All Episodes
Enter the Abyss — 215 episodes
6 TRUE Scary Stories That Will Ruin Your Sleep Tonight…
Reddit- What's the Most Dangerous Thing You've Ever Done?
Scary Stories from the Internet
Reddit- What Was the Scariest We Need to Leave Now Gut Feeling You've Ever Experienced?
Reddit- As a Kid, What's the Creepiest Thing you Ever Noticed About Another Kid's Family?
Scary True Christmas Tales
What’s a story you don’t tell people because they won’t believe you?
TikTok Stories to Freak You Out
Even More Horrifying Stories from TikTok
Horrifying True TikTok Stories
The Mystery of 3I/ATLAS
Chilling 411 Disappearances: Utah Edition
Annabelle's Haunted Demon Tour 2025
The Mysterious Reappearance of Karketa Taylor
The Ghosts in the Deadly Lake Tahoe Storm
Vanished: The Missing 411 Mysteries Part 2
Vanished: The Missing 411 Mysteries
Reddit- Who is the Scariest/Creepiest Human You've Encountered?
Horror Stories From Online- Disturbing Things in the Woods
Exploring The Hidden Webpage Creepypasta, Part 2
Exploring The Hidden Webpage Creepypasta, Part 1
The Mysterious Disappearance of Kenny Veach & His Search For the M Cave
And Then There Were More Scary Stories From Online
Reddit- What’s the Scariest True Story You’ve Heard or Told?
Reddit- Cave Explorers of Reddit, What is Your Creepiest or Most Dangerous Experience?
AI Stories of Aliens and a Killer & Other Alien Tales
The New Jersey Drones & Other Stories About Things That Don't Seem Right
Kay's Cross & Other Haunting Stories From Utah
Reddit- Glitch In The Matrix
Exploring the Haunted Clown Motel and the Ghostly Mysteries of Tonopah
Reddit- Those Who Go Into Peoples' Houses for Work, What is the Strangest/Creepiest Thing You've Ever Seen or Experienced?
The Bear Lake Monster & A "True" Bedtime Story
Reddit- What is the Most Unexplained, Supernatural, or Paranormal Event You've Ever Witnessed?
Intense Outdoor Experiences from Reddit
True Crime Cases of Adam Strong and Daniel LaPlante & Other Cold Cases
Scary Stories Online for Spooktober
Celebrity Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Part 2
Insane Motel, AirBnB, Hotel and Couch Surfing Stories from Reddit
Haunting Ghost Stories from the internet
Stories to Give You Chills
Demons in the AI- The Story of Loab
And Then There Were More Scary Stories From Online
Celebrity Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Part 1
Listener Submissions 21: The Mysterious Little People of Pryor Mountain
The Story of Jay's Journal and Other Haunting Stories
Sierra Sounds Sasquatch and Other Cryptid Sighting Stories
Scary Encounter Stories from the internet
Horrifying Stories from the Internet
Reddit Story- My Wife Bought a Reborn Doll to Cope With the Death of Our Child
Reddit Thread- People Who Live in Small, Quiet Towns, What's the Scariest Thing That's Happened to you There?
The Most Notorious Serial Killer In Every State Finale
Listener Submissions 20: The Snowtown Murders & Other Scary Stories
Reddit Thread- What's Your Favorite Creepy Campfire Story?
Scary Truck Stops, Undersea Encounters and Many More Scary Stories
A Possessed Nun's Letter & More Possession Stories
The Most Notorious Serial Killer In Every State Part 9
True Stalking Encounter
The Most Notorious Serial Killer In Every State Part 8
Reddit- What is the Scariest True Story You Know?
The Winchester Mystery House
Stories From the Middle of Nowhere
Listener Submissions 19: The Porco Murder Case and the Lars Mittank disappearance
Reddit- People of Reddit Who Claim to Have Seen A Mythical Creature, What is Your Story?
The Most Notorious Serial Killer In Every State Part 7
Even More Scary Stories from the Internet
More Scary Stories From the Internet
Listener Submissions 18: Indian Reservations and Skinwalkers
Listener Submissions 17: Cannibalism Stories
The Most Notorious Serial Killer In Every State Part 6
Reddit- What's a Scary Story From Your Childhood?
Strange Deaths & Mysterious Stories
Reddit- People Who Experience Ghost/Demonic Encounters, What's Your Story?
