All episodes
S4 Ep52: A Literal Dumpster Fire: The Centralia, PA Fires
S4 Ep51: BONUS! Interview with podcaster Branden Morgan
S4 Ep50: Case Update: The Disappearance of Asha Degree
S4 Ep49: New Kid, Who Dis? The Curious Case of Bobby Dunbar/Bruce Anderson
S4 Ep48: Say What Now? The Copiales 3 Cipher
S4 Ep47: Get Thee to a Therapist! The Great Amherst "Mystery"
S4 Ep46: Vortices, and Portals, and Lights! Oh My! The Phoenix Lights and Other Strange Goings On in Arizona
Introducing Excelsior Journeys: The Road to Creativity
S4 Ep45: A Beast by Any Other Name Would Smell as Rank: The Australian Bigfoot, Yowie
S4 Ep44: That Time Democracy Almost Collapsed: The Forgotten History of Smedley Butler and the Plot to Overthrow FDR
S4 Ep43: Three's (Tragic) Company: The Disappearance of The Springfield Three
S4 Ep42: There's a Ghost in my Quarter Pounder! Haunted Fast Food Restaurants
S4 Ep41: A Future Foretold? The Wreck of the Titan
Introducing: CRIME HOUSE TRUE CRIME STORIES
S4 Ep40: No One Mourns the "Wicked": Jack the Ripper and his Victims
S4 Ep39: Squonkapalooza!
S4 Ep38: Bullied to Death? The Tragic and Untimely Death of Aubreigh Wyatt
S4 Ep37: Tragedy on the Tarmac at Tenerife: The Deadliest Airplane Accident in History
S4 Ep36: Art Imitating Life or Vice Versa? The Stanley Hotel
Introducing The In Between Podcast
S4 Ep35: A Terrible Episode of SVU: The Disappearance of Bianca Carrasco
S4 Ep34: Ford! The Engine that Drove the Holocaust
S4 Ep33: He Will Never be Satisfied: Tarrare, the Man who Ate Everything
S4 Ep32: Jessica Buttafuoco is Coming for Them: Special Bonus episode interview with Jessica Buttafuoco
S4 Ep31: "I Want to Go Home." The Many Lives of Dorothy Eady/Omm Sety
S4 Ep30: A Race to the Bottom: Charles Dawson and the Piltdown Man
S4 Ep29: It's a Twista! The Terrifying Facts Whirling Inside Tornadoes
Special Bonus Episode! My interview with Past Life regression coach Michelle Brock!
S4 Ep28: The Strange Adventure of Donald Crowhurst
S4 Ep27: Maybe it's Demons, Maybe it's Spiritual Munchausen by Proxy: The House of 200 Demons
S4 Ep26: I Predict a Riot: The Tulsa Massacre
S4 Ep25: 50 Years Ago Today: The Murder of Timothy O'Bryan and the Ensuing Halloween Candy Panic
S4 Ep24: This is Not a Game of Clue: The Murder of Robert Wone
S4 Ep23: The Viral Dent-Headed Ghost Boy: Dear David
Presenting "Candyman: The True Story Behind The Bathroom Mirror Murder"
S4 Ep22: It's the Infrastructure, Stupid! The great Johnstown Flood of 1889
S4 Ep21: Here Come The Brown Shirts?
S4 Ep20: A Tragic Twist of Fate: The Lane Bryant Murders
S4 Ep19: Gone without a Trace: The Disappearance of Bryan Vladek Hasel
S4 Ep18: Chicks and Ducks and Geese Better Scurry! Here Comes The Jersey Devil!
S4 Ep17: Billionaire Tragedy: The Unsolved Murders of Barry and Honey Sherman
S4 Ep16: I Seem to have Forgotten My…Self: The Perplexing Mystery of Fritz Johnson and/or Larry Bader
S4 Ep15: Hijacked Cryptid! The Legend of Ogopogo
S4 Ep14: Mother Nature vs. The Hubris of Man: The Great Galveston Storm of 1900
S4 Ep13: A Hunka Hunka…Melting Wax? Is Elvis Still Alive?
