All Episodes
The McShay Show — 228 episodes
Can Indiana Become a Dynasty? Plus, Scouting QB Josh Hoover.
Demond Williams Jr. vs. Drew Mestemaker: Who’s the Better NFL Prospect?
Nico Iamaleava vs. Jayden Maiava. Plus, Our Rough Draft 2027 QB Rankings.
John Mateer vs. Trinidad Chambliss: Making the Case for Smaller QBs
Sam Leavitt vs. Darian Mensah: Which QB Transfer Is the Better NFL Prospect?
CJ Carr vs. Julian Sayin: Talking Traits, NFL Comps, Ceilings, and More
The Manning Passing Academy: MVPs, 2027 QB Lessons, Camp Surprises, and More
A Brendan Sorsby Supplemental Draft PSA. Plus, Scouting LaNorris Sellers.
Building the Board: Arch Manning vs. Dante Moore for 2027 QB1
Brendan Sorsby to the NFL?! Breaking Down Every Angle With Albert Breer.
Our Way-Too-Early 2027 QB Preview: The Highest Ceilings, Floors, and More
A 2027 Draft Primer: The Best Position Groups, Prospects, and Names to Know
Mailbag! Ohio State WR Rankings, the Rams’ Plans, a Sorsby Update, and More.
A Rookie Class Fantasy Football Preview. Plus, Hypothetical Over/Unders.
Rookie Class Predictions, Award Winners, and Superlatives
What We Got Wrong About the 2026 NFL Draft
Our Favorite Picks From Every Round of the 2026 NFL Draft
Talking Brendan Sorsby, Arch Manning, and the 2027 Class With Albert Breer
The Way-Too-Early 2027 Mock Draft: Arch Manning Vs. Dante Moore
The Best NFL Draft Classes, Biggest Steals, Boom or Bust Picks, and More
Our Favorite Day-Three Steals and QB Landing Spots
NFL Draft Second & Third Round Live Coverage
NFL Draft First Round Live Coverage
Mock 5.0: Todd’s Strongest Leans, Muench’s Favorite Picks, and Wild Cards
The Latest Top-12 Intel vs. What We Would Do in the First Round
NFL Draft Week Buzz: Everything I’m Hearing and a Top-10 Flash Mock
The Muench Mock! Plus, Why Did the Jets Cancel David Bailey’s Visit?
Mock 4.0! Plus, Frank Caliendo Joins the Show for a Trip Down Memory Lane.
Our Top-200 Big Board: Stacking Safeties, Second-Tier Edges, and WR Intel
First-Round Pivot Points, Jordyn Tyson Stock Watch, and the McShay Mailbag
Emptying the NFL Draft Notebook With Albert Breer
Our Top 150 Big Board Risers and Fallers. Plus, Don’t Be Surprised If …
Will Mendoza or Cousins Start? Plus, the Draft Outliers Confidence Index With Bain, Simpson, Lemon, and More.
A Taylen Green Epiphany. Plus, Indiana and Jermod McCoy Pro Day Reactions.
A Top-10 Surprise, Draft Dominoes, Big Board Buy or Sell, and Mendoza News
Our Updated Top-100 Big Board: Buying and Selling Round 1-3 Prospects
Ty Simpson Pro Day Reactions, Mock 3.0 Second-Round Standouts, and More
Mock Draft 3.0! Love’s Market, Simpson’s Fall, and More Round 1 Takeaways.
2026 RB Deep Dive: Love’s Comps, Our Favorite Prospects, and Finding RB2
2026 WR Deep Dive: Finding WR1, Favorite Comps, and Don’t Be Surprised If …
The 2026 QB Deep Dive: Mendoza’s Comp, a New QB3, the 2027 Factor, and More
Mailbag! Shedeur’s Future, RB and TE Notes, the Steelers’ Next QB, and More
FLASH MOCK! Plus, Free Agency Frenzy and Maxx Crosby Fallout.
Free Agency Draft Dominoes! Plus, Pound-the-Table Day Two Prospects.
Our Post-Combine Top-100 Big Board! Plus, Trent McDuffie Trade Reactions.
