All Episodes
This Is The Greatest Song I’ve Ever Heard In My Entire Life — 106 episodes
"Life On Mars?" with Conan Neutron
"Fine Line" and "Mariners Apartment Complex" with Cinema Girl Productions
Maya J'an on Ella Fitzgerald's "Spring Can Really Hang You Up The Most"
These Are The Greatest Songs Of Summer We've Ever Heard In Our Entire Lives
"Try A Little Tenderness" with Luke Lalonde of Born Ruffians
This Is The 100th Episode We've Ever Released In Our Entire Podcast
"Celebrity Skin" with Sub*T
"Dancing On My Own" with Cherry Bomb
This Is The Greatest Beatles Song We've Ever Heard In Our Entire Lives
"Ain't No Way" by Aretha Franklin with Charlie Bardey
"Help Me" by Joni Mitchell with Sibyl
"Be My Baby" with Jamie Chellar from congratulations
"Se Telefonando" with Tim Platt
"drivers license" by Olivia Rodrigo - Hosts' Pick
These Are The Greatest Songs We've Heard All Year (2025 In Review)
"I Would" by One Direction with Grace Pierce
Andrew Fox of Slam Frank on "The End Of An Act" from Team America: World Police
'West End Girl' and 'Stage Girl'
'The Life Of A Showgirl'
"In Your Eyes" With Ivory Layne
'Man's Best Friend' by Sabrina Carpenter
"Stars Are Blind" with Candice Lim
"The Subway" and KPop Demon Hunters
'Swag' and The State of Men in Pop Music
Virgin and I Quit
Brian Wilson and 'Addison' by Addison Rae
Mid-Year Catch Up and Taylor's Masters
Bonus: 2025 Grammy Award Recap
These Are The Greatest Songs We've Heard All Year (2024 In Review)
Bald Ann Dowd Was Stopped In Her Tracks By "This Must Be The Place"
Augie Isaac Is Blown Away By "Something"
Krista Doyle Likes A "Gold Rush"
Cody Meacham Wants His Funeral Song To Be "Butterflies and Hurricanes"
Leannie Feels Like She's In A Movie With "My Way"
MICHELLE Gets Thrilled by "Human Nature"
Maddie Rice Gets Into Prog With "America"
Bonus: 2009 VMAs 15th Anniversary Special
Juveria Zaheer Turns Her Orbit Towards "Jesus, Etc."
Kishi Bashi Feels Elevated By "Aqualera do Brasil"
Roger Feeley-Lussier Remembers His Mom With A "Heart Of Gold"
Bonus: God Only Knows Music Analysis (Pop Unmuted 2016 Episode Re-release)
Allie Goertz Agrees With Paul McCartney About "God Only Knows"
Jocelyn Of Walt Disco Wants All Versions Of "Send In The Clowns"
Stan Talouis Feels The Impact Of "The Message"
LØLØ's Personality Was Shaped By "Sk8er Boi"
PRXZM Turns To The Sun With "Ambrosia" and "Minnesota Is A Place That Exists"
Skylar Spence Has A Lust For Life Like "Appetite"
Gabrielle Bolin Chases An Impossible High With "Semi-Charmed Life"
Mike Post Has Never Heard It Said Like "Still Crazy After All These Years"
José Valle Travels To Italy With "How Do You Sleep At Night?" and "Be Your Home"
Chris P. Thompson Gets Shocked By "The Grid"
Austin Danger Podcast Connects To "Your Song" and "Cloudbusting"
Bonus: JLo's 'This Is Me...Now: A Love Story'
Jordan Miller Makes Better Decisions Thanks To "Silver Springs"
Billy Jay Stein Goes To The Grammys (And Remembers "Tom Sawyer")
TIFFY Appreciates Hometowns Like "Hackensack"
These Are The Greatest Songs We’ve Heard All Year (2023 In Review)
Jack Coyne Taps Into The Spiritual With ”Madame George”
Gatlin Romanticizes Heartbreak With ”Both Sides Now”
Gothsconsin Thinks About Humanity With ”Idle Worship”
Bethany Cosentino Comes Full Circle With ”If It Makes You Happy”
Berhana Hears His Family In ”Wede Harer Guzo”
Elliott Fullam Is Haunted By ”Morning Bell”
Brittany Spanos Is Launched Into Another World by ”Ray Of Light”
Bonus: Father’s Day Special
Tyke James of The Moss Connects to ”How I Get Myself Killed”
Claud Cries In The Club To ”Call Your Girlfriend”
Alex Anwandter Is Relentlessly Entertained by ”Dancing Queen”
Tamar Herman Always Knew It Would Be ”The Chaser”
Rachel Brodsky Has A Secret Tattoo Of ”It’s Only Life”
Kelsey Brannan Gets A Jolt Of Energy From ”Rosalita”
Jared Saltiel Has Visceral Memories Of Hearing ”The Beautiful Ones”
Rob Lowry Dreams Of Syncing ”A Case Of You”
Katherine Mohr Can’t Think Of A Better Bridge Than ”Cruel Summer”
Bonus: Remembering Burt Bacharach
John-Allison Weiss Puts Their Fist In The Air For ”I Won’t Back Down”
A Day Without Love Is Still Bumping ”Meet The Frownies”
Hendrik Is On ”Mountain Time”
These Are The Greatest Songs We’ve Heard All Year (2022 Year In Review)
Boy Jr. Has Never Heard Anything Like ”Toxic”
Bonus: The Greatest Songs YOU’VE Ever Heard In Your Entire Life
Hits Don’t Lie Celebrate Their Friendship With ”Jolene” and ”Pyramids”
Annabelle Kline-Zilles Connects To The Magic Of ”Green Eyes”
Bonus: Keith Serry Can’t Stand The Cardigans
Keith Serry Floats Into ”How Can You Mend A Broken Heart”
Pablo The Don Hits Play On ”Rewind” Every Day
Bobby and Lindsey from Who? Weekly Get Their Songs From Their Dads
Chappell Roan Gets Butterflies From ”The Book Of Love”
Ryan Pak Soundtracks His Life With ”The Universal”
Ruth Takes The ”Night Shift”
Mike Monaco Shows Everyone ”Deliverance”
Anna Williams Has Big Feelings About ”Feed The Birds”
Deepa Lakshmin Feels Seen By ”3am”
Bonus: These Are The Greatest Songs WE’VE Ever Heard In Our Entire Lives
Phoebe Ryan Can’t Believe ”My Heart Will Go On”
Eleri Ward’s Life Was Changed by ”Door”
Patrick Hosken Feels Pandered To By Joni Mitchell’s ”You Turn Me On, I’m A Radio”
That Brunette Gets Full Body Chills From ”Circle Of Life”
Sondre Lerche Keeps Coming Back To ”Águas de Março”
Sweaty Lamarr Embraces The Mess With ”Norman F*cking Rockwell”
Kira Grunenberg Sinks Her Teeth Into ”TigerBait”
Matt Storrs Wants To Do Good Whenever He Hears ”Let Us All Unite”
Mitski Learned How To Sing From ”Always Be My Baby”
Bonus: 10 Year Anniversary of ’Lush’ by Mitski
Tristan Miller Loves ”Short People”
Ep 0: Introduction