All Episodes
We Don't Wanna Grow Up — 449 episodes
Freestyle Friday 35 - Supposedly/Allegedly/Definitely Haunted
90s Taboo!
Freestyle Friday 34 - CK One, Guy Lights, and Spoonerisms
Felicity (Season 3, Episode 4 - Greeks and Geeks)
Freestyle Friday 33 - That's Just the Way It Is
Listener Stories: Nostalgic Theme Parks
Freestyle Friday 32 - You Saucy Minx!
Weird Stuff I Believed When I Was a Kid (Parts 1-3)
Wedding Crashers (2005)
My Best Friend's Wedding (1997)
Freestyle Friday 31 - Situation of the Week
Legally Blonde (2001)
Freestyle Friday 30 - Free Fallin
Never Been Kissed (1999)
Freestyle Friday 29 - Woof!
Freestyle Friday 28 - Back on the Mic
The 2026 Spring Screams Awards
Critters 2: The Main Course (1988)
April Fool's Day (1986)
Leprechaun (1993)
Almost Famous (2000)
Mind the Gap Trivia
Felicity (Season 3, Episode 3 - Hello, I Must Be Going)
Freestyle Friday 27 - Under Pressure
Rom-Com Trivia
Freestyle Friday 26 - A Bowl of Cherries
Blooper Reel (2025)
Elf (2003)
Holiday Games 2025
Freestyle Friday 25 - Because We're Just So Cute
White Christmas (1954)
While You Were Sleeping (1995)
Home for the Holidays (1995)
Lyrically Correct (Part 1)
Freestyle Friday 24 - A Lil Scrunchy-Scrunch
Drop Dead Fred (1991) - Rerelease with added commentary!
Name That Movie - Part 2 - Kiss Marry Dump (Spooky Season 2025)
Name That Movie (Spooky Season 2025 - Part 1)
Freestyle Friday 23 - Because I Said So
Awesomely Bad 80s Horror Movies (2025 edition)
We Don't Wanna Grow Up's Five Year Anniversary!
Spooky Listener Stories (2025 Edition)
Child's Play (1988)
Felicity (Season 3, Episode 2 - The Anti-Natalie Intervention)
Poltergeist (1982)
90s Teen Dramas - Halloween Episodes
80s Slasher Movies (Part 5)
Freestyle Friday 22 - Sick Reference, Bro!
My So-Called Life Trivia
Freestyle Friday 21 - Our Champagne PSA
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1992)
Freestyle Friday 20 - The OC vs The OA
Felicity (Season 3 - Episode 1 - The Christening)
Freestyle Friday 19 - The Smallest Winner
My So-Called Life Wrap Party (Part 4)
Freestyle Friday 18 - I'm Gonna Take Care of You, Birdy
New Kids on the Block - Wildest Dreams Special
Favorite Sex and the City Episodes and Audience Polls
Sex and the City Triva
Freestyle Friday 17 - I Was Basically Princess Vespa
Name That Tune (1988/1989 & 1993/1997)
The Albums that Defined YOUR Teen Years
The Albums that Defined Our Teen Years
Who's the Boss?
Troop Beverly Hills (1989)
Freestyle Friday 16 - The Proverbial Popcorn
Blast from the Past Trivia Game
Freestyle Friday 15 - Adventures in Jean Shorts
Favorite TV Weddings
Summer School (1987)
Freestyle Friday 14 - Marshmallows and Infinity Pools
Top Ten Brendan Fraser Movies
Freestyle Friday 13 - Half a Can of Aqua Net, and a Prayer
Flight of the Navigator (1986)
Freestyle Friday 12 - It's Gonna Be a Long, Hot Summer
1995 MTV Movie Awards
Freestyle Friday 11 - Bonus Tracks
Remote Control: Pryde of the X-Men
Freestyle Friday 10 - Whatever Floats Your Boat
Shag (1989)
Freestyle Friday 9 - Okay, now I'm seated
Favorite 80s Break-Up Songs (Part 2)
Now and Then (1995)
Favorite 80s Break-Up Songs (Part 1)
She's All That (1999)
Freestyle Friday 8 - Walking on Broken Glass
80s and 90s Pop Culture Trivia with Friend Kelly!