NFL Combine Recap: The Workout Warriors, Risers, and Lessons from Indy
Day Six From the Combine: Carnell Tate, Jeremiyah Love, Taylen Green, and more
Day Five From the Combine: Kenyon Sadiq, Eli Stowers, Dillon Thieneman, and more
Day Four From the Combine: Sonny Styles' Historic Day, Arvell Reese and more standouts from the EDGE, IDL, and LB Classes.
Day Three From the Combine: Previewing the Potentially Historic Edge Class
Day Two From the Combine: Prospects Under the Most Pressure in Indy. Plus, Titans GM Mike Borgonzi.
Combine Coverage Day One: Intel and Evaluating Who Is Primed to Shine in Indy. Plus, Patriots EVP Eliot Wolf.
Todd’s Pre-Combine Top-50 Big Board: A Surprise at 1, Mendoza Red Flags, and Other Takeaways. Plus, the Future of NFL Draft Psychological Testing.
Second-Round Prospects to Know Before the Combine. Plus, Chambliss Fallout and 2027 QB Class Intel.
What Todd’s Hearing: Is Mendoza Worth It? Plus, the Draft’s Best Edge, WR Rankings, and More.
Mickey Loomis: Saints EVP & GM | The Decision Maker Series
Mock Draft 2.0: Mendoza Trade Offers, Reese’s NFL Comp, and More Round 1 Takeaways
Our Favorite 2026 Prospects and a Super Bowl NFL Draft Retrospective. Plus, Mailbag!
The Big Board: First-Round Locks, Finding QB3, and Post–Senior Bowl Buzz
Senior Bowl Week Takeaways: The Round 1 Locks, QB Standouts, and Under-the-Radar Prospects Who Popped in Mobile
Senior Bowl Day 3 Takeaways: Receivers Shine, Second Impressions, and Other Wednesday Standouts
Senior Bowl Day Two Takeaways: Edges Steal the Show, QB Quick-Hitters, and Breakout Prospects to Know
Nussmeier’s Hand Size and Other Senior Bowl Numbers to Know. Plus, Sam Darnold Scouting Redemption.
A Senior Bowl Primer With Executive Director Drew Fabianich. Plus, the Latest Intel on Trinidad Chambliss.
CFP Championship Reactions: Undefeated Indiana wins the 2026 CFP | The McShay Show
A CFP Title Game Preview With Todd Blackledge and Chris “The Bear” Fallica
Dante Moore’s Returning to Oregon! Instant Reactions and the 2026 NFL Draft Fallout.
Mendoza vs. Beck Tape Study, a Wild-Card Losers Flash Mock, and Muench’s Minutes 1.0
CFP Semifinal Reactions: Indiana Stays Perfect and Dominates Oregon | The McShay Show
CFP Semifinal Reactions: Beck Delivers in Miami's Dramatic Win over Ole Miss
Ty Simpson Declares for the Draft: Instant Reactions and Best Team Fits
Mock Draft 1.0: The Raiders’ QB Decision, an RB in the Top Three, and More First-Round Predictions
CFP Quarterfinals Reactions: Ole Miss Upsets, Indiana's Dominance, and Oregon Flies | The McShay Show
The 2025 NFL Redraft: A New QB1, Hunter Hindsight, and the Pats Pass on Campbell | The McShay Show
The Inaugural All–McShay Show Team: Our Favorite 2026 NFL Draft Prospects
CFP First Round Live Reactions: Miami, Alabama, Ole Miss and Oregon Advance | The McShay Show
A College Football Playoff Preview With Joel Klatt. Plus, Will Dante Moore and Ty Simpson Declare?
The College Football Playoff QB Confidence Draft. Plus, the Latest Transfer Portal Buzz.
