All Episodes
Shaken and Disturbed — 388 episodes · page 1 of 4
I'm Just A Baby (No Scary Movies) - NMR #95
"Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart" Netflix Documentary Reaction - #230
The Dentist or Ed Gein? Make Your Pick - Flashback to NMR #94
Unholy Murder: The Crimes of Father Hans Schmidt - #229
"Unknown Number" Netflix Documentary Reaction - Flashback to #207
Netflix's "Maternal Instinct" Reaction: How Could A Mother Do This? - #228
U.S. Nope-N - NMR #94
The Chaotic Truth of Jeremy Thorpe - #227
Cheers Bith! - NMR #93
Netflix's "A Toxic Love Story": The INSANE Case of Michelle Hadley & Ian Diaz - #226
Magic Keeps Screaming - Flashback to NMR #92
Bonus: Nancy Guthrie Ransom Note Reaction and Analysis
Harvard Cold Case Solved After 50 Years - #225
Is It a Pokemon Or A Prescription Drug? - NMR #88
Buried In Her Backyard - #224
Explosive Diary Uh - NMR #87
The Chicago Rippers - Flashback to #202
Snoopy Is A Big Gorl - NMR #86
"The Crash" Netflix Documentary Reaction - #223
John and David Archuleta Made Contact - Flashback to NMR #86
Vinnie Politan Talks 'VPI: Vinnie Politan Investigates' - #222
Serial Plant Murderers - NMR #85
Cowboy Killers: The History of Gower Gulch - #221
Cotton Candy and Cowboy Carp - Flashback to NMR #84
"Trust Me: The False Prophet" Netflix Documentary Reaction - #220
Enchiladas Are Not Sports - NMR #109
"The Truth and Tragedy of Moriah Wilson" Netflix Documentary Reaction - #219
Mama's Not Messin' Around! - NMR #108
"The Perfect Neighbor" Netflix Documentary Reaction - #218
Why Is There Blood? - NMR #107
Executed at 21: The Controversial Conviction of Tommy Lee Walker - #217
Lady Gaga Ticket Disaster Turned Miracle - NMR #106
Did An Alligator Eat Her Husband? - Flashback to #193
Charizard-arita Is Not a Pokemon - NMR #104
Survival In South Africa - #216
Thrasher and Carp Pairs Ice Skating Duo - NMR #103
The Sunnyvale Tragedy - #215
When AI Solves Your Problems - NMR #102
The Square Mile of Murder - #214
Are You Sleeping In Trash? - NMR #101
Elmer McCurdy: The Bandit Who Wouldn't Give Up - #213
Hale and Hearty Heartbreak - NMR #100
Ask Us Anything 2025 (Part 2)
Ask Us Anything 2025 (Part 1)
Happy Holidays, Your Cat Is Obese - NMR #99
John's Mysterious Grocery Store Boyfriend - Flashback NMR #56
Selena - #212
Daryn Recaps BravoCon 2025 - NMR #98
Robert Maudsley: The Dark Journey of Britain’s Most Isolated Prisoner - #211
Are Squirrels Muscular? - NMR #97
Fear, Faith and the Final Decision - #210
Raining Deer Bones - NMR #96
"Psychic" Scams Victims Out of Millions - #209
Must Nuts Go In Everything? - NMR #95
The Killdozer: What Drove Marvin Heemeyer Over The Edge? - #208
The Dentist or Ed Gein? Make Your Pick. - NMR #94
Her Best Friends Killed Her - Flashback to #173
19 Different SAH-mples - NMR #93
"Unknown Number" Netflix Documentary Reaction - #207
Her Husbands Keep Dying - #206
Magic Keeps Screaming - NMR #92
"Devil in the Desert" with ABC News' Matt Gutman - #205
Socks In An Airplane Bathroom? - NMR #91
Horror In Ocean City, Maryland - #204
Who's Your Zaddy Now? - NMR #90
The Goleta Postal Shootings - #203
A Cherry Obituary - NMR #89
Horror In Knoxville (Flashback to #170)
Prepare For Torture, John - NMR #88
The Chicago Rippers - #202
Karen Read + John's Tony Awards Weekend - NMR #87
"Sherri Papini: Caught In a Lie" Documentary Reaction - #201
John and David Archuleta Made Contact - NMR #86
The Killer Cadets - #200