Listener Submissions 16: The Lizzie Borden Axe Murders
Halloween Special: True Horror Stories from Online
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Finale
The Most Notorious Serial Killer In Every State Part 5
Reddit- What is the Scariest Experience You've Ever Had While Home Alone?
4chan: Creepy Green Text
Listener Submissions 15: Dulce Base and Stardust Ranch & Other Alien Stories
Short True Horror Stories That Will Give You Nightmares
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 9 Part 2
Reddit- Third Man Syndrome
Listener Submissions 14: The Yuba County 5
The Most Notorious Serial Killer In Every State Part 4
Reddit- What Are You 100% Sure You Saw, But Nobody Believes You?
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 9 Part 1
Listener Submissions 13: The Haunting of the Queen Mary
Reddit- What is the Most Pants Shitting Paranormal Experience You've Had?
The Most Notorious Serial Killer in Every State Part 3
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 8 Part 2
Reddit- What Was the Scariest Place You Have Ever Been To?
A Moscow Mule Full of Poison & Other Stories
Reddit Thread- People Who Had Stalkers, When Did You Realize You Were Being Stalked?
The Most Notorious Serial Killer in Every State Part 2
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 8 Part 1
Listener Submissions 12: Texas Chainsaw Massacre & Potential Run-Ins With Serial Killers
Reddit Thread- Security Guards, What's Your Creepiest/Scariest Story?
Reddit Thread- What's the Most Mysterious Thing That Happened In Your Life That You Can't Find an Explanation For?
The Most Notorious Serial Killer in Every State Part 1
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 7 Part 2
Reddit Thread- Parents, Have You Ever Heard Anything Creepy or Unexplainable Through Your Baby Monitor?
Reddit Thread- Graveyard Shift Workers, What Crazy, Creepy, Unbelievable Things Have You Seen Workin in the Dead of Night?
Reddit Thread- I Don't Want To Sleep Tonight, What is The Scariest Thing That's Ever Happened to You?
Listener Submissions 11: People Who Have Psychosis, Share Your Scariest Hallucinations
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 7 Part 1
Reddit Thread- Creepypasta Are Great, But Does Anyone Have Any Good True Creepy Stories?
Listener Submissions 11: Jeff the Killer & Missing Persons Stories
Horror Stories Written by Artificial Intelligence
Listener Stories and Doppelgangers
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 6 Part 2
Reddit Thread- What is the Creepiest, Most Inexplicable Thing You’ve Seen?
Reddit Thread- What's Some Paranormal Activity That You Experienced?
100th Episode Halloween Special
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 6 Part 1
60: Mel's Hole Final Call & Other Mysterious Stories
Reddit Thread- What Was Your Creepy Unexplained Experience as a Child?
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 5 Part 2
Reddit Thread- What is the Scariest Ghost Story You Ever Heard?
59: The Keddie Cabin Murders, Sawney Bean & Strange Occurrences After Watching Horror Films
58: Mel's Hole Call #4 (crazy ending) & Stories of Strange Backyard Finds
Listener submissions 10: What Angels Actually Look Like & Angel, Demon and Spirit Stories
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 5 Part 1
411 Disappearances Part 3 and Other Scary Stories from Hunters
Reddit Thread- Dear Police Officers of Reddit, Have You Ever Responded to a Call for Paranormal Reasons?
57: Dead Internet Theory & Simulation Stories
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 4 Part 2
Am I the A**hole? Part 1
56: The Black Hope Curse & Haunted Cemetery Stories
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 4 Part 1
Reddit Thread- What is the Most Unexplainable Thing That Has Ever Happened to You?
55: Mel's Hole Call number 3 & Some Urban Adventurer Stories
Reddit Thread- What Is Your Creepiest, Most Unnerving Story? Real or Not, Please Creep Us Out Part 2
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 3 Part 2
54: The Town Bully, Ken McElroy & Vigilante Justice Stories
Reddit Thread- Parents of Reddit, What’s the Creepiest Thing Your Child Has Ever Said?
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 3 Part 1
Reddit Thread- What’s Your True Unexplained Story of Being in an Alternate Reality?
Listener Submissions 10: The Djinn
53: Creepy Collectors & Haunted Objects
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 2 Part 2
Enter the Abyss 2 Year Special
52: Reddit Thread- Long Haul Truckers & Road Trippers, What's the Creepiest Thing You've Encountered on the Road?