FLASH MOCK! Plus, Building a College Football Front Office With Former Eagles VP Jake Rosenberg. | Rough Draft 1.7
College Football Playoff Selection Show Live Reactions! Miami Makes It! | The McShay Show
Big Ten Championship Reactions: Cignetti Stunner! Indiana Defeats Ohio State! | The McShay Show
SEC Championship Reactions: Kirby’s Best Coaching Job, Bama’s Bad Day, Ty Simpson’s Future, and More
The Big Ten and SEC Championship Player Draft | Rough Draft 1.6
Rivalry Week Tape Truths: Bama’s D, A&M’s Title Shot, ACC Playoff Hopes, and More
The Latest Intel on Lane to LSU, Golding at Ole Miss, Penn State’s Next Move, and DeBoer at Alabama
Week 14 Reactions: Buckeye Vengeance, Latest on Lane, and More Rivalry Reactions | The McShay Show
Previewing Ohio State–Michigan With Coach Urban Meyer. Plus, Talking Lane Kiffin’s Big Decision
Week 13 Tape Truths: Dante Moore’s NFL Comp, Alabama X Factors, Underwood Evaluations, and More | The McShay Show
Week 13 Reactions: Dante's Dilemma, Mateer's Chaos, and Lane Kiffin's Future | The McShay Show
Week 12 Tape Truths: Georgia’s Rise, Special RBs, and the College Football Coaching Carousel
Week 12 Reactions: Oklahoma On Top, Georgia's Guts, & A&M's Comeback | The McShay Show
Rough Draft 1.5: Dueling 2026 Mocks and the Latest Buzz from NFL Scouts
Week 11 Tape Truths: Mendoza's Draft Stock, Ty Simpson Is NFL Ready, and King Miller's Rise | The Mcshay Show
Week 11 Reactions: Alabama Rolls, Oregon Escapes, & Heis-Mendoza! | The McShay Show
Rough Draft 1.4: The Latest Risers, Fallers, and Behind-the-Scenes Intel on the 2026 QB Class
College Football Playoff Rankings Takeaways: Big Ten Sleepers, ACC Snubs, Big 12 Respect, and SEC Musical Chairs
10 Tape Truths From Week 10: Ohio State’s Challengers, the Loaded 2027 QB Class, Clemson’s Collapse, and More
Week 10 Reaction: Arch Arrives, ACC Chaos, and Inevitable Ohio State | The McShay Show
Rough Draft 1.3: Mailbag! Talking Untold Kiper Stories, the Best Non-QBs in the 2026 NFL Draft, the College Football Coaching Carousel, and More.
10 Tape Truths From Week 9: LSU’s Next Head Coach, Ole Miss Rising, Haynes King as Tebow 2.0, and More
Week 9 Reactions: Alabama Escapes, Chambliss Shines + Brian Kelly OUT?!
Rough Draft 1.2: Todd’s Midseason Big Board! Plus, Previewing Ole Miss–Oklahoma, Missouri-Vanderbilt, and Texas A&M–LSU
10 Tape Truths From Week 8: Finding Florida’s Next HC, Buying Julian Sayin Stock, Carson Beck Trust Issues, and More
Week 8 Reactions: Gunner's Growth, Pavia Prevails, and Alabama's Assassin
Rough Draft 1.1: Todd’s 2026 QB Rankings (Midseason Edition)
10 Tape Truths From Week 7: Elite Indiana, Ty Simpson Rising, Texas’s CFP Path, and More. Plus, the Latest Intel on James Franklin’s Firing.
Week 7 Reactions: Indiana Is Legit, James Franklin Is Finished, and SEC Squeakers | The McShay Show
The Rough Draft, Week 7: Scouting Notes and NFL Comps for Fernando Mendoza, Arvell Reese, and More. Plus, Talking Oklahoma-Texas and 'College GameDay' Atmospheres With Chris Fowler.
10 Tape Truths From Week 6: Notre Dame’s Playoff Push, Miami’s Case for No. 1, Alabama’s Rise, and More
Week 6 Reactions: Penn State's Problem, Miami's Dominance, Arch's Letdown | The McShay Show
Week 6 Tape Takes! Unfiltered Thoughts on Florida State–Miami, Vandy-Alabama, Texas-Florida, and More
10 Tape Truths From Week 5: Ohio State’s Defense, Alabama’s Upside, Penn State’s Slide, and Dante Moore's Climb
College Football Week 5 Takeaways: The Mighty Oregon Ducks, Bama Back On Track, and Lane Kiffin’s Last Laugh
Tape Takes! Our Unfiltered Thoughts on Oregon–Penn State, Georgia-Alabama, LSU–Ole Miss, and More Week 5 Matchups.
10 Truths from Week 4 of College Football. Plus, Finding the 2026 NFL Draft’s Mendoza Line.
Week 4 Reactions: Miami's Ceiling, Indiana's Precision, a New-Look Texas Tech, and More
What’s Going on With Arch Manning? Plus, Picking Indiana-Illinois, Florida-Miami, and More Week 4 Games With Stanford Steve.
