All Episodes

Popcorn Pals | The Odyssey w/ Mark David Christenson

The 2AM Chicago Man Story

Priceline and Pain

Top 10 Theme Park Rides!

Very Special News From Germania!

I Went To A Stranger’s Basement!

The Rochelle Vigilante Car Chase

My Top 10 Donuts Revisited!

My Top 10 Donuts!

My 11 Things To Do In Wisconsin!

10 Delicacies That Started Out As Peasant Foods

Post-Netflix Show Mailbag!

Top 10 Vegas Food Spots!

Midnight Mailbag & My HGTV Life!

Top 10 1970s Fads!

The Street Decency Saga!

Pennsylvania Stories, Card Shows, and Pre-Paid Gas!

10 Everyday Food Items The US Military Invented!

Top 10 Most Annoying Things About Travel!

The Atherstone Ball Game

How “Plane Cow” Came To Be!

Midnight Mailbag Episode!

Top 10 Countries with the Best Food!

7 Interesting Facts About Black History Month!

Sick Day Top 10!

15 Words Derived From Mythological Creatures!

It’s A Midnight Mailbag Episode!

Part 2 of Favorite 5 from 2025 w/ Lissa Rubin!

Favorite 5 from 2025 w/ Lissa Rubin!

Dick Van Dyke is 100!

My Top 10 Winter Movies!

A Strange European Christmas Ritual!

Top 10 Movies with Bagpipes!

How Pumpkin Pie Became The Thanksgiving Dessert King!

Top 10 Card Games!

Bizarre Origins of Everyday Phrases!

5 Reasons We Like To Be Scared!

Pen Pals Podcast - Jason Sklar | RE: Halloween Costumes

The Top Pop Culture 2025 Halloween Costumes!

Halloween Around The World!

Top 10 Fall Activities

Old People Are Better Than We Think

Pen Pals Podcast - Dave Holmes | RE: Best Party Ever

Unknown Number: The High School Catfish

Top 10 Chicken Dishes

Stories from Eureka

Top 10 Fruits

How To Win At Lotto Scratchers

Pen Pals Podcast - Kyle Ayers | RE: Obsessive Tendencies

Top 11 Things You Should Have In Your Car

Mailbag Episode!

Why Do We Sleep?

Top 10 Board Games

Top 10 Coming Of Age Movies

The Legend of The North Pond Hermit

Top 10 Gas Stations/Convience Stores

10 Bizarre Summer Solstice Rituals

Pen Pals Podcast - Ryan Sickler | RE: Bumper Stickers

Top 10 Summer Concession Items

Hidden Loot In Kansas

Top 10 Breads

The Last Of Us, Coq Au Vin, and Top 10 Summer Foods

Top 10 Tom Cruise Movies

10 Most Outrageous Bets Ever Made

DC Flight and The Great American Grump Out

Top 10 Mexican Restaurant Must Haves

Top 10 Summer Activities

10 Bizarre Trends From The 90s!

LAX Drama and 10 Formerly Secret Tunnels That Are Now Open

10 Bizarre Origin Stories of Brand Names

Back In L.A., Talking TV, Travel Highlights, & The Tribune

Emails, St. Patrick’s Day, Sloppy Joes, And A Thai Mystery

Triathlon, Pi Day, and the Top 10 Iconic Movie & TV Restaurants

TV Talk

Top 10 Stories of Celebrity Items That Were Lost and Returned!

Top 10 Forgotten American Pastimes And Hobbies

SuperBowl Review and the Top 10 Romantic Comedies Of All Time!

Pen Pals Podcast - RE: Blankies

Top 10 Jobs You Can’t Get Today

1917 Deep Dive

Top 10 Most Popular Gas Station Items

Top 10 Strangest New Years Traditions From Around The World

Pen Pals Podcast - RE: Movies & Acting

Top 10 Strangest Christmas Traditions

1985 Mexico Christmas Heist

Happy Pastry Day! It’s my Top-10 Christmas-ish Movies! And as always, I read The Tribune!

