All Episodes

#46 - Bum Farto: A Fugitive From Justice

The 4 Types of Bigfoot Grifters

How I Went from Bigfoot Believer to Skeptic

///EMERGENCY BIGFOOT BRO MEETING///

#45 - The Botched Kidnapping of John Grundhofer

#44 - Planet Mars, Microbial Life, and You

#43 - El Chupacabra: A Puerto Rican Goat Sucker

#42 - The Texarkana Phantom Killer: The Unsolved Moonlight Murders

#41 - The Pascagoula UFO Incident

#40 - The 1995 San Diego Tank Rampage (A 30 Year Retrospective)

#39 - Escape From Alcatraz! (REVISITED)

#38 - 2024 Super Mystery Bros Halloween Mystery Mystery

#37 - Whatever Happened to Maura Murray?

#36 - The Florida Skunk Ape

(COMING SOON) Super Mystery Bros Phase II: Electric Boogaloo

#35 - The Westfield Watcher

#34 - The 300 Million Yen Robbery

#33 - Mokele-Mbembe, The Last Dinosaur

#32 - Mighty Morphin' Misfortune Rangers

#31 - Flight 19 and the Mystery of the Bermuda Triangle

#30 - Safety Not Guaranteed

#29 - The Ariel School UFO Landing of 1994

#28 - The Vanishing of the Thai Silk King – Jim Thompson

#27 - The Legend of Sky King - A Millennial Folk Hero

#26 - Dee Snider's Twisted Paranormal Story - A Festivus Special

#25 - David Glenn Lewis (AKA Moxee John Doe)

#24 - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

#23 - Super Mystery Bros Halloween Nightmare-A-THON

#22 - The Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp

#21 - D.B Cooper and his Legendary Leap

Super Mystery Bros 1-Year Celebra-thon

#20 - The Phoenix Lights of 1997

#19 - The Oakville Blobs - A Gelatinous Mystery

#18 - The Sinister Death of John Lang

#17 - The I-70 Killer

#16 - The Kuzbass Yeti

#14 - The Whaley House: America's Most Haunted

#13 – Gold, Conspiracy, & Misfortune – Leon Trabuco’s Lost Treasure

(BONUS) Peter's Mongolian Couch Surfing Story

#12 - The Mongolian Death Worm

#11 - The Mothman, man.

10 Episodes: A Retrospective

#10 - The Max Headroom Incident

#9.2 - (OPTIONAL) Betty Hill Hypnosis Tapes

#9.1 - (OPTIONAL) Barney Hill Hypnosis Tapes

#9 - The Betty and Barney Hill UFO Abduction

#8 - The Baffling Disappearance of Brian Shaffer

#7 - The Hole in the Ground Gang

#6 - The Mad Pooper of Pine Creek

#5 - The Mysterious Disappearance of Frederick Valentich

#4 - The Axeman of New Orleans - 2022 Super Mystery Bros Halloween SCARE-A-THON

#3 - The 1962 Alcatraz Prison Escape

#2 - The Shadow People Phenomenon

#1 - The Fresno Nightcrawler

Welcome to Super Mystery Bros!