All Episodes

Ep.59 - Jessica Lyn Keen

Ep.58 - Chelsea Bruck

Ep.57 - Cheryl Hughes (Unsolved)

Ep.56 - Case Updates: Amy Mihaljevic and Beverly Jarosz

Ep.55 - The Vanishing of Cindy Anderson (Unsolved)

Ep.54 - Katrina Smith

Ep.53 - Kalee Bruce

Ep.52 - Missing: Brian Shaffer

Ep.51 - Maria Marshall

Ep.50 - Hazel Burns

Ep.49 - Ronald Tammen

Ep.48 - The Ghost Cat of Fairport Harbor

Ep.47 - Theresa Andrews

Ep.46 Noelle Paquette

Ep.45 - Carnell Sledge and Kate Brown (Unsolved)

Ep.44 - The Indiana Dunes Disappearances (Unsolved)

Ep.43 - The King of Beaver Island

Ep.42 - Mystery at Long Point Cut Lighthouse

Ep.41 - The Defiance Werewolf (Halloween Episode 2022)

Ep.40 - Dana Rosendale

Ep.39 - Derrick Robie

Ep.38 - Florence Unger

Ep.37 - Parma School Teachers

Ep.36 - Jennifer Teague

Ep.35 - Angela Hicks

Ep.34 - The Kelleys Island Murders

Ep.33 - Ghost Stories

Ep.32 - Joan, Michelle, & Christe Rogers

Ep. 31 - JoAnn Matouk Romain

Ep. 30 - Anna Marie Hahn

Ep. 29 - Beverly Potts

Ep. 27 - Lynda Shaw

Ep. 26 - Sister Margaret Ann Pahl

Ep. 25 - Missing in Muskoka

Ep. 24 - Beverly Jarosz

Ep. 23 - Nancy Ludwig

Ep. 22 - Irene Izak

Ep.21 - Lisa & Devon Manderach

Ep.20 - Judy Martins

Ep.19 - Ceely Rose

Ep.18 - Barry and Honey Sherman

Ep.17 - The Berlin Lake Murders

Ep.16 - Geauga's Baby

Ep.15 - Amish Hate Crimes

Ep.14 - Heather Bogle

Ep.13 - London Ontario Serial Killer Victims

Ep.12 - Lynne Harper & Steven Truscott

Ep.11 - Dr. Dawn Glanz

Ep.10 - Ashley Simpson

Ep.9 - Lisa Pruett

Ep.8 - Gore Orphanage

Ep.7 - Sierah Joughin

Ep.6 - The Put-in-Bay Murder

Ep.5 - Mandy Steingasser

Ep.4 - Christine Woelk

Ep.3 - Amy Mihaljevic

Ep.2 - The Kirtland Cult Killings

Ep.1 - Introduction