Who Are the True CFP Contenders? Plus, the Latest Scouting Intel and Five NFL Draft Prospects on the Rise.
Week 3 LIVE: Clemson Collapses, Georgia Finds Its QB, and Texas A&M Upsets Notre Dame
The McShay Show LIVE: Todd’s 2026 QB Rankings, CFP Predictions, and a Week 3 Preview. Plus, Talking Caleb Williams and Big Ten Football With Dan “Big Cat” Katz.
QB Deep Dive: John Mateer’s Superhuman Saturday and Early Impressions of Arch Manning. Plus, Takeaways From Clemson, Florida, and Arizona State.
Week 2 Reactions: Mateer Magic, Florida's Flop, and Clemson Concerns | The McShay Show
The Year of the College Quarterback and NFL Rookies to Watch in Week 1
Carson Beck's Renaissance, Garrett Nussmeier's Master Class, and Everything Else that Mattered in CFB Week 1
Week 1 CFB Recap & Reactions Following LSU vs. Clemson | The McShay Show
10 Draft Prospects to Watch in Week 1 of College Football. Plus, a Mini Mailbag.
Why Clemson, Texas, and Penn State Top Todd’s Preseason Power Rankings
Todd’s College Football Power Rankings (6-4): Expectations for Alabama, Notre Dame, and Ohio State in 2025
Todd’s College Football Power Rankings (7-9): Expectations for LSU, Oregon, and Georgia in 2025
Todd’s College Football Power Rankings (10-12): Expectations for Oklahoma, Miami, and Florida in 2025
Todd’s 2026 Draft QB Tiers: The Names You Need to Know This College Football Season
Todd’s Preseason Mock Draft, Plus a BIG Show Announcement
College Football 101: Arch Manning’s Future, Transfer Portal Names to Know, 2026 NFL Draft Odds, and More
Draft-Eligible Defenders To Know for the College Football Season
The Race for WR1: Scouting 2026's Top Wide Receiver Prospects
McShay Show Offseason Mailbag! The 2026 Quarterback Class, Our Scouting Process, and More.
From Death Valley to the Draft: Why Clemson’s Defense Could Make History in 2025
Behind the Scenes at the Manning Passing Academy
Scouting Jeremiyah Love: The Notre Dame RB Looks Like a Future First-Rounder
Scouting Caleb Downs: Why the Ohio State Safety Might Be the Best Player in the 2026 Draft
Scouting Sam Leavitt: Why the Arizona State Quarterback Could Be a More Talented Brock Purdy
Scouting John Mateer: Oklahoma’s New QB Is a Talented Agent of Chaos
Scouting Fernando Mendoza: What Makes the Indiana QB a Wide Receiver’s Dream
Scouting Drew Allar: How the Penn State QB Can Be a Top 10 Pick in 2026
Scouting Clemson’s Cade Klubnik: Could He Be Bo Nix 2.0?
Why South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers Could Have the Highest Ceiling of Any 2026 QB Prospect
Scouting Garrett Nussmeier: Is He Baker Mayfield 2.0?
Is Arch Manning the Real Deal? Let’s Check the Tape!
Our Favorite Picks From Every Round of the 2025 NFL Draft
Drafting the Top NFC Impact Offensive Rookies
Drafting the Top AFC High-Impact Offensive Rookies
Self-Scouting the 2025 NFL Draft: Where We Were Wrong (If the NFL Is Right)
Way-Too-Early 2026 NFL Mock Draft: Nussmeier Goes No. 1, Rams Trade Up for Their QB of the Future
NFL Draft Recap: Favorite Picks and Full Class Breakdowns for All 32 Teams
LIVE: Shedeur Sanders lands in Cleveland and other NFL Draft Reactions with Ryen Russillo | The McShay Show
LIVE NFL Draft Day 2 Recap and Analysis! Reaction to Shedeur Falling to Day 3 | The McShay Show
LIVE NFL Draft 2nd Round Preview + Analysis!
LIVE NFL Draft 1st Round Analysis! Plus, Bill Simmons Joins! | The McShay Show
Mock Draft 4.0! One Quarterback Trade, Two Top-10 Surprises, and All the Latest Intel.
