All Episodes

Strange Stories: Middle School Sextortion

Strange Stories: Booty Burger

Strange Stories: Marinated Assault

Strange Stories: Perilous Patio

True Crime: The Staircase | Part 2

True Crime: The Staircase | Part 1

Strange Stories: Scuba Robbery

Strange Stories: Batman Burglary

Strange Stories: Ed Gein

True Crime: Ted Bundy

True Crime: John Wayne Gacy

True Crime: Jeffrey Dahmer

True Crime: Gilgo Beach Killer

Strange Stories: Killer Son Confession

Strange Stories: Single-Date Stalker

Strange Stories: Body on the Golf Course

Strange Stories: State Trooper Tragedy

True Crime: Hall-Mills Murders

Strange Stories: D.B. Cooper

True Crime: Cleveland Torso Killer

True Crime: Tylenol Murders

Strange Stories: Holiday Party

Severed Podcast Trailer

Strange Stories: Identity Theft Romance

Strange Stories: DUI in a DeLorean

Strange Stories: Silence of the Lambs Killer

True Crime: Lizzie Borden

Strange Stories: Tainted Teacher

Strange Stories: NYPD Blew It

Strange Stories: Abandoned Kayak

Strange Stories: Deviant

Paranormal: NJ Urban Legends 2

Paranormal: Myrtles Plantation

Strange Stories: Napa Valley Murders

Strange Stories: Pumpkin Pounce

Strange Stories: Brawl at the Mall

Strange Stories: Rage Quitting

Strange Stories: Burger Bandit

Strange Stories: Money Baller

Strange Stories: Mom Goes Ballistic

Strange Stories: Superintendent of Fools

Strange Stories: Chuck E. Skeeze

Strange Stories: Afterlife Airways

Strange Stories: Body in the Backyard

Strange Stories: Taylor Slam, Egg & Cheese

Strange Stories: Copsicle

Strange Stories: High While Hiking

Strange Stories: Lawn & Disorder

True Crime: Times Square Killer

True Crime: Murder on Mulberry St.

True Crime: The Sullivanians

True Crime: Son of Sam

Paranormal: House of Death

True Crime: Seduction of Jane Doe

Strange Stories: Buying Bones

Strange Stories: Hamptons Spa Murder

Paranormal: The Stanley Hotel

Strange Stories: Ditched Delivery

Strange Stories: CarMax Crash

Strange Stories: Police Chief Pranks

Strange Stories: Bear Attack Bandits

Strange Stories: Party Principal

Paranormal: The Sallie House

True Crime: Luigi Mangione

Strange Stories: Gross-ery Store

True Crime: Pastor Eli Regalado

True Crime: Lorena Bobbitt

True Crime: Amy Fisher

Strange Stories: Au Pair Affair

Strange Stories: Racquetball Romance

Strange Stories: Lured in the Psych Ward

Streaming: Who Killed JonBenét Ramsey | Part 2

Streaming: Who Killed JonBenét Ramsey | Part 1

True Crime: Montclair Spies

Strange Stories: Gift-Wrapped Weed

Strange Stories: New Jersey Drones

Strange Stories: Eggnog Explosion

Streaming: 'Twas the Fight Before Christmas (2021)

Strange Stories: Serial Killer Santa

Streaming: Murder, Center Stage (2024)

Strange Stories: Wicked Website

Streaming: This is the Zodiac Speaking (2024)

#TBT: Boo-ze & Busted: The Conjuring House

Strange Stories: Dunkin' Danger

Streaming: Woman of the Hour (2024)

Strange Stories: Missing in the Pine Barrens

Streaming: Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story (2024)

Strange Stories: Coca-Cola Confessions

Streaming: American Nightmare (2024)

Strange Stories: Nudist Ranch Murders

Streaming: Wise Guy: David Chase & The Sopranos (2024)

Strange Stories: Florida Man Pizza

Streaming: American Murder: Laci Peterson (2024)

Strange Stories: Ghosted & Fired

Severed Streaming: Baby Reindeer (2024)

Bonus: Season 1 Reflections & Outtakes

Mini Episode: The Secret Room

Paranormal: Burn Brae Mansion

Bonus: Sleepy Hollow Cemetery

Mini Episode: Death to Donuts

Paranormal: The Haunted Ackley House

Mini Episode: The Keepers: Case Updates

True Crime: Sister Cathy Cesnik (The Keepers)

Mini Episode: Scandal in Setauket

Mini Episode: Exorcism & Possession with Prof. Darryl Caterine

True Crime: Rev. Canon Paul Wancura

Mini Episode: The Satanic Panic

Paranormal: Arne Johnson

Mini Episode: Butch DeFeo Prison Interviews

Mini Episode: Butch DeFeo Trial

Streaming: Amityville II: The Possession (1982)

Mini Episode: Listener Questions

Paranormal: Amityville Horror: Part III

Mini Episode: We Ate The Death Seat Burger

Streaming: The Amityville Horror (1979)

Paranormal: Amityville Horror: Part 2

The Amityville Horror with Prof. Darryl Caterine, Religious Studies

Paranormal: The Amityville Horror: Part I

Mini Episode: Conjuring House Tour

Paranormal: The Conjuring House

Mini Episode: #GypsyRose

True Crime: Gypsy Rose Blanchard

Mini Episode: Ice Cream from Holsten's

True Crime: The Ice Man

Mini Episode: The Death Seat at the Old Canal Inn

Paranormal: NJ Urban Legends

Mini Episode: Visiting the John List House

True Crime: John List

Mini Episode: Visiting the Watcher House

True Crime: The Westfield Watcher