All Episodes
Underachievers Podcast — 308 episodes
This One is All About Jeff
Adulting Sucks But Has Its Perks
Sharing Stories On A Monday
Going Down Memory Lane
Six Years of Underachieving
Jeffrey on the DL
The One Where We Talk Hockey
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 37
Just Podcasting & Hanging Out
Witmer on the Spot
The Underachievers Are Back in 2026!
Top 10 Moments of 2025 (Part 2)
Top 10 Moments of 2025 (Part 1)
Our 2025 Christmas Special
Never Lose Your Christmas Spirit
Best All-Time Moments: 16
Our 2025 Thanksgiving Special
Best All-Time Moments: 15
The Fall of Weddings and Renaissance
A Hard Monday After A Rough Sports Weekend
Stories On A Monday
Best All-Time Moments: 14
Best All-Time Moments: 13
The Highest Part of Your Week
A Nice Summer Break
Best All-Time Moments: 12
Same Faces, New Spaces
Best All-Time Moments: 11
The Heat is Brutal
Best All-Time Moments: 10
We Haven't Skipped A Beat
Best All-Time Moments: 9
Best All-Time Moments: 8
Best All-Time Moments: 7
The Weekend of Jeff
We're Not Tanking This One
We Haven't Gone Anywhere
Best All-Time Moments: 6
Best All-Time Moments: 5
Best All-Time Moments: 4
Best All-Time Moments: 3
Best All-Time Moments: 2
A Podcast Worth Celebrating
Let's Talk About the Super Bowl
Snow Days and Sports
Best All-Time Moments: 1
We're Back in 2025!
Top 10 Moments of 2024 (Pt. 2)
Top 10 Moments of 2024 (Pt. 1)
Our Non-Christmas Christmas Special
Ultimate Chaos
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 35
An Eventful Month
Points Points Points
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 34
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 33
The Fantasy at the Renaissance Faire
Finger Lakes and Family
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 32
Weddings and Batman
Relaxing While Watching the Olympics
Telling Stories and Marvel
It's Hot Summer Time
The Highs and Lows Of A Week
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 31
Those Summer Vibes
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 30
Dogs and Toads
Let's Talk About Movies
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 29
Life and Drafts
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 28
Family Time and Terrible Jerseys
Seeing Movies and Phillies Greats
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 27
Our Four Year Anniversary Podcast
The Sports Heavy Episode
The All Over the Place Podcast
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 26
Super Bowl and Leftovers
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 25
The Guys Are Back in 2024
Top 10 Moments of 2023 (Pt. 2)
Top 10 Moments of 2023 (Pt. 1)
Our 2023 Christmas Special
Just Vibing
Let’s Get to the Rambling
He’s Back!
We’re Still Here
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 24
Catching Up
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 23
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 22
Football is Back!
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 21
The End of Summer
Welcoming A New Face
Looking Forward to Fun Ahead
Running Late and Sports Stories
Football and Godzilla
Stories and Sports
Beaches and Family
A Nice and Relaxing Podcast
Same Stuff, Different Day
The Dog Days of Summer
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 20
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 19
Food For Thought
The Many Questions of the Hour
Stories of the Hour
Baseball Games Are A Vibe
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 18
Good Vibes Only
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 17
Three Year Anniversary Podcast!
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 16
We Need Our Phillies Back
Library Date and Super Bowl
Super Bowl and LOTR
The Eagles are going to the Super Bowl!
An Apology and Leaving Early
Playoff Football Talk
Just Some Beer Talk
Still The Same Underachievers
Our Best Moments of 2022
Our 2022 Holiday Special
Best-Of Our Underachievers:15
The Movie Going Experience
Our 2022 Thanksgiving Special
We’re Back!
Bryce Harper is God!
The Downer Monday
What A Weekend For Philadelphia Sports
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 14
Wedding and Football
Let’s Talk Some More Football
Sports On Top of Sports Talk
We’re All Back Again
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 13
The Gang Goes to Maryland
The Duo Podcast
Flights and Money
Let’s Talk Some MCU!
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 12
All Madden Talk
A Nice and Easy Podcast
Our 100th Underachievers Episode
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 11
MVP and Stories
The Short and Sweet Podcast
Birthday Celebrations and Golf
Best of Our Underachievers: 10
Madden Issues
All Football Talk
March Madness and Weddings
Suits and All-Time Lakers
The Best-Of Our Underachievers: 9
Our Two Year Anniversary Podcast
Gym and Sports Talk
We’re All Back
The Split Podcast
Yeah...More Madden Talk
The Best-Of Our Underachievers: January
The Sports Heavy Podcast
We’re All Back with a Surprise
We’re Entering Championship Season
New Year, Same Underachievers
Top 10 Underachiever Moments of 2021: Part 2
Top 10 Underachiever Moments of 2021: Part 1
Oh, What A Weekend
The Three Tangent Podcast
The Story Time Podcast
Our Thanksgiving Special
We‘re Missing One
Best-Of Our Underachievers: Story Time
Football on Top of Football Talk
The Fun of Halloween
A Little Tardy and Madden Talk
Scary Connecticut Roads and Fantasy Football
Airing of Grievances
Summer‘s Over and Tailgating
Yeah... We Don‘t Know Either
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 8
The Joys of Building
Golfer Mike and Sports Video Games
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 7
The One Where We Struggle... Again
The Best Of Our Underachievers: 6
Video Game Dominance and College Sports
The One Where We Get Better as the Show Goes On
The NHL Offseason Starting to Heat Up
Later Time, Same Underachievers
The Half & Half Podcast II
We Know Our Music
Where We Are in the NHL Playoffs
The Odd Man Out
Being the Fun Uncle and Beach Trips are Back!
