All episodes
Episode 108 Allagash Abduction
After Dark: EP 19 - Worship & Tribute NERD Invasion
Episode 105 The Hypnotist Show We Watched
Episode 104 Celebrity Stalkers
How To Start A Podcast
Bonus: The Man Who Killed Hitler And Then The Bigfoot (Film Review)
Monster Madness (2019) Ep5: Finals
Monster Madness (2019) Ep4: Dobhar-chú VS Impundulu
Monster Madness (2019) Ep3: Fur Fish VS Mongolian Death Worm
Monster Madness (2019) Ep2: Succubus VS Grootslang
Bonus: Hellier (Documentary Discussion)
Monster Madness (2019) Ep1: Goatman VS Leprechaun
Monster Madness (2019) Inaugural
Episode 103 Alabama Leprechaun
Episode 102 The Little To No Research Quiz
Episode 101 Toby's Family's Spooky Paranormal Stories
Episode 100 LIVE Game Show Celebration!
Episode 99 Possession
Episode 98 Vampires
Episode 97 Zombies
Not Our Episode?
Mothman Festival 2018
After Dark: EP 17 - Helpful Guide for Mothman Festival?
Episode 96 Back To School (Crimes, Paranormal, and UFO Stories at School)
Secret Theater 2999: EP 4 - The Source Family
Episode 95 Tulpas
Episode 94 Wrestling Conspiracies
Episode 93 Shoko Asahara and Aum Shinrikyo Cult
Episode 92 Betty Andreasson Abduction
After Dark: EP 16 - The 16 Hour Drive In The Future
Episode 91 Disney Parks (Facts, Myths, & Tragedy) (W/ Guest: Bob from Nerd Or Not Podcast)
Episode 90 Friday the 13th & The 13 Club (LIVE Recording)
Episode 89 Cadborosaurus (Take Over with Zeng This & Monsters Among Us)
Summer 2018 - Toby's Mom's Paranormal Experiences (Patreon Replay)
Summer 2018 - Dark Council - Greek Mythology (Replay)
Summer 2018 - Dark Council - Mothman (Replay)
SHOW NEWS AND UPDATES (SUMMER 2018)
Secret Theater 2999: EP 3 - Alien Autopsy: Fact or Fiction
Episode 88 UPDATE Washington State Poltergeist (Keith Linder Interview)
Episode 87 Kelly–Hopkinsville Encounter
Episode 86 Montauk Project
Episode 85 DB Cooper
After Dark: EP 15 Zenger... You're Always There For Us
BONUS: Texas Podacalypse Meet Up! (4/21/18)
Episode 84 Doomsday Predictions
SPECIAL: Rudy's Totally Unfair Game Show
Episode 83 Richard Kuklinski: The Iceman
Monster Madness (2018): Ep 5 The Championship Battle
Monster Madness (2018) Ep4: Jersey Devil & Dover Demon
Monster Madness (2018) Ep3: Mongolian Death Worm & Flatwoods Monster
Monster Madness (2018) Ep2: Hawkesbury River Monster & J'ba Fofi
Monster Madness (2018) Ep1: Wampus Cat & Honey Island Swamp Monster
After Dark: EP 14 - Monster Madness Inaugural
Secret Theater 2999: EP 2 - Love and Saucers
Episode 82 MK Ultra
Episode 81 Simulation Theory
Secret Theater 2999: EP 1 - Extraordinary: the Stan Romanek Story
Episode 80 Bohemian Grove
Episode 79 2 or 3 Year Anniversary Spectacular
After Dark: EP 13 - Will You....
Episode 78 Christmas Crimes (Late Holiday Special)
Episode 77 Simpsons Predictions (Feat Best Darn Diddly Review Show)
Episode 76 Titanic Conspiracy
Episode 75 Mandela Effect 2: Mandela Harder, Judgment Day
Episode 74 Black Eyed Kids
TAKE OVER: The DeRailers Podcast - Canadian Cryptids & Legends
SPECIAL: Curse of the Man Who Sees UFOS Review (Feat. Zenger from Zeng This & David from Blurry Photos)
Episode 73 CERN
After Dark: EP 12 - The Boy Who Cried Tummy Ache
Episode 72 Go To Hell (HELL-OWEEN SPECIAL)
Episode 71 Werewolves (Lycanthrope)
Episode 70 Witches and Witchcraft
After Dark: EP 11 - Am I Psychic?
Episode 69 Sex (Facts, Myths, Cryptids, and True Crime) [NSFW]
Episode 68 Phil Schneider
Episode 67 Voodoo
Episode 66 Sky Trumpets
Episode 65 Jim Jones and the Jonestown Massacre
After Dark: EP 10 - Kristen and Rudy Show... Not Toby
Episode 64 DFW Local Legends (Best Darn Diddly TAKE OVER)
Episode 63 Rasputin
Episode 62 Close Encounters (Hynek's Scale)
Episode 61 Spooky Slumber Party Games
Episode 60 Drugs
Episode 59 Slender Man
Episode 58 Ghost Stories 2: Listener Submitted Paranormal Experiances
AFTER DARK: EP 9 - Nerd Out (Featuring Zeng This! Podcast)
Episode 57 Flat Earth VS Round Earth Trial
Episode 56 Georgia Guidestones
Episode 55 Backmasking 2: Backmask Harder
Episode 54 Jeffrey Dahmer
AFTER DARK: EP 8 - Tin Foil Hats and Canadians (Featuring The Wrassle Nerds)
Episode 53 9/11
Episode 52 Cryptid Talk (With The Royal We Podcast)
Episode 51 Area 51
Episode 50 bensplayhouse [Interview with "ben"]
Episode 49 Oklahoma City Bombing
Episode 48 Waco Siege
Episode 47 Ruby Ridge Standoff
After Dark: Ep 7 - We're back! ...and April is the worst month?