Can't Hardly Wait - 1998 (Rerelease from 2022)
It's Rex Manning Day!
Romy and Michele's High School Reunion (1997)
Name That Movie!
Freestyle Friday 7 - Nostalgic Snacks and Useless Facts
Like, Totally 80s Pop Culture Trivia Game!
Phyllis Nefler would be proud!
Freestyle Friday 6 - Y'all - I'm Wild!
Hear Me Out
Thank You for Being a Friend
Freestyle Friday 5 - Little Rose Soaps
80s and 90s Pop Culture Trivia
Where the Whiskey Drowns and the Beer Chases My Blues Away
Freestyle Friday 4 - Stated Duration
Kiss, Marry, Dump (Movie Edition - Part 3)
Black Lights and Novelty Gifts
Freestyle Friday 3 - That would not be, like, hip, man!
Misheard Lyrics (Part 1)
Okay, Darth!
Freestyle Friday 2 - Building A Mystery
The Cutting Edge (1992)
Do it, do it!
Freestyle Friday Episode 1 - "Full Sax"
House Parties of the 80s, 90s, and early 00s (Part 2)
New Season, New Nostalgia!
Stacy Reads Middle School Notes - Part 4 (Re-release from April 2023)
Stacy Reads Middle School Notes - Part 3 (Re-release from December 2022)
Stacy Reads Middle School Notes - Part 2 (Re-release from June 2022)
Stacy reads Middle School Notes - Part 1 (Re-release from May 2022)
Saved by the Bell (Re-release with added commentary)
80s TV & 90s Movie Trivia (2025)
Blooper Reel (2024)
Holiday TV Episodes (Re-release from 2021)
Home Improvement Holiday Episodes
Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992)
Holiday Trivia (2024)
Pete and Stacy Wrapped 2024
A Muppet Family Christmas (1987)
Holiday Things and Mild Themes
Thanksgiving Traditions and Dishes (Rerelease from 2020 with added commentary)
Planes, Trains and Automobiles (1987)
Thanksgiving TV Specials (Rerelease from November 2021)
Cabbage Patch Kids
My So-Called Life Wrap Party (Part 3)
A Quickie, but a Goodie!
House Parties of the 80s, 90s, and early 00s
Ask Us Anything (Part 4)
Animated Halloween Specials (Re-release from 2021)
Awesomely Bad 80s Horror Movies (2024 edition) - Part 2
Beetlejuice Beetlejuice & the beginning of Awesomely Bad 80s Horror Movies (2024 edition)
I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997)
80s Slasher Movies (Part 4)
Tuttle Eclipse of the Heart
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (Season 1, Episode 7 - Angel)
Just Let Us Live!
Spooky Listener Stories (2024 Edition)
My So-Called Life Wrap Party (Part 2)
Scream 2 (1997) Rerelease from 2021
My So-Called Life Wrap Party (Part 1)
Scream (1996) Rerelease from 2021
Favorite 90s Thrillers (Part 3)
The Craft (1996) Rerelease from 2021
My So-Called Life (Episode 19 - In Dreams Begin Responsibilities) - Our 300th Episode!
Full Send It & Cowabunga!
Favorite 90s Thrillers (Part 2)
Favorite 90s Thrillers (Part 1)
More Grease 2 (1982)
Grease 2 (1982) - Part 1
The Best of Brenda (A Tribute to Shannen Doherty)
Favorite Nostalgic Summer Movies
My So-Called Life (Episode 18 - Weekend)
Brats (2024)
Top Ten Soap Operas
RoboCop (1987)
We Don't Wanna Grow Up update & summer plans!