S4 Ep12: Voodoo and Torture and Witchcraft, Oh My! The legend of the White Witch of Rose Hall
S4 Ep11: Justice Delayed. Justice Denied: The Dr. Sam Sheppard Story Part 2
S4 Ep10: Trials and Tribulations: The Dr. Sam Sheppard Story pt. 1
S4 Ep9: In Nicolas Cage we DON'T Trust! The President's Book of Secrets
What Lurks Beneath: The Loch Ness Monster & Other Creatures of the Deep
S4 Ep8: Gone Amidst the Chaos: The Disappearance of Sneha Philip
S4 Ep7: Beware the Lesbians!! The Attack of the Lavender Menace
S4 Ep6: Ghosts of Gettysburg
S4 Ep5: A Mighty Wind: An Improbable Incident on the Mackinac Bridge
From Crimes Of The Centuries: The Defeo Murders, Behind the Amityville Horror
S4 Ep4: Staircases of Doom!
S4 Ep3: HH Holmes' Murder Hotel?
S4 Ep2: The Haunting Tale of the Mary Celeste
S4 Ep1: Henrietta Lacks: The Cells Heard Round the World
S3: From Grab Bag Collab: The Catalyst
S3 Ep46: Time Keeps on Slipping into the Future
S3 Ep45: Suzy’s Simple Solutions: The Angel Makers of Narygev
S3 Ep44: Hello From the Other Side: Wind Phones & After Death Communications
S3 Ep43: Ley Lines: Connecting the Dots from Fables to Fakes
S3 Ep42: Boot Scootin’ Cryptid Yee-Haw at Skinwalker Ranch
S3 Ep41: Not Another Statistic: Savanna LaFontaine-Greywind
S3 Ep40: Not So Fast, Spontaneous Human Combustion!
S3 Ep39: The Incident at Falcon Lake
S3 Ep38: Slenderman: From Memes to Murder
S3 Ep37: Impossible Crimes: Locked Room Mysteries
S3 Ep36: Borley Rectory: The Most Haunted House In England
S3 Ep35: Don’t Buy Any Green Bananas: The Long Con of Richard Walter
S3 Ep34: Alien Territory: The Human Body
S3 Ep33: Here’s to The Ladies Who Time Travel
S3 Ep32: Hide Your Goats: Chupacabras On The Loose!
S3 Ep31: It’s Gef’s World, we’re just living in it!
S3 Ep30: Dirty Deeds in the Dudgeon Swamp
S3 Ep29: The Prime Minister and Poseidon
S3 Ep28: Tulpas: Smarter Than Your Average Imaginary Friend
S3 Ep27: Up In Smoke: The Missing Sodder Children Mystery
S3 Ep26: Deadly Dalliance Down Under: The Bogle-Chandler Mystery
S3 Ep25: In the Seance Lab with Harry Price, Psychical Researcher
S3 Ep24: The Salem Witch Trials
S3 Ep23: Who Killed Anna Mae Aquash?
S3 Ep22: True He’s Gone: The Disappearance of Jim Sullivan
S3 Ep21: Turn on, Tune in, and Disappear: Where are Mitchell Weiser & Bonnie Bickwit?
S3 Ep20: Haunted Halls of The Congress Plaza Hotel
S3: Elevators: Terror and Death in a 6 by 6 Foot Box
S3 Ep19: The Truly Confounding Disappearance of the Yuba County Five
S3 Ep18: Club Kids & False Gods: The Party Monster Story
S3 Ep17: Silence on the Highway of Tears: What Happened to Alberta Williams?
S3 Ep16: Hey Grandma, The House Is Bleeding!
S3 Ep15: World’s Worst Dad: The Story of John List
S3 Ep14: Tamám Shud: The Mysterious Somerton Man
S3 Ep13: All Up In Your Head: Mysteries of Havana Syndrome
S3 Ep12: NostraDOH!mus: The Simpsons Predict the Future!
S3 Ep11: Johnny Gosch, Original Milk Carton Kid
S3 Ep10: Marsha P. Johnson: Hard Work Being Beautiful
S3 Ep9: How sad, How lovely: The Disappearance of Connie Converse
S3 Ep8: Get Down with the Sickness, It’s Societal Mania!