175. Villisca Axe Murders & Hauntings

174. The Athens Asylum & Hinterkaifeck Farm

173. Creepy Accounts Vol. 32

172. Tōhoku Earthquake and Tsunami & Kenneka Jenkins

171. The 2023 Recap & Nostradamus

170. The Disappearance of Joan Risch

169. Creepy Accounts Vol. 31

168. The Black Widower (pt. 2) & R.T.D.

167. Granger Taylor & The Black Widower

166. Moberly-Jourdain Incident & Maria Ridulph

165: Creepy Accounts Vol. 30 w/ Sinisterhood Podcast

164. Holmesburg Prison & Bank of America Heist (D.B. Tuber)

163. The Yosemite Murders

162. Estefania Gutierrez Lazaro

HALLOWEEN CREEPY ACCOUNTS Vol. 29 (ft. Kelsey Kreppel)

161. Elmer McCurdy & Danny Filippidis

160. Kristy Bamu & Texarkana Moonlight Murders

159. Black Dahlia Suspects & The Screaming House

158. Gef the Talking Mongoose & The Black Dahlia (Elizabeth Short)

157. Reddit Stories w/ Ladies and Tangents (season 3 finale)

156. Creepy Accounts Vol. 28

155. Creepy Accounts Vol. 27

154: Creepy Accounts Vol. 26

153. Slender Man & 'The Slender Man Stabbing

152. Hotel Del Coronado & Robert Farberger and Eva Caudell

151. The Welles House & Kris Kremers and Lisanne Froon

150. Creepy Accounts Vol. 25 (ft. Em Schulz & Christine Schiefer)

149. Khamar-Daban Incident & Chiquita Tate

148. The Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders

147. The Egg Theory & Theresa Allore

146. Creepy Accounts Vol. 24 (feat. Susan)

145. Third Man Syndrome & Athalia Ponsell Lindsley

144. Dark Histories and Odd Crimes

143. Cock Lane & Mike Williams pt. 2

142. The Moon Landing & Mike Williams

141. Creepy Accounts Vol. 23

140. Allagash Abductions & Natalee Holloway

139. Unit 731 & Blair Adams

138: Elizabeth Cochran Seaman "Nellie Bly" & Barbara Gayle Stoppel

137. Missing Time & Mr. Cruel

136. Imaginary Friends Pt. 2, Cat Cults & Taylar's Possession

135. The Fermi Paradox & Counterintelligence Spies

134. The 2001 Anthrax Attacks

133. Brushy Mountain State Penitentiary & Harris County Jane and John Doe

132. Miami Aerospace Academy Pt. 2 & Edgar Allan Poe

Creepy Accounts Vol. 21

131. Lt. Joe Clark & Miami Aerospace Academy

130. Imaginary Friends & Tara Leigh Calico

Creeps and Crimes Trailer

129. ST PATRICK'S DAY 3.0

128. The Women in White & Anna "Delvey" Sorokin

Creepy Accounts Vol. 20

127. The BTK Strangler Psychological & Behavioral Analysis (Pt. 3, Final)

LOVE IT, HATE IT: The Last of Us & Gunther's Million

126. BTK Pt. 2

125. The BTK Strangler Part 1

Creepy Accounts Vol. 19

124. The Tanacu Exorcism & The Flannan Isles Lighthouse Mystery

123. Doomsday Clock & Krystal Surles

LOVE IT, HATE IT: Kaleidoscope

122: Ley Lines & Bonnie and Clyde

121: The Vatican Girl: Emanuela Orlandi

120: Pizza Collar Bomb Case (pt. 2) & the Bellaire House

Creepy Accounts Vol. 18 (ft. Trevin & Amanda w/ Live, Laugh, Larceny) Part 1

Introducing COLD: The Search for Sheree

119: The Aum Doomsday Cult & Pizza Collar Bomb Case

LOVE IT, HATE IT: Who Killed Santa? Murderville Mystery & Glass Onion- Knives Out

