All Episodes

292: The Pet Rock: A Fad is Born (An Old Timey Podcast)

291: Mark Zuckerberg Signed This Contract

290: The Death of a Salesman

289: The My Lai Massacre

288: The Kidnapping of Martha "Doe" Roberts

287: Food Fight!

286: The Murder of Michelle Young

285: Cyclists

284: A Kidnapping... AUSTRALIAN STYLE! ft. Ellyn and Joey from I Think Not!

283: Snapped! ft. Ellyn and Joey from I Think Not!

282: A Mommy Blogger & a Disappearance in Alaska

281: The Murder of Janet Chandler

280: The Pandemic Defense

279: The Mini Madoff

278: Insurance Fraud

277: Buried Treasure??

276: A Hunting Accident

275: A Timber Swindler (and Obsessed Fest '23)

274: A Big Bad Wolf

273: A Foreclosure

272: The Murder of Imette St. Guillen

271: 16th Street Baptist Church Bombing

270: The Kidnapping of George Weyerhaeuser

269: The Nose Doctor!

268: The Disappearance of an Entire Family

267: The Coca-Cola Poisonings

266: The Murder of Martre Coles

265: SENSA!

264: The Fager Family Murders

263: Strongman Duo Chop and Steele

262: The Murder of Michelle Martinko

261: The Six Flags Haunted Castle Disaster

260: The Multiple Attacks on Donna Palomba

259: The Kidnapping of Ginny Piper

258: The Massie Affair & a Disappearance

257: A Drowning & a Shipwreck

256: The Sweetheart Swindler & a Cold Case

255: A Trip to the Movies & the eBay Stalking Scandal

254: An A*shole & a Psychic Vision

253: A Black Guy & a Disappearance

252: Ringing the Wrong Doorbell & the Disappearance of Maribel Ramos

251: A Bomb & an Irish Heiress

250: A New Neighbor & an Assplosion

249: Faylene Grant & Peanuts!

248: The Lost Script & License Plate Scanners

247: The Murder of Maddie Clifton & a Triple Kidnapping

246: Toilets & the Red Sash Murderer

245: Good Solid Policework & Monopoly

244: LGBT Bullying & a Home Invasion

243: Fires

242: Don't Mess With Moms!

241: Fugitives!

240: Liberace & Karl Karlsen

239: A Bank Robbery & SoHo Karen

238: The Tulia Drug Bust & Online Dating

237: Brandi's Wedding & Standing Your Ground

236: The Disappearance of Elizabeth Sullivan & the Tech Rapist

235: Prepare to be DP'd!

234: Back to Our Roots

233: A Catastrophe and a Preppy Rapist

232: Cameron Diaz & the Murder of a Criminal Defense Lawyer

231: The Cardiff Giant

230: Erin Andrews' Stalker & a Honeymoon Mystery

229: The Murders of Savanna LaFontaine-Greywind & Rachel Hoffman

228: The San Antonio Four & Michele Neurauter

227: Insurance Fraud!

226: CoolSculpting & the Disappearance of Michele Harris

225: This One's So Bad We Invented a Strip Club

224: The Kidnapping of Adolph Coors III & a Disappearance

223: Threatening Messages & an Airplane Pooper

222: The Hell House & a Normal Death

221: We're Terribly Sorry for this Terrible Episode

220: Dippin' Dots & the Disappearance of Jennifer Rothwell

219: 48 Hours!

218: A Victory for Gay Rights & Terrible Friends

217: A Chilling 911 Call & a Murder "Mystery"

