All Episodes

Episode #168 - Steve Wilkos Talks Career In True Crime

Another Shot #90 - Daryn’s Tik Tok Progress

Episode #167 - Self-Defense or Murder?

Another Shot #89 - Daryn Is Frankenfurter

Episode #166 - Killer Driver

Another Shot #88 - Actress Arielle Kebbel talks “Lincoln Rhyme: Hunt For The Bone Collector"

Episode #165 - Murders in the Snow

Bonus: Director Trish Wood Talks New Ted Bundy Docuseries

Another Shot #87 - Brooklyn Live Show Recap

Episode #166 - Nun Murdered in Broad Daylight

Another Shot #86 - Brooklyn Live Show Predictions

Episode #165 - The Absinthe Murders (With Guest Bartender John deBary)

Another Shot #85 - Don’t F*ck with Daryn’s Cats

Episode #164 - A Montana Murder

Another Shot #84 - The Great Tik Tok Debate

Episode #163 - Our Favorite Moments 2019 - Part II

Episode #162 - Our Favorite Moments 2019 - Part I

Episode #161 - Carjacking Conspiracy

Another Shot #83 - Toys and Relationships

Episode #160 - Medical Murder

Another Shot #82 - Live Show Announcements

Episode #159 - Bodies in the Pig Pen

Another Shot #82 - Terra Newell Talks Dirty John and New Podcast

Episode #158 - The Disappearance of the Millbrook Twins - Part II (With Buddy Day and David Karabinas)

Another Shot #81 - Matt’s Weird Thanksgiving

Episode #157 - The Disappearance of the Millbrook Twins - Part I

Another Shot #80 - Daryn Saves BravoCon

Episode #156 - Interview with Sonny Valicenti from Netflix’s 'Mindhunter'

Episode #155 - Toothpaste and Bloody Murder

Another Shot #79 - Matt Shits Down Boston

Episode #154 - She Was Found In The Tub

Another Shot #78 - A Tersch of Halloween

Bonus: Catching Up with Lance and Tim of ‘Missing Maura Murray'

Episode #153 - The Mystery of Room 1046

Another Shot #77 - Let's Go To Therapy!

Episode #152 - The Matthew Shepard Case

Another Shot #76 - Coming Out And Growing Up

Episode #151 - ‘Relentless’ Mom Helps Police Solve Son’s Murder

Bonus: Randy Havens Talks “Stranger Things” and Murder

Another Shot #75 - Daryn's Windows 98 Vacation + Come See Us In Boston!

Episode #150 - Kate Snow Talks “Relentless” and Dateline

Another Shot #74 - Past Lives

Episode #149 - Sex Calls, Psychics, and Murder

Another Shot #73 - Alien Abductions

Episode #148 - House of Cards and Murder

Another Shot #72 - Nerd Flares

Episode #147 - True Crime Obsessed Visits (With Patrick Hinds & Gillian Pensavalle)

Another Shot #71 - How Criminal Are We?

Episode #146 - Abductions at Folly Beach

Another Shot #70 - Billy Jensen

Episode #145 - The Cornfield Killer

Another Shot #69 - Psychic Readings & Mice

Episode #144 - The Kiss of Death

Another Shot #68 - Matt's Arms (Gross!)

Episode #143 - Author Maureen Callahan Talks Israel Keyes (Deluxe Episode)

Another Shot #67 - Sherri Shepherd & Gia Mantegna

Episode #142 - Buddy Day Talks Charles Manson

Another Shot #66 - Adults Don't Do This

Episode #141 - Assumed Identity

Another Shot #65 - Clowns in the Woods

Episode #140 - The Taco Bell Strangler

Another Shot #64 - National Tequila Day (with Not Another True Crime Podcast)

Bonus: Nancy Grace Talks Michelle Carter

Episode #139 - Did Michelle Carter Kill Conrad Roy?

Another Shot #63 - Crabs on the Subway

Episode #138 - Gypsy Rose Blanchard & Nick Godejohn

Another Shot #62 - Dog Sitting and Our Ride-Or-Dies

Episode #137 - Jan Broberg talks Robert Berchtold Abduction

Another Shot #61 - Nancy Grace Talks 'Injustice'

Episode #136 - Murdered in Broad Daylight

Another Shot #60 - Happy World Pride!

Episode #135 - Kathy Kleiner Talks Surviving Ted Bundy

Another Shot #59 - John the Spice Boy

Episode #134 - Death Before Divorce

Another Shot #58 - CrimeCon 2019 Recap

Episode #133 - The Bunny Phone Murder

Another Shot #57 - Listening To Your Voicemails

Episode #132 - The Killing of Bruiser Brody (with Vince Averill)

Another Shot #56 - Murderino Party Recap with Vince Averill

Episode #131 - A Body in the Garden

Bonus: The Secret Episode About Daryn

Another Shot #55 - Milkshakes & Magic Returns

Episode #130 - John Douglas Talks Career and New Book

Episode #129 - Slain By A Stripper

Another Shot #54 - Daryn’s Paris Hilton Story

Episode #128 - Murder By Proxy

Another Shot #53 - Matt Wins a SAD Award

Bonus Episode: Stephanie Bauer and Buddy Day Talk The Disappearance of Susan Cox Powell

Episode #127 - The Disappearance of Susan Cox Powell (With Parents Chuck and Judy Cox)

Another Shot #52 - Awkward Celebrity Moments

Episode #126 - The Case of Mirinda Boob and Kermit Butts

Another Shot #51 - John Breaks His Silence

Episode #125 - The Railroad Killer

Another Shot #50 - You Guys Twins??

Episode #124 - A Real Life Murder Mystery Dinner

Another Shot #49 - The 'John's Favorite Things' Edition

Episode #123 - Rodney Alcala, The Dating Game Killer

Another Shot #48 - April Fools!

Episode #122 - An Almost Contract Killing

Another Shot #47 - Gramercy Theatre Live Show Recap