Charmed (Season 2, Episode 2: Morality Bites)
Ask Us Anything (Part 3)
My So-Called Life (Episode 17 - Betrayal)
Top Ten Songs that Remind You of School Dances (Early 2000s Edition: Part 1)
Dance 'Til Dawn (1988) and Top Ten Prom Themes
Seventeen Magazine's 9th Annual Readers Poll (Part 1)
Top Ten Songs that Remind You of School Dances (90s edition: Part 1)
My So-Called Life (Episode 16 - Resolutions)
Top Ten Songs that Remind You of School Dances (80s edition: Part 1)
Clue (1985)
Love Extravaganza (2024)
Blooper Reel (2023)
My So-Called Life (Episode 15 - So Called Angels)
Holiday Trivia (2023)
The Holiday (2006)
My So-Called Life (Episode 14 - On the Wagon)
Son in Law (1993)
My So-Called Life (Episode 13 - Pressure)
Awesomely Bad Horror Movies (Part 3)
Spooky Listener Stories (2023 Edition)
80s Slasher Movies (Part 3)
Practical Magic (1998)
Spooky Listener Stories - Parts 1, 2 & 3 (Re-release)
Awesomely Bad Horror Movies (Re-release)
Kiss, Marry, Dump (Movie Edition - Part 2)
Pete & Stacy go to 90s Con!
Favorite 90s Break-Up Songs (Part 2)
Favorite 90s Break-Up Songs (Part 1)
Breaking News: *NSYNC Reunites at the MTV VMAs!
Name That Theme Song
Ask Us Anything (Part 2)
Weird Stuff I Believed When I Was a Kid (Part 5)
Favorite 90s Movie Soundtracks
That's So 90s - Trivia Game
Kiss, Marry, Dump - Movie Edition
The Albums that Defined Our Teen Years
Top Ten Favorite Barbies!
What Did the 80s Smell Like?
My So-Called Life (Episode 12 - Self-Esteem)
TGIF Summer Episodes
The Terminator (1984)
Name That Commercial!
Favorite Drew Barrymore Movies
My So-Called Life (Episode 11 - Life of Brian)
Slumber Party Listener Stories (Part 3)
E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)
Weird Stuff I Believed as a Kid (Part 4)
10 Things I Hate About You (1999)
Would You Rather - Nostalgia Edition
My So-Called Life (Episode 10 - Other People's Mothers)
Footloose (1984)
Middle School Notes (Part 4)
This or That: Cartoon Edition (Part 1)
Happy Rex Manning Day!
A Quick Hello
Say Anything (Prom Nightmares) - From the March 1994 edition of YM Magazine
My So-Called Life (Episode 9 - Halloween)
Slumber Party Listener Stories (Part 2)
Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story (2004)
Say Anything (January 1999)
Felicity (Season 2)
What did the 90s Smell Like?
Family Game Night 10 - All of Us - The Family Trivia Game for All Generations
Weird Science (1985)
Favorite Feel-Good Movies
My So-Called Life (Episode 8 - Strangers in the House)
Girls Just Want To Have Fun (Re-release with added commentary)
Signs of Wealth in the 80s/90s!
Can't Buy Me Love (Re-release with added commentary)
Only You (1994)
90s Quizpedia Game
My So-Called Life (Episode 7 - Why Jordan Can't Read)
Pete & Stacy's Favorite We Don't Wanna Grow Up Podcast Moments!