51: Haunted Daycares
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 2 Part 1
100th Subscriber Special- Spirit Box
Listener Submissions 9: Ocean Sounds
50: Ho Ho Horrible Holiday Stories
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 1 Part 2
49: 20 True Short Horror Stories
48: Mel's Hole Part 2 & A Few Of the World's Scariest Places
47: Linda Hazzard the Starvation Doctor & Let's Not Meet
Conspiracy Theory Iceberg Tier 1 Part 1
46: Reddit Thread- What Conversation or Interaction Made You Believe You Spoke to Something Otherworldly?
Listener Submissions 8: The Mystery of the Sphinx
Special Guest Episode: Analise and Clete talk the Paranormal and Missing People
Phobias Part 1
411 Disappearances Part 2- Steven Kubacki and Other Wilderness Tales
45: The Creepy Clown Episode
44: Tales from 4 Chan and Other Dark Tales from the Internet
43: Recurring Dreams & Their Meanings
Listener Submissions 7: The Bell Witch & Other Haunting Stories
411 Disappearances Part 1- The Disappearance of Haley Zega & Other Strange Encounters in the Wilderness
42: True Crime & Florida Man Short Stories
41: The Exorcist Movie Curse & Real Life Exorcism Stories Part 2
40: The Exorcist Movie Curse & Real Life Exorcism Stories Part 1
39: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 10
38: Reddit Thread- What Is Your Creepiest, Most Unnerving Story? Real or Not, Please Creep Us Out
37: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 9
36: The Creepiest Things Found In Basements & More Alien Stories
35: I Hope We Never Meet & Retail Crime Stories
34: Alien Hand Syndrome & Ronald DeFeo Jr.
33: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 8
32: Reddit Thread- Long Haul Truckers: What's the Creepiest/Most Paranormal Thing You've Seen on the Road at Night?
Listener Submissions 6: The Mountain Meadows Massacre & The Dark Watchers
31: Albert Fish & True or False Crime
30: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 7
Short Stories: Missing Children, Helium and a Phone Creep
Enter the Abyss 1 Year Special
29: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 6
28: Some More Darwin Awards
The Christmas Episode: Krampus the Evil Santa & True Christmas Horror Stories
Short Stories: Cannibals, Comfy Bins & Choose Your Crime
27: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 5
Listener Submissions 5: Darwin Awards
26: Dennis DePue, The Real Life Jeepers Creepers & Too Much Radiation
25: Reddit Thread- What Is The Best Unexplained Mystery?
24: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 4
23: Reddit Thread- As It's Nearly Halloween, How About We Share Some Creepy Stories?
22: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 3
21: Annabelle the Doll & the Jersey Devil
Listener Submissions 4: Dybbuk Box & Suicide Forest
20: Reddit Thread- What is the Creepiest, Most Blood Chilling Thing You or Someone You Know Have Ever Experienced?
19: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 2
18: It's Raining Blood and Meat & Other Mysterious Anomalies
17: Buttermilk Bluebeard & The Bloody Benders
16: Reddit Thread- Hikers, Campers, Woodsmen and the Like, What Are Your Scariest Experiences In Them There Woods?
15: The Mysterious Die Glocke & The Philadelphia Experiment
14: The Creepiest Urban Legends In Every State Part 1
Listener Submissions 3: Hinterkaifeck Murders & Lake Bodom Murders
13: Reddit Thread- What is the Most Mysterious/Paranormal Thing You Have Witnessed?
12: History of the Ouija Board & Stories of Demonic Possession
11: Our Personal Experiences With the Unexplained
Listener Submissions 2: Dyatlov Pass & the Ohio Penitentiary
10: Aliens- The First Alien Abduction & Bob Lazar
9: The Bodies of Lake Tahoe and Island of the Dolls.
8: Reddit Thread- Horrifying Facts You Could Have Lived Happily Not Knowing
Listener Submissions 1: Oak Island & The Disappearance of the Roanoke Colony
St. Patrick's Day Special
7: The Men Who Wouldn't Die- Michael Malloy & Rasputin
6: Deathbed Visions & Last Words
5: Richard Chase and HH Holmes
4: Reincarnation Stories
3: The Disappearances of Elisa Lam and Brandon Lawson
2: Skinwalker Ranch & the Wendigo
1: Foo Fighters & the Pied Piper