216: A Hollywood Scandal & the Disappearance of Annie Le

215: Wrongfully Convicted People With The Last Name Brown

214: A "Victim" & a Fire

213: A Murder Mystery & the Central Park Karen

212: An Australian Catfish & Domestic Violence

211: A Creepy Manager & Balloonfest '86

210: A Cool Teacher & Teenaged Love

209: A Durham Staircase & the Transy Book Heist

208: Easter Sunday Massacre

207: An Abduction & a Surgeon

206: Vincent Chin & a Johnson County Mystery

205: A Charlatan & a Family Annihilator

204: Wells Fargo Robbery & a Mysterious Illness

203: A Stalker & a Deeply Stupid Heist

202: Death Penalty Cases

201: Jodi Arias (Pt. 2) & Clarence Elkins

200: Jodi Arias & the Duke Lacrosse Scandal

199: Shawn Bentler & War Machine

198: The Murder of Ahmaud Arbery & a Mysterious Pool Death

197: Childhood Friends & the Kidnapping of Frank Sinatra Jr

196: Internment Camps & a Bathtub Mystery

195: Boston Massacre & Alexis Murphy

194: Newlyweds & Anthony Gray

193: An Anniversary Getaway & the Lynching of Timothy Coggins

192: A Wild Robbery and the Honeymoon from Hell

191: Bresha Meadows & Nailah Franklin

190: A Mighty Slut Shaming & Brothers

189: The Secret Serial Killer & a Mother

188: The Mysterious Death of Greg Fleniken & a Love Triangle

187: What are the chances??

186: The Murder of Robert Schwartz & a Mystery in Miami

185: The Clinton 12 & the Murder of Adrianne Reynolds

184: 2002!

183: Exonerations!

182: Kidnappings!

181: Sh*tbags!

180: Candy Montgomery & Ruth Snyder

179: A Mother-Daughter Bond & A Speech

178: An Old Timey Meghan Markle & A Possession

177: A Cold Case & A Lover

176: Disappearance of Kyron Horman & a Suicide Helper

175: A Cult & the Murder of Doris Angleton

174: A Determined Mother

173: The Kidnapping of Zephany Nurse & the Dionne Quintuplets

172: The Murder Of Botham Jean & A Fire

171: An Intruder & A Real Estate Agent

170: A Catfish & A Brutal Murder

169: Cold French Fries & a Texas A&M Professor

168: A Man Who Hated Domino's & a Family Annihilator

167: A Supposedly Sketchy Medical Examiner & the Murder of Mandy Stavik

166: An Office Romance & a Terrible Fall

165: A Missing Bullet & the Black Widow of Las Vegas

164: The Tesco Bomber & a Sinister Minister

163: Ewell Family Murders & April Kauffman

162: Undercover Mother & Another Bathtub Murder?

161: The Murder of Randy Sheridan

160: The Mysterious Death of Sarah Widmer

159: The Worst Woman on Earth & a Cruise Ship

158: Rosa Parks & a Serial Killer

157: Amber Alerts!

156: The Mysterious Lloyd Gaines & a Creepy Church Lady

155: A Killer Son-in-Law & An Innocent Joke!

154: PATREON EXCLUSIVE: Typhoid Mary & Scrunchies

153: REBROADCAST: EHR MAH GERD! A CERH BERM!

152: Embezzlement and Sisters

151: A "Massive" Defense Strategy & Ed Johnson

150: Consensual Murder & Horror at Dollar General

149: Wrongful Convictions

148: A Dwelling Defender & a Normal Middle Class Family

147: MURDER!

146: Dane Cook & Ryan Ferguson

145: The Kidnapping of Shannon Matthews & Eliza Jumel's Divorce

144: The Queen of Mean & Sunny von Bulow

143: Ruth Bader Ginsburg & Identity Theft

142: REBROADCAST: Too Much Betrayal & the Reluctant Lottery Winner

141: The Pitfalls of Being a Child Star & a Troubled Marriage

140: High Schoolers

139: A Facebook Stalker & a Foreclosure

138: The Ken and Barbie Killers & the Cocoanut Grove Fire

137: A Poisoner & A True Douche Canoe

136: The Great Molasses Flood & a Father's Love

135: Love Stories

134: The Kidnapping of Jeremy London & a House Fire

133: The Watcher & Laura Ingalls Wilder

132: Brandi's Back & the Black Widow of Keller, Texas

131: Conrad Hilton III & a Bad Pot of Coffee

130: Rebroadcast: Bad Dads! (Featuring DP)