Top 10 Christmas Movies! Listener emails! The Tribune!

Listener Emails, Calendar, Melissa Stevens, America's Most Historic Foods

Listener Emails, Calendar, Andrew Youngblood, America's Most Historic Foods

Pen Pals Podcast - RE: Blessings in Disguise

Deep Dive on An American Werewolf In London, Listener Emails, A Mini Must List, National Cat Day and more, plus The Tribune!

Top 10 Halloween Costumes, My Must List, Emails, and The Tribune!

My Wisconsin Weekend, Listener Halloween Movie Recs, Top-10 Halloween Candies, and The Tribune!

Top 10 Halloween Movies, New Orleans Stories, Emails, and The Tribune!

Emails, Backpage, & Top Ten!

Show News, The Tribune, and The Night of The Hunter!

The Backpage

Deep Dive: Dan Saunders and The Free Money

Pilot Season!

Tuesday Top 10

Weekly Calendar & The Tribune

The Backpage

Deep Dive: The TV Dinner

Pen Pals!

Tuesday Top 10

Weekly Calendar & The Tribune

The Backpage

Deep Dive: The American Diner

Must List!

Tuesday Top 10

Weekly Calendar & The Tribune

The Backpage

A Late Night Mystery

Top 10 (part 2)

Tuesday Top 10 (part 1)

Weekly Calendar & The Tribune

The Backpage

A Late Night Mystery

Pilot Season

Tuesday Top 10

Weekly Calendar & The Tribune

The Backpage

A Late Night Mystery

Classic Black and White

Tuesday Top 10

Weekly Calendar & The Tribune

The Backpage

A Late Night Mystery

The Must List!

Tuesday Top 10

Weekly Calendar & The Tribune

The Backpage

A Late Night Mystery

Pen Pals Podcast - RE: RE: Diner Regular & Childhood Ambitions

Tuesday Top 10

Weekly Calendar & The Tribune

The Backpage

A Late Night Mystery

The Must List!