Serendipity (2001)
Stacy Reads Middle School Notes From Friends (Part 3)
Ask Us Anything
Die Hard (1988)
Favorite Nostalgic Holiday Commercials
Home Alone (Re-release with added commentary)
A Christmas Story (Re-release with added commentary + A Christmas Story Christmas chat)
Gremlins (1984) (Re-release with added commentary)
National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation (Re-release with added commentary)
Dear Diary (November 1998)
Home For the Holidays (1995)
Slumber Party Listener Stories (Part 1)
My So-Called Life (Episode 6 - The Substitute)
How Close Are You? - Quiz from Oct. 1997 issue of YM Magazine (Anniversary Edition - Part 2)
New Kids on the Block (A mini-deep dive)
My So-Called Life (Episode 5 - The Zit)
Spooky Listener Stories (2022 Edition)
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1992)
The Lost Boys (1987)
Awesomely Bad Horror Movies - Part 2
My So-Called Life (Episode 4 - Father Figures)
80s Slasher Movies (Part 2)
Halloween Special (Re-Release with added commentary)
Say Anything Entertainment Awards from YM Magazine (September 1998)
Ghostbusters (Re-Release with added commentary)
My So-Called Life (Episode 3 - Guns and Gossip)
Beetlejuice (1988) Re-Release with added commentary
My So-Called Life - Episode 2 (Dancing in the Dark)
Teen Witch (1989) - Re-release with added commentary
Teen Wolf (1985) - Re-release with added commentary
My So-Called Life - Episode One (Pilot)
If My Parents Only Knew - from the August 1995 issue of Seventeen Magazine
Awesomely Bad 80s Movies - Part 1 (non-horror)
Dear Diary - First Day of School Edition
Seventeen Magazine's 10th Annual Readers' Poll from 1998 - (Part 1)
A Variety of Nostalgic Listener Stories (Part 2)
National Lampoon's European Vacation (1985)
Back to School Quiz from YM Magazine
Recasting Stranger Things - 90s (Audience Poll Results)
Weird Stuff I Believed When I Was A Kid (Part 3)
Harry and the Hendersons (1987)
Favorite Songs by Alanis Morissette
Favorite TV Weddings!
Favorite Songs from 90s Movies (Part 2)
Summer School (1987)
Wedding Crashers (2005)
Dear Diary (June 1994 & May 1997)
Weird Stuff I Believed When I Was a Kid (Part 2)
Favorite MTV Shows
Weird Stuff I Believed When I Was a Kid (Part 1)
Weekend at Bernie's (1989)
Recasting Stranger Things - Made in the 90's
Dear Diary (May 1996)
Favorite Songs from 90s Movies (Part 1)
Troop Beverly Hills (1989)
Stacy Reads Middle School Notes from Friends (Part 2)
Don't Tell Mom the Babysitter's Dead (1991)
Say Anything from YM Magazine (2000)
Can't Hardly Wait (1998)
Favorite TV Game Shows from the 80s & 90s
Senior Year - With Special Guests from our Patreon: Amber & Marybeth
Twilight (2008)
A Variety of Nostalgic Listener Stories (Part 1)
The Return of the Cozy Club
Felicity (Season One)
The Money Pit (1986)
Favorite Winona Ryder Movies
Stacy Reads Middle School Notes from Friends (Part 1)
Mean Girls (2004)
Favorite 80's Cartoon Intros
Jawbreaker (1999)
Favorite Madonna Songs
Heathers (1989)
Favorite Romantic 2000's Movies
Dear Diary -Stacy's favorites in 1994 & Diary entries from February & March of 1997
Listener Stories: Prom - Homecoming - School Dances
Romy and Michele's High School Reunion (1997)
Favorite 80s Love Songs
Batman (1989)
Most Embarrassing Moments - Part 3 & Prom Clothing Catastrophes
Favorite 80's TV Show Theme Songs
Old School (2003)
Most Embarrassing Moments - Part 2 & Prom Horror Stories
Favorite Brad Pitt Movies
Mannequin (1987)
Favorite Fictional Couples
Pretty Woman (1990)
Favorite Romantic 90's Movies
Listener Love Stories - Part 2
Singles (1992)
Favorite Romantic 80's Movies
Pretty In Pink (1986)
Listener Love Stories - Part 1
Dear Diary February 1996
Groundhog Day (1993)
The Return of We Don't Wanna Grow Up
Dear Diary December 1996
Holiday TV Episodes
Scrooged (1988)
Love Actually (2003)
Holiday Listener Stories
This or That - Christmas Edition
Elf (2003)
Christmas Movie Trivia
Top 5 Songs: Mariah Carey
Bridget Jones's Diary (2001)
This or That - 1991
Thanksgiving TV Specials
Most Embarrassing Moments - Part 1
Drop Dead Fred (1991)
Notting Hill (1999)
Top 5 90's Love Songs - Anniversary Edition
Beverly Hills 90210 - Season 1
Top 5 Songs: Janet Jackson
Jem & Goonies Trivia - 101st Episode Celebration!