118: Top Creepy and True Crime Cases of 2022

'Twas The Night Before Christmas

117: The History of Christmas & The Sodder Children

116: Varginha UFO Incident & Denise Amber Lee

IDENTIFIED: Boy In The Box / Americas Unknown Child

115: BARRY SEAL PT. 2: Life, Crimes, Career, & Conspiracies

Creepy Accounts Vol. 17

114: BARRY SEAL: Life, Crimes, Career, & Conspiracies

LOVE IT, HATE IT : The Imperfects & The Watcher

113: The Hollywood Roosevelt & Boys on the Tracks

112: The Circleville Letters & 1996 Atlanta Bombings

111: Eastern Air Lines Flight 401 & Ellen Greenberg Pt. 2

110: The LaVey Family & Ellen Greenberg

UPDATES: Alex Murdaugh, Delphi Murders, Takeoff, South Korea

Halloween Creepy Accounts Vol. 16

LOVE IT, HATE IT : Devil in Ohio & Dahmer

109: HALLOWEEN SPECIAL

108: Cecil Hotel & Elisa Lam

107: Santa Catalina Monastery & Miriam Rodríguez Martínez

106: DMT & The Night Stalker

Creepy Accounts Vol. 15

105: Disney: Conspiracies, Haunting History, and Incidents Pt. 2

104: Disney: Conspiracies, Hauntings, & Murders Pt. 1

Phoebe Handsjuk Pt. 3

103: Phoebe Handsjuk Pt. 2 & Father Amorth Exorcisms

102: Eloise Asylum & Phoebe Handsjuk

Creepy Accounts Vol. 14

101: Paul Dienach & Bible John

100: Andrew Basiago & The Murdaugh Murders

99: Problems But A Ghost Aint One (ft. TWO GIRLS ONE GHOST)

98: Skull and Bones Club & Timothy Piazza

Creepy Accounts Vol. 13

97: NXIVM & The Somerton Man

96: The NoEnd House & Tool Box Killers

95: Gloria Ramirez & Clutter Family Murder

94: CERN & Drew Barrymore

93: THE MURDER OF MARTY DAVIS

Creepy Accounts Vol. 12

MISSING: Andrea Knabel

92: Aberfan Disaster Premonitions

91: Valiant Thor & Ken and Barbie Killers

90: Dorian Corey & Sage Smith

89: "The Fruit Machine" & Mollie Olgin + Kristene Chapa

Creepy Accounts Vol. 11

88: Melon Heads & Alan Turing

87: Tupac Amaru Shakur: Life, Murder, Conspiracies

86: Arley Naomi Proctor & Johnny Gosch

85: Spontaneous Human Combustion & Kacie Woody

Q&A: Meet Our Moms!

Creepy Accounts Vol. 10 (ft. Our Moms!!)

84: Michael Taylor & Lauren Smith-Fields

83: The Finders & Ed Gein (ft. Arletta Argyle)