Tuesday Top 10

Notable Dates & The Tribune

The Backpage

Tuesday Top 10

Notable Dates & The Tribune

The Midnight Air Teaser: The Must List

The Midnight Air Calendar and Tribune Teaser

RE: Doppelgängers & Bereavement Leave

The Midnight Air Announcement

RE: New Identity & Hole in the Roof Gang

RE: Undiscovered Art & Butterfly Effect

Todd Glass | RE: Rituals & Good Stuff Gone Bad

RE: Video Games & Christmas Lights

RE: Pen Pals Announcement

RE: Gifting Books & The Perfect Album

RE: Innocent Until Proven Guilty & Kids’ Existential Questions

Andrew Youngblood | RE: No Body Odor & Cheat Meals

RE: Iowa State Fair & Deck of Cards

RE: Diner Regular & Faith-Based Companies

Luke Null | RE: The One & Being Cold

Thomas Lennon | RE: Anniversary Gifts & Singing - LIVE from SF Sketchfest

RE: Small Town America & Reimagining Life

RE: Reclaiming Birthdays & Master Cheesemakers

Taylor Ortega | RE: Speeding Tickets & Estranged Loved Ones

Langston Kerman | RE: Liquid Fingers & Unhelpful Husband

RE: Overreactions & Biff to the Future

Dave Holmes | RE: Sad Eventualities & Fishing Boat Deckhand

RE: Parenting Multiple Kids & Karaoke

Dierdre Friel | RE: Turning Back Time & Girl Codes

RE: Hamburger Helper & Body Hair

Chris Sullivan | RE: Holiday Dishes & House Fire Possessions

RE: Burning Man & Reffing

RE: Near-Death Experiences & Office Lunches

Tiffany Haddish | RE: Bad Magic & Trips vs. Vacations

RE: Tool & Travel Bets

RE: Elopement vs. Ceremony & Procrastination

RE: Wildlife Encounters & Missed Connections

Eric André | RE: Hulk Hogan & The Cannabis Line

Kumail Nanjiani | RE: Stoneman Willie & Sports Aggression

RE: Aging & Work Trips

RE: Pizza Hut Circumcision & Difficult Break Up

Laura Peek | RE: Laundry & Advice for Past Selves

Ify Nwadiwe | RE: Public Stress & Lying in Interviews

RE: Relocating & Mind vs. Body

RE: Family Legacy & Surprising Yourself

Ben Roy | RE: Gross Satisfaction & Who Not to Fight

Joe Nicchi | RE: Buffet Game Plan & Service Staff Treatment

RE: Outgrowing Friends & Grim History

RE: Bickering Couples & Animal vs. Human Life

RE: Homesickness & Cottagecore

Sarah Silverman | RE: Dealbreakers & Neighbor Feud

Nick Kroll | RE: Ridiculous Fights & Biological Parenthood

RE: Unconditional Love & Broken Phone

RE: Lake Snacks & Insider Knowledge - Live In-Studio!

Carl Tart | RE: Renaissance Fair Wedding & Questionable Coaching

Jerry O’Connell | RE: Funny Kids & World’s Largest

RE: Photographs & Oatmeal is Breakfast Chili

RE: Seasons of Life & Nic Cage

Mandy Moore | RE: ER Stories & Desert Island Songs

Rhys Darby | RE: Sensual Ghost Encounters & Dangerous Hobbies

RE: Kissing your Kids & Slides or Sleds

RE: Gifts from the Universe & Wedding Officiant

RE: Fading Passions & Ham Salad

Irene Tu | RE: Escape Rooms & Phallic Artwork

Jon Gabrus | RE: Male Hygiene & Disney for Kids

RE: Foreign Exchange Student & Pockets

RE: UFOs & Second Date Policy

Shane Mauss | RE: Teleportation Fears & Free Work

RE: Dating a Friend’s Ex & Mental Health + Art

Jay Chandrasekhar | RE: Playing Favorites & Altering Music History

RE: Transgender Child & Ruined Wedding Dress

RE: Vegas Romance & AI

Nick Thune | RE: When to Walk Away & Pure Excitement

Beth Stelling | RE: Inappropriate Laughter & Sex Work

RE: Getting Fired & Vanished Grandpa

RE: Caveman Tour Guide & Praise + Sandwiches

RE: Touring Artists

Billy Wayne Davis | RE: Pillows & Best Friend’s Girlfriend

RE: Big City Living & Spooky Google Earth

RE: Bisexuality & Potable Water

RE: Workplace Boundaries & Body Disposition

RE: Never Been Kissed & Childhood Smells

Todd Glass | RE: Deja Vu & Being Yourself

RE: Words of Affirmation & Wedding Attire

Jackie Kashian & Sean Patton | RE: Streaming Services & Disney Songs - Live from Come & Take It