The Best-Of Our Underachievers: 5
Another Week, Another Week of Nothing
The Start of the Stanley Cup Playoffs!
The Music Men
A Look at the Upcoming 2020-21 NHL Playoffs
Sliding Into the DMs
Getting the Gang Back Together
NHL TV Deal and Giroux's Milestone
Brian The Genius
The Guys Reunited Weekend
2021 NHL Trade Deadline Special
The Off Tangent Podcast
League Updates and Flyers Struggles Continue
New Day, Same Underachievers
Pulling An Episode Out of Thin Air
Flyers Deep Dive: Looking Into the Flyers Struggles
Our Attempt At A Functional Podcast
One Year Anniversary Podcast: From Bad to Ugly
Deja Vu Flyers Comeback and Senators Deep Dive
Best-Of Our Underachievers: 4
Our Lives Are Definitely Going Well Now
The Duo New York Deep Dives and Flyers Struggles
Nashville Predators Deep Dive: Feat. Pete Weber
Our Very Successful School Years
Hextall Hired and NHL COVID Outbreaks
The Master's of Nothing
Rutherford Resigns and Canadians Deep Dive
Story Time: The Weekend in Virginia
Laine/Dubois Trade and Wild Deep Dive
The Guys Week of Nothing
The All Over the Place Podcast
Flyers Season Preview
Birthday Celebrating and Recovering
The NHL Season is Here!
The Best of the Year Moments
NHL Deep Dives and a Look At Divisions
The Best-Of Our Underachievers: The Trilogy
Hank Injury and Stars Deep Dive
The One Where We've Got Nothing
Hurts and College
Dunkin and Life Goals
The Avalanche Jackets
The Best-of Our Underachievers Vol. 2
The Half and Half Podcast
The Elite Talent We Are
Hurricane Outlook
We've Gotten Better At This, Maybe
The Thrill We Have For Halloween
Doc's Retirement and Flames Deep Dive
The Smart Decisions We've Made
Adulting Life and A Little Sports
Pietrangelo Gets Paid and Hall A Sabre
Our Thoughts Before the NHL Free Agent Frenzy
The Gang is Back!
This is Why We're Friends
Stanley Cup and Bruins Deep Dive
The Clear Fun We're Still Having
Wild E Coyotes
References Galore
Flyers Season In-Review and Ducks Deep Dive
Surviving Our Labor Day Weekends
NHL Game 7's Galore
Yeah, We're Pretty Smart
Where Do the Flyers go From Here?
The Thousand Dollar Face Rises
NHL Second Round has Begun!
NHL Elimination Wednesday and Controversial Hits
We're Still Underachieving
NHL Playoff Surprises and Flyers Take Series Lead
NHL 1st Round: Looking at the Good, Bad and the Ugly
The Underachievers Minus One
Playoff Madness
The Best-of Our Underachievers:1
Hockey is Back!
The Exciting Lives of Mike and Brian
Only Days Away From Hockey
Return of the Million Dollar Face
Hockey's Around the Corner!
Adjusting To The New Normal
Who's Ready For Some Hockey?
Mini Golf: Return of the Mulligan
Some Positive News and NHL in Olympics
Change is in the Air
Lame Bezos and The Super Swede Returns
Southern Politeness
Rants Galore
We're Perfect People
Potential NHL Trophy Winners
Our Most Random Podcast
Story Time
Looking At NHL's 24 Team Playoff Format
Bone Picking and The World
Highlights of Our Hockey Podcasts #1
Summer and Office Ranks
NHL Anniversary Rants and Draft Look-backs
Quarantine is the Worst
NHL Resumption and the Smarter 2011 NHL Re-draft
We're Smart and Sports Takes
Highlights From our Hockey Podcasts #2
Complete Randomness
Missing Our Hockey
Ukulele and Vacations
Highlights of our Hockey Podcasts #3
20 Million and Concussion
Highlights From Our Hockey Podcasts #4
Thriving and That Sports Fix
Highlights From Our Hockey Podcast #5
Reliving the Past
Surviving Quarantine Life
The Randomness of our Friendship
New Face Same Space