All episodes

#125 - Best Cartoon Cat with Paul Dini

#124 - Who's The Best Spider-Man?

#123 - Best 90's Sitcom with Jesse Thorn

#122 - Clean Slate VI

#121 - Best Mel Brooks Film w/ Travis McElroy

#120 - Best Color of the Rainbow

#119 - Mac vs PC with Christopher Moore

#118 - Best Carnival Ride

#117 - The Boat Files: Best "Best Picture" Winner with Hrishikesh Hirway

#116 - Best TV Mom with Theresa Thorn

#115 - Best Movie Snack

#114 - Best Superman Movie

#113 - Best Shakespeare Play with Austin Tichenor

#112 - The Boat Files - Best Breakfast Cereal with Ted Leo

#111 - Bar Soap vs Liquid Soap vs Foam Soap

#110 - The Boat Files: Best Coen Brothers Film with Jeffrey Cranor

#109 - Clean Slate V LIVE with Welcome To Night Vale

#108 - Best Monty Python Song with "Weird" Al Yankovic

#107 - Best Ketchup

#106 - Best Super Power LIVE on Facebook

#105 - Pirates or Vikings with Carlos Alazraqui LIVE at Pensacon

#104 - Lethal Weapon or Die Hard?

#103 - Best Berry

#102 - Classic Cartoons: Warner Bros or Disney?

#101 - Worst Zoo Animal

#100 - Best M&M Variety LIVE with Ben Acker, Craig Cackowski, Marc Evan Jackson, Busy Philipps, and Annie Savage

#99 - Binge vs Weekly Episodic TV Watching - LIVE from Hal's car

#98 - Hot or Cold Sandwiches LIVE from a car

#97 - Best Finger

#96 - Stay In or Go Out on New Year's Eve?

#95 - Best Holiday Lights with Drew Ackerman

#94 - Best Fictional President with Josh Malina

#93 - Best Novelty Song with Jonathan Coulton

#92 - Chili: Beans Or No Beans?

#91 - Best Pie with Colt Cabana

#90 - Best Door

#89 - Best Indiana Jones Film

#88 - Best Cuisine LIVE with Jean Grae, John DiMaggio, and John Hodgman

#87 - Are Ghosts Real?

#86 - Clean Slate IV with Jackson Publick & Doc Hammer

#85 - Best Sense with David Rees

#84 - Best Harry Potter Movie

#83 - Best Cheesesteak with Ralph Garman

#82 - Best Movie Trilogy With Nathan Fillion

#81 - Best Vintage Toy with Janet Varney

#80 - Movies at Home vs At The Theater

#79 - Hot Dog or Hamburger at a Barbecue?

#78 - Clean Slate III with Wil Wheaton

#77 - Best Movie Villain w/ Simon Gotch

#76 - Fork or Spoon

#75 - Best Summer Olympics Event

#74 - Best Doctor

#73 - City, Country, or Suburbs

#72 - Best Original Ghostbuster

#71 - Planes, Trains, or Automobiles

#70 - Best Pasta

#69 - Best Day

#68 - Best Classic Arcade Game with Austin Creed aka Xavier Woods

#67 - Crushed or Cubed Ice

#66 - Apples or Oranges

#65 - Big Dogs or Small Dogs with Renée Colvert and Allegra Ringo (CIPYD Crossover)

#64 - Clean Slate II with Ben Acker

#63 - Calling or Texting with Paul F. Tompkins

#62 - Captain America or Iron Man?

#61 - Best Stooge with Billy West

#60 - Krispy Kreme or Dunkin' Donuts?

#59 - Practical vs Digital Effects with Tommy Haake

#58 - Best Cereal Mascot

#58a - Mark or Hal

#57 - Best BBQ with Adam Gertler

#56 - Batman vs Superman with Travis McElroy and Ben Blacker

#55 - Coffee or Tea with Cecil Baldwin

#54 - Paper Towels or Air Dryers

#53 - Best Girl Scout Cookie

#52 - The One Year Anniversary Spectacular!

#51 - Table or Booth?

#50 - Pancakes, Waffles, or French Toast w/ Annie Savage and Fred Cross

#49 - Best Saturday Morning Cartoon w/ Jackson Publick

#48 - Best Star Trek Movie w/ Doc Hammer

#47 - Best Former President

#46A - BOUNS - Carter Parton Rogers LIVE!

#46 - Star Wars vs Star Trek LIVE with Adam Savage and John Hodgman

#45 - Clean Slate

#44 - Sweet or Sour Pickles?

#43 - Best Christmas Movie

#42 - Best Christmas Special

#41 - Best Christmas Song

#40 - Worst Christmas Song

#39 - Best Thanksgiving Side Dish

#38 - Best Comic Strip

#37 - Should We Keep The Penny?

#36 - Best James Bond w/ Matt Gourley

#35 - Stick Shift or Automatic?

#34 - 10 Yard Fight w/ Zhubin Parang

#33 - Best Halloween Candy LIVE in NYC w/ John Hodgman!

#32 - Sandwich Smackdown

#31 - Best Muppet w/ Kirk Thatcher

#30 - Best TV Theme Song (w/ Mike Phirman!)

#29 - Best Classic Movie Monster LIVE at Dragon Con with Trace Beaulieu, Frank Conniff, and Bill Corbett

#28 - Best Chocolate