Dierdre Friel | RE: Emotional Unprofessionalism & Liking Your Name

RE: Warm Desserts & Drugs

RE: Atypical Families & A Good Death

RE: Belonging & School Lunch

Cipha Sounds | RE: Heteronormative Roles & Unsolicited Advice

Chad Daniels | RE: Turning 40 & Chips

RE: Offensive Comedy & Bird of the Year

RE: Hypnotherapy & Cabin Recap

Matt Braunger | RE: Restaurant Ordering & Safe Words

Jay Larson | RE: Celebrity Crushes & Setting Boundaries

RE: Career Boomerang & Sex Talk

RE: Words & Saving Musical Heroes

Jordan & Lauren Scovel | RE: Younger Self & Meat

Ramin Nazer | RE: Meaningful Friendships & Letting Go

RE: Bereavement Leave & Childhood Neighbors

RE: Vacations & Another Woman - Live on Moment House

Sklar Brothers | RE: Skilled Trades & Yard Games

RE: Late vs. Manipulative & Dogs

RE: Conflicting Viewpoints & Learning Names

RE: Our Favorite Things

RE: The Mashed Patatreon

Doug Benson | RE: Social Eating & International Stand Up

Sara Schaefer | RE: Over-Gifting & Real Magic

RE: Covid Conundrum & Losing Your Virginity

RE: Family Cabin & Celebrity Interactions

RE: Soul-Saving & Officiating a Wedding

Haley Joel Osment | RE: Pizza & Talent Shows

Kurt Braunohler & Hannah Berner | RE: Lasting Impressions & Baby on the Way Out - LIVE at Moontower