128: A Museum Heist & Dalia Dippolito

127: PATREON BONUS EPISODE: The Candyman & Buried Alive

126: Police Officer Daniel Holtzclaw & a Shocking Medical Diagnosis

125: Larry Flynt vs. Jerry Falwell & the Murder of Becki Dillard

124: The Chicago Tylenol Murders and Corruption in Kansas City

123: A World Health Organization Researcher & a Fallopian Tube

122: Fruitcakes & an Obsessed Girlfriend

121: Family Annihilator Neil Entwistle & a Tumor

120: Pizzagate & the Seton Hall Dorm Fire

119: Kate Middleton's Topless Photos & William Wallace

118: The Lululemon Murder & A Woman in a Trunk

117: The Murder of Skylar Neese & Dr. Ossian Sweet

116: The Springfield Mall Shooting & Mrs. Sherlock Holmes

115: Pepsi's Big Mistake & the Murder of Skylar Neese

114: The Biggest Idiot Ever & a Woman Who Refused to Marry a Rapist

113: The Murder of Peter Porco & the Boorn Brothers

112: The Sinking of the USS Indianapolis & the Caffey Family Murders

111: Chocolate Candy Murders & the Wrongful Conviction of Scott Hornoff

110: The Murder of Emmett Till & Justice for Cyntoia Brown

109: An Interview With The Dog Lady of Lansing Prison

108: A YouTube Lawsuit & the Disappearance of Lizabeth Wilson

107: Fatal Attraction & the Kidnapping of Brooke Hart

106: Cases Covered by America's Most Wanted

105: The Mother from Hell & the Kidnapping of Yingying Zhang

104: The Hazing Death of Matt Carrington & a Murderer Turned Professor

103: Carol Burnett v. The National Enquirer & the Seemingly Perfect Couple

102: The Origin of Miranda Rights & an "Ugly" Anchorwoman

101: Holiday REMIX

100: Can we get a re-do??

99: Another Family Annihilator & the Smiling Widow

98: Celia Fought Back & the Disappearance of Kelsey Berreth

97: A Biology Professor & Winona Ryder’s Shoplifting Trial

96: Taylor Swift’s Assault Trial & Ali Kemp

95: Mob Bosses! (a.k.a. Bob Mosses)

94: Skechers Shape-Ups & a Ton of Leaves

93: A Psychic & Nightmares in a Mansion

92: A Man Who Sued His Wife’s Lover & a Robbery at a Video Game Store

91: Fatty Arbuckle & Strangers with Candy

90: The Assassination of William McKinley & a Disturbed Young Gamer

89: The Divorces of Kim Kardashian & Susan Kuhnhausen

88: The Durable Michael Malloy & A Mother Who Took Justice Into Her Own Hands

87: A Brutal Attack on a Lawyer & Olestra

86: The Suicide of Tyler Clementi & a Discovery in a Cooler

85: The Dartmouth Murders and an Evil Phlebotomist

84: A Big Hug & An Incredible Story of Survival

83: Bad Dads! (Featuring DP)

82: Holding your wee for a Wii & the Disappearance of a Troubled Teen

81: The Kidnapping Of Edward Cudahy & A Baker Who Refused To Make A Cake

80: A Swig of Mountain Dew & the Phony Pony Bandit

79: Cruel Teenage Girls & the Snake House

78: Dating Naked & the Abduction of Amber Hagerman

77: A Home Invasion & Pepsi Points

76: A Shopaholic & the Glensheen Mansion Murder Mystery

75: The Jenny Jones Show & Brandi’s Most Horrifying Case

74: A Killer Party & An Upsetting Discovery

73: Brock Turner & The Boy Who Thought He Pulled Off the Perfect Murder

72: The Assassination Attempt on Ronald Reagan & Bite Mark Analysis

71: A Murder Mystery & Nazi Saboteurs

70: Dr. Kevorkian & IHOP

69: A Terrible Commute & The Dark Web

68: The Day Care Shooter & Misery at Taco Bell

67: Fraud, Embezzlement, and the Vatican & Road Rage

66: The Man in the Attic & an Unsolved Mystery

65: Cyberbullying & the Hot Cup of Coffee

64: Trapped in a Burger King & Eccentric Millionaire John du Pont

63: Too Much Betrayal & the Reluctant Lottery Winner

62: April Fools: The Exercise Guru & the Innocent New Yorkers

61: The Ha Ha Tonka Castle and the Acid Doctor

60: The Chipotle Lawsuit & Infidelity

59: The Milkshake Murder & Blood Spatter Analysis

58: The Sleepwalker & the McDonald’s Strip Search

57: The Seaman Family & Elizabeth Freeman’s Quest for Freedom

56: Fugitive Slave Anthony Burns & the Power of Suggestion (Part 2)