Halloween Special - 80's Slasher Movies
Spooky Stories - Part 5
Animated Halloween Specials
Spooky Stories - Part 4
Scream 2 (1997)
90's Teen Dramas - Halloween Episodes Part 2
Spooky Stories - Part 3
90's Teen Dramas - Halloween Episodes Part 1
Scream (1996)
Spooky Stories - Part 2
This or That - Halloween
Hocus Pocus (1993)
Spooky Stories - Part 1
TV Sitcom Halloween Specials Part 2
TV Sitcom Halloween Specials Part 1
The Craft (1996)
Awesomely Bad Horror Movies
(500) Days of Summer (2009)
This or That - 1996
Fast Times at Ridgemont High (1982)
Brat Pack Trivia - With Special Guest: Heather
Family Game Night 9 - 90's Trivia
13 Going on 30 (2004) - With Special Guest: Ciara
Sex and the City Trivia
The Empire Strikes Back (1980) - With Special Guest: Michael McNair
Listener Stories - The Sh*t Your Siblings Told You!
Shag (1989)
Family Vacation Stories From Our Listeners
National Lampoon's Vacation (1983)
Now and Then (1995)
Stand By Me (1986)
90's Movie BFF's
The Challenge All Stars Episode 9 Recap
FRIENDS - The One About Our Favorite Moments & FRIENDS Trivia
The Challenge All Stars Episode 8 Recap
FRIENDS - The One About Our Favorite Episodes
Family Game Night 8 - 90's Trivia 2 & Dear Diary
The Challenge All Stars Episode 7 Recap
80's Movie BFF's & Dear Diary
Family Game Night 7 - 90's Trivia
The Challenge All Stars Episode 6 Recap
Spaceballs & Girls Just Want to Have Fun
Family Game Night 6 - 80's Trivia
The Challenge All Stars Episode 5 Recap
Family Game Night 5 - 90's Trivial Pursuit
The Challenge All Stars Episode 4 Recap
Beetlejuice & Ghostbusters
Family Game Night 4 - Name That Movie
The Challenge All Stars Episode 3 Recap
The Last Blockbuster & Titanic
The Challenge All Stars Episode 2 Recap
Real World Homecoming Episode 6 Recap
Can't Buy Me Love & The Princess Bride
The Challenge All Stars Episode 1 Recap
Real World Homecoming Episode 5 Recap
The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air
Family Game Night 3 & Cozy Club
Real World Homecoming Episode 4 Recap
Clueless & Jurassic Park
Family Game Night 3.5 & Cozy Club
Real World Homecoming Episode 3 Recap
Saved By The Bell
Family Game Night 2: Saved By The Bell Trivia - kid 90 - Cozy Club
Real World Homecoming Episode 2 Recap
Teen Wolf & Teen Witch
Top 5 Cozy Shows
Real World Homecoming Episode 1 Recap
Almost Famous (2000) & Fight Club (1999)
Top 5 Favorite Toys We Owned Part II
Garfield and Friends & Annie (1982)
Top 5 Favorite Toys We Owned
My So-Called Life & Family Game Night 1: 90's Trivia
Top 5 Favorite 90's Movies
Dirty Dancing (1987) & Back to the Future (1985)
Top 5 Favorite 80's Movies
The NeverEnding Story (1984) & Jem and The Holograms Part 2
Empire Records (1995) & Happy Gilmore (1996)
Top 5 Favorite Cartoons
Ferris Bueller (1986) & The Breakfast Club (1985)
Top 5 Favorite Books
Full House & Perfect Strangers
Top 5 Favorite Christmas Songs - Part 2
National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation & A Christmas Story
Favorite Christmas Movies
Classic Christmas TV Specials
Top 5 Favorite Christmas Songs
Gremlins & Home Alone
Sixteen Candles Birthday Spectacular
Top 5 Thanksgiving Day Food and Traditions
The Smurfs & Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure
Top 5 Kids TV shows from the 80's and 90's
MTV's The Real World Season 1 & Dazed and Confused
Top 5 Board Games
The Muppet Show & Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope
Top 5 Songs from the 80's
Adventures in Babysitting & Family Ties
Top 5 Candies
Halloween Special!
The Goonies & Jem and the Holograms