All episodes

The Origins of Spirit Boards/Ouija [History]

Werewolves [Lore/True Crime]

Spooky Travels [Hiatus Catch Up]

Out of the Average Media Review [July 2021]

Candle Cove [Creepy Pasta]

Fox Sisters [Spiritualism/History]

Game Theory [Psych/Maths]

Out of the Average Media Review [June 2021]

Summer Solstice [Traditions/History]

Twin Flames [Theory]

Haunted Lakes [Hauntings/Local Lore]

Out of the Average Media Review [May 2021]

Tulpas and Thought-forms [Mysticism]

Haunted Dolls [Hauntings/Oddities]

Red String of Fate [Chinese/East Asian Mythology]

Out of the Average Media Review [April 2021]

The Witchcraft Trial of Goody Garlick [History]

Liminality [General Discussion]

Hilaria [History/Mythology w/ guest Melissa Pavlovsky]

Out of the Average Media Review [March 2021]

Pythagorean Numerology

Pythagoras and his "Cult" [History]

Flannan Isles Lighthouse Mystery [History/Mystery]

Out of the Average Media Review [Feb 2021]

Growing through Dreams [w/ guest Jamie Schumann]

Cupid and Psyche [OOTA Anniversary]

Cults, Crackers, and Cornflakes [History/Food]

Out of the Average Media Review [January 2021]

Sleep Paralysis [w/ guest Melissa Pavlovsky]

Baba Yaga [Slavic Folklore]

Welcome 2021! [General Discussion]

That's a Wrap [Folklore/History]

Gods, Goddesses, and Squid Monsters [w/ guest Tiffany - Priestess Theophania]

Presence and Mistletoe [Mythology]

Out of the Average Media Review [November 2020]

Nicolas Flamel [Man or Myth?]

Izanagi and Izanami [Japanese Mythology]

Halloween 2020

Out of the Average Media Review [October 2020]

Feminine Frankenstein [Literature/History]

Béla Kiss [True Crime]

Ley Lines [Theory]

Out of the Average Media Review [September 2020]

Dreams [Discussion]

The Hill Abduction [Aliens] w/ guest Melissa Pavlovsky

Starseeds [Introduction and Races]

Monkey’s Paw [Short Story]

Tea for Two [Superstitions/Tasseomancy]

Toilet Dreams [National Twin Day]

Past Lives Update

M.I.B.-An Introduction [Conspiracy]

Tickled in Riverdale [Conspiracy]

BONUS: "The Secret" Update & Rice Ghoul

Two Tales of Treasure [Treasure Hunts]

Horse Beings [Mythology]

The Watcher and Black-Eyed Children [Urban Legends]

No New Episode [BLM]

The Moberly-Jourdain Incident [Time Slip]

Time Travel [Media]

The Curse of Oak Island [Season 7 Opinions]

Bonus: Big News!

Past Life Part 2 [Religious Past Life Overview]

Meaghan Wall of Sacred Numbers Finance [Interview]

Past Life Part 1 [General Past Life Overview]

Southaven Park Crash [UFO]

Consciousness Shift and Anthropic Principle [Alternate Reality Bonus]

The Ghost House [Ghost Stories]

“The Storyteller at a Loss” [Celtic Fairy Tale]

Fairies [Celtic Mythology]

Alternate Reality Nosebleed [AR Overview]

Valentine's Day [Lupercalia]

Out of the Average (Trailer)