55: The Power of Suggestion & Con Man Clark Rockefeller

54: The So-Called Kayak Killer & the Girl Scout Camp Murders

53: Drug Dealer Jesse James Hollywood & Andrea Yates

52: A Celebrity Stalker & the Blended Family

51: Johnson County’s Other Serial Killer & the Graduate

50: The Wood Chipper Murder & a Robbery Gone Wrong

49: Cheaters… with Daryl Pitts!

48: Holiday Crimes!

47: Subway Spokesman Jared Fogle & a Brutal Attack on a Midwestern Family

46: The Great Brink’s Robbery & the Murder of Kelsey Smith

45: The “Other” Craigslist killer & the Watts Family Murders

44: That’s My Foot & The Tyneside Strangler

43: Deadly Love & The Unbelievable Kidnapping

42: Spree Killer Charles Starkweather & the Pricey Murder for Hire Plot

41: The Dangers of Winning the Lottery & the Unhappy Father

40: Crimes That Inspired Horror Movies

39: Intern Chandra Levy & the Wichita Horror

38: The Affluenza Teen & the “CIA” Con Artist

37: The Dangers of Letting Extended Family Live With You & the Kidnapping of Quinn Gray

36: The Scottsboro Boys & the Dangers of Cheerleading in Texas

35: White Collar Crime

34: The Brink’s Car Robbery & the Assistant Who Ended Her Boss’s Ponzi Scheme

33: The Casey Anthony Trial & the Starvation Doctor

32: The Trials of Lizzie Borden & Alice Crimmins

31: The Many Losses of Marybeth Tinning & the Cannibal Cop

30: Murders at a Chinese Hostel & Gypsy Blanchard’s Quest for Freedom

29: The Internet’s First Serial Killer & the Disappearance of Cora Okonski

28: The Kidnapping of America’s Best Businesswoman & the Murder of Lisa Techel

27: The Strange Life of Michael Marin and Game Night Gone Wrong

26: The Big Break & the Kidnapping of Bobby Greenlease

25: The Lindbergh Baby Kidnapping and the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire

24: The Charming Kidnappers & the Swope Family Murders (?)

23: Rolling Stone’s Most Outrageous Article & the Bever Family Murders

22: Food Lawsuits with the Gaming Historian

21: Never Trust a Hottie & the McMartin Preschool Trial

20: The Case of the Missing Pants & the Chicken Coop Murders

19: The Suicide of Conrad Roy & the Disappearance of Bobby Dunbar

18: The Family Annihilator & Is This Love?

17: The Astronaut Love Triangle & the @$&!?* Pre-trial Hearing

16: The Runaway Bride & the Not-So-Perfect Crime

15: The BTK Serial Killer & That Time Some Dude Stole the Mona Lisa

14: A Serial Killer in the Making & the Many Faces of Juanita Maxwell

13: The Home Owners’ Association From Hell & Jennifer Jackson’s Murder

12: Video Game Lawsuits with the Gaming Historian

11: The Finger-in-the-Wendy’s-Chili & Government Corruption

10: The Honors Student Murder & the Wrongful Conviction of Lamonte McIntyre

9: The April Fools Edition: Pranks and Hoaxes Gone Wrong

8: The Blue-Eyed Butcher & the Illegitimate Con Artist

7: The Toxic Tush Doctor & the Torn Love Letters

6: Smiling Bob & the Slender Man Stabbings

5: The Ultimate Plot Twist & the Innocent Family Photos

4: The West Memphis Three & The Corn Flake Brothers

3: Hulk Hogan’s Sex Tape & the Killer Doctor

2: Anna Nicole Smith & the Downfall of the KKK

1: Charles Manson Trial & the Diluting Pharmacist