News or Noise, and Todd’s Final Big Board! Plus, Talking Draft Day With Richmond Spider Legend Joe Douglas.
The Top-10 Domino Effect: How Jalon Walker and a Run on Edge Rushers Could Shake Up the First Round
What I’m Hearing: Edge Rushers Rising and Two Top-Five Shake-Ups. Plus, QB2 in Round 2?
The Draft Mailbag Special!
The Team Needs Dueling Mock Draft! Three Rounds, 102 Picks, Endless Chaos.
What I’m Hearing on Shedeur Sanders and Will Johnson. Plus, Offensive Line Tiers, Comps, and Tape Study.
Mock Draft 3.0! A New Orleans Dart Throw, the Colorado-to-Cleveland Pipeline, and Todd’s Favorite Team Fits.
Todd’s All-Satellite Team, the Latest NFL Draft Buzz, and a Defensive Back Deep Dive
Colorado Pro Day Instant Reactions: A Shedeur Sanders Stock Watch and the Great Travis Hunter Debate
Todd’s Top 150 Big Board! Risers, Fallers, Team Fits, and More. Plus, a Linebacker Deep Dive.
Breaking Down the Latest QB Draft Buzz. Plus, a Defensive Line Deep Dive.
The Quarterback Deep Dive: Tiers, Traits, Comps, and Tape Study. Plus, Could the Giants Still Draft a QB After Signing Russell Wilson?
The Pass Catcher Deep Dive: Tiers, Comps, and Tape Study
Mock Draft 2.0! Talking Top Five Picks, Jaxson Dart’s First-Round Buzz, and More!
Shedeur to the Browns? Plus, the 2025 Running Back Deep Dive
Todd’s Updated Top 100 Big Board! Cam, Shedeur, and the QB Carousel
NFL Free Agency First Impressions! Breaking Down the Latest Quarterback Moves, Trades, and More.
Todd’s Updated Top 32 Big Board! QBs Rise, Team Needs, and Where are the DTs?!
Risers, Fallers, and Understanding the Quarterback Landscape After the NFL Combine. Plus, Talking Life After the Super Bowl With Eagles GM Howie Roseman.
NFL Combine WR & RB Reactions: Is Matthew Golden the New WR1? Plus, The Running Back Class Shows Out.
NFL Combine Day 3 Reactions: Nick Emmanwori’s Historic Performance and Maxwell Hairston’s Big Day. Plus, An Exclusive Interview with Louisville QB Tyler Shough.
Day 2 NFL Combine Reactions: Defensive Line Winners and What to Make of Abdul Carter’s Injury.
Day 1 from the NFL Scouting Combine: Shedeur Sitting Out, Stafford’s Next Move, and Pre-Workout Draft Tiers
Todd’s Mock Draft 1.0: Abdul Carter to Tennessee and the Giants Find Their QB of the Future
Defensive Line NFL Draft Tiers: Ranking Abdul Carter, Mason Graham, the Georgia Pass Rushers, and More
Scouting the Loaded Running Back Class + Is Tyler Shough a 1st Round Pick?
Tale of the Tape: Shedeur Sanders vs. Jaxson Dart for QB2. Plus, Breaking Down the Eagles’ Winning Formula.
Super Bowl Roster Lessons, a Travis Hunter Draft Debate, and Texans GM Nick Caserio on Working With Bill Belichick and Building Around C.J. Stroud
Who’s Rising in Todd’s Updated Top 100 Prospects? Plus: Talking Team Building and Scouting Lamar Jackson With Ravens GM Eric DeCosta.
Senior Bowl, Day 3 Takeaways
Senior Bowl, Day 2: Mike Green vs. Josh Conerly Jr., Small Schools Show Out, and Is Jack Bech the next Puka Nacua?