RE: Playing the Victim & Mouth and Foot Painting

RE: Condolences

RE: Marriage Trauma & Unconventional Beauty

Seaton Smith | RE: Not Having it Together & Sensational News Stories

Rose Byrne | RE: Walking Around Australia & Absent Parent

RE: Real Love & Thoughts While Flying

RE: Now and Then & Gardening

Jack Whitehall | RE: Catchy Tunes & Lords and Ladies

Judd Apatow | RE: Home Improvements & Personal Care

RE: Potatoes & Psychic Tendencies

Andy Richter | RE: Hometown Legends & Self-Motivation

RE: Car Trouble & Nature vs. Nurture

Aimee Mann | RE: Naps & Confronting a Mooch

RE: Male Affection & Mystery in Atlanta

Chris Garcia | RE: Art of Flirting & Escaping Negativity

RE: Off-Grid Living & Dog Goodbyes

RE: Losing Passion & Fruit Essence

RE: Chasing Adventure & Powerful Art

Sona Movsesian | RE: Gender Norms & Nude Calendar

RE: Acupuncture Nightmare & Meaningful Possessions

Brett Goldstein | RE: Sitting to Pee & Polyamorous Love

RE: Buffet Style

RE: Elvis Presley & Christmas Surprise

Chris Sullivan | RE: Power of Sports & Movie Languages

Will Ferrell | RE: Senior Year & Corporal Punishment

Skylar Astin | RE: Defining Weird & Social Anxiety

Naomi Ekperigin | RE: Travel Hacks & Cabin Antics

Kevin Nealon | RE: Boat Names & Reaching Out

Hannah Berner | RE: Inconsiderate People & Consolation Prize

Adam Cayton-Holland | RE: Swedish Spirits & Work Stress

RE: Hanging Brain & Incompatible Love

Andy Samberg | RE: Toilet Paper & Horse Thieves

Kyle Kinane | RE: Father-in-Law Ghost & Something's Missing

Matt Walsh | RE: Cosmic Twins & Perfect Day

Dave Anthony & Gareth Reynolds | RE: Letting Kids Win & Emailing Ex

RE: Ham Day & A Joyous Life

Annie Weisman | RE: Cursing Children & Religious Costumes

RE: Sex Slang & Bad Heroes

​​RE: Existential Dread & Deadliest Catch

Pete Holmes | RE: Grandpa’s Romance & Go-To Drinks

Ryan Sickler | RE: Separate Beds & Olympic Medals

RE: Family Legends & Former Friends

RE: Animal Magic & Brain Teasers

Casey Wilson | RE: Balcony Kisses & Getting Older

RE: Favorite Fries

RE: Canine Condolences & Vacation Mourning

RE: Pancakes & Power Moves

RE: My French Quarter Ghost & Genetic Inheritance - with Noah Eberhart

RE: Letters of Love & A Question Of Decency

RE: Broken Brain Compensation Methods & Random Tearful Grandma Memories

RE: First Date & Back to the Future

RE: Advice For Your Younger Self & Must-Have Brands

RE: Parasocial Relationships & Fishing

RE: Coming Out & Best/Worst Vacations

RE: Thinking Differently & A Dating Question

RE: Mental Breakdowns & True Conspiracies

RE: Breathing & Guilty Pleasures

RE: Drawing Lines in Comedy & Political Leanings

RE: Classic Cars & Head vs. Heart

RE: A Tattoo Conundrum & Manic Episodes

RE: How to Say "I Love You" & A Swedish Treasure Story

RE: Big Changes & Chicago St. Patrick's Day

RE: Obscure Words & Quality Smut

RE: Thresholds & Getting Back Into Comedy

RE: Changes Since 2012 & Folklore

RE: The Girl Scout Experience & When To Call It Quits

RE: Being An Only Child & Knowing A Killer

RE: Having A Second Kid & Guilty Pleasures

RE: Favorite Clubs & Talking To Kids About Drugs

RE: Friends With Benefits & Healthy Boundaries

RE: Predictions & Sharing Your Art

RE: Crying For Myself & Favorite Chips

RE: Seasons & Senses & A Family Question - LIVE on Zoom with Patrick Keenan

RE: Roommate Stories

RE: Christmas at the Holiday Inn & A Brine Recipe

RE: Movies & TV To Watch Before Turning 40

RE: Holiday Traditions & Would You Rather

RE: The Turkey Situation & Seeing Any Event From History - Live On Zoom

RE: A Message From The Past

RE: Three Secrets

RE: Ænima & Fainting

RE: When to Come Out

RE: A Pandemic Breakup & Finding A New Hobby - Live Zoom Show with Jon Dore

RE: Being Bad At Trusting & Anxiety

RE: Sexuality & Remembering Badass Grandma

RE: Name Changes & Bucket Lists

RE: Secret Marriage & Pen Pals: The Movie - Live Zoom Show

RE: Weight Issues, Motivation, & Survivor

RE: Anhedonia

RE: Jaws Wired Shut

RE: My Best Friend's Bad-News Marriage & My First Porn Experience - Live Zoom Show!

RE: My High School Bear Attack

RE: Pinterest, House Fires, & Parachutes

RE: Gaslit By Family & Calamity Kim

RE: A Miserable Rafting Trip

RE: Backup Careers, Memorable Dreams, & Parenting While on the Road

RE: Road Trip Tips

RE: Out of Seeds, Birthday Cards, & Tripping

RE: Dan's Arches, Educating Yourself, & Candy Talk

RE: Getting To Know You Pop Quiz

RE: F2F with Dad & Losing Family Relationships

RE: Small Town Life & Accent Preferences

RE: Top Bands & Navigating My Brain

RE: Being High At Rory's Show

RE: Home Bases & The Tiki Scene

RE: Judgement House & Meat Processing Problems

RE: Dealing with Sudden Loss During Quarantine

RE: Friend Soulmates & Unsubscribing From Everything

RE: Choose Your Own Adventure - Part 2

RE: Choose Your Own Adventure - Part 1

RE: The Benefits of Massages & Early Retirement

RE: If Money Were No Object & Quick Hits

RE: Wedding Speech & The Principals Office

RE: Save Me From Covid-19 & When To Dry-Off

RE: Grief, Being Alone & What To Do When You're Dead

RE: Best Man Decision & The Lonely Lunch Club LIVE from Tuxas!

RE: External Depression & Having Kids

RE: Breakthroughs & Graduation Trip

RE: Last Meals & Cultural Dating Differences

RE: Goodbye Dan & Time

RE: Crying & Losing Religion

RE: Breaking Up & Staying Grounded

RE: Is Work Everything?