82: Terry Lovelace & Holly Bobo

81: Ouija Boards: History, Hauntings & Murders

80: The Ilkley Moor UFO Incident & Kimberley Killer

79: Erin Valenti & Barry and Honey Sherman

78 Pt. 2: TFU SECTION

78: Jaycee Lee Dugard & La Llorona

77: ST. PATRICK'S DAY 2.0

76: Arne Johnson & Keddie Cabin Murders

Creepy Accounts Vol. 8

75: TRIFECTA: The Bennington Triangle

74: Kyle Odom & Ronnie Long

73: The Greg Thread & Shaquita Bennett

72: Hotel Monte Vista & Tamla Horsford

71: Silent Twins & Kendrick Johnson

Creepy Accounts Vol. 7

70: Jonestown Massacre & Pogo The Clown

Lauren Taylor Agee

69: Aradale Lunatic Asylum & Dolly Oesterreich

68: Kennedy Curse & Tami Reay

Creepy Accounts Vol. 6

67: Pascagoula Abduction & Teresita Basa

66: The Bohemian Grove & Zack Bowen and Addie Hall

65: Hoia-Baciu Forest & Karina Holmer

64: Anneliese Michel Possession & Arlis Perry

63: The Kelly, Kentucky Encounter & Zebb Quinn

O.J. Simpson Pt. 2

62: O.J. Simpson Pt. 1 & Kardashian Konspiracies

61: Amityville Horror Special w/ The Binge Boys

60: Zodiac Killer Pt. 2 & Oak Island Money Pit

REDDIT STORIES Vol. 2

59: Ultimate Reddit Hole: Lake City Quiet Pills & The Zodiac Killer Pt. 1

58: Mt. Shasta Conspiracies & Rosemary Christensen

Creepy Account Vol. 5

57: The Dybbuk Box & The Hammersmith Ghost Murder

56: Hybrid Children & Austin Yogurt Shop Murders

55: The Exorcist & Las Cruces Bowling Alley

54: A Brooklyn Haunting & Joel Rifkin

REDDIT STORIES

53: National Parks Pt. 1 & Edmund Kemper

52: Pluckley Village & Mysterious Death of the Jamison Family

51: Travis Walton Abduction & La Pistolera

50: Oakville Blobs & Disappearance of Sneha Philip

49: Edgewood Experiments & Adam Walsh

48: The Gateway Experience & Christy Mirack

47: The Campus Killer & University Hauntings

46: Poveglia Island & Morgan Harrington and Hannah Graham

CREEPS & CRIMES TRAILER

Creepy Accounts Vol. 4

45: Loftus Hall & The Dexter Copycat Killer

44: Polybius & Charlie Brandt

Stalking Cases: Team Crime Special Bonus

43: Haunting in Connecticut & Bardstown, KY Murders

42: Lizard People & Ariel Castro

41: Doll Islands & The Suitcase Murders

40: M.I.B & Kirsten Hatfield

39: The Russian Sleep Experiment & Peggy The Doll

38: Snow White, Bad Apples, & Charles Cullen

37: Lizzie Borden Murder & House Haunting

36: George Adamski & Michelle Knotek

35: Venusian Love Story & Ray Gricar

Creepy Accounts Vol. 3

34: The Ammons Family Possession & Fort Hood Murder(s)

33: Stephen Hawking & Lynn Messer

32: LaLaurie Mansion & Katelin Akens

31: JonBenét Ramsey Pt. 2 & Reincarnation

30: Malaysian Airlines Flight 370 & JonBenet Ramsey Pt. 1

29: Navajo Skinwalkers & Madeleine "Maddie" McCann

28: The Philadelphia Experiment & Setagaya Family Murder

27: Haunting of Lancaster & Tina Watson

26: Dyatlov Pass & Tom and Eileen Lonergan

25: Irish Folklore & Michael Malloy aka Mike the Durable

24: Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum & “Bambi”

23: Australian Alien Encounter & The Lululemon Murder

22: HAARP Facility & Amy Lynn Bradley

21: Denver International Airport & Heaven's Gate

20: The Saint Valentine's Day Massacre & The Delphi Murders

19: 20 And Back & The McStay Family Murder

18: The Conjuring House & The Claremont Serial Killer

17: Black Eyed Kids & Smiley Face Killer

16: Project Blue Beam & Bryce Laspisa

15: Simulation Theory & Lori Hacking

14: Broadway Ghost & Lindsay Buziak

13: The Winchester Mystery House & Jonelle Matthews

12: Illuminati & Israel Keyes

11: Project MKUltra & Laci Peterson Pt. 2

10: Dear David & Laci Peterson Pt.1

Creepy Accounts Vol. 2

9: Salem Witch Trials & Mary Rose Keadjuk

BONUS: Hollow Earth Theory & Anthonette Cayedito

8: Yuma Territorial Prison & Rey Rivera

7: The Georgia Guidestones & John "Jack" Gilbert Graham

6: The Royal Family & Richardson Family Murders

Creepy Accounts Vol. 1

5: Bell Witch, Black Cats, & Shauna Howe (ft. Arletta Argyle)

4: Sleep Paralysis & Larry Gene Bell

3: The Stanley Hotel & Tara Grant

2: Area 51 & Diane Downs

1: Deja Vu & Jennifer Pan