Senior Bowl Day One Takeaways: Could Jaxson Dart Rise? Plus, Azareye'h Thomas Shines
Senior Bowl Primer: Finding QB3, Ranking Position Players in Mobile, and an Unforgettable Tim Tebow Story
Ohio State’s Dominant CFP Run and Ben Johnson’s Fit in Chicago
An Ohio State᠆Notre Dame National Championship Preview With Kirk Herbstreit, Plus Quinn Ewers Declares and Other Draft-Decision Reactions
Coach Prime’s Cowboys Connection, Jayden Daniels Draft Lessons, and Ranking NFL GM Vacancies
Cotton Bowl Instant Reactions: An Ohio State–Notre Dame Natty, Jack Sawyer’s Signature Moment, and Quinn Ewers’s Next Move
Orange Bowl Instant Reactions: Natty-Bound Notre Dame, Drew Allar’s Draft Decision, and Abdul Carter NFL Comps
CFP Semifinal Preview: Penn State–Notre Dame and Texas–Ohio State. Plus, the Patriots Fumble the Top Pick and Talking Titans QB Options
CFP Quarterfinal Recap: Ohio State Routs Oregon, Texas Survives OT Thriller, and Penn State Slows Ashton Jeanty
CFP Quarterfinal Preview: Ohio State–Oregon, Notre Dame–Georgia, Texas–Arizona State, and Penn State–Boise State. Plus, Quarterback Draft Thoughts.
Todd’s 2024 NFL Redraft: Daniels Vs. Maye at 1, Nabers Over Harrison Jr., and Bo Nix What-Ifs
CFP Reactions: Ohio State’s Second Act, The Dominant Nittany Lions, and Texas Holds The Line. Plus, Notre Dame Cruises to 11th Straight Win
CFP Picks: Indiana-Notre Dame, SMU-Penn State, Clemson-Texas, and Tennessee-Ohio State. Plus, Florida HC Billy Napier | The McShay Show
Pre-Playoff Draft Buzz: QB Decisions, Weak WR and Loaded RB Classes | The McShay Show
Bill Belichick as a College Coach, Todd’s Flash Mock, and CFP Prospect Rankings
Playoff QB Confidence Rankings: Dillon Gabriel the Consensus No. 1, Texas’s Dynamic Duo, and Carson Beck Injury Concerns
Conference Championship Reactions, CFP Predictions with Ryen Russillo
A Conference Championship Weekend Preview With David Pollack. Plus, Can Notre Dame Win It All?
The Case for South Carolina, Alabama’s Lifeline, and Other CFP Rankings Reactions
Ohio State’s Bad Day, A Texas Two (QB) Step, and South Carolina Makes Its CFP Case
A Texas–Texas A&M Preview and Indiana’s College Football Playoff Case. Plus: Danny Heifetz on the Next Giants Quarterback.
Ohio State’s Title Case, Colorado’s Closing Window, and SEC Playoff Scenarios
An Indiana-Ohio State Deep Dive. Plus: Jets Distress and Best Bets With Stugotz
A Two-Way Travis Hunter Scouting Report. Plus: Indiana–Ohio State Expectations and Best Bets With Chris “The Bear” Fallica.
Georgia Topples Tennessee, Oregon's Close Call, and Travis Hunter’s Historic Heisman Case. Plus: A Texas Temperature Check
Coach Prime’s NFL Influence, a College Football Playoff Confidence Draft, and Previewing Tennessee-Georgia
A Shedeur Sanders Deep Dive, Caleb Williams Concerns, and Bama and Ole Miss Surging in the SEC
Bama’s Big Night, Miami's First Loss, and A Shedeur Sanders Check-In
Scouting Cam Ward, an Alabama–LSU Elimination Game, and McShay’s Guys for Week 11
Oregon an Obvious No. 1, Big 12 Disrespect, and SEC Intrigue in the First CFP Rankings
Coaching Carousel Buzz with Pete Thamel, and Ohio State Prospect Tiers | The McShay Show
Ohio State–Penn State Takeaways, Georgia's Close Call, and Another Oregon Master Class
McShay’s Guys For Week 10. Plus: Jim Nagy on Cam Ward’s Rise and Garrett Nussmeier’s Draft Decision
Joel Klatt on Ohio State–Penn State and Colorado’s Deion Sanders Success Story. Plus, McShay’s First College Football Playoff Ranking.
Garrett Nussmeier’s Texas A&M Nightmare, Ohio State Uncertainty, and More Week 9 Reactions With Ryen Russillo
McShay’s Guys 1.0, an EMERGENCY Mock Draft, and Best Bets With Stanford Steve
Todd McShay on Cam Ward Vs. Shedeur Sanders for 2025 QB1 and Georgia as the Top Dawgs in the SEC With David Pollack and Steve Muench
Welcome to The McShay Show!