Conan O'Brien | RE: The Sex Talk & Suicide

RE: Wedding Plans & Child Therapy

RE: New Years Day & Getting The Band Back Together

RE: Best Time of Your Life

RE: 10 Kids & The 5 Stages of Divorce

RE: Slackers & Shampoo Side Hustle

RE: Podcasting Advice & First Dates

RE: New Restaurant Traditions & Impactful People

RE: The Carol Anne Episode Part 2

RE: The Carol Anne Episode

RE: Tour Life & Ring Size

RE: Pompous Fruit & Haunted Houses

RE: Our First Case & Car Accidents - LIVE from Red Clay Comedy Festival

RE: When To Shut Up and Take The Win? & Halloween

RE: Aliens & Fairies (The 2 postcards)

RE: Distracted Driving & Giving Credit

RE: An Announcement

RE: Hurricane Dorian & Comic Moments

RE: Is Blood Thicker Than Water & Unreasonable Fears

RE: Shoe Hero & Artists Who Are Bad People

RE: Pointing Fingers & Falling in Love

RE: Dementia & Stand-up Friends

RE: Flaky Friends & Bad Birthdays

RE: Staying In The Band & Reality TV

RE: Education & Screen Time

RE: Moving to Chicago & Showing Affection

RE: Getting Rid of Waste & Our Favorite Sports Movies

RE: Split Parents & What Is Reading

RE: Surprise Concert & Adult Baby Convention

RE: Jessica the Ghost & Failing the Bar - LIVE from Clusterfest

RE: Was I Mean To An Old Guy? & Bachelor Parties

RE: Music Tastes & Debating A Vasectomy

RE: A Special Message from Rory & Daniel

RE: Wrecked by an Escalator & Meeting People Through Improv

RE: Sex Addiction & A Prank War

RE: Employee Shenanigans & Hickeys

RE: Weird Texts from Mom & Seeming Mean - LIVE from Dallas

RE: Body Hair & Mystery in Manhattan Update

RE: A Year in Prison & Traveling vs Settling Down

RE: Saving Lives & Sandwich Talk

RE: Engagement Ring For Sale & Worrying About Wife's Weight - Live in Los Angeles!

RE: Tuxas Redux & Romanticizing Endings

RE: 19-Going-On-20 Advice & Theme Parties

RE: Fetishes & An Affair - Live from Tuxas!

RE: The Pigeon Mystery & The Loss of a Coworker

RE: Having Kids & National Days

RE: Mystery in Manhattan & Dumb Things

RE: Coffee Shops & Board Game Traditions

RE: A Random Roomie & A Talk with the Boss

RE: Grandma & A Big Chunk of Change

RE: The Weekend of Tuxas & A Graduation Speech

RE: Cannibal Questions & The Hydration Challenge

RE: A Karaoke Proposal & Talking Politics with Dad

RE: Ruining Christmas & Dissecting Humor

RE: Ghost Crisis & Psychedelic Drugs

RE: Calling Dibs & Rushing Ten Yards

RE: Going F2F with Mom & High School Expectations

RE: Balding & Committal

RE: Long Distance Love & Addiction

RE: The Groom's Perspective & Conspiracy Theories

RE: Millennials & Falling For A Friend

RE: Ruining A Wedding & Having A Trash-Mouth

RE: Fears & Adult Friending

RE: Communication & Ghosts

RE: Dating Dad's Drummer & Is She Cheating?

RE: Sleep Paralysis & Universal Basic Income

RE: Concerts, Being Stuck, & Worrying - with Reggie Watts

RE: Cults & Agoraphobia

RE: Acting Your Age & Family Traditions

RE: Time Travel & Friendship

RE: Favorites & Comments

RE: Eating & Finding a Partner

RE: Cohabitating & Wedding Planning

RE: Staying Informed & Toxic Relationships

RE: Golf & Best-Ratio Foods

RE: Dog Poop & Karmic Crustaceans

RE: Chasing Your Dreams & Choosing Your Cookies

RE: An Unsolved Bank Robbery & Free Will

Teaser 3 - RE: A Nipple Conundrum

Teaser 2 - RE: Taking Time to Work on Yourself

Teaser 1 - RE: Self Love