All Episodes
True Myths, One Lie with Culter35 — 54 episodes
The Final Episode of True Myths, One Lie
Not Deer, Pukwudgies, and Manananggals ft. Ryan McCauley & Seth Colon
Crawler Confrontations ft. Austin Murphy, Christopher Mennella, and Zach Sicardi
Lizard People Are Real ft. Jacob Colon, Ryan Feeney, and Seth Colon
The Winged Ones ft. Andrew Heinlein, Christopher Mennella, and Ryan McCauley
Awkward Alien Encounters ft. Christopher Mennella, Ryan McCauley, and Tom Heinlein
Fan Submitted Stories ft. Austin Murphy and Christopher Mennella
1500's Werewolf Horror Stories ft. Ariel Colon, Jacob Colon, and Seth Colon
Let’s Go Wendigo Hunting ft. Ryan McCauley & Christopher Mennella
The Florida Man ft. Zach Sicardi, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella
Haunted Doll Companies and Museum Encounters ft. Austin Murphy, Andrew Heinlein, and Christopher Mennella
Moscow Taxis & Personal Chauffeurs ft. Austin Murphy, Tom Heinlein, and Larry Mennella
Creepy Security Footage ft. Ryan McCauley, Seth Colon, & Christopher Mennella
EThe Backrooms, Inescapable Alternate Realities ft. Christopher Mennella, Ryan McCauley, Seth Colon, and Ryan Feeney
A House in the Woods ft. Christopher Mennella and Austin Murphy
Meeting Your Future Self: Time Traveler Stories ft. Christopher Mennella
New Stories From 2021's Most Popular Topics ft. Ryan McCauley, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella
Bob's Wild Childhood Stories ft. Ryan McCauley, Andrew Heinlein, and Christopher Mennella
Elf Sightings ft. Ryan McCauley, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella
Krampus AKA Evil Santa ft. Ryan McCauley, Seth Colon, and Christopher Mennella
La Llorona ft. Ryan McCauley, Andrew Heinlein, and Christopher Mennella
Crybaby Bridge ft. Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella
Fan-Submitted Stories! ft. Seth Colon, Austin Murphy, Christopher Mennella and YOU!
Skinwalker Ranch Pt. 2 ft. Ryan McCauley, Christopher Mennella, and Austin Murphy
Skinwalker Ranch Pt. 1 ft. Ryan McCauley, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella
Tom's Delivery Driver Horror Stories ft. Tom Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Larry Mennella
Halloween Urban Legends ft. Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella
C13Features Presents: Treat, Starring Kiernan Shipka
Mothman ft. Ryan McCauley, Andrew Heinlein, and Christopher Mennella
Dark Watchers ft. Ryan McCauley, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella
Even More Warren Cases ft. Austin Murphy, Zach Sicardi, and Christopher Mennella
Glitches in the Matrix ft. Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella
SCP Stories ft. Ryan McCauley, Seth Colon, and Christopher Mennella
The Chupacabra ft. Andrew Heinlein, Christopher Mennella, and Seth Colon
Conspiracy Theories ft. Ryan McCauley & Christopher Mennella
Haunted Mirrors ft. Zach Sicardi, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella
Imaginary Friends ft. Tom Heinlein, Katie Heinlein, and Larry Mennella
Obscure Horror Films (and a new host!) ft. Seth Colon, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella
Haunted Staircases in the Woods ft. Ryan McCauley and Seth Colon
The Warren Cases ft. Andrew Heinlein and Hope Heinlein
Sleep Paralysis Demons ft. Andrew Heinlein and Ryan McCauley
The Dogman Legend ft. Ryan McCulley, Austin Murphy, Christopher Mennella
Precognition ft. Ryan McCauley, Hunter Ferreira
Black-Eyed Children ft. Tom Heinlein, Larry Mennella
Bigfoot is Now My Godfather ft. Ryan Feeney, Austin Murphy & Christopher Mennella
Creepy Clowns ft. Andrew Heinlein and Christopher Mannella
Disney's Creepiest Encounters ft. Ryan McCauley & Seth Colon
Humanoid Creatures ft. Matt Casa & Christopher Mannella
Shadow People Hate Single People ft. Austin Murphy and Christopher Mennella
Cryptids & Even More Pizza! ft. Andrew Heinlein and Christopher Mennella
Ghost Stories & The Podcast Falls Apart ft. Seth Colon, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella
Urban Legends That (Mostly) Turned Out to Be True ft. Ryan McCauley, Ryan Feeney and Christopher Mennella
Alien Abductions and a Pizza Party ft. Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella
Introducing: True Myths, One Lie!