All Episodes
What's Your Favorite Scary Story? — 91 episodes
Ep. 91 - The Mystery Hijacker
Ep. 90 - Ghost and/or Hag
Ep. 89 - The Story of Marcia Trimble
Ep. 88 - Nepal, Biggie F, and The Old Man Of The Lake
Ep. 87 - A Ghostie Started The Fire
Ep. 86 - The Case of Dr. John Schneeberger
Ep. 85 - The Anniversary Special
Ep. 84 - Season Two Premiere...THE DILLYMARN
Ep. 83 - Moll Dyer
Ep. 82 - The Chest of Death
Ep. 81 - Danny Phantom
Ep. 80 - Dudleytown
Ep. 79 - The Case of Casey Anthony
Ep. 78 - Personal Encounters Pt.2
Ep. 77 - The Story Story
Ep. 76 - Swampfoot
Ep. 75 - The Case of Maura Murray
Ep. 74 - The Day The Music Died
Ep. 73 - The Lady in White House
Ep. 72 - The Giggling Granny
Ep. 71 - Personal Encounters
Ep. 70 - Cleveland's Creepy Castle
Ep. 69 - McMenamins Haunted Hotel
Ep. 68 - Jack the Ripper Pt. 2
Ep. 67 - Jack the Ripper Pt. 1
Ep. 66 - NSFFFWM: The Extended Cut, Science Edition, The Sequel
Ep. 65 - Creepy Ass Canyon
Ep. 64 - The Pollock Sisters
Ep. 63 - Pennsylvania's Most Depressed Cryptid
Ep. 62 - Gettin' Ghostly In Gatlinburg
Ep. 61 - The Story of Lacey Fletcher
Ep. 60 - WYFSS Takes On The Old South Pittsburg Hospital
Ep. 59 - The Doll That Couldn't Let It Go
Ep. 58 - The Missing Sodder Children
Ep. 57 - The Matthew Shepard Story
Ep. 56 - Schwarzwald
Ep. 55 - Demonic Elves & A Paleolithic Horse
Ep. 54 - P. Town
Ep. 53 - It's Rainin' Meat!
Ep. 52 - WYFSS TURNS ONE
Ep. 51 - The Pfister Hotel
Ep. 50 - A Very Krampy Christmas
Ep. 49 - The Baby Body Watermelon Head Cryptid
Ep. 48 - The McDonalds Massacre
Ep. 47 - The Cari Farver Case Pt. 2
Ep. 46 - The Cari Farver Case Pt. 1
Ep. 45 - The UFO Battle of Los Angeles
Ep. 44 - It's Lit
Ep. 43 - America's Scariest Motel
Ep. 42 - Our First Halloween Episode
Ep. 41 - Marlene Takes Over Again
Ep. 40 - Our Love Story
Ep. 39 - Terrors of Topanga Canyon
Ep. 38 - Underwater Ghost Town
Ep. 37 - Quirky Crimes
Ep. 36 - Snippy a.k.a. Lady the Horse
Ep. 35 - Creepy Cafes
Ep. 34 - Mexican Urban Legends Pt. 2
Ep. 33 - Oh Dam
Ep. 32 - Malevolent Malls
Ep. 31 - The Haunted Hermitage House
Ep. 30 - Mothman's Distant Relative?
Ep. 29 - Dipping Into True Crime
Ep. 28 - Little Spooky Books
Ep. 27 - The Greenbrier Ghost
Ep. 26 - Superstition Mountains
Ep. 25 - Slendy
Ep. 24 - The OG Poltergeist
Ep. 23 - The Salem Witch Trials
Ep. 22 - The Lizzie Borden House
Ep. 21 - The Conjuring House
Ep. 20 - Marlene Takes Over
Ep. 19 - The Old Griffith Park Zoo
Ep. 18 - No Neck Moth Head
Ep. 17 - Gettysburg
Ep. 16 - Mexican Urban Legends
Ep. 15 - Double Abduction
Ep. 14 - Shadow People
Ep. 13 - Black Eyed Children
Ep. 12 - Return to Winchester
Ep. 11 - Hometown Horrors
Ep. 10 - The Rock
Ep. 9 - The Most Haunted House in Australia
Ep. 8 - He Goes On All Fours
Ep. 7 - Bakersfield
Ep. 6 - I Have Lived Before
Ep. 5 - Inhospitable Hospitals
Ep. 4 - The Most Haunted Ship In The World
Ep. 3 - ¡Ay, Mis Hijos!
Ep. 2 - Houses That Survived The Civil War
Ep. 1 - The House That Spirits Built